Because you make more money in index funds with comparable security?
Bonds used to be the principal way to save and invest in the past when interest rates were much higher. Its honestly a bit of a shame that as a society loaning money to the government is such a poor investment - it more reflects on the failings of the state if there is literally nothing profitable they can do with money to justify a competitive return. States can do pretty much anything a company can and more, and in a perfect world would be the best managers of capital. Thats where concepts like single payer healthcare come from, after all.
And add to that that not everyone wants to be a capitalist. Index funds are specialization of labor - let the teachers teach and the doctors save lives while their money is invested and managed by people who are good at tracking markets.
That being said, financial advisory in general is adjacent to such prestigious professions as televangelists and online poker in my mind - the most successful in the business have almost no correlation with actually sane analytical expertise and more to do with who can advertise the best. Fundamentally it is all making educated guesses, and until shit hits the fan people flock to whoever boasts the most rather than whoever is nuanced and rational, at least until after a stock crashes or a market tanks.
Thanks for taking the time to reply! I'll reflect on what you've written.
It's good that most Robin Hood investors are young and don't have much to lose. I hope they learn their lesson before they put they are old enough to put their retirement investments at risk.
Hyperbole much? There's plenty of capitalist spirit in placing your trust in the outcomes of markets. Specialization is a perfectly rational economic decision, and requires you not specialize in other things. There's no reason to believe a medical doctor for example is going to excel at active investing, or that society would be better off if we required it.
The wonderful thing about markets is that we can all benefit from the specialization of others. Specialization (and competition) produces cheap pencils, cheap food, and even stocks that are closer to fairly valued. It is a fundamental misallocation of human capital -- I'm better off further pursuing specialization in server administration than trying to stare at stocks and newsfeeds to separate information from noise.
I admire people for investing their money actively instead of in an index.
It is the closest you can come to the capitalist spirit without actually doing anything. (Not a slight - not everyone needs to "do something" in the sense of starting a business - but being an active investor is very close to the same.)
Actively investing takes guts and a kind of entrepreneurial risk-taking.