News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by benwilber0 on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @11:23PM (#16534228)
I've never done one of these genetic tests. Partly because it's scary to me to learn what diseases I'm likely to get as I get older, but also I just don't want that information in some else's database. We're very fearful of what Google and Facebook already knows about us now imagine they buy 23andMe and then join all their data about you with your DNA (which you've already willingly given up and allowed them to "profile".

Google/Facebook user behavioral data + their users' DNA is about as scary invasive as it gets.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by cromwellian on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @11:37PM (#16534276)
On the other side of this, if massive databases of DNA and medical histories were accumulated, it's possible a great amount of human suffering and harm could be solved by aggressively mining this data to find out the connection between DNA and various diseases.

I mean, besides being denied health insurance because of what someone might find in your DNA, why are you so afraid of something even having your DNA, because it might result in GATACA-like society? If so, we need strong legal protections against discrimination by DNA, but we can't throw out the baby with the bathwater.

There's too much good that can be done to human wealth and welfare by eradicating disease and paranoia about theoretical danger should be challenged into laws to protect against discrimination.

What do you think Facebook + DNA is going to do to harm you? Try to sell you a pharmaceutical or medical treatment? A cure for balding or erectile disfunction?

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by benwilber0 on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @11:46PM (#16534304)
People already post their 23andMe "results" on their dating profiles to say "I'm clean and healthy with good genetics!"

The GATTACA society is rapidly becoming reality, just not institutionalized yet.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by notahacker on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @08:02AM (#16536046)
I can imagine "look at me, my genes are superb!" having a slightly different effect on potential dating partners' level of interest to the one intended...
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by Ultimatt on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @04:21AM (#16535229)
Great. Maybe we will have less cystic fibrosis in the world. Not sure many people would argue they would be keen for their children to inherit that. There is a big difference between knowing you naturally are a carrier of a disease, and acting on that info, and then manipulating radically and arbitrarily the genetics of humanity. Regulation internationally is fairly clear, sifting out incredibly debilitating disease is going to be ok. Making your children more aryan looking, not so much. Now if only they posted a recent STI panel result too.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by StavrosK on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @11:37AM (#16537543)
You'd be fine with someone not finding a partner because they have a chance that their child would carry a disease? Something like "I cannot find a husband because my child will have a 5% chance of cystic fibrosis, so nobody will go for me".
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by DoreenMichele on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @11:49AM (#16537641)
That isn't remotely how that works. There is no circumstance whatsoever where your child has a 5 percent chance of having CF.

CF is a homozygous recessive disorder. Both parents have to contribute a defective gene in order for the child to have CF. If one parent is a carrier and the other is not, there is zero chance of the child having CF, barring random mutations which have been known to happen. If both parents are carriers, there is a 50 percent chance the child will be a carrier, a 25 percent chance the child will have no defective genes and a 25 percent chance the child will have CF.

If you actually have CF, you have two defective genes and you can only produce children who are either carriers or who have CF, depending on the genes contributed by the other parent. If the other parent is not a carrier, the children cannot have CF.

As someone who both has CF and has raised a child with it, I absolutely do not want more children with CF. It's a horrible burden for the parents and only a deeply sick sadist would wish such a thing upon their child.

I have never lacked for male interest. I don't know why the hell that is because I'm quite open about my medical situation. I am now menopausal, so it is a moot point. But I absolutely spent some years agonizing over how to screen out CF carriers from the dating pool. Having another child with CF is one of my worst nightmares. I would rather be taken out and shot.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by StavrosK on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:00PM (#16537750)
Sure, that's for CF, but my question still stands for all the other heritable diseases.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by DoreenMichele on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:03PM (#16537771)
Uh, no. All other heritable diseases are either homozygous recessive or they are passed via a single dominant gene. In neither case is there a 5 percent chance of passing it on. All recessive disorders follow the exact same math outlined above.

This is genetics 101.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by ddorian43 on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:54PM (#16538254)
I think I've read it's for bipolar:10% if only father, 50% if both parents.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by DoreenMichele on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:57PM (#16538288)
And I am guessing that's not a case where they have identified specific genes. Please correct me if I am wrong. But I am not aware of bipolar genes being a thing.

There is a difference between hand wavy "runs in the family, but we don't really know how it works" and a bona fide genetic disorder whose alleles have been mapped to some degree or another.

Edit: To be perfectly clear, if it is not genetic and merely tends to run in families, it may be due to a variety of nongenetic factors, such as diet and lifestyle. Smoking also tends to run in families. Smoking is not a genetic disorder, though it significantly impacts health.

If it is not genetic, it's heritability is not going to show up on your 23 and me profile. Fretting that it will basically means you don't know what you are talking about.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by ddorian43 on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @05:39PM (#16540647)
You are right, no genes. They are doing a study for depression + bipolar: https://www.23andme.com/depression-bipolar/
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by DoreenMichele on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @06:01PM (#16540797)
There is a disease that was thought to be genetic, but was ultimately traced to ritual cannibalism spreading an infection. Relatives would eat the dead and what body part you got depended upon how closely related you were. This caused the disease to very much mimic a genetic disorder in its pattern of dispersal throughout the family.

"Runs in families" needs to be very clearly distinguished from genetic disorders per se. The former suggests correlation with an as yet unidentified cause or causes, as there may be various contributing factors. The latter is a case of identified cause.

Easy enough to confuse if your own life does not depend upon it, but absolutely not the same thing.

[dead]
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by dang on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @01:18PM (#16538476)
> Are you being intentionally obtuse?

That's not ok here, as I'm sure you know. Please re-read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and post civilly or not at all, regardless of how someone else is being.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by DoreenMichele on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:19PM (#16537897)
Are you being intentionally obtuse?

No, but you are being intentionally insulting in violation of HN guidelines and also moving the goal posts. I already stated above my diagnosis appears to be no barrier whatsoever to getting romantically involved with someone. Except from my end, as I have chosen to be celibate for medical reasons for a lot of years.

I am 100 percent okay with someone like me being able to screen out carriers. Because I have CF, it is entirely up to the father's genetic contribution as to the outcome. I am also 100 percent okay with having some means to have a potentially awkward conversation up front.

There are, in fact, worse things in life than sleeping alone.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by propman on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @01:24PM (#16538534)
I think the OP you responded to is being intentionally obtuse, you have made your point clear repeatedly. If you are aware you have CF gene and are also aware your partner does too, then you will not mate with them and instead find another mate. Some diseases can be eliminated like this.

I also have a condition similar to you and there is no way I'm letting another child suffer with that, so I'm not going to ever mate with a woman who carries that gene.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by DoreenMichele on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @02:12PM (#16538939)
I think the value in knowing upfront is you just avoid getting attached to begin with and you go bond with someone who doesn't introduce such big scary questions to the relationship. It is much easier to walk away before you get attached, no hard feelings. It is only when you fall in love first, have already invested substantial time into the relationship and then find out you both carry genes for something horrifying that it winds up being an agonizing question.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by cbr on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @10:56AM (#16537227)
"Making your children more aryan looking, not so much"

People strongly consider race in dating; we're kind of already there: https://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/race-attraction-2009-2014...

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by 908087 on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @09:19AM (#16536466)
Is that really a thing now? Sounds like it would have the opposite of the intended effect on most people. How awkward.

"I don't really have much to offer, but this DNA surveillance company says I have great genes!"

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by chrisan on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @11:24AM (#16537420)
I don't think it is _super_ awkward. Most of my friends, prior to having children, get screened https://www.webmd.com/baby/genetic-tests-before-pregnancy

I understand the negatives of having everyone compare genes can get kinda "master race"-ish but at the same time it is still heart breaking for kids to be born with stuff that could be prevented.

For people really heart-set on having children, I think it would be important to know your odds ahead of time before you get to the point of "ok lets have a kid together".

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by pasbesoin on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:39AM (#16534503)
Have you ever been denied health insurance?

I have.

I was 26 or thereabouts (it's been a while), in good health, but had one "touch base" appointment in my prior 2 year medical history (what the prospective insurer wanted, at that time). The appointment had no ongoing medical/treatment implications; it was simply a follow-up with a prior provider. Fortunately, a friend of a friend ran my application "unofficially" by the insurer's underwriters; if it had been a formal application, the result would have ended up in a cross-insurer database of decisions made whether to insure. Yes, there actually is -- was, certainly, at that time -- one, and if you landed in it with a "deny", getting anyone else to insure you became an order of magnitude more difficult. So I was told by this industry professional -- again, as a favor to my professional contact and friend.

More recently, I've had a minor condition that an eminent surgeon refused to operate on. Cost/benefit didn't merit it; his recommendation was simply to monitor.

When I changed from employer provided insurance to individually insured, I was denied. There was nothing I could do, and the condition did not hinder me in any way. Nonetheless.

Again, through the fortune of having a (different) professional contact and friend in the industry, with an allied company, I was able -- via a flaw in their processing of the application -- to get a re-evaluation. And a policy written, albeit with a rider excluding that condition.

But their initial reaction, before I "pulled strings"? They didn't offer me a policy with an exclusion rider. Nope, just "deny".

SO, many people who are paranoid about this kind of thing and "their health data getting around", are for damned good reason.

I agree, the knowledge and health benefits of sharing this data could be enormous. Think of what it could do for epidemiology. Best practices. Etc. Etc.

But, you want me to share it? You want me to sign on to a public program of same. You're going to have to guarantee that the data won't be used against participants.

As in, you do so use it, and you personally go to jail with a felony conviction and a multi-year sentence. And your company gets severely penalized and, if the behavior is widespread and with significant negative outcomes for those discriminated against, its own "death penalty".

You want the data? Demonstrate your good will. In ironclad terms.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by cromwellian on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @01:19AM (#16534608)
Why not solve it with national single payer, so no one can be denied under any circumstances?
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by pasbesoin on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @01:41AM (#16534691)
I'm amenable.

I could also live with a system like Germany's, where insurers are private but the state requires equal treatment and effective systems of cost control.

No system's perfect, and every system needs to be effectively managed.

I've long since come to the point of wondering how much the U.S. behavior actually negatively impacts other countries' health care systems.

In many ways more indirectly that this following, but also explicitly in Canada, they keep pushing for increased privatization. Want that marketshare, and to be the middleman between patients and services.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by zaarn on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @04:43AM (#16535300)
In Germany very few insurers are private. Most are state-nonprofit, private is split into most being private-nonprofit and the tiniest part being private-forprofit.

I think the good part is that we have a very good state healthcare, it's non-optional for basically 99.9% of the population.

The sad thing is that our actual healthcare system (doctors and hospitals) are in need of workers and doctors which leads to them preferring the privately insured patients.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by ianai on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @05:33AM (#16535499)
Do doctors not have ways to earn more based on expertise?
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by zaarn on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @05:36AM (#16535515)
Doctors do get paid more with experience but it's the lack of doctors that's the problem.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by pasbesoin on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:16AM (#16543086)
Thank you for that clarification.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by avcdsuia on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @08:29AM (#16536185)
Chinese gov is building and testing their national wide DNA database[0], what do you think of that?

[0]:https://www.wsj.com/articles/china-snares-innocent-and-guilt...

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by pasbesoin on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:21AM (#16543105)
That you'd better not have too much Uighur (Uyghur) DNA, among other things.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by prater on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @01:00AM (#16534560)
Wait a second. Is this recently? For all of Obamacare's problems - I thought that it at least solved this particular abuse.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by pasbesoin on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @01:30AM (#16534641)
The policy I got was with a good company (I mean, once you actually had a policy), for a reasonable rate. They then exited the individual market in my state. I ended up being shunted to a lower benefit, higher cost policy with a "second tier" company (if that). My premium costs about tripled in the span of a couple of years.

The Affordable Care Act's full enactment came just in time, for me.

Unfortunately, all legislation consists of two essential components: 1) The law, itself; and 2) funding (the budget process).

Republicans baldly stated, after Obama's election, that their primary, number one objective was to make him a one-term president. Before all else.

Despite its coming out of what was essentially a Republican design, then Governor Romney's health care insurance program in Massachusetts, Republican's went after the Affordable Care Act -- after labeling it "Obamacare" -- with a vengeance.

A primary way they crippled it, was by not providing the funding that was written into the law.

Insurers were given a 2 year time frame in which they could recoup their losses, until new participants' "deferred care" was taken care of and the companies had better demographics and cost projections (actuarial studies) upon which to carry forward.

When they went to the government to be made whole, under this provision, they were paid about 15 cents on the dollar.

So of course, premium costs increased dramatically, plan options became more limited, and companies started to exit the ACA marketplace.

Meanwhile, the Republicans made endless attempts to "repeal" the ACA in one fashion or another. Claiming they had a "better plan", that would provide better coverage at lower cost.

Now, they've had both houses of Congress and the executive for over a year. Still no sign of an actual "plan". Just continuing efforts to destroy the ACA.

So, going forward? No, I don't think this problem of pre-conditions can be considered solved. The party in power keeps trying to reintroduce it.

And I, for one, have no more trust in our society. Maybe I'll find another position that includes an employer-provided group insurance plan. Or a group plan through a professional organization.

If I didn't have various things tying me here right now, including elderly parents, and I had the opportunity, I'd leave the country.

I've always lived modestly. And it seems that is even part of my problem. The U.S., always somewhat hypocritical, is becoming more and more a land of "winners" and "losers".

Just look at our "fearless" leader, using the "L" word -- quite derogatorily -- left and right. If we're supposed to take our cue from our leadership, well then, f-ck this place.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by sjg007 on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @01:06PM (#16538369)
Republicans used the ACA as a wedge issue to motivate their base. Driving up premium costs was them hitting the hammer. The press failed to hold them to account. There was a big backlash though in some town halls where they would get called out so much so that they stopped attending town halls! Insurers want rescission and pre-existing conditions because it is a very profitable business when you don't have to pay out claims. I agree that we are lacking in trust as a society, we only trust the almighty dollar and maybe our local communities. The real problem is that people keep voting republican because they refuse to think. But that excludes the massive voter suppression they engage in in their red states as well. You can see that if people vote most states will turn blue. We need more engagement.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @01:00PM (#16538323)
>Despite its coming out of what was essentially a Republican design, then Governor Romney's health care insurance program in Massachusetts,

Calling anything that comes out of MA "republican design" is a little less than truthful.

Regardless of how you feel about the merit of the MA system or the federal system there are no republicans in MA, just democrats who will say what they need to say to run against incumbent Democrats.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by zaptheimpaler on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:23AM (#16534445)
We already have so much data in the healthcare system that people are unable to use or hamstrung by regulation to use (and to be fair it is probably very difficult to make sense of..). One doctor has no idea what another doctor wrote in my chart. Hospitals don't share data most data with others or with scientists for research.

When medical research even begins to use the massive amount of data they already have on patients from billions of routine visits, tests and hospitalizations productively, we can think about giving them more. We are so laughably far from that point that adding more data to the mountain doesn't make sense.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by simias on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @08:06AM (#16536065)
Why couldn't we have our cake and eat it too? Have anonymised data used for research that could never be traced back to you. A government agency could be in charge for that (like they are for censuses for instance). I'd sooner give that type of information to my democratically elected government than some corporation overseas.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by dfxm12 on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @01:59PM (#16538820)
Someone is making money from my DNA and it isn't me!

In all seriousness though, with as much good as this data can do, it belongs to the public, not to the highest bidder.

Also, regulations go ignored and legal protections are only available to people who can afford a lawyer who can prove wrong doing.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by acct1771 on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:19AM (#16534424)
> What do you think Facebook + DNA is going to do to harm you?

If you're actually looking for a pie in the sky answer, what happens when one if these entities gets popped and someone (state actor?) takes regional data to produce a very effective targeted bioweapon?

But the real answer is: you tell us when you find out the hard way. In the meantime, my personal info, of any kind, will continue to be protected, to the very best of my ability.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by TheSpiceIsLife on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @01:20AM (#16534610)
While I agree that throwing babies or bath water out is wasteful...

The primary goal of business is to make money. Or, in other words, to isolate us and make us feel inadequate so we buy more things with money we don’t have to impress friends we don’t have.

I mean, if I was being cynical. I’m not, but if I was...

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by lefstathiou on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @09:01AM (#16536345)
I did 23andMe many years ago around when it first came out (and I therefore have access to certain results others can’t get since this was pre-FDA settlement).

At the time, I ignored the fact that it said I was 4x more likely to develop colon cancer (I was in early 20s). My sister was diagnosed with colon cancer 3 years ago. When you are a woman diagnosed in your early 30s, apparently it is due to genetics. She discovered it by going to three different doctors after insisting she wasn’t feeling well and that it felt “deeply internal”. The doctor who suggested a colonoscopy did so because he had an internship for a year at a cancer clinic in Boston. The others thought it was in her head. Well they found a malicious tumor and the prognosis from the nations leading cancer clinic was to remove her colon, her uterus and ovaries and large intestines (in their entirety). You can imagine this is a lot to ask of anyone. We asked for data that supported the conclusion that if we don’t remove all of these parts the cancer would spread to her ovaries and kill her and there was literally none to be had. It was 100% based on the doctors personal experience (again we were at one of the top clinics in the world for this).

There is something structurally off with the modern medical system. I believe it relies too heavily on anecdotal experience and memory. I don’t know about you but I can’t remember what I ate yesterday. I think services like 23andMe are on to something, if only as a data point to empower patients to self advocate. We did nothing with the data but he moment I got the phone call I couldn’t help but wonder if we could have found this earlier.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by mr_overalls on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @10:00AM (#16536805)
> We asked for data that supported the conclusion. . . and there was literally none to be had. It was 100% based on the doctor's personal experience

On a semi-related note, I've had a few conversations with physicians about the utility of AI in medicine, and all of them seem to be adamantly against any technology that displaces the individual doctor as dictator/hero of the medical hierarchy.

In one memorable exchange with a surgeon (and friend), I pointed out that doctors, like most other educated humans, are pretty terrible at applying statistics to any kind of complex decision-making - and I brought up your observation that doctors are limited to the knowledge/anecdotes/heuristics that fit in their own heads. Why not employ some kind of machine intelligence to at least aid in diagnosis, double-check treatment plans, prevent medical errors, etc? My friend abruptly changed the subject and began waxing poetic about how his decades of experience allowed him to glean enormous amounts of information from the mere tactile sensations of a loop of bowel in his hand during surgery. How would a machine replicate that, he asked. The conversation wasn't even about robotics.

I don't have a lot of faith that doctors - outside of a few pioneers - will begin using medical expert systems until they are forced to.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by milesdyson_phd on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @10:14AM (#16536890)
You bring up a great point. I think a lot of people, not just surgeons, would trust their own experience and intuition over AI (at least initially). Not to mention the whole human characteristic of resisting pretty much any sort of change (even if it's for the better).

I think AI in medicine can be great, especially if you start using it to augment a physician by keeping them up to date with the most recent research/papers/literature on a given topic.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by lefstathiou on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @05:55PM (#16540759)
I've had this conversation with doctors quite a bit. The missing link, in my opinion, is that the mind is an incredible tool only made better with good data. I don't think you or anyone is advocating to replace doctors with a TI-86, we just want data driven / supported decision making and I just can't figure out why we can't bridge that little gap.

I have a spreadsheet that I actively log the total amount of time I spend with my doctors and their staff when I see them in person. All I am going to say is god bless nurse practitioners.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by jonlucc on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @06:07PM (#16540834)
Before, lots of data was based on billing codes, which are a total mess. With electronic medical records, now they can finally collate the data in a meaningful way. Dr. Atul Butte is doing that at UCSF for the entire UC system, but it just didn't exist before a year ago. I just saw a presentation of his a few weeks ago, and he's digging into stuff like "why are there hundreds of treatment paths in the first 12 months for patients diagnosed with T2D at UC hospitals?"
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by slededit on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @08:34PM (#16541568)
A gentleman's hands are already clean - no need to wash before a procedure.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by mistersquid on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @10:05AM (#16536840)
Thank you for sharing these details. It's helpful to know details about aggressive therapeutic regimens doctors might suggest.

Excuse me if I am intruding and do please disregard my question if you prefer not to answer.

I'm presuming your sister did not follow the therapeutic regimen recommended to her. If this is the case, would you mind sharing what treatment she did pursue and whether she is currently in remission?

In any case, I hope your sister is well as she can be. I hope also that you and the rest of your family remain healthy despite your genetic predisposition.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by lefstathiou on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @05:49PM (#16540725)
I appreciate the kind words and don't mind chatting about it at all. My sister taught me that it is much better to talk about these things as it could save someone's life someday. She did take the treatment and the cancer is in remission.

I am happy to chat about this and she is as well to the extent you wish to go straight to the source. After her recovery, she organized a group of young mom's that meet regularly to help each other cope with cancer (and what she considers to be the more onerous issue - the thought of not seeing your kids grow up).

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by merralea on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @11:47PM (#16534311)
I’ve thought since consumer-level genetic testing first came out that there would be a place for a company to do it fully, truly anonymized using tor+crypto or something similar. It’s a bit surprising to me that it doesn’t exist yet; if I had the right background I’d probably go for it myself. There has to be a decent number of people that want to know, but don’t want anyone else to.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by Real_S on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @11:32AM (#16537492)
Unfortunately, there is limited interest in genome privacy. There is also a BIG interest in getting people to surrender their genomes.

""But its for the good of humanity, so don't worry about any possible downside.""

Personally, I am trying to develop molecular cryptography, so that genetic data can be protected even if, theoretically, we cannot trust our computers.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by benwilber0 on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @11:52PM (#16534322)
> anonymized using tor+crypto

I'm sure sure how that would work? How do you send a bio sample over the internet?

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by merralea on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:12AM (#16534398)
It would have to be something to the effect of getting the kit in a store and sending it in with a public key and no return address. They check that the associated account has paid, run whatever analysis and add the encrypted results to the account. The major bottleneck is probably getting the kits to the user; workarounds I can think of that don’t involve having your own kit available in stores would be either having a list of generic kits that would work or piggybacking off of 23andme’s distribution and accepting their kits (though I’m sure they wouldn’t be happy about that, to say the least).
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by Ultimatt on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @04:35AM (#16535279)
I mean this is already how almost all sequencing labs around the world work...
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by lozaning on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:17AM (#16534413)
Im imagining some kind of system where:

The Alice company would either put DNA collection kits for sale on Amazon or tell people where they can buy a kit that meets the required criteria for collection.

Then people pay the company in bitcoin (how to separate your bitcoins from your identity is left as a exercise for the user) and once they've paid they're provided an input field to enter a public key they've generated.

The website would then generate a barcode you'd use to label your sample before mailing it in, or it could be a QR code of your public key.

When a sample arrives at the lab they scan the barcode, and check to ensure that there is a public key tied to that bar code and that they've paid.

They then run the sample and publish the results online, accessible to all, but also encrypted with that users public key.

The user then checks the website every day for week after they've sent their sample in. Once they find their results by searching all results for the one labeled with their public key they download the results and then use their private key to unencrypt them.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by gnarbarian on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:15AM (#16534407)
I did 23andme back before they had to stop doing some of the medical stuff. They discovered a serious and potentially harmful mutation that I had. I showed my GP who then confirmed it with other tests. It's something that could kill me, and knowing about it allows me to avoid situations where it could.

The ancestry stuff is really really cool too. I'm 2.7% neanderthal! My whole family discovered aspects of our history that we didn't expect.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by shdh on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:25AM (#16534457)
Check out https://promethease.com/ if you want more information.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by alex- on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @11:32PM (#16534256)
It really is scary. They claim to anonymise the data, but to me it feels like removing your name and address from your DNA is like removing the make and model from a car schematic (where only one model was produced).
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by seibelj on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @11:31PM (#16534251)
I wanted to know. It turns out I’m a carrier for cystic fibrosis, and my wife is not. If we were both carriers, we might have chosen to adopt children rather than have our own. So there is more to learn than just your future health. It’s also interesting seeing who my distant cousins are.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by corvallis on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @11:57PM (#16534343)
Pre-conception genetic testing is also available through normal healthcare avenues. It even comes with highly trained genetic counselors.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by fragmede on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @03:16AM (#16535025)
> normal healthcare avenues

It's worth noting that's not a selling point for many Americans.

From incomprehensible billing and having to fight for coverage with health insurance, to dealing with antiquated offices (fax? really?), never mind the hassle of scheduling an appointment over the phone, going in to an office, and seeing a doctor who's rushing you out the door, "normal healthcare avenues" is cumbersome, and persists only due to lack of real competition in the marketplace. (The doctor, of which there are really truly awesome ones, is a cog in a far larger machine.)

Still, the technology that allows us to screen a fetus at 12-weeks of pregnancy is quite impressive.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by afsina on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:13AM (#16534402)
Probably very expensive.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by brokensegue on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:02PM (#16537764)
probably covered through insurance
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by mc32 on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:23AM (#16534443)
Of special concern would be entities like FB and LinkedIn having thins kind of data _and_ availing it to private health insurance as well as potential future private sector employers.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by Ultimatt on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @04:38AM (#16535285)
The insurance argument for genetics is incredibly over blown. Very few people have some large quantifiable risk with high certainty found from their genetics. Something like a smart watch mobile phone fitness app that records you are clinically obese and dont move around is far more of a problem than your genetics will ever be. Just because you have the genetic potential for higher or lower risk is nothing compared to measuring the actual state of your person right this second and over your lifetime. I work for a company that records and uses both simultaneously. Trust me when I say your smart watch with a heart rate monitor is probably about 1000x the existential threat to your insurance premium. The genetics is helpful for parameterising models and adjusting you from say an "average" human. But there is nothing like actually measuring daily who you are. The power of that data is actually incredible.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by Kelbit on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @12:04AM (#16534378)
Aren't these PCR tests against known sequences of base pairs? It's not like they're sequencing your DNA or anything, they are just testing for the presence of selected markers. I don't think the data they have is meaningful outside the context of the tests.
Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by epistasis on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @01:03AM (#16534572)
It's a SNP chip, not PCR, but similar level of information at ~100k sites.

Definitely not sequencing, though.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by nickysielicki on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @01:57AM (#16534753)
I feel I'm in an interesting scenario in that both of my parents have done 23andme, but I have all the concerns you have.

You're not just making this choice for yourself, you're making it (to some degree) for everyone you are or will ever be related to. That has profound implications that people aren't entirely considering when they spend the $50 (or whatever) and spit in a cup.

Re:23andMe Granted FDA Authorization for Genetic Test on Can... by bpevsner on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @11:42PM (#16534293)
I wonder... GDPR probably covers this, right? So EU citizens probably have the right to have this data erased adter they learn what they need to?