On a semi-related note, I've had a few conversations with physicians about the utility of AI in medicine, and all of them seem to be adamantly against any technology that displaces the individual doctor as dictator/hero of the medical hierarchy.
In one memorable exchange with a surgeon (and friend), I pointed out that doctors, like most other educated humans, are pretty terrible at applying statistics to any kind of complex decision-making - and I brought up your observation that doctors are limited to the knowledge/anecdotes/heuristics that fit in their own heads. Why not employ some kind of machine intelligence to at least aid in diagnosis, double-check treatment plans, prevent medical errors, etc? My friend abruptly changed the subject and began waxing poetic about how his decades of experience allowed him to glean enormous amounts of information from the mere tactile sensations of a loop of bowel in his hand during surgery. How would a machine replicate that, he asked. The conversation wasn't even about robotics.
I don't have a lot of faith that doctors - outside of a few pioneers - will begin using medical expert systems until they are forced to.
I think AI in medicine can be great, especially if you start using it to augment a physician by keeping them up to date with the most recent research/papers/literature on a given topic.
I have a spreadsheet that I actively log the total amount of time I spend with my doctors and their staff when I see them in person. All I am going to say is god bless nurse practitioners.
Excuse me if I am intruding and do please disregard my question if you prefer not to answer.
I'm presuming your sister did not follow the therapeutic regimen recommended to her. If this is the case, would you mind sharing what treatment she did pursue and whether she is currently in remission?
In any case, I hope your sister is well as she can be. I hope also that you and the rest of your family remain healthy despite your genetic predisposition.
I am happy to chat about this and she is as well to the extent you wish to go straight to the source. After her recovery, she organized a group of young mom's that meet regularly to help each other cope with cancer (and what she considers to be the more onerous issue - the thought of not seeing your kids grow up).
At the time, I ignored the fact that it said I was 4x more likely to develop colon cancer (I was in early 20s). My sister was diagnosed with colon cancer 3 years ago. When you are a woman diagnosed in your early 30s, apparently it is due to genetics. She discovered it by going to three different doctors after insisting she wasn’t feeling well and that it felt “deeply internal”. The doctor who suggested a colonoscopy did so because he had an internship for a year at a cancer clinic in Boston. The others thought it was in her head. Well they found a malicious tumor and the prognosis from the nations leading cancer clinic was to remove her colon, her uterus and ovaries and large intestines (in their entirety). You can imagine this is a lot to ask of anyone. We asked for data that supported the conclusion that if we don’t remove all of these parts the cancer would spread to her ovaries and kill her and there was literally none to be had. It was 100% based on the doctors personal experience (again we were at one of the top clinics in the world for this).
There is something structurally off with the modern medical system. I believe it relies too heavily on anecdotal experience and memory. I don’t know about you but I can’t remember what I ate yesterday. I think services like 23andMe are on to something, if only as a data point to empower patients to self advocate. We did nothing with the data but he moment I got the phone call I couldn’t help but wonder if we could have found this earlier.