News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by cddotdotslash on Monday February 26, 2018 @10:57AM (#16466197)
The best part about tech in NYC is that it isn't a non-stop, in-your-face bubble the way that it is in SF/SJ. I work in tech but enjoy having friends in fashion, finance, real estate, advertising, etc. The conversations here are much more diverse. Interestingly, that same diversity helps improve the tech sector.
Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by technofiend on Monday February 26, 2018 @11:41AM (#16466600)
I can't help but wonder if the recent tax changes will have any effect in consolidating East Coast tech jobs. Previously you could live in NJ and work in Manhattan and write off the respective taxes of each. Now it's my understanding you'd be better served (for example) living and working solely in New Jersey.

See [1] for an actual discussion on the tax law changes

    State and local taxes.
    Taxpayers can deduct a maximum of $10,000
    from the total of their state and local income
    taxes or sales taxes, and their property taxes
    (added together), a measure that might hurt
    itemizers in high-tax states such as California,
    New York and New Jersey. The $10,000 cap applies
    whether you are single or married filing jointly;
    if you are married filing separately, it drops to
    $5,000.
[1] https://www.investopedia.com/taxes/how-gop-tax-bill-affects-...

Based on that maybe we'll see clustering on each side of the river? Entirely speculation on my part, of course.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by lotsofpulp on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:04PM (#16466839)
I don't see what the federal tax changes would have to do with commuting from NJ to NY?

The change in federal law has to do with deducting the total amount of state and local taxes paid, which is, going forward, capped at $10k. New Jersey credits any tax paid to New York, which is staying the same.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by technofiend on Monday February 26, 2018 @03:50PM (#16468847)
> New Jersey credits any tax paid to New York, which is staying the same.

1) I was concerned that may no longer be the case, so thanks for that, but 2) if your net tax burden is > $10k because of double taxation then doesn't it make sense to exit one of the two places taxing you, thus lowering your overall burden? I.E. Even if NJ Tax is $6k and NYC is $5K that still means there's a $1k incentive to no longer work in one place and live in the other. That's my point.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by lotsofpulp on Monday February 26, 2018 @04:09PM (#16468982)
"Double taxation" would be if you paid income tax in full to both NJ and NY, but that's not what happens since NJ provides a dollar for dollar credit for the income tax you pay to NY. Therefore, you only ever pay the maximum of either the income tax you owe NJ or the income tax you owe NY.

You're right that the new federal tax law could incentivize people to move from places with higher state and local taxes to places with lower state and local taxes, but the differences between NJ/NY/CT are negligible. The only big difference would be moving out of New York City, as that would save you up to ~20% (federal tax rate) of 3.5% (NYC income tax rate) of your income, but I doubt many people are willing to trade in their quality of life in NYC just for that.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by mdolon on Monday February 26, 2018 @11:29AM (#16466473)
This was a critical factor that led to me relocating from SF to NYC. While it's nice having every tech giant and startup in close proximity, the homogenous conversations and social interactions were a huge drawback.

There's definitely a trade-off -- while it's nice being exposed to the issues people experience in a variety of industries, it was nice having easy access to engineers/friends willing to hack on ideas in SF.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by elefanten on Monday February 26, 2018 @11:47AM (#16466670)
Sounds like something of your own making. Actual tech employees in the Bay Area are still an overwhelming minority of people. Yes, tech is more of a minority in NY and NY is more of a hub for other industries.

But if you only hung out with tech employees in SF, that was a bubble of your own creation.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by mdolon on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:13PM (#16466903)
Having lived in both SOMA and the Mission, I wholeheartedly disagree. The vast majority of people I met at coffee shops, restaurants or bars in the city worked in tech.

Living in Manhattan (East Village) and Brooklyn provided a completely different experience. It was a rare to meet people who work in tech.

In both circumstances, I haven't been going out of my way to try to meet people in any specific industry.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by randomdata on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:25PM (#16467022)
> Having lived in both SOMA and the Mission, I wholeheartedly disagree.

No need to rely on anecdotes though. According to San Francisco’s Controller’s Office, a little over 6% of the population work in the tech industry[1]. That is an unquestionably small minority of the overall population.

If the people you have met predominantly worked in tech, it is likely due to a bubble you created yourself. Perhaps, for example, the majority of the population outside of tech cannot afford to spend time at those coffee shops and restaurants?

[1] https://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/03/20/why-san-francisco-...

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by mbesto on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:41PM (#16467179)
> the majority of the population outside of tech cannot afford to spend time at those coffee shops and restaurants?

That's probably the parent's point - your likely to see more people in your cohort in NYC that don't work in tech then those that do.

> According to San Francisco’s Controller’s Office, a little over 6% of the population work in the tech industry[1]. That is an unquestionably small minority of the overall population.

SF is just one part of the bay area. Head down to PAMPA and MV/Cupertino where the big employers are and I'd be willing to bet that % is much higher.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by CydeWeys on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:56PM (#16467335)
Now what % of people between the ages of, say 22-30 in SF work in tech? A bit more than 6%. You aren't "creating a bubble" simply by hanging out with people your own age or liking certain foods or cafes. The fact is that in NYC there are plenty of young working professionals who are not in tech, who you will meet without having to go out of your way to alter you own interests.
Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by randomdata on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:28AM (#16474965)
> You aren't "creating a bubble" simply by hanging out with people your own age or liking certain foods or cafes.

If that is not the epitome of a bubble, what is? I completely understand why someone might find themselves in that kind of bubble, and even like it that way, but that is not the same as the bubble not existing. I expect you will find that 22-30 year olds in SF themselves are a minority.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by CydeWeys on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @11:28AM (#16484067)
People have always hung out with their own age cohort. This isn't anything special or unique to SF, and it doesn't "make it a bubble". What makes it a bubble is that that age cohort in SF is so tech-focused, in a way that it isn't in other cities. So when you do the perfectly natural thing of hanging out with other people your own age in, say, NYC, you get a variety of professions and types of people. When you do it in SF, you end up with mostly techies.
Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by randomdata on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @11:46AM (#16484261)
> People have always hung out with their own age cohort.

That does not mean they are not living in a bubble. There are always people in other age cohorts that they could associate with. Nobody is saying that bubbles are not natural. You find them everywhere in nature! It is indeed natural to be in a bubble with your own age cohort, but remains a bubble of your own making. There is absolutely nothing stopping you from popping that bubble and exposing yourself to people in other age groups and careers. After all, those outside the bubble represent the majority of the population.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by timr on Monday February 26, 2018 @02:01PM (#16467942)
"If the people you have met predominantly worked in tech, it is likely due to a bubble you created yourself. Perhaps, for example, the majority of the population outside of tech cannot afford to spend time at those coffee shops and restaurants?"

And yet, since moving from SF (after nearly a decade) to NYC, I can confirm the OP's observation that I rarely encounter people who work at tech companies, anywhere in the city. Regardless of whether or not you think we're creating a bubble for ourselves by how we live our lives, the reality is that the bubble is different in New York. And it's not like there aren't tech workers here: there are just a lot more of other kinds of people.

For me, personally, it's refreshing. San Francisco has descended into a form of groupthink self-parody that is uninspiring for people who like to make new things.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by randomdata on Monday February 26, 2018 @02:27PM (#16468181)
> the reality is that the bubble is different in New York.

I think that goes without saying. 6% is a minority, but 6% all working in the same industry remains significant. Where I currently live one of the largest industries makes up about 3% of the workforce. And even at that lower rate it already feels like everyone I meet works in that particular industry. Just imagine what 6% is like. I am not at all surprised that it feels like nobody does anything other than tech. 6% is staggering!

Nobody denies that SF (and the Valley in general) is heavily weighted towards tech professionals. With 6% of the population involved, they are going to be everywhere. However, they still only make up a minority share of the entire population. There should be no shortage of opportunity to find people doing other things.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by mdolon on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:50PM (#16467288)
Sorry, I was simply sharing my own experience and point of view. Please do treat it as such.

You can also say I created my own bubble by choosing to live in SOMA and the Mission (or anywhere downtown SF in general). I'm just sharing my experience of encountering mostly tech employees in those neighborhoods. If you've experienced otherwise, kudos to you! :)

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by toephu2 on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:46PM (#16467243)
"a little over 6% of the population work in the tech industry"

That was in 2013. 5 years ago. That article doesn't provide a source for that number either, it simply quotes the chief economist for San Francisco’s Controller’s Office who also doesn't provide a source. I'm sure the number is much higher now.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by savagedata on Monday February 26, 2018 @05:06PM (#16469407)
I couldn't find a more recent source (this is from 2013), but it claims that 12% of SF (San Francisco-San Mateo-Redwood City, CA) jobs are in "high tech" and 29% of San Jose-Sunnyvale-Santa Clara, CA jobs. My guess is the difference between the two sources is that yours is looking at the whole population, which would include children and retired folks.

Close to a third of jobs in one region being in tech is an insanely high number, and it's no wonder that people would feel that the Bay Area is lacking diversity.

https://web.archive.org/web/20130308072135/http://www.bayare...

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by JackFr on Monday February 26, 2018 @01:41PM (#16467774)
> a little over 6% of the population work in the tech industry

I'm sure many people are cooks, janitors, bus drivers and the like and I'm sure a many people work for the the state, county or city (especially including healthcare). Any city needs services both private and municipal -- but they are not the driver of the economic engine.

I imagine that 6% would be much higher if we excluded non-service, non-municipal jobs.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by adrianparsons on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:15PM (#16466934)
I completely agree.

I also love the influence NYC industries have on tech startups. Warby Parker is tech+fashion, Buzzfeed is tech+media, Betterment is tech+finance.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by longerthoughts on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:58PM (#16467351)
Seems like it's time to stop calling companies tech companies just because they hire software engineers and leverage some degree of modern technology to provide their product or service. Warby Parker sells glasses and Buzzfeed is a media company - I have a hard time seeing how either of these qualify as tech startups.
Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by Cd00d on Monday February 26, 2018 @01:20PM (#16467580)
There's a meet up group here in NYC called Tech in Motion, and a few years ago launched an annual awards event. The company that won 'Best Tech Company of the Year' was Casper, and my only thought was 'selling mattresses through the mail is considered technology'?
Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by longerthoughts on Monday February 26, 2018 @01:32PM (#16467688)
Perfect example. I guess at some point along the way the familiar tech startup narrative got peoples' minds to associate all startups with tech.

Makes me wonder where the line is. What qualifies a company as a tech company? Software/computing services/hardware as a primary revenue source?

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by Apocryphon on Monday February 26, 2018 @02:08PM (#16468032)
Then, are Uber, Lyft, on demand services even tech? Aren't they just fancy logistics/transport/delivery companies?

Is Amazon only tech when it comes down to AWS and Alexa?

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by longerthoughts on Monday February 26, 2018 @02:45PM (#16468318)
>Then, are Uber, Lyft, on demand services even tech?

I would argue that they are not. They provide services that rely on technology and have been incredibly successful largely due to their embrace of technology, but I would describe Uber as on-demand transportation provider rather than a technology provider.

>Is Amazon only tech when it comes down to AWS and Alexa?

I understand calling Amazon a tech company because they have significant business lines as a technology provider, even if these do not constitute their entire business.

While I have intuitive responses to companies like these, I really don't know where the line is (e.g. how much business one would have to do as a tech provider). I didn't intend to suggest a hard definition but posed the question because I'm genuinely interested in seeing peoples' thoughts on what constitutes a tech company.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by adrianparsons on Monday February 26, 2018 @02:18PM (#16468109)
pg has some thoughts on what a "startup" is [0].

I used Warby Parker as an example because their business model is disruptive, they're high-growth, and they leverage technology. I think the disruption and innovation are really important aspects.

0: http://www.paulgraham.com/growth.html

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by longerthoughts on Monday February 26, 2018 @02:56PM (#16468402)
Note that PG is addressing startups generally and not limiting his discussion to tech startups. From the third sentence in the post you linked:

>"Nor is it necessary for a startup to work on technology..."

I absolutely agree that Warby Parker has a disruptive business model and see them as a shining example of an innovative startup, I just wouldn't call them a tech startup because tech is not their business.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by adrianparsons on Monday February 26, 2018 @03:13PM (#16468567)
Ah, gotcha. That makes some sense to me.

Would you call pre-streaming Netflix a tech startup? It feels like a startup to me, but at first it was just Blockbuster through the mail.

Maybe the difficulty in categorizing is that every company today has to use technology. When Netflix started out, getting a DVD in the mail was pretty novel. Nowadays, e-commerce doesn't have quite the "wow" factor it used to.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by longerthoughts on Monday February 26, 2018 @04:08PM (#16468978)
>Would you call pre-streaming Netflix a tech startup?

Startup, but not a tech startup.

>Maybe the difficulty in categorizing is that every company today has to use technology.

Yep, this is exactly what I was trying to get at. That being the case, it seems more accurate to shape a definition of "tech" companies based on output (i.e. products/services offered) rather than input (i.e. tools employed).

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by cylinder on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:41AM (#16472397)
Apparently if your e-commerce site has trendy enough fonts, you're a tech startup
Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by giantsloth on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:27PM (#16467037)
I find statements like this both cringe and problematic. The heavy emphasis on industry defined identity is creepy, extremely impersonal, and backwards.

I've been a software developer in advertising, various startups and have friends in fashion and finance. While sure you can get some interesting insights into their industries, for example Gucci's new operating room spread is dope af, or the fact that hedge funds year over year make 20% on average using their "genius quants" (aka insider trading), I find that the actual people themselves are a relatively homogenous subculture across industries. That is a typically upper middle class white with a BS/BA in econ/finance/cs/communications who got "really drunk" in college, "loves" IPAs now and does sober February's as a challenge.

These are all various shades of yuppie identity non-diverse in thought, culture, or world perspective. They are boring.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by stcredzero on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:48PM (#16467252)
> > The best part about tech in NYC is that it isn't a non-stop, in-your-face bubble the way that it is in SF/SJ

> I find statements like this both cringe and problematic.

I think the 1st sentence of the 1st comment is amusingly and inadvertently supported by the 2nd.

These are all various shades of yuppie identity non-diverse in thought, culture, or world perspective. They are boring.

You're painting with a pretty broad brush there, yourself.

The diversity of thought and culture in the NYC area is breathtaking. It takes a lot of effort to navigate it at times, but it's definitely there. Hundreds of years worth. It used to be that the North East of the US kinda was the US. Half of the soldiers who went to fight in Europe in WWI were from New York state alone.

A big part of US history of the 20th century has been the demographic, economic, and cultural shift away from the North East to the West and South. As a part of this, it's only natural that a new intelligentsia would arise on the West Coast and pooh-pooh the North East. It's a very common historical pattern. However, when it comes down to it, people living, thinking, and working in close proximity will create cultural value. To denigrate this is to throw out the baby with the bathwater if you are a humanist, or a progressive.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by byproxy on Monday February 26, 2018 @01:15PM (#16467529)
I've always thought the stereotype was that of the metropolitan North East pooh-pooh-ing the West, e.g. : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MaCXa3ZSH8
Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by stcredzero on Monday February 26, 2018 @01:38PM (#16467751)
the metropolitan North East pooh-pooh-ing the West

That's the other side of the historical pattern. It also happened between Europe and the "New World."

My Louisiana Creole girlfriend (at the time) and I showed up for a concert with Joanna Newsom and Phillip Glass. Let me assure you that there are older West Coast elites who can wonder aloud about you and look down their nose at you just as much as Mainline and old New England preppies. (Basically the fans of Phillip Glass wondering about the Joanna Newsom fandom hoi polloi.)

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by dsacco on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:53PM (#16467307)
Your “genius quants (aka insider trading)” quote is an easy target, but instead I’m going to respond to this:

> That is a typically upper middle class white with a BS/BA in econ/finance/cs/communications who got "really drunk" in college, "loves" IPAs now and does sober February's as a challenge.

These are all various shades of yuppie identity non-diverse in thought, culture, or world perspective. They are boring.

Speaking as someone who is a software engineer in NY, your broad generalization has not been my experience, nor does it apply to me. Moreover, I consider it pretty dismissive to reduce such a wide swath of people to the stereotypical yuppie. According to you, software engineers are homogenous and boring.

If you really can’t find more diversity in the conversations you’re having, I strongly encourage you to seek out more diverse people. To put this politely: the lack of self awareness you’re evidencing in this comment borders on hubris.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by sinker on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @03:25AM (#16481553)
You're missing the point. He meant that the differences you see (what you call diversity) are superficial differences. When you look deeper past these differences (job, skin color, neighborhood, etc) you find that people in NY, professionals at least, are actually very similar.

I don't agree 100% with this sentiment, but I doubt the OP does either.

What I agree with is that "diverse" has become a stupid word. Diverse is used nowadays to indicate only superficial differences. If you see a black man, a lesbian, a asian woman, and a hispanic girl together in the same office, you have diversity. Yet they're all in the same office, have the same standard of education, are just about the same age, probably have the same political affiliations, grew up in roughly the same geographic area, etc. Is it really diverse?

Culturally, not so much. But NY is not so different from any other place. People near each other tend to be similar. I just wish we would stop regurgitating the word "diverse."

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by untog on Monday February 26, 2018 @01:31PM (#16467679)
If you're not experiencing variety of culture and thought in New York City then, frankly, you're doing something very wrong.

The OP's statement wasn't limited to software developers, who I agree still tend to be a relatively homogenous group even in NYC. But you really ought to stop outside your professional circle once in a while. If you go to a bar in SV it's nothing but people in tech, talking about tech. If you go to a bar in NYC you don't see it anywhere near as much.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by ikeyany on Monday February 26, 2018 @01:21PM (#16467586)
Hey that's not true.

There's plenty of upper middle class Asians too.

Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by camgunz on Monday February 26, 2018 @02:18PM (#16468106)
There are infinite subcultures in NYC. I'm as misanthropic as the next guy so I identify with what you said a little, but honestly no matter what you're into you can find your people here. Probably more than anywhere else in the world, actually.
Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by rch on Monday February 26, 2018 @11:52AM (#16466724)
Agreed. Although I did miss meeting engineers from other disciplines (EE, Mechanical, Chem. E., etc). I'm not sure if they are simply scarce in Manhattan, or if I was in the wrong places.
Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by mdolon on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:05PM (#16466850)
There are a ton of tech meetups in the city, check them out. https://www.meetup.com/find/tech/?allMeetups=false&radius=5&...
Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by rch on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:11PM (#16466891)
I did, and they were fine. Still no aerospace engineers or plasma physicists (for example).
Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by lotsofpulp on Monday February 26, 2018 @11:57AM (#16466774)
I'm assuming that a greater portion of that type of work isn't do-able in an office farm. Businesses need to make a certain amount of money per square foot, so labs and whatnot aren't feasible.
Re:Tech takes over: New York is the sector's second city by tomkarlo on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:49PM (#16467267)
Given the share of SP500 profits that the Google/FB/Apple/Amazon gang currently capture, it's hard to describe it as a "bubble". Maybe "corporate hegemony"... but the situation is SF/SJ at this point is clearly driven by actual cash profits, not speculation, at this point. E.g. Google alone apparently owns the equivalent of 14 Salesforce Towers (the largest building in SF) worth of commercial real estate.