News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:21AM (#16459606)
? It's his money that he actually decided to give away why should you or I have a say in it?
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by makotech222 on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:27AM (#16459639)
The argument is, why do we as a society allow people to amass wealth on the scale of nations. Instead, perhaps that wealth should be democratically owned, and then put towards what the society needs, rather than what one person decides.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by scarface74 on Sunday February 25, 2018 @01:45PM (#16460421)
While you are thinking that "we" shouldn't allow "them" to amass that type of wealth, remember that the average household income in the United States is $60,0000 a year. If you are an average experienced developer in a major city in the US - especially if you are part of a dual income household -you are probably in the 85-90th percentile.

Meaning when people start voting in policies that "tax the rich", you will probably be considered one of "them" by the average working class American.

Look no further than the new tax code that basically hurt the "rich" in places like CA and NY.

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @02:39PM (#16460725)
Very good point. People love to frame it in us vs them not realizing that most likely to majority of the world you are likely one of "them".
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by ianai on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:33AM (#16459670)
Two things can happen. We can be a society that ensures social needs are met while allowing vast concentrations of wealth.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by leetcrew on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:55AM (#16459806)
> We can be a society that ensures social needs are met while allowing vast concentrations of wealth.

I don't know exactly what you mean by "social needs" here. you could be referring to a specific level on the mazlow hierarchy, if so, I'd like to know why you pick this specific level as the benchmark. or you might be referring to some more vague concept of societal needs.

the particular definition of "needs" is very important to the validity of the quoted claim. if basic or "social" needs are defined as some absolute standard of living, this will be increasingly easy to fulfill as society grows richer.

I very rarely see anyone talking about needs this way though. instead, the definition of needs seems to move as people at the top grow more wealthy. it seems more likely to me that, as long as billionaires exist and live lavish lifestyles, people will never agree that their needs are being met.

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by Daishiman on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:56AM (#16459815)
That is, historically, false. Concentration of wealth always ends up implying power, whether soft or hard. Having such amount of power outside of democratic institutions is a threat .
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by tatersolid on Sunday February 25, 2018 @10:26PM (#16462852)
This is, historically, true: in communist countries with “equal sharing of misery”, power and wealth was 100% concentrated into the hands of a few elites or outright tyrants.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by ryukafalz on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:56AM (#16459811)
Perhaps we could be. But that's not the society we live in today, and has that ever happened before?
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:32AM (#16459666)
What is "democratically owned"? State owned companies? That has being tried did not work out too well.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by sgift on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:38AM (#16459698)
That works very well and is used in many countries. What didn't work well is a state-owned economy. Two different things.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:43AM (#16459727)
OK give a single example that is not related to raw material extraction or power generation. (A company receiving massive government subsidies to not go bankrupt would not be considered a good example at least in my opinion.)
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by Daishiman on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:02PM (#16459845)
Most European public transportation companies have a majority stake by the government, and they work exceptionally well in executing their mission. A huge amount of banks are government-owned and they're as profitable as their private counterparts.

There's a huge number of examples (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_government-owned_compa...).

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:26PM (#16459990)
Most public transportation companies are subsidized. I never dealt with gov. bank that was run well but there are might be some that are. I def never heard of gov. owned software company that was doing well though.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by BerislavLopac on Monday February 26, 2018 @04:01AM (#16464062)
That is the whole point. State-owned companies make total sense when their goal is to ensure some common benefit (like mass transport, public utilities, health care etc), as opposed to making profit. With that in mind, subsidies are logical, because the alternative is to have a purely state-owned system (like police or military) which has no income except for government subsidies.

Essentially, if you think of government subsidies to private companies as assistance in making profit (which happens often when a government wants to promote a certain industry, even if it's only in form of a tax cut), having commercial companies to take care of common utilities is a way to assist the government paying for those utilities.

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by TomMarius on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:18PM (#16459942)
Can you post some examples where it works well?
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by allendoerfer on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:27PM (#16460000)
VW, the largest car company in the world, is partly state-owned. Same for Deutsche Bahn, KfW bank and a few others. They don't always work perfectly, but they sure can compete or are even market leaders.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by TomMarius on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:51PM (#16460142)
>They don't always work perfectly, but they sure can compete or are even market leaders.

Most of the time it's because these companies are government-approved monopoly (no other company can enter the market) or because they're heavily subsidised using taxes (no other company can enter the market practically because competing against someone who you fund at the same time is impossible and because the prices are below the actual expenses) and are actually losing huge amounts of money. Typically railways all around Europe are not profitable at all.

Volkswagen is a very special case, but you're partially right. I'd say it's an exception to the rule though.

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @01:03PM (#16460214)
VW is not really an exception Porsche family controls majority of voting rights in VW AG.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by TomMarius on Sunday February 25, 2018 @02:31PM (#16460687)
Yeah. I said he was partially right because it's true that the government had some influence in the past so VW can technically be considered a success.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:41PM (#16460078)
VW is not run by government appointed managers and gorvernment does not have control of the votes. Now even if it did I doubt we want to use VW as an example of good corp. citizen.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by allendoerfer on Sunday February 25, 2018 @01:14PM (#16460268)
VW basically does what everybody else is doing (see news about Daimler and BMW). The state-owned aspect changes nothing, it just says that 30% of VWs profits go into the pockets of the German state of Niedersachsen instead of the pockets of a private investor.

That was the key point of the original discussion about Gates' money and rising inequality, so the example is very valid.

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @01:33PM (#16460365)
It's valid in a sense that if government does not control voting rights and plays no role in day to day operations sure there is no difference. If you start taxing the stock and transferring stock to government eventually government will have control of all entities though.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by bmelton on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:11PM (#16459909)
Because we, as a society, allow people to do things that we don't like. We aren't usually very good at it, but when you consider that it affords people the luxuries of doing things that others might not approve of, like having a relationship or marriage with a member of the same sex, or creating video games with unpopular themes, or creating rap music, or burning the American flag, etc.

If we only allowed people to do the things that everyone approved of, we wouldn't actually allow people to do very much at all. Freedom, art, society, and speech would all suffer.

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by ryandrake on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:41AM (#16459716)
I think the point is, we're extraordinarily lucky that he is choosing to use his money for good rather than for evil (for whatever definition of good and evil exists). The idea that the public should not be involved with determining what counts as "public good" is super risky.

The problem with relying on philanthropy to fund the public good is that we the people are counting on the philanthropist to have goals that align with our goals. Imagine a world where the top two richest guys, instead of deciding to use their wealth to fund vaccines and education, used it to fund warlords and dictators. We could have just as easily gotten that dice roll instead of the Warren Buffet and Bill Gates world.

This is ostensibly one of the reasons "we" choose to democratically organize a government to fund the public good: So that we're not so reliant on the whims of a few rich people. It's to avoid the nightmare scenario where the worlds richest person decides instead to use his money for evil. Not saying that government can't use their power for evil, just that, at least in theory, we can vote in new government. We can't vote for different World's Richest People.

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by dotancohen on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:50AM (#16459767)
> Imagine a world where the top two richest guys, instead of deciding to use their wealth to fund vaccines and education, used it to fund warlords and dictators. We could have just as easily gotten that dice roll instead of the Warren Buffet and Bill Gates world.

Actually, you did get that dice roll too. Look up the house of Saud.

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by braderhart on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:07PM (#16459880)
Imagine how much further we could be if Microsoft didn't spend all that money subverting open source efforts, and spending infinite money to create a new generation of crippled developers.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:49PM (#16460132)
It's an interesting question I know a lot of people for whom desire to unseat MS was a major driver in the amount of effort they dedicated to various open source proj. Would truly be interesting to see how things would look if MS did not reach it's dominant position. (One possible outcome could have being that IBM would've remained in it's dominant position).
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by hawkice on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:46AM (#16459743)
This is deeply strange to me. If he wanted to support an evil empire or grow a petroleum multinational, you admit you'd have no say. But Gates wants to serve the public good -- now suddenly you're in charge. Seems backwards, at the very least.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by ryandrake on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:59AM (#16459827)
I'm saying we, the public, are not in charge either way, and we're very lucky he wants to actually serve the public good.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:47AM (#16459750)
"The idea that the public should not be involved with determining what counts as "public good" is super risky". You are involved in democratic process that drives the laws being passed which not only can determine "public good" but actually enforce behavior that will maximize "public good".
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by icebraining on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:40AM (#16459710)
1) Why is it their money? Were the processes that funneled all that money to a single person, fair? Or are they overcompensating certain individuals? Even if we think "the deal is done" in this case, should we change things for the future?

2) We impose many restrictions on use of money. Some things can't be bought at any price; others already have restrictions (e.g. campaign contribution limits). Are all of these inadmissible?

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by kthejoker2 on Friday March 02, 2018 @06:57PM (#16506844)
If someone in their garage invented teleportation or a cure for cancer or a battery that ran on happy thoughts, why would it not be their money?

I'm not saying this is the case I Bill Gates but I'm not sure of any other way to encourage risk taking at the bottom except the promise of obscene wealth.

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by madez on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:44AM (#16459733)
It's so trivially obvious and endlessly discussed that things are taken away from individuals by the society for the greater good, for example with taxes, that your comment has no substance and gives no insight.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:54AM (#16459803)
He is not trading in money he is trading in ownership to give to charity. There are many individuals that are not doing that and for the most part no country is taxing owning stock.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by madez on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:05PM (#16459861)
I avoided focussing on the financial aspect, because even ownership of things/lands/rights can be, and is taken away from individuals by the society under certain conditions.

It is intellectually lazy and moot to say everybody is free to do what they want with what they have (be it money or not) because that's not how we live nor want to live.

A proposal to take from an inidivual for the greater good can be worth a discussion. Just crying out for extremist, reality-ignoring individualism is not an acceptable comment worthy of HN, in my eyes.

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:31PM (#16460024)
Coming from USSR no surprise to me that left leaning individuals deem it acceptable to determine what is worthy or not worthy to be discussed. Those certain conditions are very narrow and in societies were they are not narrow USSR, North Korea etc. things have not worked out too well.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by madez on Sunday February 25, 2018 @01:58PM (#16460494)
There are successful countries with very high taxes and other means by which the society takes from individuals. Just the amount of how much is taken is not an important metric. It does not matter how much is taken, but under what circumstances, i.e. is it equal law and equally binding for everybody, was it decided in a democratic way, is it used for what it is intended for, and can it practically and effectively be challenged in a fair trial?

Please, let's discuss proposals, but reasonably and with thoughtful arguments, and not with "? It's his money that he actually decided to give away why should you or I have a say in it?".

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @02:33PM (#16460699)
Give an example of successful country where ownership of stock is taxed.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by Erwin on Sunday February 25, 2018 @05:58PM (#16461717)
As I understand it, Netherlands have a wealth tax: rather than tax capital gains, net ownership is taxed at a 30% rate of assumed gain. So essentially you pay 0.6 to 1.5% of your shares, non-primary housing etc. in wealth tax depending on size of your assets.

http://taxsummaries.pwc.com/ID/Netherlands-Individual-Income...

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @07:51PM (#16462208)
very reasonable system (although can be easy circumvented by moving). It would not have prevented anyone from accumulating the wealth that everyone is complaining about in this thread though.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by madez on Sunday February 25, 2018 @03:56PM (#16461119)
Article 106 of the german Grundgesetz/constitution states that in Germany there is an ownership tax. It was used until 1997 when the former practice was ruled unlawful, but no adopted form of collection was introduced, while the government still has the right to collect ownership tax. There is an ongoing debate about reinstating the collection.

AFAIK, France is currently collecting ownership tax.

The USSR and North Korea suck because they are autocratic, corrupted regimes, not because of single aspects of how they run their economies.

But even beside specific examples, if we decide that it is a good thing, then we can introduce new law.

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by lkbm on Sunday February 25, 2018 @02:40PM (#16460732)
Why does it need to be ownership? Doesn't capital gains tax match his description?
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @03:01PM (#16460858)
Nope because people can have tax free access to their holdings by taking out loans against the stock. For individuals in question their stock appreciates a lot faster compared to the % they have to pay for the loan.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by patja on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:42AM (#16459721)
There is an argument that the tax breaks mean that some portion of the money is really the public's and should serve the public interest. When you give a million to a charity and get a tax break for 250k or 300k or whatever, is that money really yours? If you hadn't given it you would only have 700k or so, not 1m. You would not have all of it if you hadn't made the gift.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by schoen on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:47AM (#16459748)
Apart from any philosophical considerations about whether the money is "really yours", this evaluation is already built in to the 501(c)(3) process because the IRS reviews charities before granting them that status to see if they serve a public purpose. Not all not-for-profit organizations quality. The status can also be revoked if the IRS determines that an organization isn't meeting the 501(c)(3) criteria in the future.

You can't get the tax deduction by donating money to organizations that haven't passed through this review process.

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:50AM (#16459769)
At this scale you you would have 1m of stock that you would not have to sell if you didn't want to donate that 1m to charity. How that would make things better?
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by ianai on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:27AM (#16459643)
Yep, we should have say in it at the point where we contribute money to his largesse. Ie viable market alternatives.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by mars4rp on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:48AM (#16459755)
Because it is tax deductible!
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:56AM (#16459816)
It's sale of stock to fund this donation. He would not have to pay any tax if he simply keeps the stock.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by MrLeap on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:59PM (#16460186)
It's as simple as society gives his money value, and American society is getting anxious and resentful.

As an abstraction, I like to think of money as crystalized human effort. Society makes decisions by the power of individual behavior in aggregate.

A bunch of people buy a ~new thing~. Over time and at scale, society creates a river of money towards the ~new thing~. Its depth and breadth calibrated to reward other people for working towards bringing that ~new thing~ to society. Entrepreneurs gather marketing, sales and laborers to build a village by the river. This is society's intuitive understanding of business.

Society's intuitive understanding of competition between villages is that it occurs as an innovation arms race. Lower prices, better products are the result.

The experienced village builder learns that the best way to win is to divert the river into a cave and build a moat around the entrance.

Patent portfolios, information asynchrony, non compete employee contracts, vendor lock-in, yearly subscriptions, Byzantine government regulations and a hundred other things deepen your moat.

These kinds of moats improve your margin -- but in a different way than what society is used to. It isn't resulting in better products at lower prices, it's making competition more difficult.

Other experienced builders try to take a tiny drop from every river, for every transaction. They're starting to build their villages vertically and profit from the organically grown river network. Exploiting insider knowledge on the foreign exchange market, transaction fees, whatever.

These kinds of businesses intercept money that would normally return to society when the people in the villages go home.

The village builders have begun consolidating and moving upstream, getting closer to society. Society has BENEFITED. Their desires are now easier and faster to fulfill than ever before!

And yet.. society (remember, people in aggregate) is starting to get weary. Most people are restless and anxious, despite full employment, stock market blowing up, etc. Your average person can feel the reservoir getting lower, while other people are filling lakes.

"U.S. consumer spending rises; savings drop to 10-year low".

Money is power. Your average run of the mill person is slowly shifting from a belief in the Virtuousness of the American System, Land of Opportunity to one of Powerlessness within inevitability of whatever that system hands you.

Ultimate power is derived from a mandate from a masses, and most people on some level know that! They just feel like they're strapped in to a slow motion train wreck, and they're afraid of how it's all going to end.

Just my opinion on why people might have the audacity to discuss and critique how some billionaires spend their money.

Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter by qaq on Monday February 26, 2018 @01:05AM (#16463479)
You are prob right just after living first hand in society that faced what happens after you run out of "other people's money" to spend (USSR) I am really averse to this line of thinking I guess.