Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by dotancohen on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:50AM
(#16459767)
> Imagine a world where the top two richest guys, instead of deciding to use their wealth to fund vaccines and education, used it to fund warlords and dictators. We could have just as easily gotten that dice roll instead of the Warren Buffet and Bill Gates world.
Actually, you did get that dice roll too. Look up the house of Saud.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by braderhart on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:07PM
(#16459880)
Imagine how much further we could be if Microsoft didn't spend all that money subverting open source efforts, and spending infinite money to create a new generation of crippled developers.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:49PM
(#16460132)
It's an interesting question I know a lot of people for whom desire to unseat MS was a major driver in the amount of effort they dedicated to various open source proj. Would truly be interesting to see how things would look if MS did not reach it's dominant position. (One possible outcome could have being that IBM would've remained in it's dominant position).
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by hawkice on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:46AM
(#16459743)
This is deeply strange to me. If he wanted to support an evil empire or grow a petroleum multinational, you admit you'd have no say. But Gates wants to serve the public good -- now suddenly you're in charge. Seems backwards, at the very least.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by ryandrake on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:59AM
(#16459827)
I'm saying we, the public, are not in charge either way, and we're very lucky he wants to actually serve the public good.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @11:47AM
(#16459750)
"The idea that the public should not be involved with determining what counts as "public good" is super risky". You are involved in democratic process that drives the laws being passed which not only can determine "public good" but actually enforce behavior that will maximize "public good".
The problem with relying on philanthropy to fund the public good is that we the people are counting on the philanthropist to have goals that align with our goals. Imagine a world where the top two richest guys, instead of deciding to use their wealth to fund vaccines and education, used it to fund warlords and dictators. We could have just as easily gotten that dice roll instead of the Warren Buffet and Bill Gates world.
This is ostensibly one of the reasons "we" choose to democratically organize a government to fund the public good: So that we're not so reliant on the whims of a few rich people. It's to avoid the nightmare scenario where the worlds richest person decides instead to use his money for evil. Not saying that government can't use their power for evil, just that, at least in theory, we can vote in new government. We can't vote for different World's Richest People.