Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:31PM
(#16460024)
Coming from USSR no surprise to me that left leaning individuals deem it acceptable to determine what is worthy or not worthy to be discussed. Those certain conditions are very narrow and in societies were they are not narrow USSR, North Korea etc. things have not worked out too well.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by madez on Sunday February 25, 2018 @01:58PM
(#16460494)
There are successful countries with very high taxes and other means by which the society takes from individuals. Just the amount of how much is taken is not an important metric. It does not matter how much is taken, but under what circumstances, i.e. is it equal law and equally binding for everybody, was it decided in a democratic way, is it used for what it is intended for, and can it practically and effectively be challenged in a fair trial?
Please, let's discuss proposals, but reasonably and with thoughtful arguments, and not with "? It's his money that he actually decided to give away why should you or I have a say in it?".
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @02:33PM
(#16460699)
Give an example of successful country where ownership of stock is taxed.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by Erwin on Sunday February 25, 2018 @05:58PM
(#16461717)
As I understand it, Netherlands have a wealth tax: rather than tax capital gains, net ownership is taxed at a 30% rate of assumed gain. So essentially you pay 0.6 to 1.5% of your shares, non-primary housing etc. in wealth tax depending on size of your assets.
http://taxsummaries.pwc.com/ID/Netherlands-Individual-Income...
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @07:51PM
(#16462208)
very reasonable system (although can be easy circumvented by moving). It would not have prevented anyone from accumulating
the wealth that everyone is complaining about in this thread
though.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by madez on Sunday February 25, 2018 @03:56PM
(#16461119)
Article 106 of the german Grundgesetz/constitution states that in Germany there is an ownership tax. It was used until 1997 when the former practice was ruled unlawful, but no adopted form of collection was introduced, while the government still has the right to collect ownership tax. There is an ongoing debate about reinstating the collection.
AFAIK, France is currently collecting ownership tax.
The USSR and North Korea suck because they are autocratic, corrupted regimes, not because of single aspects of how they run their economies.
But even beside specific examples, if we decide that it is a good thing, then we can introduce new law.
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by lkbm on Sunday February 25, 2018 @02:40PM
(#16460732)
Why does it need to be ownership? Doesn't capital gains tax match his description?
Re:Tough questions we get asked: 2018 Annual Letter
by qaq on Sunday February 25, 2018 @03:01PM
(#16460858)
Nope because people can have tax free access to their holdings by taking out loans against the stock. For individuals in question their stock appreciates a lot faster compared to the % they have to pay for the loan.
It is intellectually lazy and moot to say everybody is free to do what they want with what they have (be it money or not) because that's not how we live nor want to live.
A proposal to take from an inidivual for the greater good can be worth a discussion. Just crying out for extremist, reality-ignoring individualism is not an acceptable comment worthy of HN, in my eyes.