News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by ilovecars2 on Sunday February 11, 2018 @11:45AM (#16353375)
This is kind of a meta comment, but I’ve been lurking on HN for a while on car posts in particular.

I have the impression that HN in general doesn’t like cars all that much, and in fact we would be much better of without them.

I can’t argue with the facts: congestion and pollution in large cities, such as London, have never been higher where almost all on-road public transport is still run on diesel.

However, I think driving for a lot of people is a liberating and pleasurable experience. and, before we go there, I’m not talking about being stuck in traffic, which is often a issue with poor planning and lack of infrastructure investment rather than an issue with cars themselves, but the pure pleasure of driving.

I’m quite concerned that self driving cars will take this simple pleasure and satisfaction from us, and perhaps that’s just a selfish opinion. I don’t know?

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by rkcx on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:22PM (#16353559)
The response-by-analogy is that people still ride horses for pleasure, and we should expect to see the same thing with cars: a (comparatively) small base of enthusiasts practicing the activity in a way that doesn't endanger others.

Broadly speaking, it seems like there are an infinite number of potential "simple pleasures" out there that people could enjoy, and if we have a chance to transition lots of people from a simple pleasure that endangers others to other pleasures that don't, we should probably do it.

I think a better way to reason about the tradeoff (since reasoning by analogy is unreliable) is to suppose that we were in a world where cars had always been autonomous, and imagine how it would play out–specifically, would enthusiasts in such a world try and build human-driven cars (maybe?), would they drive human-driven cars on public roads (probably not?), and would the non-enthusiasts feel a sense of longing for the joys of the road (for the most part, no?).

The future we should try to reach is the future that we would aim for regardless of our starting position. To me, that seems like a future where no one has to drive cars, and some people who want to do drive cars, but no one has to be impacted by the manual-driving of cars if they don't want to. So I think the response-by-analogy is probably correct in this case.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by iraphael on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:04PM (#16353464)
> I’m not talking about being stuck in traffic, which is often a issue with poor planning and lack of infrastructure investment rather than an issue with cars themselves

I disagree with this statement. I believe that cars are not a transportation solution that scales like public transportation, for instance, does.

For these same reasons I believe Musk's Boring Company's plans are exactly the wrong kind of urban planning ideas that will just create a "fast lane" for those who can pay, instead of a solution that works for all.

Maybe cars could come with this romanticized "freedom" and "pleasure" when they're not prevalent enough to cause the issues that make driving undesirable. But I think the last time that happened was when cars were luxury items, reserved for the rich suburban white America and I don't want the future to involve making transportation more under-democratized.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by ilovecars2 on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:19PM (#16353547)
> I believe that cars are not a transportation solution that scales like public transportation, for instance, does.

One thing I would like to add is that public transport is too very difficult to scale. For example, the Northern, Central and Piccadilly lines on London Underground are massively overcrowded to the extent where it’s borderline dangerous.

I don’t really know what TFL can do about it, because the lines already operates at maximum capacity. They could build more lines at £15Bn each (http://www.cityam.com/279301/gbp148bn-crossrail-project-face...), but even if money grew on trees these projects take 5-10 years to complete, by which time population has grown so much that they too are overcrowded by the time they open.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by slyall on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:40PM (#16353662)
> One thing I would like to add is that public transport is too very difficult to scale

A quick check show the Piccadilly line is doing 21 trains per hour and they have a capacity of 684 people. Around 14,000 people per hour.

That is roughly a 7 lanes of highway traffic under optimal conditions. Not even thinking about the other direction.

I think you find that it is easer to build a new underground line though central London than a 10+ lane highway.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by Doctor_Fegg on Sunday February 11, 2018 @01:36PM (#16353998)
London was recently faced with exactly that question: how to transport more people across the city efficiently without paying the astronomical sums required for either another Crossrail or an unthinkably damaging motorway.

The solution is in place now and is working. It’s the North-South and East-West Cycle Superhighways.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by watchdogtimer on Sunday February 11, 2018 @01:47PM (#16354074)
Any estimate of how many people these can move at peak volume? I'm curious how it compares to the Underground.
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by madeofpalk on Sunday February 11, 2018 @01:42PM (#16354039)
So I think the insight here is that, as with everything, it can only scale so far.

Here's a question though: is it easier to build a new underground tunnel now compared to 100(?) years ago? While previously there was a lot less existing infrastructure to have to worry about disturbing, these days we have a lot more advanced technology to make the process easier.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by namelost on Sunday February 11, 2018 @03:30PM (#16354623)
Chinese cities have grown tremendously large metro systems in a very short amount of time. China has 5 of the 10 longest metro systems, and 4 of them were started operating in the 90s or later. The Nanjing metro is the 6th longest in the world and was started running in 2005.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_metro_systems#List

So the answer is a resounding yes, it is much easier to build metro systems than it was in the past. As long as you do so in China.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by bjelkeman-again on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:29PM (#16353600)
Having lived in London I am starting to wonder if really large cities aren’t going to suffer under overcrowding and increased housing prices to the point where it very painfully (maybe) self regulates?
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by ghaff on Sunday February 11, 2018 @02:57PM (#16354421)
It already does. Far more people would live in the desireable areas of London and Manhattan, among others, if the housing were available at half the current prices. The effects in the greater Metro areas are less—people trade off commute time for lower prices/more space—but people still absolutely factor in CoL when making location choices. I certainly would never consider a number of areas for that reason.
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by userbinator on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:19PM (#16353548)
I agree, but it's more than just that --- self-driving cars will take more control away from individuals and put that in the hands of corporations and governments, who will have a much easier time tracking --- and even controlling --- the large-scale movement of the population. When they decide to outlaw non-self-driving cars almost completely, "the frog will have been thoroughly boiled."

Of course, it's all done under the argument of safety. But I don't think a perfectly safe world, one with no risk at all, is one worth living in either. There's enough dystopian scifi around to predict rather accurately what will happen.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by icebraining on Sunday February 11, 2018 @01:40PM (#16354022)
Regular cars are already being tracked. Real-time license plate scanning is a solved problem.

You're probably more anonymous buying a bus ticket with cash than driving your car.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by visarga on Sunday February 11, 2018 @04:37PM (#16354965)
You already got one or more GPS wireless tracking devices in your car, though.
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by userbinator on Sunday February 11, 2018 @06:38PM (#16355465)
I have a GPS but I can turn it off when I don't want it, and I'm pretty sure it's off because it ceases to function when it's unplugged.
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by visarga on Monday February 12, 2018 @03:45PM (#16361940)
Do you also turn your phone off, because phones can be triangulated by cell towers.
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by tonyedgecombe on Sunday February 11, 2018 @11:57AM (#16353425)
Being stuck in traffic is a problem with cars, we can't build our way out of that problem, more roads just generate more traffic as longer commutes become viable.

I suspect self driving cars will make this worse not better, if a 60 minute commute is OK with you then perhaps 90 minutes is if you can read a book on the way.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by ilovecars2 on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:12PM (#16353505)
I agree, more roads are not the solution. That said, there are definitely poorly thought out roads in cities all over the world that actively create traffic because they unnecessarily disrupt traffic flow.

But, more generally I believe the solution to traffic is to provide compelling alternatives. It’s all about creating a balance. In London we have the opposite issue, there are too many people trying to take the tube and mainline rail, leading to massive overcrowding.

Now, is waiting 20 minutes to get on a Northern Line train, because the last four have been packed to the doors, a problem with people, or is it a problem with planning and infrastructure?

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by gervase on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:13PM (#16353516)
Let's assume your worst-case scenario comes to pass, and politicians decide (or are influenced) to outlaw manually-driven vehicles from public roads.

First, you would still be able to drive on private tracks; plenty of car enthusiasts already do this today. If your enjoyment is derived from driving fast, or taking curves, this should be able to satisfy your requirements.

Second, if your satisfaction is derived from aimlessly driving, simply enjoying the scenery and the zen of the road, this is not something that is incompatible with self-driving cars. Hell, there could be a "Scenic drive" button that randomly takes you on different routes every time.

If you are concerned that you will no longer be able to combine these activities (driving aggressively on long, rambling courses), I think this is something you are likely to lose out on. On the other hand, if this is the case, is it even appropriate for you to be doing this on public roads today?

If your argument is that you don't want to invest the time or money to use tracks or private courses for this purpose, then I think you should reexamine just how much enjoyment you derive from driving, and where it comes from specifically.

Ultimately, it goes to a core discussion of whether roads are for transportation or for recreation; I imagine similar discussions have occurred in the past between wagons and horseback riders, for example, or later, between horse-drawn vehicles and cars. Today, I would argue that more than 50% (and probably much more) of the cars on the road are being used for transportation rather than recreation, which suggests that modifications that streamline that use will eventually crowd out the remaining percentage through the tyranny of the majority.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by Bizarro on Sunday February 11, 2018 @01:25PM (#16353935)
Let's assume your worst-case scenario comes to pass, and politicians decide (or are influenced) to outlaw manually-driven vehicles from public roads.

There seems to be some confusion around HN about politicians signing/voting for laws and the people just magically acquiescing because a hundred guys decided it was for the best.

There's consequences for everything and the people can push back hard if bureacrats aren't thinking clearly.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by dsfyu404ed on Sunday February 11, 2018 @10:50PM (#16356388)
>First, you would still be able to drive on private tracks; plenty of car enthusiasts already do this today. If your enjoyment is derived from driving fast, or taking curves, this should be able to satisfy your requirements.

This is false choice. It's like saying you can still drink beer and watch sports in a bar even if you can't buy beer and can't buy a cable subscription.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by emodendroket on Sunday February 11, 2018 @04:14PM (#16354838)
Well, beyond that, I have to wonder if self-driving cars are really the solution we're looking for, rather than more mass transit.
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by megy on Sunday February 11, 2018 @07:54PM (#16355750)
Mass transit is clearly the solution we need, but it is tricky to convince people since they are so used to private transport.
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by emodendroket on Sunday February 11, 2018 @08:16PM (#16355834)
Right, like, OK, maybe mass transit isn't the solution for rural areas. But most Americans do not live in rural areas; they live in metro areas, which can probably be served by mass transit. Even the suburbs, I think, could plausibly be served much more by mass transit.
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by thisisit on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:17PM (#16353537)
> I have the impression that HN in general doesn’t like cars all that much, and in fact we would be much better of without them.

In a discussion forum, people are free to form their opinions and rebut anyone, who they think is being incorrect. So, I don't understand why do people say this forum is unfair to x,y and z, stuff like HN in general doesn't like "cryptocurrencies" or "cars" etc doesn't help the discussion.

As for self-driving, when I read stuff like this:

But the final one speaks loudly about what city roads of the future could look like: “that autonomous vehicles (AVs) in dense urban areas should be operated only in shared fleets.”

https://www.popsci.com/self-driving-car-fleets#page-2

I can't help but get worried.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by tpm on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:06PM (#16353470)
Being stuck in traffic is a problem with cars. Driving can be a liberating and pleasurable experience. I do enjoy driving on empty country roads. I don't enjoy driving to and from work every day. If the time comes and driving by humans will be banned, I will happily accept that deal. But I don't think that day will come in the next at least 20-30 years. Biking (without any engine) is also a liberating and pleasurable experience.
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by amenod on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:05PM (#16353466)
I am quite sure that people who will want to drive cars will still be able to - but not necessarily on the same streets as self driving cars. Isn't it the same now with horses and carriages?
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by CM30 on Sunday February 11, 2018 @02:17PM (#16354229)
Not sure where you live, but over here, horse and carts can indeed travel on the same roads as cars/lorries/buses/bikes/pedestrians/whatever. They're obviously a lot less common than they used to be, but every now and then you'll see a horse and cart go trotting by like it's still the 1800s or what not.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/code-of-practice-...

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by transpostmeta on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:09PM (#16353495)
Yes, this is a selfish opinion. Traffic kills a lot of people, and it's not just the ones doing the driving. Traffic is terrible for the environment, causes noise pollution and respiratory illness.

I can understand that some people need to drive. But driving for pleasure is not something that should ever happen.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by ilovecars2 on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:21PM (#16353554)
What is your opinion on flying for pleasure (i.e vacation)? We know that flying too is very damaging for the environment and creates terrible noise pollution. Would love to hear your thoughts on this!
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by clfougner on Sunday February 11, 2018 @12:47PM (#16353713)
That isn’t the same thing at all. When you fly for a vacation, the flying is a means to an end (transportation), not the goal in itself. This discussion is about driving for fun, in which the driving is the goal in itself, not transporting yourself to a “fun” destination.
Re:Self driving cars and beyond by saltcured on Sunday February 11, 2018 @01:47PM (#16354070)
So, I understand you'd be OK with driving to get somewhere (anywhere?) as the ends justify the means. And driving around a race track just for the purpose of driving sounds really bad? Or is the purpose of racing somehow different than someone taking a Sunday drive to nowhere? The race car also produces a lot more particulate emissions than a highway cruiser, both from fuel combustion and from the friction wear of tires and brakes.

What about taking the "scenic route" to get somewhere instead of the most direct route available? You still have a destination and purpose, rather than driving just for the sake of operating the vehicle, but you might drive a little further and take the car's emissions into a nicer area. What about driving a big, gas-hungry SUV or luxury vehicle to be comfortable instead of the most economical compact car that is feasible? What about people operating off-highway vehicles instead of hiking and using mule trains to get deep into the woods?

Starting with the same initial argument that it is wrong to operate a vehicle for pleasure because of its impact on others' health, why do we allow people to create filthy camp fires in the very locations where the most people will be exposed in national parks? Compared to a modern car, the fire is pumping out horrendous unregulated emissions...

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by King-Aaron on Sunday February 11, 2018 @09:01PM (#16356019)
We get it, you take the bus.

To not be completely facetious though, it's going to be hard if not impossible for you to understand someone's passion for something, if you don't have any concept of enjoyment for it yourself.

A great many people find enjoyment in driving, for she sake of the activity itself. There are inherent risks and environmental downsides to it, for sure, but the same could be said for many things.

Your comment is however, the sort of thing that the grandparent comment was about - this attitude is expressed a lot on DN, and while this is an assumption on my part, it makes me feel that these people (such as yourself with your comment) must live in an environment where you haven't had the chance (or necessity) to use vehicles in the capacity that gives you an appreciation of the leisure aspect to them.

Even if that's not the case, however, it does pay to at least recognise that while you're strongly against something you can at least be objective in how you express your opinion.

BTW I think cars are super fun, I'm actively involved in motorsport, and I can completely understand when people aren't interested in it.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by ilovecars2 on Sunday February 11, 2018 @02:53PM (#16354394)
Not necessarily, you could be doing both at the same time. This is actually quite popular, as a kind of Grand Tour.

For example, a driving tour of the French Alps would, I think, count as driving for pleasure, especially when you could take a coach and do the same trip. You can even pay to go on organised tours, such as http://petrolhead.tours.

Re:Self driving cars and beyond by KozmoNau7 on Sunday February 11, 2018 @01:01PM (#16353802)
Why don't you think driving for pleasure should happen?

It doesn't have to be damaging to the environment, or dangerous if you're on the open road.