Fortunately in the age of the Internet and advanced search engines, you actually can be your own diagnostician.
You have to learn to decide when you must have medical attention, and you must not accept dismissiveness from doctors. Yes, you must also not be a hypochondriac -- that will cost you money and crowd out others who need the care. But this is why you must... become good at being your own diagnostician.
This is very much not what doctors want. It's not what the FDA wants. It's not what anyone should want. But the quality of care is so variable, and so dependent on someone noticing in less than the only five minutes they want to spare you, some detail that you have days to notice... that you just have to be your own diagnostician.
Arm yourself with knowledge before you get to the doctor's office or ER.
The doctors I was working under weren’t bad. They were, however, forced to run ragged all day without a break for a shit, allowed no more than a few minutes per patient. They didn’t like it any: they’d openly say “don’t emulate this,” while running to the next room.
The funny thing is, surgeries and pharmaceuticals and medical equipment are expensive. A doctor’s time? If he’s not a top renowned specialist, not much. But people have gotten so used to insurers playing the middleman retailer (buying healthcare services cheaply and reselling them to patients at a premium...), they’ve forgotten they can just -pay for the doctors time-.
It doesn’t require playing amateur medical sleuth. It just requires admitting that a highly skilled worker that had to train for a decade to do the job costs more than 20$.
You just can't know if you are receiving competent service if you have no level of competence on practicing it.
Solving a problem may be a useful guide. Find someone who can complete some specific task reasonably well, and even if you don't know how to do that task yourself, you may be able to make an assessment amongst various practitioners. This is easier to accomplish for simple tasks than hard ones (say: running a 100m sprint, or deadlifting 250 kg), but is the principle at the heart of, say, Jakob Nielsen's usability testing.
The problem is that there are domains in which tasks are complex, the time to determine successful conclusion is long, etc., etc. In this case, you may need to farm out the evaluation process, or look to evaluate institutions rather than individuals (say, in education, or medicine -- and there are reasons that the collective evaluation approach has validity for each, though also for adjusting for student population / case mix). The general problem of audits or programme assessment exhibits this.
My point isn't that assessments are easy, simple, straightforward, or not prone to their own issues. Only that there does exist a possibility in many cases for making valid assessments of service competence without specific competence in the service being assessed.
Ditto, say, accountancy. You have to have a clue.
My firstborn is 2 months old and I'm always afraid of things like this!
We had extreme lethargy and high fever for a couple days, and our threshold was crossed when the vomiting started. The boy walked into the ER with us, collapsed during chest x-rays, and was diagnosed with pneumonia a few minutes later.
Having had the pleasure of dealing with a (different) child experiencing febrile seizures, I'm not sure I'd want to wait for seizing before getting a diagnosis and supportive care. Seizure protocol involved multiple LPs.
I'd love better criteria than "extreme discomfort" and "clammy skin". Persistent high fever is one (but apparently flu can take a turn within 48 hours, so that's out the window). Relapsing fever is a good one. What else are the clear signs?
Appearance:
“TICLS” Tone – the newborn should have a normal flexed tone; the 6 month old baby who sits up and controls her head; the toddler cruises around the room.
Interactiveness – Does the 2 month old have a social smile? Is the toddler interested in what is going on in the room?
Consolability – A child who cannot be consoled at some point by his mother is experiencing a medical emergency until proven otherwise.
Look/gaze – Does the child track or fix his gaze on you, or is there the “1000-yard stare”?
Speech/cry – A vigorously crying baby can be a good sign, when consolable – when the cry is high-pitched, blood-curling, or even a soft whimper, something is wrong.
If the child fails any of the TICLS, then his appearance is abnormal.
Work of Breathing: Children are respiratory creatures – they are hypermetabolic – we need to key in on any respiratory embarrassment.
Look for nasal flaring. Uncover the chest and abdomen and look for retractions. Listen – even without a stethoscope – for abnormal airway sounds like grunting or stridor. Grunting is the child’s last-ditch effort to produce auto-PEEP.
Stridor is a sign of critical upper airway narrowing.
Look for abnormal positioning, like tripodding, or head bobbing
Circulation to skin:
Infants and children are vasospastic – they can change their vascular tone quickly, depending on their volume status or environment.
Without even having to touch the child, you can see signs of pallor, cyanosis, or mottling. If any of these is present, this is an abnormal circulation to the skin.
Failing any one of these is worth a serious doc visit. And, I’ll add one of my own: any infant that works so hard at sucking down milk that it makes them sweat gets a free trip to the ER.
The ER physician took one look at him and admitted him, shocking us by saying he was within hours of death. He spent a couple days being pumped full of antibiotics, and recovered, but it was a close call. The doctors never did figure out just what it was.
All these years later, and it still distresses me.
How were you supposed to know a tiered guy was at death’s door?
You got lucky, but in the end you did well.
The old Dr's refused to send me anywhere, and immediately got their lawyers when my parents asked questions. The asshats also gave me milk of magnesia at 10pm because "I didn't eat anything for a few days." So that was a great night...
My dad made the call to the other hospital and they arranged an ambulance. I spent a week at the first hospital, and after 3 hours at the new one, I was already under the knife. That was the first time I saw people at a hospital run because of what they were seeing on scans.
The new Dr told my parents (after i was OK) that the only thing he could think about once he initially saw me was that he was "operating on a dead boy."
Scary stuff.
I can't remember exactly what I had, but it was different than what your child had. Very similar experiences though.
I have stomach issues and occasionally use that on a day when I know I can spend the entire next day sat near a toilet, that stuff is absurdly effective as a laxative almost dangerously so.
Kinda makes me want to get back into optics. Imaging like that should be as routine as taking a temperature. Be nice to see stuff like diffuse light and ultrasound get super cheap so it's used routinely.
I've no idea how disruptive technology like cheap ultrasound compares with "traditional" medical equipment. It may be possible to do it cheaply now, but I'd assume the big equipment manufacturers will try to justify their six or seven figure prices for as long as they can, and those in charge of the hospital budgets will probably not be totally unbiased when it comes to making purchasing decisions. It may take some time to filter down into hospitals (like the internet).
Consider a $40k higher end ultrasound machine. Now consider the capital cost of the machine over 10 years. $4000/yr or $10 a day. Yeah the bill you get for an ultrasound is all pork.
It’s funny how popular the Wizard of Schenectady story is on HN when it’s about engineers, but somehow fails to be applied to non-engineers.
Kind of focuses one's attention on the expensive test.
I guess if utilization is low the technicians can end up costing a lot. But say they cost $200,000 a year and do one scan each working day. That's something like $1000 of labor, but it also assumes that they only manage to do 1 thing each day they work.
It was my point was that the 'expensive' isn't due to the capital or maintenance cost of an ultra sound machine.
Although portable units do have the advantage that in a lot of cases the attending physician can bypass the cash cow radiology department completely.
As for the rude tone of your comment, I have a tens of thousands worth of test equipment on my bench and I'd never dream of billing a client an 'oscilloscope fee', a 'logic analyzer fee' or a 'spectrum analyzer fee'. And every other industry works like that, except medicine.
When we had our first kid, my wife had a “fun scan” done. A fancy 3D color ultrasound. It was $120 for a 1/2 hour session. Same diagnostic ultrasound cost $1000 on a much older machine, same person running it.
There was an article on here a couple of years ago about cheap, hand held ultrasound. I was downvoted for saying youl’ll never see it in use.
tingle
Just add if one thinks a bit one can find a lot of industries that depend on renting out expensive capital equipment. Consider a taxi. A taxi might cost $25,000. Smog machines that auto shops have are not cheap. An Boeing 787 costs around $600,000 a seat. Rent a hotel room lately?
But he ended up in surgery pretty quickly after we arrived at the hospital. It took them a day to analyse his X-rays and realise he was not responding to regular antibiotics, and the decision was made to transfer him to the larger hospital for the operation. As for the misdiagnosis made by our family doctor (G.P. or General Practitioner, we call them), I'm not qualified to comment on whether it was a reasonable error or not.
We have the same term and abbreviation in the US for the same people, but I never know how many people who didn't grow up around medical people know it.
> As for the misdiagnosis made by our family doctor (G.P. or General Practitioner, we call them), I'm not qualified to comment on whether it was a reasonable error or not.
Sometimes it is, and it still goes to court. I'm biased towards the US in my knowledge, but a doctor or nurse can be legitimately afraid of, essentially, the precise kind of case your son was the victim of: The extremely rare serious problem masquerading as a very common and not-very-serious problem. That road goes directly into malpractice lawsuit territory, and when you're on that road everyone goes a bit insane.
Everyone in the medical field carries malpractice insurance because, as I've implied, some malpractice lawsuits are inevitable, due to a confluence of reasonable judgement and an unreasonably uncommon malady. Does this mean malpractice law needs to be reformed (read: done away with)? No, because some people out there practicing medicine are really incompetent, or lazy, or just go a bit weird and start cutting their initials onto livers like some deranged Zorro. We need some way to get those people out of the profession.
I guess I'm not really leading anywhere with this. The fact innocent people will have to go to court over reasonable judgment which leads to a bad outcome because of blind chance is just magnifying the unfairness of the whole event, increasing it and spreading it around. Will it make the MD more likely to correctly diagnose next time? It might make them more likely to order a test that's probably not warranted statistically. That's not the same thing. Everyone's human, and humans are sometimes incompetent and malicious, so we need malpractice law, but humans sometimes make honest mistakes and always use limited evidence to reach conclusions which are sometimes wrong, so malpractice suits catch innocents and send them through a wringer.
I agree that it's the right answer in a cold-blooded "improving the practice of medicine" sense, but laws have to take human behavior into account.
Yet that's precisely what the aeronautic industry does.
If, god forbid, our son had not recovered, it would have been a different story, there would have been anger to vent and likely a court case.
This is enforced by all of the HCP registration bodies (GMC for doctors; NMC for registered nurses and midwives; HCPC for allied health professionals). It's also supported by the NHS Litigation authority (the body who'll pay out for negligence claims, or defend those in court), and various medical protection organisations (the legal organisations that represent HCPs in court cases). The MPTS (the tribunal service that holds hearings in fit-to-practice cases) also strongly recommends that HCPs apologise in full.
In England and Wales we have a bit of law ("The Compensation Act") which means an apology outside a court for something that went wrong isn't an admission of liability, which makes it a bit easier for HCPs and their employers to apologise.
I've collected a bit of information here: https://medium.com/@dan.bealecocks/advice-to-doctors-about-s...
But this statement: "fevers that abate only to flare up again after the child seems to be over the worst of the illness" reminded me of something that happened to my son.
When he was 7, he came down with a flu-like illness that lasted a week, and because it was a bad flu season we were told to stay away from the doctor's surgery. After about 4 days of fever and no eating my wife railed against the advice and took him along, only to be fobbed off by her regular doctor who said there was nothing to worry about, he had an ear infection, and prescribed some antibiotics.
So for the next day or two he seemed to improve. Then, on the Sunday, he suddenly faded away again and seemed to lose all interest in getting better. The only thing he complained about was a perpetual pain in his neck. I took him back to the surgery, and because it was a weekend I saw a visiting doctor rather than our regular one. The guy took one look at him and phoned the hospital, told me to get him there urgently.
It transpired he had a very advanced pneumonia, and had to be transferred to a bigger hospital for an operation to remove 1 litre of fluid from his lung. That was what had been causing the neck pain: the sheer weight of the fluid on one side of his chest. After the op, they managed to treat the infection with about the fourth antibiotic they tried (I think there were only a couple left after that, which was scary). Another week later and he went home, and made a full recovery, thankfully.
When questioned, our family doctor very defensively said she had never come across such an advanced case of pneumonia in "someone who could still stand up", and so she had discounted it. This fact seemed to be borne up by the fact that our son was a prize exhibit at the teaching hospital he'd been transferred to, surrounded on a daily basis by medical students listening through stethoscopes and being told "this is what a pleural empyema sounds like in a child - note the lack of the classic rattling noise you associate with pneumonia" ... so maybe our doctor was correct. Anyway, we were just glad to have our son well again and were not interested in lawsuits.
But every time either of our kids gets a fever or anything that seems like the flu now, we play extra close attention and refused to be fobbed off by over-worked doctors.