News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by Simulacra on Saturday January 20, 2018 @04:00AM (#16192677)
It worries me greatly when communities, businesses, another private entities start recording the license plates.
Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by krapp on Saturday January 20, 2018 @07:04AM (#16193068)
Why? License plates are meant to be public, that's why they're on the outside of cars, where anyone can see them. It's no more sinister than knowing your name and address.
Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by vijayr on Saturday January 20, 2018 @09:53AM (#16193528)
Why?

Your phone number is public, but you wouldn't be happy if the lat/long of your phone during various times of the day is public, right?

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by krapp on Saturday January 20, 2018 @10:18AM (#16193612)
Maybe not, but if I knew when I bought the phone that I would be legally required to carry a placard around with my current lat/long on it, I wouldn't be shocked if people knew where I was, even if I put the sign down once in a while.

I've got no real issue with being able to cover your plates while parked, but doing so doesn't do much to prevent surveillance or identification - that much is even mentioned in the article.

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by thomastjeffery on Saturday January 20, 2018 @03:11PM (#16195172)
Walking around in public does not make it reasonable for someone to track where you are at every moment.
Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by krapp on Saturday January 20, 2018 @06:11PM (#16195956)
Having a license plate doesn't make it possible for someone to track where you are at every moment.

Anyone is able to view a license plate in a public place. Just like names on mailboxes and house numbers, it's a publicly viewable identifier, not an Orwellian form of surveillance.

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by brokenmachine on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:55PM (#16219957)
Oh, you sweet summer child.
Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by brokenmachine on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:52PM (#16219950)
Would you have a problem with an all-seeing drone flying high above that tracks your every movement and is always recording your movements?

http://www.radiolab.org/story/eye-sky/

Also, I don't want everyone knowing my name and address either. Why not post yours here? Or do you have something to hide?

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by on_and_off on Saturday January 20, 2018 @03:31AM (#16192611)
I am genuinely curious : why do people want to cover their plates while the car is parked ?
Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by b6 on Saturday January 20, 2018 @03:54AM (#16192665)
Well, police cars are driving around all the time. Tireless electronic eyes look out of the vehicle for plates, and records of every single one are made: timestamp, location, etc. The vast majority of the data collected is on people who are not suspected of any crime. But the data can be misused in innumerable ways. It would be easy to pick out patterns and then flag deviations, like the patterns show that this guy works from 8-5, but for some reason, his car was at a hotel from 1-3. On and on.

There are lots of reasons to not want this kind of omniscient eye on us. My favorite is that a lot of laws are wrong, and people are violating the laws righteously, and they will be vindicated by public opinion someday, but it's going to take time for everyone to catch up. We don't want perfect police. There needs to be some slop so that we can see where the laws are wrong.

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by jaclaz on Saturday January 20, 2018 @09:17AM (#16193400)
>Well, police cars are driving around all the time. Tireless electronic eyes look out of the vehicle for plates, and records of every single one are made: timestamp, location, etc. The vast majority of the data collected is on people who are not suspected of any crime. But the data can be misused in innumerable ways.

And - as a side note - whenever there is information stored (and poorly protected, i.e. "always") there is a good chance it will go in the hands of someone that is not the police or government.

There is the known case of the Oakland Police ALPR, which data was initially available through public record request:

http://records.oaklandnet.com/request/8562

Now the data is not "public record" anymore, but I wouldn't be surprised if - one way or the other - data harvesting companies would be able to get a copy.

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by Fnoord on Saturday January 20, 2018 @04:46AM (#16192782)
The problem you describe is its part of mass surveillance, not targeted surveillance.

I feel, even though we're not discussing text, the spirit of this quote is appropriate to mass surveillance post processing:

"If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him." --Cardinal Richelieu.

Discussion about authenticity e.g. here [1]

[1] https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/23785/what-did-r...

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by dave84 on Saturday January 20, 2018 @03:44AM (#16192645)
First paragraph:

>This simple privacy measure would create an opportunity for drivers to protect sensitive information about their travel and whereabouts from mass collection by law enforcement and private data brokers.

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by on_and_off on Saturday January 20, 2018 @03:46AM (#16192648)
I already read it :)

But I still don't see how it works .. this info can still be collected while you are driving. And what kind of info are you worried private data brokers will get out of your parked car ?

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by falcolas on Saturday January 20, 2018 @10:08AM (#16193573)
"Why are my health insurance premiums going up?"

"You regularly ski, an activity associated with a greater chance of injury."

"You have been visiting a private clinic for months, which raises your risk of having a major health issue you have not yet disclosed to us."

"You regularly eat at McDonalds, raising your long-term health care costs."

Or... "Why has my auto insurance gone up?"

"You are regularly at locations associated with illegal street racing."

"You are regularly near after market parts stores, and after market parts are correlated with high risk drivers."

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by dave84 on Saturday January 20, 2018 @06:59AM (#16193056)
Well, if we black mirror it up a bit you could be denied a mortgage because you regularly park outside a bookmakers.
Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by on_and_off on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @12:31AM (#16220558)
Makes sense.

I still have trouble getting the US mentality.

I frequently mock the CNIL because of its overbearing decisions but AFAIK this kind of organism would prevent this kind of use of your personal data.

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by Blazespinnaker on Saturday January 20, 2018 @01:45AM (#16192384)
“Data collected by EFF from across the state show that only .08% of vehicle plates captured by police ALPRs are connected to a crime.

Lol. What percentage of cars are connected to crime?

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by mcny on Saturday January 20, 2018 @02:01AM (#16192421)
Why are you running data if you don't suspect a crime?

A friend of mine moved to a new neighborhood. Apparently, her neighbor was in the police. She said she was out walking her dog and the neighbor greeted her with her first name and middle name when she had barely moved in. We didn't know her legal middle name was different from what we called her. So we pretty much know he looked her up (driving licence info?) and he wants her to know he looked her up.

Why? Who knows but he did.

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by metilda on Saturday January 20, 2018 @02:18AM (#16192473)
Illicit querying of NCIC should be a crime in and of itself that officers and anyone else with access (admin personnel & some security guards) are commonly prosecuted for.

We should have a right to security in our information, and privacy of it from meddlers and nefarious actors like the aformentioned neighbor. Sadly, many of my fellow Americans are all to happy to claim they have nothing to hide, despite how much that attitude continues to hurt them.

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by b6 on Saturday January 20, 2018 @02:27AM (#16192493)
> Illicit querying of NCIC should be a crime

I'm not disagreeing with this, but I don't think we can trust people to make a system that, e.g., automatically collects and stores the locations of all cars with plates visible to all the roving police cars -- and then not use that information improperly.

I'm hoping that we'll gradually choose deliberate ignorance of certain things we could know because although the knowledge could be helpful in certain cases, it's also too dangerous.

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by r00fus on Saturday January 20, 2018 @12:29PM (#16194251)
There shouldn't need to be such a choice. Make both more difficult - license plate tracking and inappropriate lookups.
Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by tzs on Saturday January 20, 2018 @02:22AM (#16192484)
Is she a renter or an owner? If the latter, her name could probably be found on the property sale records which are public.
Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by metilda on Saturday January 20, 2018 @02:25AM (#16192490)
Why should it matter, said officer shouldn't be querying NCIC to dox his neighbor. I doubt he actually bothered to use the local parcel viewer.
Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by tzs on Saturday January 20, 2018 @07:07PM (#16196165)
It matters because to make the inference that he was connected to the police and misused police resources to find her information, that information has to not be readily available to the general public.

If she had been an owner, the information would be available to the public, and not even all that odd for a neighbor to look up (I look up sales records for houses that sell in my neighborhood to see what they sold for, for example, to get an idea of how the market is).

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by mcny on Saturday January 20, 2018 @04:15AM (#16192709)
In this case, Renter. Just moved. License would still have old address. You couldn't have "accidentally" found someone like that.
Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by ryanwaggoner on Saturday January 20, 2018 @12:17PM (#16194154)
You’re making a bunch of leaps in logic here. How do you know he is law enforcement? Also, you said she just moved, so how does her license have her new address? So how exactly did he identify her to look her up?

Maybe he just saw a piece of her mail.

Edit: also, the most obvious question: why didn’t she do the normal thing and ask “hey, how do you know my name?”

Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by brokenmachine on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:58PM (#16219970)
Seriously, a stranger stating your full name including a middle name they shouldn't know doesn't seem threatening to you?
Re:California Police Chiefs Misrepresent License Plate Priva... by 13of40 on Saturday January 20, 2018 @03:30AM (#16192610)
Speeding is a crime, so about 99.998%.