There are lots of reasons to not want this kind of omniscient eye on us. My favorite is that a lot of laws are wrong, and people are violating the laws righteously, and they will be vindicated by public opinion someday, but it's going to take time for everyone to catch up. We don't want perfect police. There needs to be some slop so that we can see where the laws are wrong.
And - as a side note - whenever there is information stored (and poorly protected, i.e. "always") there is a good chance it will go in the hands of someone that is not the police or government.
There is the known case of the Oakland Police ALPR, which data was initially available through public record request:
http://records.oaklandnet.com/request/8562
Now the data is not "public record" anymore, but I wouldn't be surprised if - one way or the other - data harvesting companies would be able to get a copy.
I feel, even though we're not discussing text, the spirit of this quote is appropriate to mass surveillance post processing:
"If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him." --Cardinal Richelieu.
Discussion about authenticity e.g. here [1]
[1] https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/23785/what-did-r...
>This simple privacy measure would create an opportunity for drivers to protect sensitive information about their travel and whereabouts from mass collection by law enforcement and private data brokers.
But I still don't see how it works .. this info can still be collected while you are driving. And what kind of info are you worried private data brokers will get out of your parked car ?
"You regularly ski, an activity associated with a greater chance of injury."
"You have been visiting a private clinic for months, which raises your risk of having a major health issue you have not yet disclosed to us."
"You regularly eat at McDonalds, raising your long-term health care costs."
Or... "Why has my auto insurance gone up?"
"You are regularly at locations associated with illegal street racing."
"You are regularly near after market parts stores, and after market parts are correlated with high risk drivers."
I still have trouble getting the US mentality.
I frequently mock the CNIL because of its overbearing decisions but AFAIK this kind of organism would prevent this kind of use of your personal data.