News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by KasianFranks on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @05:37PM (#16163412)
Time to buy. Down from what price since January? Cryptocurrency is a long term play from a software and financial engineering vantage. It also continues to irritate the hell out of banks (bank accounts are being closed and restricted from exchange transfers, including coinbase) and general investors. It's not liquid enough yet, creates no need for middle men and Bitcoin itself is now being manipulated by futures contracts based on supply being increased artificially.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by spookthesunset on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @05:52PM (#16163547)
Ahh the "time to buy cheap coins" rally of the die-hard bitcoin shysters. Your own post says "It's not liquid enough yet, creates no need to middle men and Bitcoin itself is now being manipulated by futures contracts based on supply being increased artificially." Does that sound like buying now is a good idea? Doesn't to me...

Bitcoin is, was and always will be a highly manipulated penny stock. It spiked from $1000 to $20k for absolutely no reason, and now it is dropping down to $10k for absolutely no reason. Any price bitcoin spikes or drops to has no reason behind it... what kind of "store-of-value" / "currency" does that?

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by nukeop on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @05:57PM (#16163589)
What do you mean "no reason"? Supply and demand are the reasons the prices are shaped the way they are. It's a near perfect market.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by lkrubner on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:29PM (#16163906)
What is the P/E ratio of Bitcoin? There is none. So there is no rational basis for any price. $1 is as valid as $1 million. There is no traditional way to analyze this investment and figure out its real worth.

To the limited extent that Bitcoin helps Chinese citizens out-maneuver the capital controls that the Chinese government has tried to enforce, then it could be analyzed as a shadow of the Chinese currency, but since the action is illegal, the data is dark. Thus Bitcoin, and other crypto currencies, are the world's most opaque investment.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by gfodor on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:50PM (#16164057)
What's the "rational basis" for a specific value of the P/E ratio?

There are many stocks that belong to companies that have no mechanisms in place nor could they be reasonably expected to introduce mechanisms to directly return profits to shareholders. These stocks have the same form of "intrinsic value" as gold or Bitcoin: whatever the hell the next person is willing to pay for it.

Pretending that an underlying asset that doesn't throw off any yield or return of capital is somehow more rationally valuable than another doesn't make sense.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by FabHK on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:32PM (#16164356)
Glad you asked. P/E ratios can be anchored (with expected earnings growth and a risk premium) to interest rates.

Whether stocks pay dividends or not is not terribly relevant, see Modigliani-Miller.

Thus, share prices are rationally anchored to economic reality. Of course, there's a lot of estimation involved, and people can get it wrong for a while, individually or collectively.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by imtringued on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @05:22AM (#16166839)
>Pretending that an underlying asset that doesn't throw off any yield or return of capital is somehow more rationally valuable than another doesn't make sense.

Lets say I have a company with 1 billion dollar worth of assets and a 100 million dollar profit per year. I have issued 100 million shares during IP. How much is a single share worth? At the very least $10.

Next year I have a 1.1 billion dollar company. How much is a single share worth? At the very least $11.

You have 1000 shares worth $11000.

I can now either pay the profit out as dividend or not. Your shares will be worth less by exactly the amount that was paid out. Your 1000 shares will be worth $10000 and you will have $1000 in cash or alternatively I don't pay out a dividend and you still have 1000 shares worth $11000.

Where did that growth come from? With a company it's easy to answer. They sold more of their existing products. Released a new product. Reduced costs through technology. We have more stuff now. Investing in a stock helps a company indirectly even if stock buybacks never happen. The company receives better lending conditions from banks.

What about cryptocurrency? A currency shouldn't move in price at all. Where did that growth come from? From other people. Nothing new was created. Existing wealth merely gets redistributed.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by svachalek on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:35PM (#16164377)
Even if a stock does not return dividends, it still represents a share of ownership in the company. It has a real value to anyone who might want to purchase a controlling share in the company, value in reasonable proportion to the profit or profit potential of the company.

From that perspective, taking control of Bitcoin may have a measurable monetary value but as I understand the system the value isn't in the coins, it's in the miners.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by roywiggins on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @08:08PM (#16164581)
Buy enough of the company stock and you own the company. You can't do that with Bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by m3kw9 on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:06PM (#16164165)
Bitcoin isn’t a stock that has earnings. They are more like gold or silver. The usefulness + scarcity should determine its price. Right now people are buying because other people are buying, and a whole lot o hype
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by GenericsMotors on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @05:30AM (#16166870)
Even gold has some real-world usefulness that can drive demand as it's used in electronics manufacturing.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by 21 on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:39PM (#16163977)
> There is no traditional way to analyze this investment and figure out its real worth.

Is that bitcoin's problem or a traditional economists problem?

Behavioral economics does have frameworks for thinking about bitcoin price, but then again, behavioral finance is not traditional and highly controversial. For once, it dispenses with the myth of the rational investor (homo economicus)

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by lalaland1125 on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @02:07AM (#16166060)
> Behavioral economics does have frameworks for thinking about bitcoin price, but then again, behavioral finance is not traditional and highly controversial.

So, how does behavioral economics supply a price for Bitcoin?

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by spookthesunset on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:00PM (#16163632)
> What do you mean "no reason"?

As in "why is the price what it is". Saying "because of supply and demand" is useless, unhelpful pedantry.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by celticninja on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:31PM (#16163924)
I think that's an unfair accusation, ultimately the price is determined by supply and demand for the product, your question should really be what are the fundamental reasons behind people buying at X price and I think those are many and varied.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by bsaul on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:04PM (#16163670)
Was that sarcasm ??

In case you don't know, things like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_manipulation exists..

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by kakarot on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:02PM (#16163643)
With a healthy dose of FUD from several directions.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by KasianFranks on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @05:58PM (#16163604)
Efficient Market Theory is dead. There is no zero sum game. In the Markets things do not work based supply and demand but on perceived supply and perceived demand. Based on what I've learned I'd rather work with crypto than stocks or other more manipulated trading vehicles.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @05:58PM (#16163611)
creates no need to middle men

I've seen this consistently touted as a structural advantage to (bit)coins, but have yet to see a compelling technical explanation as to how/why this would be the case. The Satoshi paper doesn't discuss middlemen at all.

Very few people (relatively) are actually mining and most are just buying with USD from an exchange which by default is a middleman. Many of the other coins are pre-mined so aren't decentralized at all, which takes that whole point out of possibility.

Where's the proof of this claim?

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by VMG on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:02PM (#16163647)
The Satoshi whitepaper calls middlemen "trusted third parties"
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:10PM (#16163727)
Yes, good point, however I interpreted the "trusted third party" as preventing a central bank managed authority process that would "devalue" a currency through monetary creation. Nothing prevents that with bitcoin unless it was strictly used - you can always create derivatives that you sell to people.

It's like expecting people to trade goods with gold etc...

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by KasianFranks on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:01PM (#16163638)
P2P baby.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by jhwang5 on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @12:51AM (#16165777)
miners baby
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by justrobert on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:12PM (#16163747)
The futures contracts trade less than 1% of the global spot btc volume on any given day.

The products so far have been a failure.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by FabHK on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:20PM (#16164279)
> irritate the hell out of banks (bank accounts are being closed and restricted from exchange transfers, including coinbase)

It irritates banks not, by the way, because they're oh so scared about this fantastic new competitor to "their" money and money related businesses, but because it's often used (when it's used) for illegal transactions.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by Mandatum on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @12:02AM (#16165597)
I think it decentralizes account fees, lending, term deposits, funds, everything. It turns the traditional banking model on its head because anyone can "become a bank" and handle the traditional "keep your money safe" model that banking was originally created for. Those getting paid for transactions will be those investing in the network infrastructure - which is also decentralized, because again - anyone can jump in and do it.

The only downside to it all is if whoever handles your "account" (or wallet) is breached, or someone steals your "money".

Right now - no one will insure it. It'll come, and when it does - it'll likely be decentralized again, because that's entirely possible - throw 1% of your "account" into "insurance" and suddenly everyone is paying for their own insurance and third-party investigations into claims. That in itself will be heavily regulated by the companies running it, and I think the lower the fee - the more information they'll want from users.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by spookthesunset on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @12:57AM (#16165797)
Do bitcoin pumpers ever come up for air? None, I mean absolutely none of what you are writing will ever happen. Why? Because if Bitcoin boosters understood anything about politics, economics, math, finance, computer science, monetary policy, business, accounting, marketing or seemingly life in general.... they too would look at it and go "sounds way to good to be true. no thanks".

Every single thing in your post makes zero sense.... it is all breathless hype.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by imcoconut on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @02:26AM (#16166122)
> Every single thing in your post makes zero sense

Not true. Most of the post makes sense. Trustlessness and decentralization are pretty much the only benefits to bitcoin and others like it. There are obviously real costs for these features, but also real benefits. Do the benefits justify the current valuations - only the market can determine that. I personally am quite bearish on almost all cryptoassets (so I would not be considered a "pumper"), but certainly you must see the threat they pose to the incumbent masters of the monetary system?

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by Mandatum on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @07:00PM (#16173297)
Aren't we already seeing this in developing countries? Zimbabwe for instance has a great peer-to-peer lending platform. Currently backed by a bank, but what if the currency was simply tokens pegged to fiat such as USD by another company? (Similar to what Cryptopia has done with NZDT.)

Another example I've seen in real world use is the "startup" retail banks popping up throughout Africa that have no offices, and are purely operated over mobile.

The lack of regulation in these countries have lead to massive leaps in innovation in the banking space. Seriously, you can read articles about it - but until you go to countries like Nigeria or Kenya and try it out, it's incredibly impressive.

I'm not a major investor in crypto anything, I think most, if not all, coins created right now are completely pointless - but blockchain as a public, auditible ledger and fiat-backed crypto/tokens I think we'll see some very cool innovation that own't overhaul the banking industry completely. There's too many smart people in banking to get "caught out".

However I do think we'll see some new contenders in the space as the industry begins to break down into smaller units. And that'll be good for everyone.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by tikkabhuna on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @09:54AM (#16168312)
"Anyone can become a bank" isn't a good thing. What stops people at the moment is the requirement to be regulated. Compliance with that regulation costs money and is a barrier to entry but a necessary one.

Your "only downside" is enormous! I'd never consider paying my salary or keeping my savings in an organisation that has no regulation. My money could just disappear overnight.

You add that I could put 1% of the account into insurance, but that is essentially a 1% (yearly?) cost. Why would I do that when I can have a GBP bank account regulated by the FCA for free? In fact, the FSCS guarantees up to £85,000 per banking group (eg. HSBC).

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by Mandatum on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @07:20PM (#16173447)
That was just an example, it may be larger - it may be smaller depending on the amount you hold. I assume it'd be less than current fees you pay to hold accounts, make transactions, margins paid in FX. I'm thinking aloud, and I totally get the "why would I do that when I can use something that's existing and trusted".. But think about the early days of banking.

We've seen entire banks collapse and people lose their money in the past decade alone. The early days of banking was rife with fraud and scams.

I don't expect this to change in the short-term, however think about the convenience you'd see on day-to-day banking and how fast new features could be developed compared with our current banking system. Even if you only held a very small amount in a "new bank" and "currency" and kept you significant savings and assets in a traditional bank, I could see this slowly chipping away at existing banking services very quickly once a consensus on currency is reached within a community.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @05:41PM (#16163454)
Yes, but what? Ripple's seen maybe the biggest loss, but it's not clear that part of its loss isn't due to decreasing confidence in the underlying, which is bad if you want to BTFD. Same can be said for many others.

Though if you look at todays charts e.g. in ETH, it's clear someone's probably made good money intraday buying dips.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by m3kw9 on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:09PM (#16164187)
A lot of people don’t understand how ripple works and how the underlying mechanism works, it seems far more useful than bitcoin because of the transaction speed. But I think it is going down because that is the one they went up the most recently, which means the gains are more likely from hype than anything
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by KasianFranks on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @05:49PM (#16163524)
Agreed. Crypto is experiencing manipulation like stocks, bonds, debentures, CDs and derivatives of all kinds. Sharks, snakes, wolves are part of the game now for all kinds of reasons but the development communities also have a real chance at creating a better balance with assets based on the blockchain.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by spdy on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @05:58PM (#16163607)
Does it even matter? Everything went up LTC for example went from 3$ to 360$ Just wait till everything goes to the bottom and diversify between the top coins put them on an usb stick an forget about them until the next wave.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by cableshaft on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:19PM (#16163817)
Ripple will bounce back up (maybe not back up to $3 anytime soon, but I'm pretty sure it will go back up). A lot of people that got out are just trying to time the bottom as well as they can. I'm tempted to buy more myself. Part of me wants to wait to see if it drops more, part of me thinks I should just get in instead of trying to time the market and missing the opportunity.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:22PM (#16163845)
Why so sure? It seems to have gone up based on the news that Japanese banks were getting involved, but then it turns out they likely won't use the actual coins, just the tech?
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by cableshaft on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:37PM (#16163966)
Just based on the general patterns and trends, and that it seems to be the favored coin of the banking world, at least so far. But I very well could be wrong. Someone can be very confident and very wrong.

But as a general rule I'm conservative with how much I put into these things, just a small amount each month. I can afford to be very confident and very wrong about Ripple.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by scotty79 on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:19PM (#16163819)
I'd wait few months. Bitcoin tends to stabilize for few months before next ride up.