Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by wmf on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:39PM
(#16120833)
I know hardware is a sunk cost, but you should probably put some amortization in there.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by mrb on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:59PM
(#16120916)
You are right. However even sunk costs have been recovered very quickly lately. To give an idea: an S9 deployed in early November has already fully recouped its cost ($1500 in 40-60 days).
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by ekiara on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:59PM
(#16121495)
Honest question (I have no actual ASIC experience, I'm just curious)
Where are you getting the USD1500 price tag, I've just done a quick search and I only found a bunch of S9 Miners (Bitmain Antminer S9) advertised for over USD6000 on Amazon.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by mrb on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:56AM
(#16121705)
The batches sold and shipped in Nov were priced $1500. That was the price when buying directly from bitmain.com. Since then Bitmain hiked the price: the latest batch released yesterday (now sold out) was priced $2300. But yeah, since Bitmain's batches sell out in minutes, S9s often reach ~$5k in unofficial resale channels.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by thelittleone on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:07AM
(#16122420)
In that case, wouldn't it be more profitable for Bitmain to keep what they make and mine coins themselves?
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by SmallDeadGuy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:49AM
(#16122589)
It is if they want to bet on the value of bitcoin. Why use some hardware for 40-60 days to mine some coin which may or may not be worth $1500 when you could sell immediately for that amount? Sure you can mine for longer, but I'd bet they have more stable returns by investing profit from sales back into the business for fast/cheaper manufacturing, expanding their area of operations, etc.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by samolang on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:51AM
(#16122828)
Pretty sure they do.
https://www.reddit.com/r/BitcoinMining/comments/7jg14f/one_o...
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by rk06 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:30AM
(#16122751)
"During the gold rush its a good time to be in the pick and shovel business" - Mark Twain
the same analogy applies here, BitCoin mining is quite profitable, however hardware business is more reliable and in demand.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by mrb on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:43AM
(#16124129)
Yes, and they operate a decent amount of mining farms. However mining comes with a certain risk (eg. Bitcoin could crash) which is eliminated when selling the hardware right away. They can also manufacture hardware a lot faster than they can deploy data centers.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by jknz on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:30PM
(#16120786)
This means that miners in these areas operate with a 1500% profit after buying hardware equipment (1500% is computed with current price of 1btc=$16000 and the break-even point at 1btc=$1k). So are they scaling up and buying more hardware as fast as they can?
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by cwkoss on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:38PM
(#16120828)
Yep, the best ASIC Bitcoin mining hardware is almost always sold out... at least until a new better ASIC comes out.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by gcb0 on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:54PM
(#16120898)
and the grapevine says that they are mostly refurbs from actual mining operations that already have a new unpublicized version running.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by oh_sigh on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:37AM
(#16122290)
Right...why would this middleman sell them? Use them for your own operations!
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by cwkoss on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:44PM
(#16127123)
There have been several instances where the manufacturer mines with each manufactured device for a few months "for quality assurance purposes" (enriching themselves at lower difficulty levels, and then shipping after they've pushed difficulty up).
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by Cthulhu_ on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:44AM
(#16123032)
They've earned the investment back many times over and the newer devices are 2-4x as efficient, probably?
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by chisleu on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:56PM
(#16121125)
The large mining operations all own factories that build the ASICs.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by fyi1183 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:37AM
(#16122089)
To put it mildly, that seems pretty unlikely given the ridiculous amount of know-how and capital investment required for chip manufacturing.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by wwweston on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:59AM
(#16122163)
Might not be that would-be miners are acquiring that know-how, might be that people with the know-how tend to get into mining.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by user5994461 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:39AM
(#16122296)
He's probably talking about the ASIC design, not the manufacturing.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by dleslie on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @10:41PM
(#16121256)
So what ASIC boxes should I overnight to my house?
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by skrowl on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:41AM
(#16123729)
Antminer S9 is what you want. Good luck finding one. They should be $2500, but people are gouging up to 3x that for them.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by mpfundstein on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:02AM
(#16122640)
How many machines would you need to be sure that you actually mine a block in a given year? AFAIK its a stochastic process right?
I think I calculated once that , given the current hash power, you'd need about 20 miners in order to have P(you mine a block within a year) close to 1.
Can you confirm/discard my conclusion?
I'd post my calculations but I don't have it here at work!
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by mrb on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:46AM
(#16124143)
That's right, at current diff (1931e9) you need about 19 S9s (14 TH/s each) to mine a block in a year:
19 × 14e12 × 3600 × 24 × 365 / (2^32 × 1931e9) = 1.01
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by sudhirj on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:56AM
(#16122848)
Don't all fleets mine as pools these days? You put your hash capacity in a pool, and if any machine in the pool mines successfully the BTC is shared according to contributed capacity.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by golergka on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:59AM
(#16124224)
Mine pools.
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by denverpat on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:31PM
(#16120788)
Does the supply of miners not affect the reward? What is the average ROI for these miners? Do you know?
Re:Bitcoin Can Drop 50% and China Miners Will Still Make Money
by ShirsenduK on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:00AM
(#16122164)
It does. The bitcoin protocol adjusts its difficulty every 2 weeks by analysing the number of miners in the network. The adjustment is such that a block is discovered every ~10 minutes.
This is assuming $0.05 per kWh (which is a rate available to many miners outside of China, eg. Gigawatt Mining in Washington State pays $0.028 per kWh,) and a miner efficiency of 0.1 joule per gigahash (such as the popular Bitmain Antminer S9). The break even point is calculated with:
j_over_gh × cost_per_kwh / 3.6e6 (joules per kWh) / reward × (2^32 × diff) / 1e9
The parameter are: j_over_gh = 0.1, cost_per_kwh = 0.05, reward = 12.5 BTC per block, diff = 1931136454487.72. (This ignores transaction fees which have pushed the average block reward from 12.5 to around 17 BTC over the last few weeks, so the true break even point is even lower, around 1 BTC = $680).
I am occasionally interviewed by journalists who write about Bitcoin mining and they often get many details wrong. This one is no exception—Dan Murtaugh should have contacted me :)