News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by isoprophlex on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @12:38AM (#16103879)
Can't agree more. Also I am getting pretty sick of the impact crypto trading is having on office conversations. All I hear these days are inane conversations about getting rich quick. Everyone is an expert in technical analysis these days.

At best, trading these currencies is a zero-sum game where you take money from others without providing any intrinsic worth to humanity. At worst is a pyramid scheme plain and simple.

Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by baddox on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @01:13AM (#16104000)
I have no problem with valid criticism of cryptocurrency, and especially of its fanatics, but I’d be curious to hear you back up your claim that at best it’s a zero-sum game. That seems to me to be clearly incorrect.
Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by Synaesthesia on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @02:10AM (#16104209)
Of course it’s a zero sum game, I’d like to hear how it’s not. It’s not creating any value, any gains are at the expense of someone else.
Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by baddox on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @02:22AM (#16104245)
Who are they at the expensive of?
Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by Synaesthesia on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @06:18AM (#16105243)
The people buying the coins when you sell it. It would be impossible for everyone to profit from bitcoin. There would always have to be losers.
Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by vec on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @02:12AM (#16104214)
Person A mines 1 BTC. Since a Bitcoin has no intrinsic value (as distinguished from market value), Person A has not created any value. They have created $0 worth of goods.

Person A sells their coin to Person B for $1,000. A is $1,000 richer and B is $1,000 poorer.

B sells the bitcoin to C for $2,000. A is still $1k richer, B is $1k richer, and C is $2k in the hole.

C sells to D for $3k. A, B, and C are all $1k richer, but D is out $3k.

At no point in the chain is any actual value created or destroyed; it merely changes hands. So even though the price keeps going up, the total value across all participants never goes up. The sum of the gains and losses of all participants is $0.

(Note that I'm using "$" to represent a generic indicator of value. Feel free to substitute € or ¥ or gold or shares of Facebook stock or whatever.)

===============

There are two simplifying assumptions above, both of which make Bitcoin not exactly zero sum.

Good news first. Bitcoin can and does create some value in the same way that other currencies do: by facilitating mutually beneficial exchanges of goods and services. Commercial use appears to only be a tiny fraction of all Bitcoin transactions (and an even smaller fraction that wouldn't have been facilitated anyway using some other means of exchange), but it does happen so credit where credit's due.

The bad news, though, is that all of the above requires electricity. A lot of electricity, as it turns out. Both the initial mining and every transaction thereafter require someone, somewhere to burn some amount of power in order to generate proof of work. Since proof of work is explicitly designed to be useless, all that spent power is essentially deadweight loss.

I haven't seen any good numbers on the first recently (and I would love to have my assumptions proven wrong), but given the ginormous estimates of electricity consumed by the second I have a hard time believing the network as a whole isn't substantially worse than zero sum.

Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by baddox on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @02:29AM (#16104262)
The proof of work needs to be “useless” in order for it to protect the blockchain (there are proposals that dispute this, and I won’t claim to be an expert, but that’s the fundamental idea behind Bitcoin).

When you say that the net value is negative even if the network itself has some positive benefit, what is the negative component there? The only negative component of all that electricity usage is externalities, which apply equally to each unit of energy regardless of what it is used for. Pricing externalities into the cost of electricity is obviously something I approve of, but that’s a separate issue, and I doubt the externalities of electricity usage are anywhere near the magnitude of the positive impact of bitcoin.

Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by vec on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @03:03AM (#16104392)
Electricity isn't free. In the US it's about $0.12/kWh. If I spend a kWh of electricity mining Bitcoin, I owe the electric company in my town another $0.12. Presumably the electric company uses most of that $0.12 on the fuel and maintenance costs necessary to generate and provide me a kWh, costs which they would not have incurred but for my choice to mine Bitcoin.

Incidentally, this is (as far as I understand) where most of the transaction fees ultimately end up. They're paid out to the miner who actually commits a transaction. Mining's a relatively competitive field so people aren't going to be able to charge much of a premium. The miners then have to turn around and use those fees to cover their costs, which in practice means their hardware costs and their electrical bills.

Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by olalonde on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @02:18AM (#16104233)
Some see enormous value in an mathematically defined, uncensorable, permissionless, trustless, programmable, digital currency.
Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by oxide on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @02:25AM (#16104252)
and rightly so! the boom of ICO's is proof of concept if I've ever seen it, even though almost every single one is a scam as far as I've seen. I've had to discourage friends from investing in obvious scam ICO's, unfortunately. And my mother who is the most gullible sucker ever.

It's pretty strange to see people so consumed with it. It reminds me of beanie babies, and my horrible step-grandmother who would send me in to buy them once she had hit her limit. She was an awful speculator and probably has a worthless collection today for all the money she spent on ebay back then. She'd drive to Vegas to buy them, neighboring towns, all over the place. Totally consumed by speculation gambling. It sickens a person to see someone so...lost in that temptation. I'm not sure how else to put it.

Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by olalonde on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @02:40AM (#16104291)
> and rightly so! the boom of ICO's is proof of concept if I've ever seen it, even though almost every single one is a scam as far as I've seen.

Agreed, I've yet to see an ICO that seemed legit.

Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by llamataboot on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @01:01AM (#16103961)
Naysayers would point out that trading increases liquidity which ostensibly increases the ability of a market to parlay information into value.

But I'd be likely to agree with you. While blockchain technology /does/ have a future and will enable forms of socio-economic organization that were previously impossible, it's not there yet, and at the moment we're mostly passing tulips off to the greater fool.

Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by walrus1066 on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @02:33AM (#16104274)
'at the moment we're mostly passing tulips off to the greater fool.'

At least tulips have some intrinsic value, I.e. They can be quite pretty!

Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by BoiledCabbage on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @01:10AM (#16103988)
> Naysayers would point out that trading increases liquidity which ostensibly increases the ability of a market to parlay information into value.

And increasing opioid supplies, increases the ability of the market to efficiently parlay money into an altered mental state. Doesn't mean it's a net positive for society.

The "liquidity" argument is such a terrible and simplistic justification for so many things.

Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by oxide on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @02:14AM (#16104222)
Trust me, those opioids would be just as easy to acquire with Amazon Gift Cards, Paypal, Western Union, a bank deposit, you name it pal.

If you're trying to stand on some kind of anti-opiate moral ground for why cryptocurrency is evil it's a poor hill to die on.

Re:China wants an orderly exit from Bitcoin mining by jv22222 on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @02:43AM (#16104303)
> where you take money from others without providing any intrinsic worth to humanity

I beg to differ. Not all crypto projects are like that. For example Omise Go is a promising project that stands to make a difference to many people who have no access to banking services.

They have solid financials, already processing over $500m transactions per day with $110m investment.

They are making a completely decentralized open value exchange DEX based on the block chain. Any developer/provider will be able to build apps on top of it.

Any person with a phone will have instant access to essentially a bank account with no need to hand over social security and ID.

So basically giving 2 billion people who have no way to interact with financial systems a way to join in with global commerce.

> It’s not creating any value, any gains are at the expense of someone else.

Except, not in the case of Omise Go. You may earn a dividend simply by possessing the token.

By staking Omise Go tokens you will have the option to validate transactions (proof of stake) for which you will get paid.

Also note, with PoS there is no electricity burden on the system like Proof of Work with mining.