News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by stretchwithme on Friday January 05, 2018 @06:56PM (#16082833)
If I invented a cheap machine that did all your housework and fixed your car for free, GDP would fall. Despite the fact that everybody's lives would be permanently improved.

Say a person saves his money and lends it to people in another country. He's creating wealth for himself. The other country is getting further into debt. Maybe the money is spent frivolously or invested in a soon-to-collapse bubble. Or it's spent on productive investments. Either way, the effect on GDP is the same. And it goes to the borrowing country, not the one accumulating assets (unless the borrower makes successful investments).

As individuals, trying to maximize our own GDP would mean spending every dollar we get and avoiding investments that could reduce how much we need to spend to live our lives. That's the opposite of our best interests.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by dragonwriter on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:04PM (#16082874)
> If I invented a cheap machine that did all your housework and fixed your car for free, GDP would fall.

Probably not, because people would redirect both time and resources currently spent on housework and car repairs to other pursuits; this would most likely by GDP neutral or positive.

> As individuals, trying to maximize our own GDP would mean spending every dollar we get and avoiding investments that could reduce how much we need to spend to live our lives.

Technically, no, for several reasons. First, “your own GDP” (what might be called “gross personal domestic product”) is not increased by spending that goes to anyone but you, so maximizing it is just maximizing what people pay you for goods and services, not what you spend.

But to maximize your personal activity reflected in national GDP, your description is still wrong. Certainly, you are going to want to maximize spending on domestic goods and services, but spending on capital goods that reduced future cost doesn't hurt. Since economic wants are unlimited, any cost reduction has no necessary effect on your total future spending, it just increases the realizable utility at any level of spending.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by stretchwithme on Friday January 05, 2018 @09:15PM (#16083452)
Yes, the saved resources can be redirected to other uses. But not necessarily in the same economy.

As for your second point, I should have said "your own contribution to GDP" rather than "your own GDP". And with that, you CAN invest what you don't spend on yourself in other economies, as I said. It may reap benefits in the future. But GDP calculations can credit some other economy's GDP, as I said.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by stretchwithme on Friday January 05, 2018 @10:33PM (#16083691)
I should say that the housework we do ourselves is not captured in GDP.
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by wahern on Friday January 05, 2018 @11:55PM (#16083924)
Sure it is. It's captured by its effect on our overall productivity.

A significant share of the growth in U.S. GDP since the 1970s can be attributed to women leaving the home and entering the workforce. It's not that they were doing any less work beforehand, but a woman who sucked at housework but excelled at piloting an aircraft could work more productively, improving overall efficiency of the economy.

GDP didn't grow simply because her work was now measurable in dollars and cents. People lament that to have a similar standard of living today as 60 years ago, a family needs two wage earners. Yes, and part of the reason is because women entering the workforce _depressed_ wages. In other words, as women earned more money men began earning less. (Except it happened slow enough that men's absolute earnings never declined, they just grew more slowly.) Nonetheless, we're all better off when a woman can make better use of her unique skills. Our economy became more efficient overall, so overall GDP went up commensurately.

Many of the criticisms in that article aren't pertinent to a large, diverse economy like the United States. No economist believes that the GDP figures for a natural-resource intensive economy are as meaningful as for the U.S. They can absolutely be meaningful in some contexts, but are obviously less meaningful in others. Kudos to the journalist for admitting his young naivety, but he's assuming that the his elder contemporaries at the time were similarly naive about the limitations of GDP. The better assumption is that economists in the 1990s that had the same amount of experience as he enjoys today were similarly wise to the limitations of GDP.

Analogies about personal GDP don't work very well. GDP is a macroscopic view that is predicated on various behaviors averaging out. If you had an economy of a single person who only did housework, GDP is obviously useless. But so what? That doesn't say much of anything about it's utility for measuring the overall productive capacity of a huge, diverse economy.

Regarding the relevancy of GDP to Japan... that's why we have metrics like per capita GDP and metrics like the Gini coefficient. Japan is shrinking thus their rate of growth in GDP will slow if not shrink. As a population grows you can asymptotically approach a more efficient allocation of labour and resources, but if its not growing or shrinking you lose out on that avenue for improved productivity. If your entire economy is a single, two-person household, someone will invariably have to specialize in doing housework all day while the other works outdoors. If you have an economy of 300 million, you can out-source both mundane housework and mundane outdoor work and everybody gets more work done overall; certainly more so than an economy of two, but also more so than an economy of 200 million.

But population growth isn't the only opportunity to improve productivity. Japan has a high quality of life partly because of low inequality and thus a low Gini coefficient. Higher inequality tends to signal a more inefficient allocation of labor and resources. Which isn't to say that Japan doesn't have room to improve efficiency (sex inequality is still a big thing), but in many respects they're in a better place than the U.S. to begin with.

Like the the case with natural-resource intensive economies, the Gini coefficient tells us something about the accuracy and meaning of GDP, except in a quantified way. (And if you can't quantify something, you can't easily apply that knowledge.) A high Gini coefficient (and high inequality) suggests that we should be more careful about the conclusions we draw from GDP. In particular it suggests that our presumptions about things "averaging out" are more questionable. Inferences about particular details of the economy will be less accurate, and predictions more volatile. So it's not so much the case that GDP is a poorer way to measure quality of life in Japan, it's that because of our higher Gini coefficient it's a poorer way to measure quality of life in the U.S.

OTOH, it also follows that over the period where GDP growth in Japan has slowed relative to U.S. GDP growth, quality of life in the U.S. has probably in many ways improved faster. The effects mitigated, of course, by our inequality. Likewise, we can find all sorts of fault in how accurately GDP reflects particular details about China, but in relative terms if quite obviously reflects (as expected) a rapidly improving quality of life.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by sulam on Saturday January 06, 2018 @03:53AM (#16084466)
Do you actually do “housework”? You have some strange statements in here from the perspective of someone who lives in a dual income family with shared responsibility in the home. All the time-consuming chores of yesteryear take much less effort and time today. It takes me roughly 20 minutes to do a load of laundry, and we have to do 3-4 of those a week. It takes me 30 minutes to wash dishes once a day and the dishwasher is effectively a few minutes per day at most. Grocery shopping takes an hour or two, and that is getting serious tech applied to it lately, to the point that we may well not need to spend more than 10 minutes a week on it in the near future. Also it takes me about 15 minutes to make tea the way I like it. ;)

There are a lot of factors that contributed to women entering the work force, and one big one is home automation that left them with more free time.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by tinymollusk on Saturday January 06, 2018 @12:22PM (#16086267)
I ask this as a general question, as someone with a passing interesting in history, but no formal training: how do we know that free time caused women to enter the workforce, rather than women entering the workforce gave them enough money to trade money for time in household work, thus craeting a housework automation economy?

In history, things seem so... fuzzy[0]... that identifying the cause from effect seems so arbitrary.

[0] More formally, we never really know the full history, we generally rely on unreliable/biased narrators, and we don't know what information we don't know.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by sulam on Saturday January 06, 2018 @04:53PM (#16087683)
In general we can establish causality for socioeconomic theories using natural studies. For instance your question can be answered by comparing the timing of introduction of technology into the home and the rise of women in the workplace. You can ask people how much time they spend doing housework and compare to what people with technical alternatives spend. This is a relatively easy natural study since so much of the data was well collected at the time. Harder ones that are more recent ask things like whether or not raising the minimum wage increases unemployment. You’ll be able to find studies that used Seattle’s minimum wage law to determine the answer to that question.

In the narrow case of women entering the work force, the biggest factor was the employers being willing (forced) to hire women because they were the only workers available quite suddenly. Women would have entered the work force in more substantial ways before that but they were perceived as taking jobs from men. WW2 changed all that. One reason they were able to keep working after the war is because they had money and the products were available to allow them to get the housework done in less time. It was a status symbol in the 50s (and probably still today) to have a very bored wife at home.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by wahern on Monday January 08, 2018 @05:04PM (#16101122)
FWIW, my point isn't predicated on why women were able to enter the workforce. I was merely arguing against the claim that informal labor isn't reflected in nominal GDP. See my reply elsethread.

IIRC, I first came across the claim about women disrupting the labor economy in one of Francis Fukuyama's books, probably either "Trust: The Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity" (1995) or "The Great Disruption: Human Nature and the Reconstitution of Social Order" (1999). It's been awhile since I read it, however; but I've read many books since then and while I don't know if any other source I've personally read made such a straight-forward claim, I think the contention is largely accepted and, especially more recently, widely acknowledged that women entering the workforce (for w'ever reason) substantially suppressed the nominal wages of men.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by wahern on Monday January 08, 2018 @04:36PM (#16100836)
It doesn't matter _why_ women entered the workforce. I was arguing against the idea that GDP only reflects nominal wages, and doesn't reflect the value of labor outside the formal labor market. My point was that when women were primarily homemakers, the average salary of the man indirectly reflected the work of the entire household and thus was actually reflected in the GDP. Not perfectly, of course, because she wasn't as free to participate in the labor market as men, and thus society systemically undervalued her labor. But to a large extent it was indeed reflected in nominal wages.

Likewise, when the article discussed how the per-capita GDP of Kenya, at only $2, clearly didn't reflect the "real" amount of labor and wealth in Kenya, it's wrong and misleading. Much of that value is reflected in $2 in that $2, in nominal wages, is all you need to subsist. Remember, there's no such thing as "intrinsic" value, not in economics. If $2 is all the Kenyan labor market is willing to pay, then $2 reflects rather well how the Kenyan labor market is structured, and reflects what value any investments can leverage in the short-term. (Would you invest $100 million in Kenya in exchange for help harvesting your fields and babysitting your kids?) We don't need some ad hoc system to quantify the potential of the Kenyan labor economy because the potential is implicit in the huge difference between the Kenyan GDP and the GDP of richer countries.

Look at it another way: if I sit here and pour myself into writing HN posts all day rather than participating in the formal labor market, can I complain that GDP isn't accurately reflecting the value of my labor? It's nonsense. I would be neither wrong nor right. My complaint would only beg the question, value by who's reckoning?

There's a debate to be had, at the margins, about the limits and accuracy of metrics like GDP, but the notion of trying to quantify wealth outside the formal economic system is fundamentally and hopelessly flawed. Rather than trying to create some framework to guesstimate the value of supposedly hidden wealth, people should be working to plug these systems of labor and exchange into the formal economy. A free market economy based on supply & demand and a fungible currency is fundamentally a pricing system. It's a giant calculator with a built-in unit for determining and expressing "value". For all its many flaws, it's foolish to believe anybody can do any better by trying to tally behaviors individually. Such systems are invariably worse in terms of systemic biases. It's why communism failed--at scale no system of pricing the "value" of objects and labor is more honest, accurate, and consistent than what people manifestly are willing to freely accept in exchange; and no system of quantifying that value is more honest, accurate, and consistent than a nearly perfectly fungible, nearly perfectly substitutable commodity--currency. It's not perfect, but it represents the best that is achievable.

If you find flaws in how the system prices those things, it usually has something to do with 1) the lack of freedom of accepting or rejecting exchange or 2) the medium of exchange (i.e. currency). Thus debates about whether, e.g., healthcare should be considered some sort of right (forcing government or employers to express the cost, previously hidden by silent pain and suffering, in nominal currency) so that people would be more free to change jobs. The issue and task is to figure out a way so that these things can be more transparently priced into the formal economy, rather than spending time trying to quantify these things in some ad hoc, contrived model. What good would such a number be, anyhow?

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by james1071 on Friday January 05, 2018 @08:01PM (#16083141)
That's not correct.

In general, the effect of new technology is to increase the output of the economy - we get more stuff.

This translates into a higher GDP.

Now, consider your specific example.

The effect of the machine would be to free up time for people to do other things.

Some of this might be increased leisure (not capured by GDP) , while some of it will be increased output in the economy, which will show up as increased GDP.

Your comment about individuals striving to increase GDP is silly - GDP is an aggregate statistic and the result of people trying to maximise their own personal welfare.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by maxander on Friday January 05, 2018 @08:39PM (#16083322)
If someone invents a machine that does some necessary consumer-level work (say, a washing machine) and the result is not increased leisure, something is Very Wrong. Sure, we could spend the time we save doing dishes on productive labor, but this wasn't time we owed to the workforce in the first place.

"Increased activity occupies surplus generated by increased efficiency" works for corporations, which is why economists like it, but not for humans, which is GP's point. In fact, GDP is only of practical utility at all insofar as that equation does not hold, since leisure and autonomy and generally not-being-beholden-to-work is the economic end of "human welfare."

There's other points, which I think GP was referencing in a less clear way, about how GDP measures all sorts of economic "activity" that is useless altogether- financial speculation in bubbles, competing advertisement campaigns, etc. But the main point is that GDP is a measure of output, not welfare, and for humans (all else being equal) we're better off the less that we're required to do.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by james1071 on Saturday January 06, 2018 @06:42AM (#16084851)
We know what happens when labour saving machines, such as washing machines, were invented - married women, who used to spend most of the day on housework entered the workforce.
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by pteredactyl on Saturday January 06, 2018 @02:57AM (#16084339)
Who is to say fixing your neighbors machine is not leisure time? With the added benefit of increased social capital ( if I’m going to be clinical about it ).
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by naravara on Friday January 05, 2018 @08:47PM (#16083357)
>someone invents a machine that does some necessary consumer-level work (say, a washing machine) and the result is not increased leisure, something is Very Wrong.

Leisure isn’t free though. Increased leisure time is going to create work/spending in other areas. So you save time on household chores due to the cheap machine, that means you probably end up spending more money on your leisure activities. You buy more books, video games, hiking boots, sports gear, etc.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by stretchwithme on Friday January 05, 2018 @09:19PM (#16083468)
Or sleep. Or studying. Or taking a walk with a loved one.

The point is that a lot of the benefit to us of such an innovation is not going to show up in GDP, even if some of that time is used for fun activities. GDP doesn't count increases in fun either.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by eropple on Friday January 05, 2018 @11:39PM (#16083884)
> You buy more books, video games, hiking boots, sports gear, etc.

Why? I have hiking boots. They'll last me twenty years. I have more books and video games than I could ever read and play already.

Why should leisure time be considered a vehicle for consumption of stuff in the first place?

Self-actualization isn't reflected in GDP, and yet it actually matters.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by Godel_unicode on Saturday January 06, 2018 @01:48AM (#16084189)
You're aware that your response here is atypical, and the exact kind of problem that is addressed by behavioural economics, yes? While what you're describing (using new found free time to engage in free leisure activities) is what you see as desirable, it is emphatically not what humans as a population do.

When discussing macro things like GDP, the homo-economicus minimax behavior of the few is inconsequential and has no place in a discussion of what would happen. However much we might not wish it so.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by eropple on Saturday January 06, 2018 @04:14AM (#16084514)
OK. So let's keep going. You are correct, what I'm describing is atypical. Why is it atypical?

Is it because they need more stuff? Or is it because their brains are under near-constant assault from a barrage of advertising that melts their willpower and creates a link between having a free moment to themselves and consumption, a desperate instillation to keep up with the Joneses?

I would contend, and I'd fight about it, that the answer is the latter and that it is an overwhelming, brain-breaking external imposition. And it's in the service of making that particular number that's the topic of that article just a little bigger.

We need to stop fucking ourselves up as people and as communities and measures that do not take that into account are bad measures that should not be fetishized. (And they are fetishized. They are drooled over. And yet nobody dies taking pride in how they made GDP bigger.)

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by usaar333 on Saturday January 06, 2018 @01:44PM (#16086759)
> Is it because they need more stuff? Or is it because their brains are under near-constant assault from a barrage of advertising that melts their willpower and creates a link between having a free moment to themselves and consumption, a desperate instillation to keep up with the Joneses?

Generally, increasing incomes in developed countries lead to increased service consumption or at most indirect manufacturing. While some of this is "keeping up with the Joneses", I think a lot of it is just rational time valuing.

e.g. I've found that as my income has gone up considerably in the last half-decade (several hundred percent), I am spending more - but not on buying more goods. Generally it is bucketed under:

Spending more to save more time (increased value of time):

* online grocery shopping

* spending more to live close to work

* use of more expensive cab-services (lyft/uber) rather than public transit or biking

* flying direct rather than multi-stop.

* Spending more on childcare to maximize time spent on more intellectually stimulating endeavors (including work) or at times traveling

Higher quality:

* higher end food and restaurants

* more expensive travel options (distance/exotic)

* larger housing units to feel less cramped that also offer time-saving amenities (in-unit laundry, gym/pool, 24/7 package delivery)

I'm getting more leisure -- and directing a lot into the GDP numbe.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by abalashov on Sunday January 07, 2018 @04:41AM (#16090099)
Because capitalism. Even the mountain you hike keeps business hours, requires vehicular propulsion to get to, and charges a fee for parking.

Laws and social conventions alike discourage simply standing around doing nothing in particular in most public places, and loitering ordinances sometimes expressly forbid it. There aren’t that many places to go or things to do, both as a matter of practical exigencies and sociocultural rituals alike, which don’t involve some business to transact.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by coliveira on Saturday January 06, 2018 @02:53AM (#16084332)
This is the only answer that is possible within the narrow view of capitalism. If you have more time, you should spend more, according to them, otherwise the economy will flounder. It's not a surprise then that capitalism societies strive to have most of their population earning only enough so they don't have the temptation of forgetting to spend all the money they receive.
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by kelnos on Saturday January 06, 2018 @12:40AM (#16084033)
Ugh, that sounds terrible. In my utopia, machines do all the work, and everyone in the world gets to do whatever they want, which will mostly be leisure. Yes, there will be some people for whom leisure means work, and more power to them. I still don't understand the drive to be "productive". What's the point of technology if not to shift the need to be productive away from humans?

It sounds like a very sad world to me where people automate their jobs away in order to just find new jobs to fill their time. Of course, that is the world we _currently_ live in, just on a smaller scale than I'd hope we'd eventually achieve. I think it'd be a wonderful world where we can only dream up jobs for a tiny percentage of the population, assuming the wealth created by automation is distributed so people who don't work can still live great lives.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by rland12 on Saturday January 06, 2018 @01:34AM (#16084154)
I think about this a lot.

People 100 years ago, if they teleported to today, would look at our lives, our possessions, the conveniences offered to us every single day by all of this increased productivity... They would probably wonder why we don't cut the hours we've worked by half or more. I don't quite understand it myself. Why does all of the time we've gained go to working, when it seems to me the cost of a "whole lifetime" has gone down by so much in the past 50 years.

Machines seem to already do most of the work necessary for a human life for us.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by Fricken on Saturday January 06, 2018 @03:45AM (#16084430)
Karl Marx anticipated the machines would allow us to live lives comprised largely of leisure by now, but here we are all working. The thing is, if we were content with middle class living standards of the 19th century we'd be working a whole lot less. So when it becomes possible to do something crazy like build out an asteroid mining industrial complex, or something, will we say 'ahh, we don't need to do that, let's put our feet up', do you think we'll take it easy or will we keep working? I think we'll keep working.
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by DonaldFisk on Saturday January 06, 2018 @03:56AM (#16084472)
Not just Marx: John Maynard Keynes thought we'd be on a 15 hour week: http://www.econ.yale.edu/smith/econ116a/keynes1.pdf
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by Godel_unicode on Saturday January 06, 2018 @01:51AM (#16084199)
You might be interested in reading about the hedonistic treadmill, if you haven't already heard of it. Effectively, good things don't make us very happy for very long before we need more.
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by projektir on Saturday January 06, 2018 @03:08AM (#16084351)
The hedonistic treadmill is someone's hypothesis. I am very skeptical that it is actually correct, as working around it seems fairly simple (certain video games are a good example).

I would rather we didn't base major social attitudes on someone being convinced that a normal, healthy human wouldn't be able to make themselves happy.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by kelnos on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @12:38PM (#16107977)
A sibling poster covered this, but a maybe-not-terrible analogy occurred to me: it's like writing software. Even when you've finished building out all the features you want to build, it's still never done. There might be bugs that need to be fixed, or you might want to make some slow parts of the code more efficient, or users have come up with some new use cases that require you to add new features. It just never ends. It's rare to find a software project that's "done", aside from abandoned projects.

I guess people are just never satisfied with some kind of end state. And I guess that's a good thing; life is pretty good these days (if you're reasonably well off in a developed country), but, well... we still don't have our jet packs or hoverboards or flying cars. All progress depends on people not being satisfied with the status quo.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by imtringued on Sunday January 07, 2018 @05:44PM (#16093163)
The benefits are captured by spending more on exclusionary rivalrous goods like land, education and healthcare.
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by lordnacho on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:17PM (#16082936)
I think a more apt example is this.

It's definitely bad to live in a society where violence and robbery are common. We'd rather be without those things.

But if everyone spends money on bodyguards, that ends up in GDP.

In a comparable society where violence and robbery was not common, you would use the money for other things that are definitely preferred over giving it to bodyguards, security camera shops, locksmiths, and so on.

So measuring GDP in the way we do is defective; it gives near equal figures for both societies when clearly one is better than the other.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by dragonwriter on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:25PM (#16082980)
Everyone knows GDP (and all other existing economic measures) are imperfect, limited tools that don't capture all meaningful variations.

That's not a meaningful criticism of using GDP at all, or of using it as the headline measure of economic performance.

To validly criticize using GDP as the headline measure, you need to show not merely that GDP is flawed, but that there is an alternative measure that can be practically calculated that is on-balance better at capturing the overall picture.

To validly criticize using GDP at all, you need to go further and make the case that there is no purpose for which there is not a better measure available.

“GDP doesn't capture the whole picture” is an easy but meaningless criticism.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by naravara on Friday January 05, 2018 @09:01PM (#16083410)
>To validly criticize using GDP as the headline measure, you need to show not merely that GDP is flawed, but that there is an alternative measure that can be practically calculated that is on-balance better at capturing the overall picture.

Why? Maybe we should be more humble about what metrics can and can’t do for us.

Maybe we should admit that many of the things that matter to us are subjective rather than avoiding the difficult questions by fixating only on things that appeal to positivists?

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by dragonwriter on Friday January 05, 2018 @11:57PM (#16083929)
> Why?

Because if it's the best tool we have for a purpose, then it's the right tool for that purpose even if it's not the platonic ideal of a tool for that purpose.

> Maybe we should be more humble about what metrics can and can’t do for us.

Not only do I agree with that, I've made the same point elsewhere in this thread:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16082943

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by kaycebasques on Friday January 05, 2018 @08:17PM (#16083221)
Are there any GDP alternatives or variations that attempt to give more weight to socially-positive output and less weight to anti-social output?
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by mch82 on Friday January 05, 2018 @09:01PM (#16083408)
Umair Haque proposed an option in his HBR essay “Betterness: Economics for Humans.” He uses the analogy that GDP is like the RPM gauge on a car, hard to use without the context of a speedometer. He proposes new measures to supplement GDP and help indicate if real wealth is being created. Not sure how these ideas have developed since 2010.

https://www.amazon.com/Betterness-Economics-Humans-Kindle-Si...

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by ferongr on Friday January 05, 2018 @08:50PM (#16083369)
What is "socially-positive" output and who gets to decide that?
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by naravara on Friday January 05, 2018 @09:02PM (#16083412)
Whatever consensus based decision making body your society uses to engage in collective action.
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by emiliobumachar on Saturday January 06, 2018 @05:50PM (#16087927)
Well, that would make it hard to impossible to compare different societies, or the same society at different times.

Even if we ignore corruption and bad incentives, values change.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by naravara on Sunday January 07, 2018 @12:58AM (#16089502)
So change the metrics with them.

Cross comparisons are certainly not that valuable if the metric you’re using to compare is motivating people to engage in maladaptive policy.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by coliveira on Saturday January 06, 2018 @03:00AM (#16084341)
The biggest flaw of GDP is that governments around the world try to maximize it. And, as we see in many cases, making it bigger doesn't necessarily make it better. Take education for example: you can have free schools and free universities for everyone, bringing zero additional GDP. Or you can have for profit schools and universities that will be afforded only by a few, but with big GDP impact. Another clear example is given by the USA: nationalizing health care would be great, but it would also reduce the GDP because of destruction of the for-profit industry. In this case, however, lower GDP could bring better health outcomes for most people in the country.
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by Godel_unicode on Saturday January 06, 2018 @01:56AM (#16084208)
But why are you hand waving away the compounding GDP value of those other things??

Buying things which allows for employment and investment to invent yet other things is pretty obvious capitalism 101. Safe societies have a value which shows up in GDP long-term, see also spillover benefits.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by Alex3917 on Friday January 05, 2018 @09:41PM (#16083545)
This isn't exactly a new idea. This is from the early 90s:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0q-lEATP-9Y

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by fjsolwmv on Friday January 05, 2018 @09:23PM (#16083484)
GDP is an enshrinement of the Broken Windows Fallacy of economics. It completely miscounts externalities as benefits.
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by GreeniFi on Saturday January 06, 2018 @04:28AM (#16084554)
The biggest beef I have with GDP is that it does not capture how we run down natural capital to create financial capital. Pollute our seas, cut down our forests, poison our air: this is all a capital loss, but reflected as a financial gain in GDP statistics, even though finance is a human abstraction and our natural capital is real. In Swahili, the word for nauture is maliasili, also translated as ‘genuine wealth’. We have something to learn from that.
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by beiller on Saturday January 06, 2018 @08:07PM (#16088457)
Something I always find interesting is the word Eco-Nomics which is a greek and latin mashup for "study of the home", but still the Eco prefix seems to have a similar meaning here.
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by cryptonector on Friday January 05, 2018 @10:04PM (#16083608)
GDP wouldn't necessarily go up nor down due to such an invention. However, a useful invention that increases productivity (as yours undoubtedly would!)... frees up resources (capital and labor) for other uses, which, if they're actually put to such other uses, may well lead to additional production.

Don't fall for the ATM fallacy (that ATMs killed the bank teller job, therefore made people poorer -- they did not do the latter!).

It's true that malinvestment initially shows up as growth, but later turns into a destructive, recessionary force.

Maximizing current GDP is not the same thing as maximizing future GDP. The latter is a much better activity, while the former can lead to ruin. Exactly as you say.

But, at the end of the day, with all economic activity aggregated, measures like GDP are actually useful and meaningful. Of course, context helps. Growing GDP in a context of massive malinvestment is definitely not a good thing!

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by InclinedPlane on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:38PM (#16083039)
If I invented an expensive machine that destroyed your house then GDP would increase because manufacturing the machine (and rebuilding the house) count as economic activity. This is a big problem with military spending as reflected in GDP. GDP isn't a measure of wealth or quality of life it's a measure of economic activity that is mostly relevant in regards to trade and almost nothing else.
Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by dragonwriter on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:43PM (#16083065)
> If I invented an expensive machine that destroyed your house then GDP would increase because manufacturing the machine (and rebuilding the house) count as economic activity.

This is again a faulty assumption; while they would count as economic activity, it likely wouldn't be additional economic activity, but displacing economic activity that would otherwise take place, especially the house rebuilding.

Also, destroying someone’s house doesn't guarantee it gets rebuilt, anyway.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by InclinedPlane on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:50PM (#16083092)
Sure it would.

Why are you building a house destroying machine (let's say tank) in the first place? Let's say it's because your nation is going to war, and has gone into deep deficit spending to finance high levels of production of war materiel. That's a lot of economic activity that wouldn't have happened otherwise. Similarly another nation going to war and paying you to build them tanks might be a similar situation.

This isn't hypothetical. In the US GDP and military spending went way, way up during WWII though overall quality of life remained stagnant or went down (due to rationing). Only after the war when production capacity was re-allocated toward consumer goods did quality of life and wealth start to increase.

The same is true for houses. Not having a house (or lots of people being recently deprived of houses) is great motivation for building houses. Lots of resources get leveraged that would not normally have been leveraged. The economy isn't a zero sum game, even in regards to production capacity. You notice this all the time when there's a recession or a boom. Total capacity (manufacturing, home building) is elastic, it responds to demand, and that can vary a great deal on a huge number of factors. Destroying a house doesn't guarantee it gets rebuilt, but destroying lots of houses will typically be associated with a lot of home building in response.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by jabl on Saturday January 06, 2018 @05:56AM (#16084743)
> If I invented a cheap machine that did all your housework and fixed your car for free, GDP would fall.

This experiment has (partly) been made, not that many decades ago, actually. The introduction of many household appliances like the washing machine, the dishwasher, and the vacuum cleaner reduced the amount (mostly women) spent doing house chores, and allowed women to enter the workforce.

Re:The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure t... by mhh__ on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:35PM (#16083025)
> If I invented a cheap machine that did all your housework and fixed your car for free, GDP would fall.

If we take "free" to mean something along the lines of [Negligible compared to current cost] - i.e. no free lunch: Is it not the case that this has already happened, at least in terms of technological advance (of a similar magnitude), and overall GDP has not fallen.

Or, by GDP falling, do you mean in ideal conditions where nothing else changes (i.e. All other variables held constant)?