News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by snitko on Sunday August 15, 2010 @03:27PM (#1605716)
As a Russian I'm, of course, concerned about it. Almost every intelligent young person under 30s here believes that the system is really broken. However we don't see any changes and I've been puzzled why.

Theoretically, even the most egoistic government who's only purpose is to get more for themselves must realize that in order to preserve it's welfare it must make sure the citizens are doing fine. Russians are not desperate yet, so maybe the government has found the right balance. Obviously, many are involved in the scheme and many people have things to lose if the government initiates a real war on corruption. So the government must be afraid too and that fear is greater. However, I don't think you can keep that balance forever. Like the article suggests, the brightest flee the country and someone has to make the economy going.

I realize I probably don't know many things guys up there are aware of, but it seems pretty obvious from down here that the only thing that should be done to help the country bloom is to eliminate corruption. For real. Then all those silicon valleys and scientists start reappearing on their own, healthcare starts recovering, investors begin coming back. Focus.

Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by mattchew on Sunday August 15, 2010 @03:58PM (#1605783)
Theoretically, even the most egoistic government who's only purpose is to get more for themselves must realize that in order to preserve it's welfare it must make sure the citizens are doing fine.

This is true if the government is secure in its power. If the rulership--or factions within the rulership--are worried about losing their privileges, they may just grab what they can when they can.

Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by snitko on Sunday August 15, 2010 @04:04PM (#1605808)
That's a popular point here. Many think they're just grabbing as much as they can while they can. I don't know. Maybe it's true, but it seems to me it would be quite a task to run and hide later. It may be easier to stay and secure the environment (by eliminating corruption and making it safe). Maybe I'm wrong.
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by sliverstorm on Sunday August 15, 2010 @05:09PM (#1605942)
Not to stereotype, but I have noticed all my friends who have a live-fast, die-hard sort of attitude- the type that is appropriate when you're not entirely sure if you'll see tomorrow- were born in Russia.

So, I would hazard a guess the folks you speak of are simply not conditioned to be thinking about 'later'.

Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by snitko on Sunday August 15, 2010 @05:25PM (#1605978)
That is probably one of the most correct stereotypes about Russians. For example almost no one ever saves money here. Nor in the banks, neither under the pillow.
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by lfnik on Monday August 16, 2010 @10:35AM (#1607872)
I have married a Russian and I can also confirm this. Adrenaline junkies galore in Russia
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by fgf on Monday August 16, 2010 @04:02AM (#1607159)
An interesting comparison I'm not really qualified to make is between the relatively secure (?) and cohesive (!) chinese communist party elite and the chaotic free for all (?) in russia. The countries elites both help themselves to quite a bit of wealth but the russians seem to experience an unsolved tragedy of the commons issue. If this is true, will united russia (or whatever it's called) solve the problem of maximising returns from their control of the country (it did take the PRC communist party a few decades)? How could they?
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by houseabsolute on Monday August 16, 2010 @04:08AM (#1607168)
I read an economics paper on this once, but I forgot its title. Couldn't have been a very advanced paper because it was undergraduate economics. The thesis was basically exactly what you just said.
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by pvg on Sunday August 15, 2010 @04:39PM (#1605872)
Theoretically, even the most egoistical government whose only purpose is to get more for themselves must realize that in order to preserve its welfare it must make sure the citizens are doing fine.

Sadly, this theory has eluded Russian and Soviet governments for many decades.

However we don't see any changes and I've been puzzled why.

I think, fundamentally, the transition to a society ruled by law is a very long and difficult one. It was long and difficult in the countries where the modern form of the notion originated. It's probably going to be longer and harder elsewhere.

Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by radu_floricica on Sunday August 15, 2010 @04:40PM (#1605878)
Read some Hernando de Soto: http://www.amazon.com/Mystery-Capital-Capitalism-Triumphs-Ev...

No time to go into depth, and probably won't do it justice, but a good summary would be "Institutions matter". Like it or not, the kind of negative entropy found in the west isn't easy to come by, and trying to build it from nothing most times will fail in strange ways.

Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by learner4life on Sunday August 15, 2010 @10:38PM (#1606629)
"Theoretically, even the most egoistic government who's only purpose is to get more for themselves must realize that in order to preserve it's welfare it must make sure the citizens are doing fine."

The trouble is an egoistical government rarely possesses the ability to draw a line and stop interfering(rules and regulations) and collecting money(taxes,bribes) so that people can have enough to do fine. The people who run it are blinded by greed and always want a little bit more. Also, while the people at the top might realize that corruption should not exceed beyond a point, it is hard to enforce as your lowly clerk/officer does not possess the ability to see the bit picture. All he/she knows is everyone is corrupt(it is institutionalized) and tries to take the biggest pie he/she can.

Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by snitko on Sunday August 15, 2010 @03:36PM (#1605742)
That is to say, eliminating corruption is a dangerous and a difficult task. Someone really smart should be working on it. I can tell by the speeches they're not doing it at all right now.
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by jeromec on Sunday August 15, 2010 @04:49PM (#1605898)
I watched an interview with President Medvedev in which problems like corruption were brought up. It seemed like he is taking a long term view of improving conditions in Russia, which makes sense to me, because it's not possible to transition to the kind of democracy with limited corruption we see in the U.S. overnight. What do you think of the actions or non-actions of the current Russian leadership? Are they at least on a path toward improving the situation?

Interview: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HwZLhqDEnSo&feature=playe...

Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by snitko on Sunday August 15, 2010 @05:21PM (#1605969)
If you listen carefully to this interview and others, you'll only hear he says he's going to fight corruption, but he doesn't say how. Politicians are usually all like this in any country, though. I listen a lot to Obama's speeches and interviews and he's pretty much the same. It's all blabbing.

To give you an impression of how it probably should be, may I remind you of Mikhail Saakashvili, a Georgian president, who is so much hated in Russia. Personally, I don't know what happened at that war in 2008, but what many people in Russia realized recently is that he managed to eliminate corruption in Georgia in a matter of 3-4 years. How? One example: they fired all of the police force there overnight, hired and trained new people, raised their salaries and punished seriously for any bribes. What was the result? A great raise in respect for police in Georgia in less than 2 months.

Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by jeromec on Sunday August 15, 2010 @05:40PM (#1606021)
Yes, I'm aware that politicians often speak "empty words". However, I would point out some politicians are indeed active and effective. President Obama has already signed over 200 bills into law, including one so large and complicated it took over 50 years of unsuccessful attempts: healthcare. I was just wondering if President Medvedev is more of the "empty words" type of politician, or does he genuinely feel compelled to do his best to improve conditions? As much as he safely can, that is.
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by lsc on Monday August 16, 2010 @07:14AM (#1607419)
>President Obama has already signed over 200 bills into law, including one so large and complicated it took over 50 years of unsuccessful attempts: healthcare.

I will believe it when I see it. Right now, the situation is that nobody will sell me health insurance /at any price/ and the things that are wrong with me are really pretty minor. The health plan says this won't be a problem in 2014.

Then, the people this bill was really meant to help are screaming bloody murder because they are now going to have to pay for health insurance. the thing is, most people are just getting by. Sure the bill provides help for low-income folks, but people worry they might not meet the low-income cut off, what with the payments on the truck and the house.

So yeah, I'll be /very/ surprised if this actually goes in to effect. My personal plan is to try to get a group plan for prgmr.com; I've gotta bring nick on full time anyhow, so I might as well.

Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by temphn on Sunday August 15, 2010 @07:22PM (#1606234)
Obama is a government official increasing govt power. That's easy comparatively, govt has the guns and the pulpit. Going against the flow is hard.
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by jeromec on Sunday August 15, 2010 @08:00PM (#1606298)
Obama is a government official increasing govt power.

Government power in the U.S. is limited by the Separation of Powers as well as the Constitution.

Edit: Someone downvoted me? Why not post an argument with your position?

Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by vorg on Monday August 16, 2010 @12:45AM (#1606867)
I'm always amazed how many U.S. Supreme Court decisions are passed by a 5-to-4 vote. Government power in the U.S. is limited by the beliefs of the 9 lifelong Supreme Court judges, interpreting written laws and precedents according to their own subjective belief systems.
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by jeromec on Monday August 16, 2010 @08:38AM (#1607576)
Yes, that is how it's set up and yet the Supreme Court does not make the laws or set policy. So the judicial branch of government is limited too -- just as it is meant to be -- by the Separation of Powers.
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by fgf on Monday August 16, 2010 @04:14AM (#1607177)
there is no position to disagree with, just a well known fact posted as if it was in opposition to the quoted statement..
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by jeromec on Monday August 16, 2010 @08:43AM (#1607589)
That's just it. It is in opposition if it's a fact. The OP said President Obama is expanding government power. If it's a fact that government power is limited by the Constitution and Separation of Powers then no president can expand government power without circumventing these checks and balances. They may expand government influence but not government power. So for the OP to be correct I guess the claim is that President Obama is circumventing the Constitution, Congress and the Supreme Court?

Edit: Actually, I take that back. Since the citizenry and Congress can neglect their oversight duty, presidents can in fact increase government power, as evidenced recently by George Bush Jr. However, in theory the mechanisms exist to place limits on what any single person/politician can do. Making a blanket statement that Obama is increasing government power without providing specific arguments how is not substantive. After all, the same could be said by picking any of the other 43 presidents at random.

Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by snitko on Sunday August 15, 2010 @05:57PM (#1606078)
Well, how am I supposed to know if he's genuine, I'm not his psychoanalyst. And I don't think it matters. I don't see how he can change anything - that's the problem.
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by jeromec on Sunday August 15, 2010 @06:18PM (#1606111)
I agree that progress, if any at all, would be slow. President Medvedev recently toured Silicon Valley, opened a Twitter account, and proclaimed Russia "open for business". Unfortunately, with articles like this I don't think he will get many takers. However, I do think such efforts can plant the seeds of improvement better than doing nothing at all. That's why I mentioned a long term view. This article looks at Russia now, today, and we see people even is this thread talk of leaving. But if there were at least honest attempts to change things for the better, maybe people wouldn't be in such a hurry to leave, hurting chances for progress before they even get started.
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by varjag on Sunday August 15, 2010 @06:46PM (#1606170)
None of his personality traits matter until he fires his puppetmaster buddy Putin. And that just ain't gonna happen.
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by vorg on Monday August 16, 2010 @12:42AM (#1606858)
Vibrant countries seem to have "started again" more recently than more stagnant ones. E.g. Gernamy and Japan were "re-started" after conquest, China was restarted after a takeover by new people from the PLA and Communist Party, Georgia after a new police force. Startups and successful businesses thrive in countries with more lenient bankrupcy laws. This ensures the decay-death-rebirth rolls around quicker.
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by fgf on Monday August 16, 2010 @04:11AM (#1607173)
switzerland, the US and the UK haven't had any restarts for a long, long time. they are doing good. canada, australia and new zealand never had one (after the initial settlement). the wealth of germany and japan was a re-convergence in spite of bombing.. try again=)
Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by adobriyan on Sunday August 15, 2010 @05:36PM (#1606012)
> he says he's going to fight corruption, but he doesn't say how.

That's because he doesn't have a clue.

Last step is to rename "militia" to "police" with trivial changes to law enforcement and direct insult of all those who served in supposedly "ineffective" Soviet militia.

Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by dchest on Sunday August 15, 2010 @05:24PM (#1605976)
It's actually in the article:

Russian President Dmitry Medvedev agrees—in theory at least. [...] But his bold speeches against corruption are largely ignored.

Re:Corruption is forcing Russia’s best and brightest to flee... by smikhanov on Monday August 16, 2010 @10:12AM (#1607818)
Do you know that career opportunities in Moscow, despite being less great than in 2005, are dramatically brighter than anywhere in Europe (can't tell for the US)?

I left Moscow for Vienna 4 years ago. In Moscow some of my former classmates (in their late 20s) are managing departments in Big Four companies; in Vienna people spend 20 years working at the same desk.

When oil prices are high, the opportunities are booming. Young middle-class career-builders sure consider Russia as a temporary location ("I'll leave as soon as I'll be able to") and their children will attend Western universities and will stay some other place forever, but certainly idea about overthrowing this government is a last thought in their heads now.