News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by aetherson on Thursday December 28, 2017 @01:38PM (#16023884)
I'm 40, and some of my coworkers are like 25. I'm about two management levels above the basic engineers, but we're a small company and everyone knows everyone.

So I'm having lunch with some of the engineers, and one of them shares out of the blue that she regrets getting a computer science degree at her (good) college, and thinks she should've gone into business instead. And my immediate thought is, "For god's sake, don't SAY that shit around me, I'm someone who has a big say in your career prospects."

I like having a casual, informal work experience. But it's a thin layer. Ultimately, this is still a hierarchy, and ultimately, you have to think about who you're talking to.

(Separately: Don't get an undergraduate degree in business. What a worthless degree.)

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by rainbowmverse on Thursday December 28, 2017 @01:45PM (#16023930)
>> (Separately: Don't get an undergraduate degree in business. What a worthless degree.)

It's hard for people to learn things like this if they're afraid to talk to people who've gone down that road for fear that an honest expression of concern will be read as a critical lack of confidence.

Just because we're yelled and beaten down for every expression of vulnerability growing up doesn't mean we have to perpetuate it into adulthood. Stop the cycle.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by foobarchu on Thursday December 28, 2017 @02:03PM (#16024064)
I don't think the point was that she shouldn't have shared that information with peers at all, it's that she needs to be more careful about exactly who she's telling it to. OP may easily be in a position later of promoting her to another position. Even if she is confident in her choices by that point, OP will still have that information tucked in their mind, and will (maybe unconciously) utilize it in their decisions.

Nobody is yelling at her or beating her down about this, but she needs to be more discrete in who she shares what information with. Even if you see someone as a friend, friends aren't all equally deserving of your hopes and fears.

I think a good analogy is group projects in school. If you had a classmate who you were good friends with, and they had been sharing with you how much they were struggling and that they were considering dropping the class...wouldn't you factor that information in when choosing partners for a group project? You might decide that "no, I like them too much", and go with them, but it's going to be a decision you have to make because you already possess the information.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by rainbowmverse on Thursday December 28, 2017 @02:16PM (#16024153)
A good group project with people who are mature enough to handle someone's expression of vulnerability without judgement might be what keeps them in the class.

If you reject someone over an expression of doubt, it was never about the doubt.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by greenrd on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:19PM (#16024975)
The reality of group projects is that all too often, one person ends up doing most of the real work.

Group projects don't need to be more infantilising, they need to be more "shape up or ship out!"

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by watwut on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:13PM (#16025418)
It is not infantilizing to accept expression of doubt or some kind of negative feeling. People have opinions and feelings and sometimes express them. Getting scared of that and yelling "shape up or ship out" is as immature as stopping the work altogether because of it.

Also, in my experience, the people who express such feelings are the ones who tend to be willing to do a lot of work and also the boring work needed to finish the thing.

The one person doing all the work in group project imo, is because group projects are quite dumb exercises. It has little to do how real cooperation in just a little competently managed work works and keeps more hardworking people hostage to lazy ones. Regardless of whether it is lazy or hardworking who is more open about his state of mind. It has nothing to do with infantilization - many adults in same situation will slack, because that is how incentives are lined up.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by harlanji on Thursday December 28, 2017 @03:09PM (#16024530)
The one grayed down comment. I agree whole heartedly.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by peoplewindow on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:39PM (#16025652)
It's by a shadowbanned account. You'd need to have showdead on to see it.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by crispyambulance on Thursday December 28, 2017 @02:40PM (#16024331)
The thing is you can never _really_ know, in advance, who is going to be empathetic about expressions of doubt and who is going to silently and permanently pass judgement upon it.

Saying that stuff to peers has little risk especially if the peers know each other. But aetherson has a supervisor role here and he is at least being honest to us that such a remark will condition his future opinion of the blabber-mouth.

That's perhaps one of the things that takes people some time to learn after leaving school-- what you say can hurt you, asking the wrong questions can damage your career, and, your boss is not your friend.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by drvdevd on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:45PM (#16025158)
> your boss is not your friend

I wholeheartedly agree. This is why you should be planning from day 1 on ways to make sure that your career is never dependent on a single individual’s or organization’s whims. They will be doing the same for you if they are smart.

This may sound ugly or cynical, but it’s a fact of life. Discretion is not just about what information you choose to reveal, it’s also about figuring out who is and isn’t “on your side” for the long run. I think we all fail at this at various points in our lives in some way or other.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by scarface74 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @03:25PM (#16024646)
Your boss is not your friend, but your boss can be your mentor. I've had to form a level of trust with my boss because I really needed his advice as a first time tech lead.

I knew the technology I was implementing pretty well but now knowing how to approach higher ups and people in other departments is just as important.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by aetherson on Thursday December 28, 2017 @08:04PM (#16026618)
Let's be clear, though: I'm not her boss. She's two levels below me and not in my direct chain of command, currently. I'd actually be less down on it if I were her boss, and she was speaking just to me, seeking advice or something. There's a sort of "Let's have an open discussion about career stuff" venue in which you kind of agree to suspend judgment.

Just randomly dropping that factoid in a group discussion where it's difficult or impossible for me to probe deeper and understand what's behind it is not a great idea. That makes it easier for someone to take a bad impression from it.

But, also, yeah, I agree, your boss is never fully your friend. I like a lot of the people who work for me, and in other circumstances I think I could be friends with most of them, but part of my job is to evaluate them, including negatively. There is an art to expressing vulnerability in a way that creates intimacy without making a person question your abilities. You can't just assume that everything that you say will have only positive consequences.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by scarface74 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:06PM (#16024875)
And adding on, I try to avoid it, but sometimes you have to tell your boss personal stuff. When I was looking for a house, I had all sorts of short notice appointments. If I didn't let him know, the first thought is that I was interviewing.

Also, I have "cold induced asthma". Whenever I catch a cold, my asthma flairs up and I'm heavily medicated. I had to explain why I spent so much time working from home.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by crispyambulance on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:12PM (#16024926)
I agree with your points. "Your boss is not your friend" just means that you can't talk to your boss just like you talk to a friend. But it can be easy to mistake one's boss as a friend, and that's where there's a risk of saying things that should not be said.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by harlanji on Thursday December 28, 2017 @03:18PM (#16024604)
All your end advice is true, and I recognize the sentiment of "you can never know". Indeed, a date recently asked me if I could read her mind, as happens often, but this time I said I can read her body so basically yes, I can read her mind. I can do this in interviews as well, which is a curse in a slimy rotten marketplace. It's pretty easy to see the next question to ask somebody and corner them if you want. Lack of mental clarity or lack of social exposure or programming can hinder one.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by throwaway0255 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @02:54PM (#16024434)
> Just because we're yelled and beaten down for every expression of vulnerability growing up doesn't mean we have to perpetuate it into adulthood. Stop the cycle.

This is like shaking your fist at gravity.

Everyone's in competition all the time whether they like it or not, that's the universe we live in. Given a choice, you're going to advance the person who's glad they got into computer science, all things being equal.

Even worse than regretting her degree in computer science is the poor judgment she displayed by saying that in front of a manager. The statement is clearly not in her own best interest, it's fairly obvious, and she completely failed to recognize that.

It's not a huge deal by any means, but objectively, it's a negative indication. Why should managers ignore that? Those are relevant data points she just revealed.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by rainbowmverse on Thursday December 28, 2017 @03:05PM (#16024502)
Yeah, I've heard the recruiting pitch. I don't buy it. The universe is vast and indifferent to our puny existence. The belief in the necessity of hostile, anti-vulnerability, winner take all, exploitative competition is a human thing, not a universal truth.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by throwaway0255 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:08PM (#16024899)
I don't know about necessity, necessary or unnecessary. It's just a thing that is.

I'm not saying be hostile. Granting advancement to somebody who exposed weakness over someone who didn't, if all other things are equal, would be even more of an act of hostility. That's not fair to the other person at all.

And I'm not saying don't expose vulnerability. It's just, work isn't for that. We should all talk to friends and family about that (and I'm sure most of us do).

You see this as an imposition on the people exposing their vulnerability, but demanding that managers suspend reason and ignore relevant data in their decision making is an imposition on them, and it's also just a bad way to run a company.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by greenrd on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:26PM (#16025021)
The person you are replying to didn't say exploitative competition. They just said competition.

Indeed, exposing vulnerabilities (of the personal kind, not the security kind) can be imposing in a very inappropriate way.

Your colleague is not obliged to be your free therapist. Don't impose emotional labour on them if their body language or response indicates they don't want to be having this conversation. You don't know what issues they are dealing with, which may be much worse than your own. Talk to a friend or family member, or pay for a therapist.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by neltnerb on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:00PM (#16024835)
I admit I am slightly confused, I would take that comment as an indicator that I should give her more opportunities to sit in on how business decisions are made since she may be far more valuable as a computer-savvy business person. I suppose if she was very negative about the actual work of computer programming I'd be biased against trusting her with long-term projects since she might abandon them. So I suppose it could equally well be somewhat tactical disclosure to get out in the air that she'd like to try some more business-focused work.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by peoplewindow on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:48PM (#16025730)
She obviously is more interested in business, but that's a terrible way to communicate it. That has to be the least business savvy way to express interest in a transfer imaginable.

Thoughts I'd have if I heard that:

1) So when we asked her why she wanted to work here and she told us she would find the work interesting, she was lying?

2) Is her current work any good? It can't be if she's demotivated.

3) If I invite her to a business meeting, is she going to say something similarly thoughtless? Maybe she blurts out that she thinks the customer's request is stupid, or something similar? Seeing as she just said in front of her manager that she regrets her entire career choice, which should have been just an obviously bad idea, can I trust her basic judgement in other areas?

4) Apropos 3, if she shows such a lack of social awareness surely keeping her away from the business side and in front of a computer is for the best.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by scarface74 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @03:22PM (#16024627)
I spent 9 years at one company- seven years longer than I should have - and by the time I left in 2008, I was way behind where I should have been. I spent from 2009-2016 admitting weaknesses left and right so I could learn from other people.

I think that might have kept me from getting ahead at the 3 companies I worked at during that time, but it was worth it for the skills I picked up.

Even at my current position as a tech lead, I still have to admit weaknesses. My weaknesses now are around a lot of things that I know are best practices but I haven't had a chance to implement fully before and that I've never been responsible for hiring and recruitment. I have had to be up front about both to ask advice.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by greenrd on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:42PM (#16025135)
As a tech lead, it's actually easier for you to admit weaknesses, since your subordinates will be happy if you arrange things such that their job satisfaction is high, regardless of how much or little technical work you do. For a front-line engineer it's more dangerous, particularly if there is a perception (even if unfair) of a discrepancy between how they presented themselves at interview, and how they are presenting themselves now. Front-line engineers also don't necessarily know if their employer is thinking of firing them - they therefore are best advised to play it safe with regards to any little thing that their employer could pick up on as a straw that breaks the camel's back. Better safe than sorry.

But yes, there are times when we all need to ask for help, and even here, there are better and worse ways to do it. Again, for a team lead to express vulnerability can be positive in the right circumstances - because it can allow a junior (or indeed a senior) to puff up their chest with pride as they may then be able to help out their boss, show off their knowledge and look really good - and it can help to bond with the team. In contrast, showing vulnerability as a subordinate, to the wrong manager, can just give them an excuse to fire you. That's happened to me twice - I've learned my lesson.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by scarface74 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:11PM (#16025397)
The only times I've been closed to getting fired weren't because of technical skills. I don't believe I've ever come up against a technical challenge that I couldn't solve by putting enough man hours into it.

But, the one thing that I've gotten a couple of "improvement plans" about were surrounding my lack of emotional intelligence and attitude. Those nine years between 2008-2016 were just as much about improving my emotional intelligence as learning technical skills. I look back in horror about some of things I did during the first 12 years of my career. I can very much see where the article is coming from.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by Strudelnoggin on Friday December 29, 2017 @01:10PM (#16030846)
God, this hits home for me. I have suspicions that my oversharing and fraternization with my co-workers has hurt me and continues to hurt me, in the eyes of my superiors. I have recently been given more responsibility over a coworker whom I am consistently seen hanging out with and sharing with. However rather than take that as a indication that things are moving in the right direction, I'm starting to feel like I missed an official promotion because I look like I can't use discretion. At least I'm starting to see this stuff now. I can't be filling in the downtime at work with sharing at work with coworkers if I want to be seen as management 'material'. All this and I am also just passed year 12.

And trying to do a review for a guy you talk to on a regular basis and come up with a way to bring him 'in line' with the level your boss expects you to evaluate him at? Not fun. Not to mention these evals were revealed to me in confidence to be complete horseshit BY MY OWN BOSS. Anyway I digress.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by sturgill on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:43PM (#16025139)
Having a trusted group of advisors is strongly recommended. Confusing everyone in your office as your professional advisor is ill advised.

Find people that have had success in fields that interest you and cultivate relationships with them. And explicitly ask, "Would you be willing to be one of my professional advisors?" You'll want 3-5 of these.

From time-to-time, grab lunch or coffee. And ask the advantages of an MBA or whatever certification. Ask "does job X seem like a good next move for me given my career goals?" Then pick up the tab.

But never, ever confuse lunch at your company's cafeteria as the time or place to raise professional doubts. Absolute confidence at work; and raise your personal insecurities in private with people you can trust and that are expecting that kind of conversation.

Here's my current advisor group:

My mom and dad. I'm mid-30's with three kids of my own. My own parents are a great sounding board for "how is my work/life balance? Am I focused too much on cash at the expense of time with my kids? Will another relocation be too much to ask of my children?" They don't know much about what I do and can't help me build business models, but they raised 5 kids and can effectively call out my B.S.

The dean when I got an MBA. We did a lot of work together while I was at school. He's an incredibly connected individual and is someone I trust to guide me with business ethics. In a failed startup I had some private issues. I met the dean for coffee and he gave me some of the best advice I've ever received: "keep your chin up, your mouth shut, and your integrity intact." Basically "That sucks, move on." He's a "big picture" / "career arc" kind of guy who could help me get a conversation with just about anyone I want. And he's a wonderful person I consider a good friend.

A previous co-worker who is a marketing executive. We hit it off at work. I'm passionate about quantitative marketing. He was more brand oriented. Enough overlap where we had shared interests; different enough we weren't direct competitors at the office. He's been around and knows the pitfalls of business. Sample advice: "ignore all 'Growth hacker' job listings. They're brutal jobs and the first to get axed when numbers are missed. You'll be held accountable for the things you are least likely to be able to control."

None of these conversations happen casually. They are planned discussions with people I have a close relationship. And none of them work in my org (I asked my old coworker to be an advisor _after_ he left).

Be purposeful in what you say to whom.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by codingdave on Thursday December 28, 2017 @03:13PM (#16024555)
> I'm someone who has a big say in your career prospects.

No, you have a big say in their progression within one specific organization. Their career prospects overall are up to them. Frankly, I will quit a boss who acts like they own my career.

(Separately: Your undergrad degree is what you make of it. There is no worthless education, only worthless application of that education into your life.)

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by lnanek2 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @06:54PM (#16026238)
I've seen plenty of bosses who will try to improve someone even if they know they are leaving in a couple years, telling people to make sure to get on LinkedIn so they can rate them up, etc.. There's much less loyalty to companies nowadays, but people do have loyalty to their superior if the superior is setting them up for success no matter what. So I think a good boss does have some traction on a person's career, not just their advancement in a single organization. Companies and management that push to make their employees better overall and not just for themselves often brag about it too.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by codingdave on Friday December 29, 2017 @10:27AM (#16029878)
True -- but GP's comment didn't sound like a mentoring relationship to me. He was saying he expects people to watch what they say around him, implying that open and transparent communication is not part of their culture. Had he said that he took the person aside later and talked through office communications and culture, THAT would sound like mentoring.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by greenrd on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:47PM (#16025182)
Neither quitting in a fit of pique nor being fired look good in an interview. You can get away with a prima donna vibe - but only if you're really good - and sometimes not even then.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by misterbowfinger on Thursday December 28, 2017 @02:50PM (#16024408)
> And my immediate thought is, "For god's sake, don't SAY that shit around me, I'm someone who has a big say in your career prospects."

Did you tell her that? Why or why not? Seems like a really good opportunity for a teachable moment.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by rhombocombus on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:30PM (#16025042)
I have been very fortunate to have bosses pull me aside and give me advice like this while I was young. It has helped me tremendously throughout my working life. I try to keep that in mind as I work with younger people. It can be hard to bring these sorts of things up diplomatically, but it is really important to do it if we expect folks to change their behavior.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by alecco on Friday December 29, 2017 @12:44PM (#16030664)
That could backfire. It's low probability but it could carry big consequences.

The current climate of accusations is not good for managers.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by mc32 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @02:49PM (#16024403)
My take, is work with what people offer in an official capacity and ignore the informal communication because many people who have similar doubts and inner thoughts simply don't express them.

So basically, you'd be "punishing" someone for being honest and potentially promoting someone who is better at "manoeuvering" through the corp labyrinth.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:12PM (#16024928)
There's two sides to this.

From the boss's side, yes, punishing someone for honesty and promoting someone else for keeping their mouth shut on the same feelings is... suboptimal at best.

From the worker's side, though, you don't know how smart the boss is. You don't know whether they are a jerk or a compassionate human being. Don't give them ammunition to use against you. (If you know your boss well, and you know they won't use it against you, that's different. I've had bosses that I would absolutely trust with that kind of information. And, I've had bosses that I wasn't sure I could do that. And I've seen one that I absolutely know I couldn't trust with anything negative, but fortunately he was never my boss.)

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by greenrd on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:50PM (#16025202)
Don't ever trust your employer. I've learned this the hard way. It's 2017 - employers have no loyalty to us when the shit hits the fan - and we should have no loyalty to them. Stay if you like it, go if you don't - because there's probably something better out there.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by mc32 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:35PM (#16025082)
I agree with what you said with respect to bosses. Some will certainly hold your doubts and or honesty against you, and that's unfortunate.

So, yes, beware of who your boss is.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by tjr225 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @03:15PM (#16024583)
> (Separately: Don't get an undergraduate degree in business. What a worthless degree.)

Anecdotally, I have an undergraduate business degree and it has opened many doors for me.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by lkrubner on Thursday December 28, 2017 @01:41PM (#16023907)
Exactly. That sums it up. When you hear something like:

"Yeah, I know, I’m so scared. When Lawrence offered me this job, I was so worried about whether I could do it. I mean it’s all so complicated, and the connections to be made over the network are so uncertain, and then, everything, the timeouts, the servers, lost messages, everything I have to think about it, it’s just really overwhelming and scary, you know?"

It sounds like a lack of confidence. However, Deborah Tannen has suggested a different interpretation.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by eeZah7Ux on Thursday December 28, 2017 @01:56PM (#16024015)
> lack of confidence

Hide your doubts, smile and act confident and you'll be OK most of the time...

..but when it fails it can lead to disasters, especially if entire teams are engaging in this behavior.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by spoiler on Thursday December 28, 2017 @02:56PM (#16024444)
Not sure if you're being funny, but I disagree that we should hide our doubts or insecurities. I know it sounds contrary to what you want to do in that moment, though.

However, don't exaggerate or emphasize them too much either, but rather get in the mindset of wanting to become better at the skill/subject, and display that mindset.

I'd think much higher of a person who did that than someone who pretends everything is fine when they are struggling. Also, if you display this mindset, people will offer to help you, too!

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by eeZah7Ux on Thursday December 28, 2017 @07:36PM (#16026465)
Read the second part of the sentence.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by mr_spothawk on Thursday December 28, 2017 @02:37PM (#16024314)
> when it fails it can lead to disasters

do you have any examples of this?

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by neltnerb on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:06PM (#16024882)
If you're falling behind and are finding a problem is more complex than originally estimated, it is your job to express that doubt to your manager so that they can either get you more resources or otherwise... manage... the issue.

They have to make a lot of pieces fit together that all converge to a solution at the right time to keep everything overall moving, and can't do that without good information.

It's more important to the company that the project get done than that you did it all by yourself, and if you're afraid to disclose your barriers or doubts then it will fail spectacularly. You will look infinity times worse failing to meet a deadline without advance warning than if you go to your boss a month before and explain that the problem has <x, y, and z> unexpected issues and that you need help.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by losteric on Thursday December 28, 2017 @03:42PM (#16024743)
Are you asking for examples of failure resulting from one or more people overstating their confidence in achieving expectations?
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by jupiter90000 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:05PM (#16024870)
If they don't like computer science why do you think they'd want to advance a career related to computer science? Maybe speaking it out loud is helping them move towards fulfillment of what they'd really like. People are allowed to regret their career choices in front of people if they want to. It may have consequences, but that's their business.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by aetherson on Thursday December 28, 2017 @07:54PM (#16026573)
If she wants to get out of engineering, that's something she can do at any point, on her own recognizance. She doesn't need my help to do it.

But, on the other hand, if she does decide she wants to continue as an engineer in our company, she's now added a kind of negative datapoint to my evaluation of her suitability, and for something that's not entirely within her control -- it's partly within mine. It's just a bad idea for her to do this.

It's not the only data point I have, and I tend to think that she'll actually do fine in engineering if she decides to continue down this path. But my job isn't to make her dreams come true, it's to find the people to make the best investments of the company's money in personnel.

Let's give a not-entirely-hypothetical. Let's say that Alice is the name of the engineer who expressed regrets about going into engineering (not her real name, to be clear), and Betty is the name of another, very similar engineer, who has expressed no regrets.

A tech lead spot is opening up in Alice and Betty's field. It's likely to be the only such spot in the near term. Alice and Betty are both seemingly good candidates for the job. But I have to be worried that whichever one I don't pick for the role will feel that they have no career path at our company, and quit.

Now, I could pick Alice. But I know that at least at one point in the past, Alice was regretting becoming an engineer. It sure would suck if I pick Alice, Betty quits, and then six months later Alice pursues her dream to go into business. Whereas if I pick Betty, and then Alice quits, well, maybe Alice was going to get out of engineering anyway.

I feel that I have to give some weight to this information I have about Alice. It's not that I dislike her or feel that she's weak for expressing doubts. It's that she's given me a reason to doubt that she'll be here long term, and if I'm going to invest a limited resource in her versus her peers, I want to do so with the most assurance possible that she'll be here long enough to make that investment worthwhile.

Ask yourself if it would be fair to Betty for me to pretend I didn't know this about Alice.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by jupiter90000 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @08:00PM (#16026605)
It made sense how you thought of what she said. If she doesn't like computer science, maybe you passing her for a promotion would help motivate her career change. So doing what you are saying may actually be helping her dreams come true in a roundabout way.

Edit: Why should she put on an act for the sake of money/career/boss if she doesn't want to? Maybe the argument is she didn't know better (which may be true).

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by DoreenMichele on Thursday December 28, 2017 @07:59PM (#16026598)
Thank you for this explanation.

I was an excellent student. I also spent a lot of years as a homemaker. Such thought processes often aren't obvious to me and they often aren't explained well, making it easy for people to feel like "the boss is playing favorites" or whatever, which I really don't like to do personally but I am often not equipped to argue it if other people do it.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by greenrd on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:04PM (#16025331)
The point is, these consequences can include everything up to and including termination, and a resultant difficulty in finding a subsequent job that pays as well. The young woman probably didn't think of that when she blurted that out. Or maybe she has a trust fund to fall back on, but the people around her may not, and she wasn't setting a good example.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by jupiter90000 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @08:03PM (#16026614)
I get it. If she doesn't like computer science though, maybe the termination will be part of her process to finding something she enjoys. Edit: my point is she doesn't have to pretend if she chooses not to. Who cares if that's what she chooses to do. I guess maybe the concern is she was oblivious to the impact of what she said.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by jclos on Friday December 29, 2017 @04:44AM (#16028614)
Why not use that information to see whether there is a better place for her in your company? Ultimately it's in your (the company's) best interest to keep smart people around, and the transversal skills obtained from forming an engineer in business practices can be extremely valuable.

I agree with your statement on informality - there is a very thin line that's right inbetween boring formality and obnoxious casualness and it takes some time to learn how to walk it, but I don't think your engineer's words are that bad. A good manager (even N+2) should have some idea of the career aspirations of their employees, and your employee sounds like she'd rather be moved to a different position with less computer science stuff than be promoted for more of the same thing.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by amorphid on Thursday December 28, 2017 @10:12PM (#16027219)
> (Separately: Don't get an undergraduate degree in business. What a worthless degree.)

As one who has a bachelors in business, I wouldn't my degree completely useless, but I can't think of a reason I'd recommend someone might go down that path. I would say 80% of the value I got from my degree could be achieved by taking courses in 2 or 3 classes, maybe accounting, finance, marketing, and management.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by rajacombinator on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:14PM (#16025426)
I’d wager if such an unimportant comment would have a serious effect on her prospects working for you, her prospects weren’t that good to begin with.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by Daishiman on Friday December 29, 2017 @06:24AM (#16028915)
It's not an unimportant comment at all.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by mulmen on Thursday December 28, 2017 @03:49PM (#16024775)
I get a lot of value from my undergraduate business degree and resent your characterization of my education and career choices.
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by bootsz on Thursday December 28, 2017 @03:54PM (#16024802)
* > (Separately: Don't get an undergraduate degree in business. What a worthless degree.)

Depends on the major. Accounting is a pretty legitimate degree with high-ish earning potential. Finance can be semi-legit, but most Wall Street jobs will just as easily take people with math or engineering degrees, often preferring them, and those degrees are way more versatile. Most others will not increase your career options. I made this mistake sadly.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by mulmen on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:00PM (#16024841)
This is a toxic generalization and is unfair to anyone who put in the work to earn and then take advantage of a business degree. Are you honestly arguing that the entire discipline of marketing is worthless? What about project management? Process improvement? Human resources? It's flat wrong to say a business degree is "worthless".

I have an undergraduate business degree and I have done very well with it. Your mistakes are your own, don't blame the program.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by bootsz on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:48PM (#16025190)
Worthless is not a fair adjective, I have rephrased. But I still maintain that (outside of Accounting) I would not personally recommend a young person to get their undergraduate degree in business assuming it will be their sole undergraduate degree. Business is a great add-on to a specialty in something else, though. Thus the popularity of people going from science/engineering undergrad to an MBA later on.

What was your major, and what type of job/position did you take post-undergraduate?

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by mulmen on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:50PM (#16025751)
My major is irrelevant to this conversation because I have classmates with successful and fulfilling careers in all the disciplines offered by my business school. Their business degrees (and mine) are their primary degree and are worth more than they cost.

I think you do a disservice to young people by giving them absolute advice like that. Business school does not work for everyone, that does not make it worthless or only good as a supplement.

My degree opened doors to a career that I would not have with any other degree. That doesn't mean everyone should do it but a lot of people can. It certainly means that your absolute statements are incorrect.

Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by make3 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @02:29PM (#16024237)
you likely wouldn't be eating with them on a regular basis
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by greenrd on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:17PM (#16024959)
See - even this woman who studied CS and got a job in the field ended up regretting it. And that's hardly an isolated example. I'm not saying all women who study CS regret it - far from it - but maybe James Damore was onto something?
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by abiox on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:26PM (#16025020)
it's not stated why they felt that way. i'm a guy and have thought that at times myself... for me, mostly because it seems (from this angle) that MBA types can get a great/better salary and have a FAR higher income/status ceiling, all while seemingly having a much easier life than engineers (grass is always greener :P).
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by greenrd on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:53PM (#16025228)
I can't relate to that at all. Having to stay awake in even more boring meetings? Not being able to write code any more? Why would any programmer want that - unless they didn't actually enjoy their job?
Re:Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by shar... by bokstavkjeks on Friday December 29, 2017 @10:57AM (#16030051)
Some people want to be a business partner more than an employee. Not that that's impossible as a software engineer, but it may be easier from a different starting point.