News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by code4tee on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @09:50AM (#16015016)
Boeing played the market correctly here. When everyone was oohing over the A380 Boeing said super jumbos were on their way out and focused on the 787. If it hadn’t been for Emirates buying so many A380s to begin with it would have been a flop from the start (Emirates alone operates almost half of the A380s ever built).

The future in long haul is mid-size highly efficient twin engine jets and here Airbus is scrambling to catch up with Boeing in both sales and design.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by jdietrich on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:32AM (#16015287)
There was a shift in the aviation market that wasn't entirely straightforward to predict. Airbus bet that the market would continue with a hub-and-spoke model, with lots of regional jets providing connections to hub airports. Boeing bet that the market would shift towards point-to-point service, with direct flights between second-tier airports facilitated by mid-size jets with extended range.

Boeing clearly made the right call, but there's an element of hindsight at play. Emirates, Etihad and Singapore have been very successful as pure hub-and-spoke airlines and there's still a vast amount of traffic going through the major hub airports.

The lead time on new aircraft designs is immense - the A3XX project started in 1994 and took the first orders in 2000. Airbus made some strategic blunders and didn't respond quickly enough to market conditions, but in some respects they were just unlucky. Boeing's 747X project failed and they have struggled with sales for the 747-8, but they avoided heavy losses by re-using old IP rather than launching a completely new platform. Both manufacturers were caught off-guard by the events of 2008.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by cryptonector on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:19PM (#16017688)
I wonder if Boeing's execs arrived at their strategy by the appeal of being contrarian to Airbus' bet. Perhaps they felt they had no choice: with the jumbo market fractured they might never be able to profit from it, so why not develop the alternative and hope for the best? No doubt they had data and information from their contacts at the airlines and could sense the brightness of the point-to-point future, but having no future in splitting the jumbo market with Airbus must have been a big factor too.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by jdietrich on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @04:45PM (#16018304)
Boeing certainly have an advantage in terms of agility. Airbus is a messy conglomerate, formed from the merger of aerospace companies from France, Germany, Spain, the US and the UK. With so many corporate and governmental stakeholders, their projects tend to become bloated and overly complex, and it's difficult for them to react quickly to market conditions. The A380 project suffered severe delays, in large part because the design effort was spread between teams in four countries using different processes and software.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by pmcollins on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:00AM (#16015068)
Boeing's market analysis said that the market could barely support one super-jumbo, let alone two, so they opted for the much cheaper 747 upgrade and we got the 747-8 (which is also headed for extinction).

I heard an analyst say that you have to carry a lot of fuel to carry a lot of fuel. The optimal size from an efficiency perspective is the much smaller 737 -- the more you deviate from that, the larger the efficiency penalty.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by froindt on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:41AM (#16015347)
>I heard an analyst say that you have to carry a lot of fuel to carry a lot of fuel.

Yep! Aerospace has been on the leading edge of manufacturing methods for many years because of it. Even worse is having a heavy airplane at the start of the flight (the weight is always there).

In school we were talking about manufacturing aerospace parts, and the joke is that you always take a nice chunk of aluminum and machine away 85% of the volume.

GE has been doing lots of work with metal additive manufacturing, in some cases increasing performance while also decreasing cost. It allows geometries which are otherwise impossible with traditional manufacturing methods.

Metal AM is also hella expensive. You won't see tons of metal AM parts on consumer cars anytime soon, as the metal powders and machines are expensive, and production rates are often slow in comparison to traditional manufacturing methods.

For reference, my professor passed around a part which weighed around 2 pounds and fit in your hand. The all-in cost to get that printed in steel was around $5,000, and around $8,000 for titanium.

https://www.ge.com/reports/epiphany-disruption-ge-additive-c...

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by louithethrid on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:04AM (#16015507)
Never understoood why they would not use the fuel as stability element- basically- the elments carrying the fuelweight, are made from a carbonsponge that holds frozzen fuel..
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by briandear on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:30AM (#16015709)
The complexity and logistical difficulty of what you describe is mind blowing not to mention adding non trivial safety concerns.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by api_or_ipa on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @04:27PM (#16018178)
> I heard an analyst say that you have to carry a lot of fuel to carry a lot of fuel.

In rocket applications, this is known as Tsiolkovsky rocket equation [0].

0 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by dghughes on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:43AM (#16015357)
Boeing plays a lot of games like getting 40% of its revenue from the US government but crying unfair when other countries get any subsidies at all. Look at the nearly 300% duty it demanded added on to the parts made by their competitor Canadian aircraft manufacturer Bombardier.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by valuearb on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:46AM (#16015377)
This is a lie. Bombardiers planes don’t compete with any Boeing planes.

Yet still Boeing flexed their lobbyists.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by undersuit on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:07AM (#16015529)
Delta chose to go with Bombardier planes in this case[1] which directly affected Boeing's ability to sell them their equivalents. That sounds like competition.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CSeries_dumping_petition_by_Bo...

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by kogepathic on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:54AM (#16015963)
> which directly affected Boeing's ability to sell them their equivalents.

Boeing's bid to Delta was some Embraer E series they had from an Air Canada trade-in. [1]

No model of 737MAX competes with the C Series for Delta's RFP. Both Boeing and Delta have readily admitted this when asked (see [1]).

Boeing has nothing in the market to compete with regional jets like the C Series. This is exactly why they are now looking into buying Embraer to counter Airbus acquiring a majority stake in the C Series. [2]

[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/scotthamilton5/2016/05/17/embra...

[2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-12-21/boeing-is...

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by undersuit on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:57PM (#16016525)
That sounds like there is competition for this market between Bombardier and Boeing.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by kogepathic on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @01:04PM (#16016591)
> That sounds like there is competition for this market between Bombardier and Boeing.

Not sure how you came to that conclusion. Let me try again:

It's like going to a Ford dealership and asking them for a scooter. Because Ford doesn't manufacture scooters, they offer to sell you a Vespa instead because the last customer traded one in.

Sure, they'll make a sale, but it's not like Ford makes the Vespa or the replacement parts for a Vespa (maintenance contracts are a BFD in aerospace, often worth more than the initial plane order).

So now you (Delta) come and want to buy 100 Vespas, and Ford still doesn't make a Vespa and has no plans to. So while slagging Vespa (Bombardier) for detracting from Ford's scooter sales they start talks to buy Vespa's closest competitor (Embraer).

Yeah... Totally competing in the same segment...

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by valuearb on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @02:20PM (#16017182)
Yea, it's like Chrysler suing to block Ferrari imports because they want to re-sell McLarens.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by megablast on Thursday December 28, 2017 @12:28AM (#16020501)
Is that example really supposed to make anything clearer?
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by valuearb on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @02:18PM (#16017169)
Your own link explains how uncompetitive they are. Boeing's 737s range from 138-200+ passengers, the CS100 is in the 108-133 passenger range. More importantly the CS100 is significantly smaller and lighter, helping make it cheaper to operate on the routes Delta wanted.

So to bid against Bombardier, Boeing didn't even try to offer 737s, knowing they can't fit Delta's needs. Instead they offered 717s and Embrauers, both of which are used (Boeing canceled the 717 over a decade ago).

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by inferiorhuman on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @04:02PM (#16018005)
The risk isn't that Boeing competes with Bombardier right now. The risk is that the Bombardier will stretch the C-series and create a CS500 that will compete directly with the 737. You can't do that with the Embraer.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by valuearb on Thursday December 28, 2017 @10:18AM (#16022390)
That’s a risk our trading rules aren’t supposed to address.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by inferiorhuman on Thursday December 28, 2017 @03:36PM (#16024711)
Agreed.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by louithethrid on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:05AM (#16015517)
Lobbyism is what saved the american car industry.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by majormajor on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @01:25PM (#16016730)
The American car industry is safe in the US market as long as nobody outside the US figures out how to compete with the F150. Even if it had to eventually ditch everything but the trucks, the cash cow shows no signs of dying anytime soon. Make them aluminum, carbon fiber, electric, turbo, whatever - it's the form factor that sells.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by selectodude on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @06:53PM (#16019155)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicken_tax

Foreign automakers can't sell trucks in the US.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by kalleboo on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:29PM (#16020104)
Sure they can, they just can't import them. Japanese car makers have had manufacturing in the US for ages now.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by valuearb on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:21PM (#16016244)
Citation needed, cause no.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by junkscience2017 on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:23AM (#16015656)
Yet Bombardier itself is subsidized to the point where many have suggested it would be easier to just nationalize it...yet no one is critiquing that arrangement
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by alexland on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:24PM (#16017730)
That arrangement is heavily critiqued, particularly that Bombardier is still controlled by private shareholders (and is receiving significant public funding).

It's pretty clear that airplanes are expensive to build, and every large plane manufacturer has government subsidies, but Boeing is being particularly anti-competitive in this instance and is getting away with it.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by Analemma_ on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:52PM (#16017928)
What does "particularly" anti-competitive mean? Boeing, Airbus, and Bombardier all get government subsidies. Are there are reliable numbers about how large these subsidies are showing that Boeing's are significantly bigger?
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by toyg on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @09:41PM (#16019929)
> What does "particularly" anti-competitive mean?

The fact that they have instigated litigation in what is, for them, a relatively fringe sector.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by namdnay on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:03AM (#16015081)
I think that for airlines that want to differentiate on comfort/quality, the A380 is a must-have: You can pimp up the interior of a 787 as much as you want, it will never be as comfortable as what you can do with an A380 (see my other comment on the Emirates A380).

However this segment probably isn't big enough to justify such an expensive production line...

@frik - for some reason you are "dead" - no-one can see your comments since 5 days ago. Edit: now you're not! Congratulations I guess?

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by code4tee on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:12AM (#16015137)
I’ve flown just about every commercial model of airplane made in the last 30 years including Emirates A380 biz class. While that was undoubtedly an amazing trip, it had a lot more to do with the airline than the airplane. My enthusiasm for the trip also dropped off when I had to spend several hours waiting around in the middle of the night at their hub in Dubai.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by namdnay on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:13AM (#16015143)
Yes! See my other comment - the DXB stopover is their Achilles heel I think.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by oblio on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:50AM (#16015402)
Why? What happened in Dubai?
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by nhf on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:36PM (#16016367)
Many flights in Dubai happen late at night / very early morning due to a combination of time zone alignment and daytime heat making it harder to service large planes.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by dmfdmf on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:08PM (#16020246)
It could be fueling issues. I once had a Summer flight which was suppose to be direct from Athens to NYC that had to make a pitstop at Heathrow for fuel. It was so hot in Greece they couldn't fit enough fuel on board to jump the pond without a top off.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by arnon on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:16AM (#16021269)
I've never heard of that before, and I've taken flights out of Israel in 43°C weather. Could just be a 'fuel price' thing
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by personlurking on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:21AM (#16015638)
Probably has to do with the way airlines schedule their flights, depending on the final destination and direction. Sometimes you'll catch a flight and can't make a connecting flight for several hours.

How Airlines Schedule Flights https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dGXahSnA_oA

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by startupdiscuss on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:14AM (#16015148)
But the segment has an outsized impact on revenue.

Say a business class ticket for a transatlantic flight is 5x an economy and a first class ticket is 10x an economy.

And the plane, of course, is largely fixed costs.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by jsjohnst on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:13PM (#16017654)
That’s part of the reason US based airlines don’t fly to most gulf region airports anymore.

1) they could essentially justify a lightly loaded economy section due to Business / First passengers (I’ve done several cheap mileage runs before where I had multiple rows to myself in economy). When those $$$$ passengers switched to the nicer Emirates/Etihad/etc flights, they lost that marginal advantage.

2) on top of #1, another major factor is that Etihad/Emirates/etc are heavily subsidized by their national governments. Due to this, the slot fees were much cheaper for them than US based airlines further reducing any money to be made on those segments by US based airlines.

The end result of the above is that now you have to use an alliance partner + connection to get from US to the Middle East (or fly a MENA based airline) where as before you could choose from dozens of directs.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by TremendousJudge on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:19AM (#16015185)
The business seats on a plane make more money than the economy seats. However, there aren't lines where you can fill a whole plane of business: economy is there mostly to fill up space
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by namdnay on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:25AM (#16015231)
There are some, but they're very rare. One example is the BA shuttle between London City and New York - only business. I believe there is a French airline doing a "cheap business" Paris-New York as well.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by dillondoyle on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:52AM (#16015422)
La Compagnie! I really like them the couple times I've flown. For the price it's really great value. Worst part is the NYC airpot 'lounge'

Not the fanciest interior/seat but the food and service were great when I've flown.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by isostatic on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @06:19PM (#16018964)
Qatar operate a small business only A319 from Doha to London once a day, or did when I took it two years ago. I preferred the a350 and 787 flights which are 1-2-1 rather than 2-2, but for a 7 hour day flight it wasnt too bad. It was half empty though, not a great use of a Heathrow slot.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by mpweiher on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:33AM (#16015294)
Also the new Boom supersonic jet is intended to be all business class seats (around 60, IIRC).
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by ghaff on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:01AM (#16015483)
I'm not holding my breath for any of these supersonic jet projects to come to market. But, if they do, I expect the nominally "business" or "first" class seating will be more like domestic business today than typical international business class--as was the case with the Concorde.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by markonen on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @01:37PM (#16016843)
That’s Boom’s business plan explicitly. Cut down the flight time to a couple of hours and you don’t need to offer a bed, making the per seat cost comparable.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by gsnedders on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:08AM (#16015535)
> One example is the BA shuttle between London City and New York - only business. I believe there is a French airline doing a "cheap business" Paris-New York as well.

Both are done by BA, and both are stopping.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by jsjohnst on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:06PM (#16017599)
Singapore Airlines used to have an all business flight to NYC, but it’s been phased out.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by smachiz on Thursday December 28, 2017 @08:15PM (#16026695)
It's coming back in 2018 with a A350-900 ULR with only Business and Premium Economy, no Economy seats.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by yeukhon on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:23AM (#16015214)
I agree it is a fixed cost, but the initial cost is expensive by itself before we consider the cost for maintenance. Also 5x for economy is really expensive, I highly doubt that many customers would want this 380 experience for 5x of econ. Airbus 380 is ideal for long distance, then 5*800 from NY to Asia would be too damn expensive: then why not first-class on non-380?
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by namdnay on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:27AM (#16015245)
I think you misunderstood the parent. They are saying that business is 5x economy, not the A380.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by frik on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:15AM (#16015162)
I cannot upvote you enough, it's true.

A380 is in its own league, super comfortable, super low noise. No 747, 777 or 787 can match the comfort. They are noisier, or have downsides.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by _Codemonkeyism on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:30AM (#16015272)
Exactly, when flying economy I always try to get an A380. 747 is the most painful plane there is in economy.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by rconti on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @01:18PM (#16016667)
Lufthansa economy on the A380 is the best, if you can get one of the upper deck seats, particularly a window seat where you have a massive storage console/armrest between you and the window.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by dawhizkid on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:15AM (#16015153)
I don't think they're scrambling. The A350 is their 787 competitor and looks amazing. Can't wait to try it out.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by avh02 on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:23AM (#16015212)
Flew the A350 and 787 a week apart (recently, via Qatar) - the A350 is a surprisingly quiet machine on the inside.

The 787's larger windows (combined with being tall) means I get an almost 360 view around the plane through windows around me over people's heads (until they dim everybody's windows by default * shakes fist * )

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by samfisher83 on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:33AM (#16015740)
The 787 windows seem to block cell phone signals. Their tinting technology seems a a little unnecessary.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by myrandomcomment on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:56AM (#16015984)
The reason for the tinting is really simple - weight. You have to be able to shade the windows and doing this way is less weight then have pull down screens. Everything in aircraft design here comes down to weight reduction.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by avh02 on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:42PM (#16016417)
I also think giving crew control is a factor. Rather than asking/telling individuals to open their shades you just control it. I guess this makes compliance with regulation easier.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by samfisher83 on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @01:03PM (#16016570)
Lets say there are 52 windows and each shade weight 2 pounds which I don't think they do. That is 104 pounds on a 380,000lb aircraft. That is .02% of the weight of the aircraft.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by chiph on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @01:26PM (#16016744)
There's also the cleaning and maintenance aspects. I would guess the pull-down shades broke/tore more often than the dimming technology fails (repairing either would require pulling the seat row and wall panel to get access, so more reliable == win)
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by badosu on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:59PM (#16017989)
I guess the better calculation would be:

Cost of a typical trip w/ shades x Cost of a typical trip w/out shades

Then account for the average number of trips in a year.

May seem like an exaggeration but the impact of some decisions, even though seemingly tiny, may be bigger than expected.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by jsjohnst on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:26PM (#16017745)
> Lets say there are 52 windows

The actual number is almost double that, but that doesn’t negate your point. More than weight, I think it was seen as a “nicety”. I think with the new Gen 2 (and soon Gen 3) Windows, people won’t mind them as much as the newer generations are MUCH darker.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by samfisher83 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @12:22AM (#16020486)
If there were a 100 windows lets assume there are 1 on each side so that is 50 rows. lets say first 10 rows are first class. That would leave 40 rows. Its 9 seats across that is 360 people. There 1st class rows have 4 across 787 does not hold 360+40 people.

Also it doesn't get all the way dark. I just feel it was a piece of engineering that doesn't need to be there in my opinion.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by myrandomcomment on Thursday December 28, 2017 @06:35PM (#16026092)
Because:

1. Removing weight. 2. Removing moving parts. 3. Removing cleaning cost

Does not seem like a good idea?

I have friends that are involved in aircraft design. They tell me they count every tie wrap for wiring vs. weight requirements. The remove as many moving parts as they can to cut mantaince cost.

I worked at a company that made a complex piece of networking equipment. On the board they spent a ton of time engineering out caps. They only cost a few cents per board. The cost was not the issue. It turns out that removing as many as they could upped the MTBF by 40%.

Everything is never that simple. Boeing did not just add this type of window because they thought it was cool.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by jsjohnst on Thursday December 28, 2017 @08:18AM (#16021822)
> 787 does not hold 360+40 people

Correct, but not every window aligns directly with a row.

Let’s use an UAL 787-8 for example. There’s ~10 windows per side in first class, but yet only six rows of seats (6x6 = 36 seats for about twenty Windows). In economy, there’s about 32 windows (give or take 2) on each side and yet only 20 outside rows. The middle section has 21 rows, all sections having three across seating, for a total of 183 seats in economy.

> Also it doesn't get all the way dark.

As I said, the Gen 2 windows (just rolling out now) and the forth coming Gen 3 help solve that problem. Rather than the dark blue of the current Gen 1 windows, each successive generation gets darker with the Gen 3 windows being 100x darker.

Source: https://thepointsguy.com/2016/01/darker-windows-coming-to-78...

> I just feel it was a piece of engineering that doesn't need to be there in my opinion.

I mostly agree with you, but I personally enjoy seeing out the window without the glare of the sun in my face. YMMV

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by gok on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:59AM (#16016007)
Size-wise the A350 is more like a 777; the 787 is more directly competitive with A330neo.

Are they scrambling? Not really. Boeing is making a fair amount more money than Airbus but they’re producing about the same number of planes (Airbus probably has a slight edge in order count). Airbus was formed as a program to address Europe’s concern about relying on North America for airliners. It’s not clear even today that they really care about actually making money from selling airplanes.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by code4tee on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:21AM (#16015205)
Um, there’s 5 787s flying around for every A350. On the future book Boeing also has around 50% more 787 orders than Airbus has A350.

So yeah, I’d call that being a bit behind in that market segment.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by tolien on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:55AM (#16015445)
The 787 first flew 4 years earlier too, cost 3x as much to develop and aren’t selling for three times the price.

To the end of last month there were 858 orders (133 delivered) for the A350 versus 1287 (625 delivered) for the Dreamliner. Considering the 787 had a head start (787 introduced in 2011, A350 XWB in 2015), the pressure’s on Airbus to keep ramping up deliveries (the last few years it looks like Boeing’s stabilised at ~130 per year) but that gap’s going to shrink pretty quickly…

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by yardie on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @05:34PM (#16018654)
The A350XWB was their second attempt. The original A350 and 787 were introduced around the same time. But the all aluminum A350 was DOA compared to the flashy new carbon fiber 787. It showed in the order books as well, no one wanted their warmed over A350.

TL;DR the 787 didn't have a 4 year head start. The A350 arrived 4 years late after a complete redesign.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by tolien on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @05:55PM (#16018790)
That's all true but I don't see how it refutes what I said.

The 787's been in production and delivering aircraft for 4 years longer than the A350 XWB, which is still ramping up [1]. If that's not a head start when we're comparing delivered aircraft between the two then I don't know what is; the fact that Airbus let Boeing have that lead by wasting their time trying to hawk an A330 with revised wings and engines is neither here nor there.

> Airbus plans to increase its production rate from 10 monthly in 2018 to 13 monthly from 2019, while the Boeing 787 production will increase from 12 to 14 per month in 2019, and six A330 are produced monthly.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_A350_XWB#Production

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by xvf22 on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @07:40PM (#16019385)
And yet they managed to save the program and avoid the lithium battery issues of the 787 all while not being anywhere near as overweight as the 787 was upon introduction.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by _Codemonkeyism on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:31AM (#16015285)
It's 1250 to 850 orders.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by jonknee on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:46AM (#16015381)
And it's 625 to 133 deliveries...
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by masklinn on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:01AM (#16015487)
And it's 2011 to 2015...
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by 24gttghh on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:48AM (#16015389)
850 x .5 = 425

850 + 425 = 1275

Looks pretty damn close to 50% more orders for Boeing, so I'm not sure what you are implying.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by thisacctforreal on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:36AM (#16015767)
protip: 1250 / 850 = 1.4706, ie 147%
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by dingaling on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:36AM (#16015771)
> The A350 is their 787 competitor and looks amazing

The A350 is considerably bigger than the 787, it actually competes against the 777 ( original and X ).

The 787-8 and -9 have the same floor area as the much older Airbus A330-200 and -300 respectively.

Airbus doesn't have a direct rival to the 787 other than the warmed-over A330Neo.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by ptero on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:22AM (#16015209)
> The future in long haul is mid-size highly efficient twin engine jets and here Airbus is scrambling to catch up with Boeing in both sales and design

I agree with your first paragraph, but not at all sure about this. Current air transportation is very stratified, but some of its numerous rules could get a major rework in the next N years (N >= 10). Current setup has mid-size sweetspot when optimized on existing rules on routes, airport slots, weather requirements and in general ATC that is over 30 years old.

Even if only parts of the plans get accepted they can change optimizations significantly, e.g. if and when Nextgen allows planes fly directly from A to B (instead of along a few pre-defined segments) it might push sweetspot from mostly mid-size to a bimodal distribution: smaller for small airports, larger between main hubs. Or some other way.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by code4tee on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:28AM (#16015257)
It’s actually the airlines dragging their feet on a lot of this, not “30 year old ATC.” Many airlines don’t upgrade their planes to have the latest equipment. Flew in a small personal plane with a friend that’s a pilot and he was explaining how in several areas his small plane has more advanced avionics than commercial airliners. For example, his plane is certified to fly the latest 3D GPS based landing approaches while many commercial airliners still don’t have the necessary equipment onboard.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by ptero on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @01:24PM (#16016717)
> It’s actually the airlines dragging their feet on a lot of this, not “30 year old ATC.” Many airlines don’t upgrade their planes to have the latest equipment.

Yes, and I believe they do not upgrade because it makes no business sense for them. Regulators say, for example, "install ADS-B so you are compliant with latest standards" which at the moment has no tangible benefits for the airline. If, by installing it airline would get useful additional capabilities, such as being able to fly direct from point A to point B or allow for lower separation I suspect they would upgrade quickly.

The above is not (really) bashing ATC -- there is a very low tolerance for mid-air collisions, so regulatory change is very, very slow.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by bsder on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:09PM (#16017620)
> Yes, and I believe they do not upgrade because it makes no business sense for them.

Agreed. Those little wingtip flip-ups--man, those went through the industry like wildfire. I never saw those and then BAM suddenly they were on every plane I flew on.

The airlines can move like the wind when money is actually involved.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by danmaz74 on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:17AM (#16015172)
> The future in long haul is mid-size highly efficient twin engine jets and here Airbus is scrambling to catch up with Boeing in both sales and design.

Isn't the A350 already a very good contender there?

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by _Codemonkeyism on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:25AM (#16015230)
Yes but HN always has been a pro-Boeing board.

The A350 has around 850 orders vs. Boeing 1250 orders for their 787.

So "scrambling" is highly subjective and suggestive.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:43AM (#16015361)
> Emirates buying so many A380s

The governments of Dubai and Abu Dhabi have invested a fortune into their international hubs. The shift away from hub-and-spoke is a demise for them, too.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by zerkten on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @09:58AM (#16015052)
It seems like a company can only make one successful move at a time (in what I find a very ugly) industry. At the lower end Boeing struggles with the 737 being too large for a lot of markets. There Embraer, Bombardier (now part of Airbus), and a bunch of other companies seem to have an opportunity, if they can execute. It'll be interesting to see what Boeing does there given the cozy relationship with Embraer.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by rchowe on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:15AM (#16015154)
Bombardier is not a part of Airbus now, they just sold 50.01% of the C-series program to Airbus so that they could manufacture them in Alabama and dodge the 300% tariff imposed on them by the US government. It is unclear where the C-series airplanes for non-US markets will be made, but it's suspected to still be by Bombardier in Canada.
Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by gsnedders on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:11AM (#16015552)
> It is unclear where the C-series airplanes for non-US markets will be made, but it's suspected to still be by Bombardier in Canada.

It's pretty clear—Canada. That said, there's a significant change: sales, and post-sales work, will mostly be handled by Airbus, who already have much more contact with many more airlines and leasing companies than Bombardier.

Re:Airbus ready to axe A380 if fails to win Emirates deal by raverbashing on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:39AM (#16015331)
Boeing did put some money on the 747-800 it's not like they ignored that part of the market