News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by oliv__ on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @07:15PM (#16011907)
One step closer to our amazing future. This is really getting out of hand...

Why do 300m people have to suffer for the boogeyman terrorist? I mean isn't this the whole point of terrorism? To get you to do things you don't want to because hey 1 in a million potential threat? Where does this stop?

This has nothing to do with security and everything to do with control and mass surveillance. It's pretty depressing.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by erric on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @07:27PM (#16011950)
>One step closer to our amazing future. This is really getting out of hand...

It was already well out of hand when congress approved the patriot act as a knee jerk reaction to terrorism. That was the proverbial straw and everything since has just been gravy for the MIC and other companies milking the government teat.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by sebnap on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @07:56PM (#16012063)
Read Carroll Quigley, read Gioele Magaldi, combine.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by zeep on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @02:06AM (#16013360)
thanks Obama for repealing, not signing the extension and for not expanding the "PATRIOT" Act /s
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by csallen on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @02:15AM (#16013382)
> I mean isn't this the whole point of terrorism? To get you to do things you don't want to because hey 1 in a million potential threat?

Is that really the point of terrorism? Is there even such a thing as a general "point" to all terrorism? I would assume there as many different goals as there are terrorists, or at least terrorist organizations.

Rather, what's more interesting is what the people in power do to take advantage of terrorism. The policies they implement, programs they put into place, etc. Terrorism (and other external threats) can act as a convenient cover for domestic actions that would otherwise be scrutinized.

And then there are the more mundane issues. Sometimes the changes that become visible to the public come from relatively low-level managers and officials, who simply enjoy playing with a bigger budget and new toys. It's not all conspiracies in dark rooms at the top.

We have to give democracy its due as well. Just because people can vote doesn't mean we inspire the most desirable behavior in our leaders, because the masses aren't rational. Who wants to be the politician responsible for having weakened security before the next terrorist attack? It's similar to being "soft on crime." The public will hold you responsible, right or wrong.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by closeparen on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @04:08PM (#16018051)
Terrorism is the deployment of asymmetric warfare techniques by an organization we won’t dignify as a state or military.

Getting the victim to raise its defenses doesn’t have to be a goal, but it can.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by meddlepal on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:03PM (#16012334)
Devil's advocate: What is so bad about everyone being tracked and accountable for where they are at any point in time? It would seem a lot of mistaken identity, fraud, and he-said she-said issues could be removed if we can locate people at any point in time.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by solatic on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @11:35PM (#16012847)
False positives. No system is 100% accurate, but the closer that systems get to 100% reliability, the more people confuse those systems with 100% reliability.

The Panopticon™ claims you robbed the bank. You know you were at work, in a meeting, and your coworkers vouch for your alibi. But the Panopticon™ is "always" right, so you get fast-tracked through the courts (saves taxpayer money not to have the case dragged out) and sentenced to ten years for a crime you didn't commit (your public defender was a huge help at sentencing). Because after all, if you couldn't trust the Panopticon™, then why the hell did they spend $600 billion of taxpayer money building it?

American society was founded on the bedrock of a few principles: you're innocent until you're proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, crime is prosecuted and not prevented, your reputation can be reset by moving somewhere new and making a new beginning, and trust, faith, and forgiveness are more worthy aims than proof, evidence, and justice, for the latter can only really obtained with great difficulty and cost through the courts. Panopticons go against all these principles.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by miketery on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @10:25PM (#16012605)
The problem isn't with the ideal scenario, the issue is when systems fail or are used outside of the ideal scenario. Generally this will be in a muzzling and controlling capacity when it comes to surveillance.

Interestingly merely paranoia of surveillance results in self muzzling and self imposed restrictions.

In the end the results are not conducive for societies progress.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by zamber on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @01:15AM (#16013229)
> Interestingly merely paranoia of surveillance results in self muzzling and self imposed restrictions.

My dad got me paranoid about surveillance. Once I grew up old enough to look more than 2 years ahead I started censoring myself because the internet never forgets and I don't want to give a dossier full of potentially incriminating data when/if we slide from democracy to dictatorship.

The upside is that social media is ruined for me forever ;). In light of recent commentary, links to depression and addiction it looks like it turned out healthier for me.

Nonetheless I'm fully aware of the level of self-censorship I tend to sustain.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by rhizome on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:14PM (#16012376)
Facial recognition will not make a dent in "mistaken identity, fraud, he-said she-said issues" without displacing something like "the entire military budget," which is not going to happen. Facial recognition also doesn't work.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by meddlepal on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:25PM (#16012416)
Maybe not facial recognition, but why not chip everyone with RFID and GPS and track people? Require biometric auth to use computers or enter buildings? Stop using cash and require all transactions to be electronic. I'm just asking the questions about what is so awful about massive transparent surveillance? We're never getting this back in Pandora's box so we might as well acknowledge it and make it a part of our existence.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by newscracker on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @02:11AM (#16013375)
Your argument is against fundamental freedoms that humans have granted one another, which have allowed civilization to improve over time (with "bad times" alongside). Anyone against dictatorial (not the benevolent kind) powers would never argue for everyone to be micro-chipped and tracked, disallowing all cash, etc. Even in democratic setups these kind of additions and restrictions tweak the power asymmetry significantly, and are causing a lot of human suffering. In short, these moves aren't great for humanity as a whole.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by sterlind on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:33PM (#16012442)
unless the entire government is as transparent as your massive surveillance, no thanks. our democracy is extremely fragile. if information collection goes into a black box it's a turn-key solution for totalitarianism.

for instance, see the Stasi.

...however, if intelligence gathered were all open-access, and classification abolished, I'd be into it.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by 13of40 on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:33PM (#16012441)
As long as we can stop dancing around the fact that most of us drive faster than the speed limit, smoke dope, and/or have unconventional sexual relationships at some point in our lives.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by meddlepal on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:38PM (#16012457)
Fair points. What if everyone else's information was open and accessible so that nobody could hide anything from anybody thus removing potential asymmetric knowledge?
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by astronautjones on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @11:48PM (#16012902)
There are systems of power that will never fall that make this egalitarian idea irrelevant (and dangerous)
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by 13of40 on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:47PM (#16012490)
Suppose someone didn't want their grandparents to know they were gay.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by aplummer on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @10:03PM (#16012540)
Or worse, the government of a country where that gets you the death penalty.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by gregmac on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @01:11AM (#16013214)
Worse still, a government comes to power in your country and changes the law so you get the death penality, and it's retroactively enforced by looking through everyone's location history.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by meddlepal on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @04:40AM (#16013826)
Yea, this is a troubling one. I brought up my original post as a thought experiment and I think some arguments presented were better than others.

Governments are fallible just like human beings. I suppose in some sense it is arrogant to believe the US will always remain a democracy and certainly other countries have much more tumultuous histories.

I still like the idea of a totally open and transparent society but without something totally incorruptible and unbiased taking the role of government it does not seem practical.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by andrei_says_ on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @10:08PM (#16012555)
What about consent?
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by rhizome on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @10:09PM (#16012556)
What policies and processes would ensure transparency?
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by DashRattlesnake on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @10:38PM (#16012660)
It would also be a great help in controlling dissenters and subversives. Once we have the infrastructure in place, it's there for anyone with enough power to use for any reason...
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by pmiller2 on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:20PM (#16012401)
Let's say I make frequent visits to mosques, and there's a government unfriendly to Muslims in power, as one of many hypothetical scenarios where this could be a real problem.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by bonesss on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:17AM (#16013574)
Looking at data storage rates and 'digital permanence': we should be equally concerned that such a government may one day be in power and retroactively use that data against you.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by meddlepal on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:32PM (#16012436)
Sure but all your activities and everyone else's activity would be tracked. Assuming rule of law continues to be upheld and we don't devolve into something worse it should be pretty easy to show innocence if needed.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by macintux on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @10:32PM (#16012641)
Innocence is remarkably difficult to prove.

Let's say I visit a church regularly, and someone who later turns out to be a terrorist was often there at the same time. Not surprising, since houses of worship often have predictable schedules of events.

How do I prove I wasn't collaborating with the terrorist?

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by pmiller2 on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @10:22PM (#16012599)
All it takes is one cop who doesn't give a shit to abuse the system.
[dead]
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by meddlepal on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:18PM (#16012395)
It's just technology: Some will use it for good and some will use it for evil. Isn't that the mantra we've been repeating since forever within the hacker community?
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by Too on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @02:58AM (#16013509)
It's not just technology. It's technology given exclusive right to a single party. The state can watch you but you can't watch the state.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by DashRattlesnake on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @10:42PM (#16012672)
> It's just technology: Some will use it for good and some will use it for evil. Isn't that the mantra we've been repeating since forever within the hacker community?

This smells like a troll.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by meddlepal on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:05AM (#16012965)
Why? Seriously, the same argument has been used to defend BitTorrent and various other tools that might be used to circumvent laws.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by DashRattlesnake on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @01:32AM (#16013269)
Yes...if you strip out so much context for the similarity to become meaningless.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by zxcmx on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @06:17AM (#16014127)
Suppose your job was to work out whether the identity of people entering or exiting your country matched what was stated on their travel documents.

How would you do it? It's not just about terrorism. What if you had to do that at scale and cared about errors?

Actually a lot of people have that job and many of them are not silly and some of them influence technology acquisition. This is a super hard problem, technology can put a dent but human identity is a super gnarly problem.

The use of a "centaur" system (face matching with a tunable rejection threshold backed up by trained humans to work out exceptions) would probably be the most socially acceptable right?

[I am assuming that you pretty much understand whats happened with machine readable travel documents over the last while and that your reference and actual can be captured at multiple points during the entry and exit process].

DNA takes too long, humans for everything suffer from decision fatigue travel delays and high labour costs, fingerprinting is socially unacceptable.

I guess if what you're saying is that you don't really want border controls to work I can accept that, but I also don't fault the people who are legitimately doing their best at system design to meet their responsibilities. These people get panned for things that don't work, is it fair to pan them for things that do work (based on what I know of process in au/nz) too?

Doing this on departure is a new, but logical measure. I don't know of anywhere else in the world this is done but I suspect it is a data gathering trial to help the U.S. justify it as an entry requirement.

If you didn't want it to be a visible gate I suppose that a "check harder" icon could appear on the exit processing officer's screen when comparing your camera picture to your passport reference, rather than exposing gate automation to you directly. It might turn out that UX is more socially acceptable. The political stakes for wrong decisions are too high for computer face rec not to be deployed at control points.

Does it seem more socially acceptable to you if the face matching feels like a point-of-check aid to a possibly fatigued human and the results aren't logged?

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by saguro on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @07:18AM (#16014317)
> and results aren't logged

There. That's the problem with this shit. The results are logged. We are tumbling head first into a future where every flight you make, every video you watch, every destination you drive to, every person you meet: your entire life, really - is logged.

Do you know how many phone apps and games are built these days? First the author asks 'what data do I want to collect from a large number of people', and only secondly 'what kind of game or app do I build to successfully distribute my data probes?'

The population hasn't even yet realized that this future will bring a drastic shift in how people live their lives, much less began to understand the various implications of that shift. The fact that both governments and large corporations are taking full advantage of this ignorance to build a massive tracking web before the public wises up and is able to resist, or that they actively stonewall any serious discourse on this topic, that fact makes it quite obvious that pervasive logging is not in the interest of the public.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by zxcmx on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @07:40AM (#16014415)
I agree it's obviously a political problem but you're sort of deflecting the point.

We're not talking about corporate surveillance we're talking border control. Emotionally these things are connected, practically, the system is just trying to validate the eligibility of people to use travel documents.

What do you expect people are doing at country entry and exit points and do you want them to do something that works or not?

I think it's valid to say that for ideological reasons you don't really want travel documents matched against travellers properly but you do need to understand your own position properly and how that plays out politically to be able to effectively fight that battle.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by saguro on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @07:59AM (#16014497)
I feel like either you're not understanding the implications of the logging aspect in particular, or you're being disingenuous.

Firstly, we are talking about corporate surveillance. Maybe not today, but certainly tomorrow. The Australian government is already gaging private sector interest in their facial ID database, which was quietly sneaked through legislation as an anti terror measure only 2 years ago.

Secondly, these records, and all records, inevitably reach the hands of government, corporate, and finally criminal actors - usually in that order. This is again only a question of when, not if. And with access to all that data? That goes back to my original point - we haven't even thought about the implications of having such data available. But we have had a glimpse with e.g. feds getting caught looking at data of love interests.

This isn't just 'border control'. Border control is merely one of hundreds of facets in everyday life where people are being stripped of this privacy by actors who ultimately do not represent their interests.

Are you seriously going to claim that this removal of privacy and systemic logging of everyone's life is a reasonable way to tackle border control so we can stop some terrorists from being one of America's least significant causes of death? More people die to lightning strikes every year in the US than to mishaps at border control resulting in terrorism or such.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by zxcmx on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @08:14AM (#16014558)
Yeah I'm gonna go ahead and claim that automated matching between the headshot on the passport NFC chip and the natural person at the gate is totally reasonable.

Bearing in mind that you don't need to hook up to any external databases to do this (all the data is on the chip)

Like seriously, why would you NOT do that?

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by saguro on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @08:34AM (#16014633)
You're dismissing everything I said because you 'don't need' to do the logging. That's not much of an argument even if we ignored the fact that governments will 100% certainly be collecting and storing and correlating and ultimately selling that data even though technically they don't need to do that in order to just make the border control aspect work - as I have shown with the AU government doing literally that with facial ID data.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by microcolonel on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @08:40PM (#16012226)
> To get you to do things you don't want to because hey 1 in a million potential threat

People are willing to curtail the right to keep and bear arms (and it is a right, whereas there is no official right not to be surveilled in public) for a threat which is within an order of magnitude of it; and we can only really tell what the rate is like with the current countermeasures. If the rate climbs after removing countermeasures, will your opinion change? I'd still be against pervasive surveillance if the rate went up maybe tenfold.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by hammock on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @08:43PM (#16012238)
It could be argued that all the lawful gunowners together are causing less harm and/or hassle than all the TSA combined.

In other words, having a gun as last resort protection against a tyrant isn't hurting anyone the way an extra hour of unproductive scanning and associated privacy intrusions are.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by krapp on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @08:52PM (#16012284)
It could also be argued that having a gun and not using it is, in terms of societal effects, precisely the same as not having a gun to begin with. So the comparison of potential force on the part of gun owners with actual force by the TSA is a bit disingenuous.

Other than that, you're right.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by thinkmassive on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @01:47PM (#16016909)
When you’re unarmed you have no option to use a weapon to defend an innocent life. When you’re armed and have the option, you need to determine whether the risk of using a weapon is worth the potential risk of unintended side effects causing unintended damage.

These are two very different situations. If you fail to understand the difference then I hope you never go out into public armed, and maybe you should consider never owning anything primarily used as a weapon at all.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by macintux on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @10:38PM (#16012657)
It's a "right" by way of an awkwardly-phrased amendment that could easily be construed differently than the NRA does today, designed at a time when "arms" meant something vastly more innocent than today.

(In fact, the NRA itself wasn't all that upset about gun control in the fairly recent past.)

And "mass surveillance" would have meant something very different 200 years ago. Why bother writing something into the Bill of Rights when no government could possibly afford to do what they can today?

So I personally would rather we focus on natural rights that reflect today's technology, rather than artificial ones from the 1790s.

Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates by microcolonel on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @10:55PM (#16012719)
> awkwardly-phrased amendment

It's only awkwardly-phrased if you try to read it with 2017 Standard Coastal American English and without the context of the complete document (as it is supposed to be read, evidenced by the rather broad definition of speech and the press applied to the first amendment), the intent of the drafters, and a deep understanding of the writing style and cultural influences on interpretation which affected the drafters' choice of words.

> could easily be construed differently than the NRA does today

The NRA construes the second amendment to the U.S. constitution as the Supreme Court interprets it. If you have a disagreement with the Supreme Court's interpretation and standards regarding the second amendment to the U.S. constitution, state them in terms which thoroughly challenge the painstaking review of evidence which informed their interpretation. I recommend going to the wonderful folks at Oyez, they have recordings (the official transcripts have glaring errors, including literal binary flips of meaning) of hearings and briefs for you to review and couch your disagreement in.

> designed at a time when "arms" meant something vastly more innocent than today.

This is false, don't rely on pundits to understand and accurately convey a history of the design and manufacture of arms. There were semi-automatic firearms (handguns and rifles) of arbitrary magazine capacity in manufacture at least 40 years prior (and if you include the Kalthoff repeater [which may have not been commonly known in the colonies, and requires two actions to fire], 155 or more years prior) to the drafting of the second amendment (December 1791). Furthermore, the amendment actually makes no attempt to define the type of arms covered, not even defining that they be firearms or specifically rifles or handguns or guns (cannons) or shotguns.

> So I personally would rather we focus on natural rights that reflect today's technology, rather than artificial ones from the 1790s.

The right to keep and bear arms is a natural one, because the purpose is self defense, and the common defense. Humans are defined largely by their capacity to design, build, and/or use tools, so it is obvious that access to the tools which have become essential to the natural right to defend your person would themselves warrant the same recognition.

It is a natural right to use appropriate and proportionate means to defend your property (including your life), and to retain those means in advance of such an occasion.