Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates
by meddlepal on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:25PM
(#16012416)
Maybe not facial recognition, but why not chip everyone with RFID and GPS and track people? Require biometric auth to use computers or enter buildings? Stop using cash and require all transactions to be electronic. I'm just asking the questions about what is so awful about massive transparent surveillance? We're never getting this back in Pandora's box so we might as well acknowledge it and make it a part of our existence.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates
by newscracker on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @02:11AM
(#16013375)
Your argument is against fundamental freedoms that humans have granted one another, which have allowed civilization to improve over time (with "bad times" alongside). Anyone against dictatorial (not the benevolent kind) powers would never argue for everyone to be micro-chipped and tracked, disallowing all cash, etc. Even in democratic setups these kind of additions and restrictions tweak the power asymmetry significantly, and are causing a lot of human suffering. In short, these moves aren't great for humanity as a whole.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates
by sterlind on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:33PM
(#16012442)
unless the entire government is as transparent as your massive surveillance, no thanks. our democracy is extremely fragile. if information collection goes into a black box it's a turn-key solution for totalitarianism.
for instance, see the Stasi.
...however, if intelligence gathered were all open-access, and classification abolished, I'd be into it.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates
by 13of40 on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:33PM
(#16012441)
As long as we can stop dancing around the fact that most of us drive faster than the speed limit, smoke dope, and/or have unconventional sexual relationships at some point in our lives.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates
by meddlepal on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:38PM
(#16012457)
Fair points. What if everyone else's information was open and accessible so that nobody could hide anything from anybody thus removing potential asymmetric knowledge?
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates
by astronautjones on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @11:48PM
(#16012902)
There are systems of power that will never fall that make this egalitarian idea irrelevant (and dangerous)
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates
by 13of40 on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:47PM
(#16012490)
Suppose someone didn't want their grandparents to know they were gay.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates
by aplummer on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @10:03PM
(#16012540)
Or worse, the government of a country where that gets you the death penalty.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates
by gregmac on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @01:11AM
(#16013214)
Worse still, a government comes to power in your country and changes the law so you get the death penality, and it's retroactively enforced by looking through everyone's location history.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates
by meddlepal on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @04:40AM
(#16013826)
Yea, this is a troubling one. I brought up my original post as a thought experiment and I think some arguments presented were better than others.
Governments are fallible just like human beings. I suppose in some sense it is arrogant to believe the US will always remain a democracy and certainly other countries have much more tumultuous histories.
I still like the idea of a totally open and transparent society but without something totally incorruptible and unbiased taking the role of government it does not seem practical.
Re:Not Ready for Takeoff: Face Scans at Airport Departure Gates
by andrei_says_ on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @10:08PM
(#16012555)
What about consent?