That’s exactly Marx’s point when he discusses his theory of Surplus Value. I know that that theory has been “debunked” and “proven” to be false, but I’m just reading now about it in its “Grundrisse” (I had read its Capital I some years ago) and it’s frightening about how right he was about subjects reguarding capitalism way back in the 1850s (in this particular case about capitalists’ dependence on their workers’, well, surplus work; if you look at the issue under this light it makes perfect sense why capitalists would insist on their workers not decreasing the number of hours they spend working). I’m no socialist nor marxist (even though I think he’s one of the best social and political thinkers ever) but if we want to really understand how things reguarding humans work we should not be blind-sided by political allegiances.
Marx's microeconomic theory is even more wobbly than many of his more capitalistic contemporaries at the best of times, but his writings on the lengthening of working days at mills is particularly irrelevant to modern service-based Western societies and even wealthy programmers and lawyers still working more hours a week than they would prefer. There's a kernel of truth in the idea that employers will tend to profit from people working longer than they're contracted to work, but you don't need to read Kapital to understand people like getting more than they originally asked for.
Dude this sounds incredibly close the experience of American retail workers nowadays.
Workers can only change income by applying for more jobs, or by having exceptional skills. (Which may or may not be genuinely high-value, but do have to be perceived as high-value.)
Since most workers don't have high value skills, that means most people have to work multiple jobs to survive. From the Marxist point of view, it's completely irrelevant if someone is working two shifts for two employers or one very long shift for one employer.
What matters is the loss of personal freedom and opportunity for the worker, who not only gives up personal time, but also lacks both the finance and the time - never mind the energy - to develop any independent small business prospects.
The political reality is that there by the end of the 19th century there were aggressive anti-capitalist movements working hard to limit hours and raise pay against very aggressive - sometimes criminal and murderous - pressures in the other direction.
These movements were less successful in the US than in most other countries, but they still had some influence - which had mostly faded by the end of the 20th century, and has now reverted back to the 19th century ultra-exploitative model for most of the working population.
The shocking thing about the US is the extent to which these movements have been written out of history. Instead of an accurate historical account of what happened, US economic and business history seems to have been rewritten entirely by propagandists who not only ignore the influence of worker movements on pay, social mobility, and working hours, but also use spurious pseudo-economic arguments to pretend that the oppressive policies that benefit the ownership caste also benefit the rest of the country.
Control and keeping high turnover is an objective in retail management. It’s usually cheaper and more efficient to have full time staff, but it’s easier to skimp 5% of labor hours and force the salaried manager to fill the breach.
This is the law of unintended consequences as applied to the ACA. If they give you more hours care their costs go up dramatically unless they're already offering health.
It’s not just health care. Intrusive regulation like requiring a nominal amount of paid sick leave is mandated in my state over a certain number of hours. (32 iirc)
https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2014/09/16/3489562...
And not just retail workers, they are only one of the canaries in the coal mine.
>Why hasn't economic progress lowered work hours more?
Because lowering the work hours of laborers who provide more profit by more hours worked, over the short run or the long run, was not the intention of allowing economic progress to begin with.
The ones employing those workers are supposed to benefit by increased leisure time for themselves, not reduced hours for the workers, even when financial rewards are more liberally dispensed across the board as economic progress occurs.
The purpose of the US Federal Reserve was to better control economic progress not for the benefit of workers or the general citizenry, but for the bankers themselves, largely those in the Northeast with the oldest money. This was particularly important to them after major deposits of precious metals were discovered and exploited in the west. (Which is one of the major reasons why SV is where it is.) Hard currency or especially gold when the dollar was based on it could not have been allowed to continue to be held by working citizens or the potential power shift could have been too much to enable the growth of their capital gains to continue to outpace labor.
Before the Federal Reserve took control, economic progress was much more out-of-control in a way that was not was as bad for workers who in bad times could still always work for subsistence, compared to pure capitalists who were subject to non-increasing gains, reduced gains, or gasp actual losses even when they were in what was supposed to be the least risky investments.
After decades of control and supposedly harmless gradually increasing financial incentive for laborers, union power became too great anyway by the early '70's so Nixon & the Fed put a stop to it by inflating the currency in a way that would never had been possible if citizens had been allowed to retain gold or hard currency. Gold was for banks only for decades up until that time.
Gold could only be re-allowed to the public after it was fully decoupled from the dollar.
They don't want you to work for mere subsistence (especially on your own farm or business) nor allow enough collective wealth to accumulate among the workers, since either extreme reduces the incentive to put in as many of the hours which lead to Wall Street profits.
This trickles down right through SV to any new company whose ultimate outcome is an IPO through a Northeastern stock exchange.
In order for people to work less hours at their job there would have to be strong local communities and a kind of socio-economic framework to support constructive, productive and satisfying activities outside of their day job. Things like improving or fixing up the neighborhood or your own household, political activism, caregiving, teaching, citizen science are all examples of things that one could do not for money but for the benefit of the community or the betterment of society. But due to the capitalist mode of production people are alienated from each other and the product of their labor so much that they think of work as a commodity to be traded for money only. And rather than doing these things as a way of finding fulfillment and building communities, people contract others to do it for them for money.
In the real world there's nothing mysterious about employers preferring to get as many hours out of employees as possible. There are fixed costs per FTE that don't scale with the number of hours worked - everything from training to health care to the size of the parking lot.
Looking at it with modern eyes, it would be easy to make said machinery operate like an amplifier of labor. Meaning that for each unit of labor used to operate the machine, the owner would get a multiple of said labor out.
Marx instead tried to reason that machines were simple stores of labor, never giving more out than was used to make the machine in the first place.
He still managed to make some observations that i will claim still holds to this day.
While in volume one he focused on the industrial labor side, as a way to lay the foundation of his other commentary, his later volumes pulls in finance and lending.
From that he concluded that it would actually be in the best interest of industrial capital to collaborate with labor in a common front against finance, but that sadly they would side with finance capital until it was too late.
I agree with this, but trying to look at the issue with Marx's eyes I think he saw the subject like this (I'm no Marxist, nor an economist, just making an educated guess): Of course that the machines help their owners (the capitalists) make more money in absolute terms (the amplifier of labor you mention), but at the end of the day what matters for a capitalist (and is one of the essences of capitalism, I think) is that he should make more money compared to the other capitalists.
Now, I think Marx says that all capitalists (as a class) can have access to the same machines -> they can all enjoy the same returns caused by said newer, better machines -> so technology/science progress is no differentiator in the long run between capitalists, because the new, better machines bring them the same rate of profits (of course a company or two can go bankrupt if they haven't modernized fast enough, but we're talking about more general stuff). What I think Marx is saying is that the main (and in his view the only one that counts) differentiator between capitalists consists in how well they can "squeeze" out labor out of the, well, labor-classes (industrial workers back in Marx's time). And if you look at the economic history of the past 25 years (give or take) you can see that the grand winner of this period, China, is actually a capitalist country (I'm ignoring its one-party rule thing) that knew pretty damn well how to squeeze out labor out of its citizens/workers, and also that the United States has had a better economic run compared to Europe also because it treats its workers worse (and unfortunately people over here in Europe have started noticing this and have started copying the US).
> From that he concluded that it would actually be in the best interest of industrial capital to collaborate with labor in a common front against finance, but that sadly they would side with finance capital until it was too late.
That sounds pretty interesting, I've never got to read his Capital II and III, I guess I'll give them a try.
Actually, no. This has nothing to do with Marx "surplus value". And his idea of "surplus value" was wrong by several reasons. The funny thing about Marx is that he failed to understand capitalism as much as good ol' Ludwig von Mises.
Working more is a short term solution to increase the productivity of a team, but on the long term the benefits of doing so aren’t that obvious.
Some of it is probably due to startup culture but people seem to work at insane hours.
Lots of commits during the night or the weekend, or even now during the Christmas break.
In general, the culture in the US seems way more pro employers and companies and anti-employees and consumers.
We've got a bunch of perverse incentives where it's cheaper for the patient to choose the option that's more expensive for the payer. Straightening those out would be a small first step, but complexities of the system and incumbent powers have made it pretty difficult.
I can sympathize with this because I remember needing a medical procedure that I was forced to travel to a different country to solve, it wasn't even about the money but a case where I the patient was given poor information and then ignored, I actually took the doctor to the board over it in the end, and they ultimately provided a correct solution but it was easier in the end just to travel abroad to fix it.
Law is meaningless if workers don't make it happen.
They are also designed in ways which makes people end up resenting unions. I register a lot of union hatred in the US which simply doesn't exist in Norway. Part of the reason seems to be from how unions function in the US.
You are either a union shop or you are not. People are forced to join the union or they are forced to not join it. People don't like being made to do things. In Norway it has always been free choice to join a union. There is no such thing as a "union shop".
Unions in the US also don't seem to hold much power except in its ability to sabotage the company, and so that seems to be what they do. In Germany and Norway unions are more like partners with management. They are on the company boards. They can't be ignored as easily as in the US. To be heard in the US, it seems like unions have to cause trouble. I think this creates a very unhealthy union environment and creates a bad reputation for unions.
Unions in Norway form hierarchies so that you huge national unions which together with representatives for employers negotiate work life in Norway on regular basis.
The other part I think is that Norway and Germany has quite extensive welfare systems, so unions are not as actively protecting particular jobs as they are trying to protect people. Losing your job in Norway or Germany is not the same catastrophe as in the US. So people are more accepting towards it. Instead what people want to see is things like job training and aid to help you get a new job.
My point is that law is only part of the equation, people need to fight for keeping it relevant.
I never said it was easy to do so.
Forming a union is never easy, even in Norway.
> Underlying Germany’s surplus is a decades-old accord between business and unions in favour of wage restraint to keep export industries competitive. Such moderation served Germany’s export-led economy well through its postwar recovery and beyond. It is an instinct that helps explain Germany’s transformation since the late 1990s from Europe’s sick man to today’s muscle-bound champion.
This isn’t a problem for the US states sharing a currency because they have the federal budget spending balances most of this out.
This includes IT related jobs.
If people on US and other countries want these benefits, choose to get strong instead of demonizing unions.
There's a saying you should be careful with what you wish for, you might as well get it.
(I deliberately didn't pick SV/NYC. Dallas and Berlin are very similar cost of living wise.)
There is probably a point in there about shorter work days and legally mandated overtime pay, but it doesn't add up to 40k per year.
Honestly, the more I look at this, the more it seems like there are hidden mechanisms that keep pay below market value in many European countries. E.g. wage collusion and the like. I am almost certain that this is part of the picture, although there are also other factors at play. (Smaller, less homogenous markets than the US, more restrictive laws around business ownership, fewer gargantous and profitable companies that compete for talent, etc).
The High-Tech Employee Anti-Trust Litigation looks very curious to my Norwegian eyes. Cold-calling employees at competitors for recruiting is widely considered inappropriate behavior. I would not be surprised to find out that there are eerily similar unwritten agreements between large employers here.
Income taxes in Texas for 95k amounts to about 27%. Income tax in Berlin for $60k (30y, no children, left other options on defaults) amounts to 33%. The after tax difference is about $30k then.
Tuition in UT Dallas, 4y engineering bachelor degree, is $45k. Free in DE, but you pay that in less than two years with the difference in salary.
Public transport? In US the TCO is estimated at $8500 yearly. In Berlin you can get an annual tickets for $1100. It's not directly comparable but you get the picture. For better perspective, NYC 30d passes sets you back at $1450 per year.
Texas:
$95k pre-tax falls into the marginal 28% bracket, but after subtracting 401k + IRA deferral ($18k + $5.5k), $95k falls to AGI of $71.5k. Then after subtracting standard deduction ($6.35k for single 30y, no children), personal exemption ($4.05k), taxable income falls to $61.1k. For this, the tax calculation is:
0-9325: 10%x9325 = 932.5
9325-37950: 15%x28624 = 4293.6
37950-61100: 25%x23150 = 5787.5
Total tax: 11013.6
Post-tax income: 84k
Income Tax rate: 11.6% since no income tax in Texas.
Social security+Medicare: 7.65%
Post-tax and post-SS: $76.7k
Berlin:
Pre-tax: $60k USD x 1 Euro/$1.19 USD = 50240 Euro
I entered this number into a German tax estimator [1], which gave me the following output for the tax bracket calculations:
Total tax: 9.908,56 Euro
Post-tax income: 40331 Euro
Income Tax rate: 19.7%
Obligatory Pension: 9.35%
UI+Health Insurance+Disability: 8.4%+1.5%+1.425% = 11.325%
Post-tax and everything: $35.8k USD
The difference becomes $40.9k. If you amortize the 4y engineering bachelor degree over 4 years, I think the difference in income is quite significant.
Of course, there's both deductions and non-income taxes also, which complicate the issue. In Norway, the total tax pressure is significantly greater than 50% for most people. (VAT at 25% always deducted from already-taxed income, long-term capital gains at 30%, pre-salary employer tax at 14%, company profits taxed at 24%, salary taxed at ~33% on average, fuel tax ~30%, wealth tax 0.85% of net assets after deductions +++).
It isn’t easy to compare apples to apples but generally I’d guess in Europe highly paid professions are subsidizing the poor relative to the US.
If we do have shareholder lobby groups, they certainly do not have any impact on policy. Capital gains tax increases one percentage point to 31% next year, up from 27% five years ago. In addition, there is the 0.85% wealth tax on net assets above ~180,000 USD. There is no deduction for long term capital gains.
There is also non-cash compensation that doesn't get reported in "average" salary. For example, my telecom engineer friend in Germany has a benefit of having a car leased for him by the company. The level of the car depends on the position, so he has 3-series (only German cars can be leased, of course). The reason for this it's more profitable for the company tax-wise to lease cars for employees than to pay same amount in cash.
(free healthcare doesn't count as the US amount usually includes insurance)
How about 35hour work weeks and the fact that overtime is paid? If you factor that into account and add to the healthcare and extra vacation days I'm pretty sure those fictional $40k/yearly fade out rather quickly.
And by the way, average income means jack shit when the income distribution is so lopsided, particularly when discussing issuez linked to poverty and the lack of basic services.
Not only is Germany poorer than the US, but Berlin is among the poorer cities in Germany. Hence I don't think it says much about the results of unions.
Norway has equally strong unions as Germany and close to 80% of Norwegian workers are unionized.
I am pretty sure that if you compared to developer salaries in a richer country such as Switzerland you would also find much higher software developer salaries.
And then there are national peculiarities. E.g. more developers in Germany than in many other European countries might be associated with manufacturing industry which doesn't necessarily value software developers as high as a more startup like scene.
I checked and dev salary in the rest of Germany. Not very different from Berlin.
Switzerland does pay handsomely. But, unlike neighbors, unions have quite minor role. And labor laws are way more lax than France or DE.
About prevalece of manufacturing in Germany, France has similar salaries despite being a more services oriented economy.
[1]https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?cou...
[2] https://www.glassdoor.com/Salaries/oslo-software-engineer-sa...
Engineers and software developers are if anything members of what could be more called trade groups. These groups don't negotiate or push for salaries on behalf of members, nor do they do things like organize strikes.
To test you hypothesis I think you have to look at several countries in Europe at similar GDP number and compare salaries. Then you'd have to compare between those of different GDP numbers and see whether GDP or unionization rate correlates most with salaries.
I got to point out however that such a task is momentously difficult, because differences in how things are recorded and rated. As an example I just remembered several other factors in addition to the previous mention that I forgot.
1) The salary quoted in Norway, is the money workers get after special income tax is deducted by the employer. This is about 14%. So a 65k salary is more like 75k if you consider this tax.
2) High living expenses in Norway is heavily influenced by a very high VAT tax of 25%.
Sure that doesn't mean the money is suddenly in your pocket but it means it doesn't just disappear. It goes to cover extensive welfare services, which e.g. Americans would have to pay for out of pocket.
In essence it is hard to compare very high tax regimes with extensive welfare benefits to one with low taxes and few benefits.
Also I am in doubt about how many Norwegians report to these web pages. It would be more accurate to look at statistics gathered by NITO among its members.
One aspect you have to consider with respect to the US and Europe in general is that Europeans work a lot fewer hours. A lot of difference between US and European software developer salaries could simply be down to difference in hours worked.
I make about $97 000 at current exchange as a software developer in Norway. But I work only 37.5 hours per week. I got 5 weeks vacation per year. In addition to a lot more public holidays than in the US. I haven't worked overtime in over 10 years. While judging from accounts from Europeans working in the US, it is quite normal with very long work weeks and overtime.
Oslo living expenses will look extra high because we are most likely at at the top of a property bubble. We never had a downturn in 2008 for the housing market.
Also living expenses in Norway is usually hard to compare with other countries since food prices and recently housing costs are quite high. However health care, education, child care etc is quite cheap. Many consumer goods are also relatively cheap. E.g. food is much cheaper in Spain than in Norway but buying a TV is cheaper in Norway.
It ia worth every penny I get less than Dallas, life is not always about money.
1. The cost of living in Dallas is roughly equal to the cost of living in Berlin.
2. The cost of living like you're in Berlin in Dallas is much higher than the cost of living in Berlin.
You see those kinds of adjustments with female employees: there's a decent amount part-time work and no-overtime in that segment, especially at families with decent income.
But not so with males. And often, for males with the privilege to work less, their job is their identity. So it's natural they like going to work.
But if the stats of this Gallup survey[1] are correct, that 70% of Americans hate their job, the reason clearly isn't love, but necessity.
[1]http://www.nydailynews.com/life-style/majority-u-s-workers-n...
Higher wages may also support more smaller/domestically owned businesses, which tend to treat their employees more humanely than huge corporations.
I’m curious what you base that statement on, as I’ve generally not found it to be true during my career.
Employers, especially those that pay benefits, want you working as much as possible. Anything less is money on the table.
(I'm not an employer.)
It's good for an employer if you work overtime, all he has to pay is time, or time and a half, or nothing if you're salaried. He doesn't have to pay more benefits, as he would with an additional employee. Of course an employer wants to get as much work out of you as possible for benefits paid.
As an employee, working overtime only gets you more cash (or even none). Working less makes your benefits more valuable.
Even if employment is strictly for money, with no benefits at all, there's an administrative overhead to hiring and managing more employees.
As long as we are employed by employers, and especially if we get health insurance through our employer, there will always be pressure to work more, not less.