News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:22AM (#15994781)
Millennials' ideals don't originate from their lack of exposure to the failings of the baby boomers, their ideals originate from their actual lived experience. To believe otherwise would be to dismiss the relevance of the things that have actually happened in their lifetimes and the economic situation they currently face. They saw their future prospects destroyed by a deregulated financial market, and now they're seeing the economic restoration that follows skipping them entirely and consolidating global wealth in the hands of a few while they struggle with basic necessities. All the while they're being perpetually maligned because prior generations lack the ability to relate to their day-to-day reality on a basic level and the fear of something different is a great driver of ad revenue.

Millennials are moving away from techno-libertarian ideals because laissez faire attitudes towards the application of technology have placed fundamental aspects of their lives in the iron grasp of private corporations who regularly harvest their data for the explicit purpose of manipulating their behavior without their knowledge.

http://highline.huffingtonpost.com/articles/en/poor-millenni...

EDIT: As an aside, I find it kind of amazing that the myth of personal responsibility for outcomes is so prevalent among the very people who take the mass-scale manipulation of user behavior for granted. How can these people who spend massive amounts of money and resources studying how to best psychologically exploit their users and who can see directly how the most minute aspects of outside influence can reliably change behavior find it so easy to then turn around and claim that people are fundamentally responsible for their own situation? Do tech libertarians really believe that they're immune to the forces they use to manipulate others on a daily basis?

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by spamizbad on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:45AM (#15994899)
I agree completely.

And what's sad is that, for many millennials, they're stuck in a financial tar pit in large part by following the advice of their elders.

As an older millennial, my generation had two pieces of advice drilled into our skulls by boomers:

* What degree you get in college isn't that important, a B.A. will let an employer know your teachable

* Student loan debt is the best debt you can have: better than mortgage debt even

* (post dot-com crash) Don't bother trying to come a professional software developer -- it's the new textile industry: it's going overseas.

This created a generation that didn't factor in their professional or economic trajectory when choosing schools, deciding loans, etc. I had peers that walked away from free rides to college to go to their school of choice because student loans were "no big deal" -- and their parents encouraged this!

Boomers should have looked at their own jobs and paid attention how their own companies were hiring in the new economy: that new junior analyst? Makes less than the median income, despite an econ degree from top-tier school. Why did they think their kids, with a middling academics, could land the same job with a degree in english lit? The writing was on the wall even in the 90s that this wasn't a good idea: The world was more globalized and competitive. Labor's power was greatly diminished.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by jordanb on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:20PM (#15995435)
> * What degree you get in college isn't that important, a B.A. will let an employer know your teachable

And the lies we're telling the next generation are

* Get a STEM degree, they're always in demand

* Become a programmer, there will never be enough programmers.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by Apocryphon on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:34PM (#15995826)
Generals always fight the last war.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by stickfigure on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:47PM (#15995271)
Millennials are moving away from techno-libertarian ideals because laissez faire attitudes towards the application of technology have placed fundamental aspects of their lives in the iron grasp of private corporations who regularly harvest their data for the explicit purpose of manipulating their behavior without their knowledge.

This contradicts my observation, which is that "concern over privacy" correlates with age. I see older folks ragequitting social media; the kids are sexting and snapchatting.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:58PM (#15995322)
The "kids" have a life that has been deeply intertwined with their own personal internet ecosystems almost since the day they were born. It's a lot more colossal of a proposal on someone's life to quit facebook when they literally grew up on it. There are social and economic forces in my life that straight-up require me to be a part of social media. Acting like separation from facebook is trivially easy is completely ignoring the reality of modern life. And I couldn't even separate myself from google if I tried, I can't do my job without it. Not to mention that all that data they've collected on me so far? That belongs to them forever.

It's also completely ridiculous to go about blaming actual children for becoming ensnared by systems that were designed from the ground up by the greatest minds of our generation in order to capture their attention.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by austincheney on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:03PM (#15996244)
I quit Facebook and deleted my account. I have done hard things in life and that is certainly not among them.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by cgmg on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:38PM (#15996150)
I'm curious. What are these forces that require you to be a part of social media?

And why are you using Google rather than alternatives like DuckDuckGo?

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by 1337biz on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:53PM (#15996203)
Social peer pressure. Most kids want to have the respect/admiration of their peers.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:48PM (#15996435)
The problem is that you're still thinking about this in terms of "kids". I wouldn't have been able to get any of my two past jobs without the networking I've done through social media. Not to mention the fact that I've strongly relied on social media for the promotion of products, etc.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by 1337biz on Saturday December 23, 2017 @06:05PM (#15996811)
Impressive! What are you core channels?
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by Can_Not on Sunday December 24, 2017 @01:59PM (#16000765)
Most kids don't want to be completely left behind because they're the only ones off social media.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by perl4ever on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:56PM (#15995945)
I regularly read claims on the Internet that young people don't use Facebook...
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by malvosenior on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:47AM (#15994912)
If their concerns are economic, then it makes even less sense to attack the tech industry. That's the one place where you can still achieve a middle to upper middle class lifestyle based on hard work.

Going back to my comment about baby boomers, it seems to me that the 20th century idealized lifestyle was very much backed by the technology available at the time. Mainly mass media. Bandwidth was great enough to broadcast media to a massive amount of people, but not so great as to individualize content delivery. This limited "shelf space" for content lead to a market for high end content creators.

The internet exponentially increased bandwidth and democratized (and devalued) content creation. It also created channels for publishing new types of content that require tech skills (apps, web...).

You would think that millennials would embrace the 21st century technology driven reality, but instead it seems way too many people ended up chasing high value content roles via expensive liberal arts degrees. Or at least that anti-technology combative mindset that was foreshadowed in this piece.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:12PM (#15995066)
The notion that millennials' woes are the result of getting a liberal arts degree in women's studies or something is a baseless claim that has been perpetuated specifically because it's an emotionally resonant myth. The millennials that are suffering the hardest right now are the ones who couldn't even afford to go to college (because college tuition is priced ridiculously). The vast majority of millennials that did go to college got a degree in a traditionally "useful" field. The only place where you see a preponderance of liberal arts degrees that aren't specifically career-focused are rich kids who got to go to Ivy Leagues; these people are nothing like your average millennial.

https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/students-at-most-colleg...

https://www.npr.org/2014/11/18/354196302/amid-the-stereotype...

And the notion that they should've all just got a job in tech is equally ridiculous. The frameworks and techniques I'm using right now didn't even exist when I went to college. And I'm someone who specifically approached my degree with the anticipation of future technology!

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by megaman22 on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:34PM (#15995186)
I'd argue that the ones that are really struggling are the ones that went to some college, but didn't manage to finish. My generation was sold hard on the idea that everybody needed to go to college, but the reality is that most of them were not prepared or equipped to actually complete a college-level education. So an alarming number struggled through a few years, bounced around a couple schools, and dropped out, with little to show for it besides a heaping pile of student debt. Now they are competing for the same jobs as their compatriots that didn't waste a few years and tens of thousands of dollars, and were earning and gaining real-world skills in the meantime.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by alexasmyths on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:16PM (#15995714)
" The vast majority of millennials that did go to college got a degree in a traditionally "useful" field. "

? What ?

No. Most college degrees are minted in non-professional or degrees for which one will have very little direct ability to land a job [1].

There is no rule that says 66% of society should be able to spend four years getting an English degree.

Higher education is, and always will be expensive because it requires input from others.

[1] https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/05/09/310114739/what...

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by malvosenior on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:24PM (#15995119)
> The frameworks and techniques I'm using right now didn't even exist when I went to college.

Yes they did. Being a self taught programmer has been a thing since the dawn of personal computing. The Homebrew Computer Club was way before millennials after all.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:34PM (#15995180)
Yes, it was so easy to be a self-taught programmer living in Silicon Valley in the 1980s...

You see how this doesn't scale as an assumption about people and their situations, right? Just because it was possible for some people does not mean it was possible for a meaningfully large number of people. We take for granted how easy it is to train oneself as a programmer these days, but then most of us in this space have been doing this since elementary school. Who would I be today if my dad hadn't made enough money to buy me my own PC when I was in the 3rd grade?

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by malvosenior on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:43PM (#15995239)
You can’t expect society to instantly leap into the future immediately for everyone. That’s not how it works.

In the 80s computing was starting to be accessible to a few. If you could access it, you could teach yourself.

In the 90s-00s (millennial time) it was even more accessible. You also had the internet to learn from and a vastly larger market for all things tech.

This trend will continue and that’s a good thing.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by alsetmusic on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:51PM (#15995926)
> In the 90s-00s (millennial time) it was even more accessible. You also had the internet to learn from and a vastly larger market for all things tech.

I think you're overstating the degree of access that large parts of the population had for furthering interest in this area.

I was a teenager in the mid-90s. This is when I read about Linux for the first time somewhere online. I remember going to bookstores and trying to find books on learning Linux, but none existed where I lived (Midwest). I managed to install MKLinux on my PPC Mac at the time, but had no idea where to go from there. Online resources were locked behind a dial-up connection and there were no computer clubs or technology meet-ups in my area. Web searches were still a joke at the time.

It wasn’t until years later that I became familiar with Unix and Unix-like systems. The change finally came as a result of widespread broadband adoption and the rise of Google. Around this time, Mac OS X had also arrived and I could finally begin learning the command line without having to dual-boot my computer.

I think you’re overstating the level of access that large parts of the population had for truly going further in the 90s. I’m highly envious of young people today and the access that they now have to resources that essentially didn’t exist when I was that age. That’s probably true for every generation, however.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by malvosenior on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:58PM (#15995954)
All I said is that the tech was more available in the 90s than the 80s. Your story is pretty in-line with what I was thinking honestly.

My point is: fighting technological progress because it’s not happening fast enough seems weird. Should we not encourage it to happen even faster?

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:21PM (#15996313)
We should be looking at where it's exacerbating inequality and come up with intelligent, data-driven solutions. Many people act as if the concept of any type of government regulation or non-market-driven solution is incapable of having a positive impact, but I have seen no compelling evidence to prove that. You can hand-pick any number of past bad regulations with negative outcomes, but for every one you show me I can show you a regulation we're deeply reliant on. Regulations are a tool, they can be designed well or poorly, and we can examine them analytically. Even if you truly believed that government intervention of any kind necessarily must introduce inefficiencies, I'd hope you'd agree that economic efficiency is not always the exclusive good that we should be aiming for. Ideally we want a balance of economic efficiency and the overall health, equality, and well-being of the populace. The argument that when the economy improves everyone does better is blatantly false, and we have data to indicate that. Moreover, economic inequality itself can destroy markets.

https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/8/8/16112368/pi...

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by malvosenior on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:29PM (#15996343)
And I've seen no compelling evidence that regulation adds anything to technological progress. In fact I've personally experienced quite the opposite. Have you ever worked on a global tech property? The EU and Germany in particular have some pretty onerous regulations regarding content that can be published (even on user generated content services). You will waste real man hours complying with these regulations. You'll also forgo legitimate innovation in favor of this mollycoddling busy work.

I don't want to ask permission from the state to build something and I surely don't want them involved with my endeavor once I get going.

You can experience these effects first hand if you try to build something innovative and it takes off.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:03PM (#15996502)
My dad's company is an international medical device manufacturer and I am keenly aware of the regulatory hoops (some of which I will even admit are legitimately unfair and should be reformed!) that he has to jump through and the sheer amount of money it costs his company to make sure they're complying with regulations. It, without a doubt, is an economic burden on them.

I still don't want someone dying because a faulty medical device was used on them. I think that the trade-off between ease of new innovation and public safety is a decision we have to all make collectively, and I think that the necessarily massive gulf between consumer and producer information necessitates that government be involved. Market solutions are bad for situations where there is wide information asymmetry.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by pesmhey on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:03PM (#15997864)
You could also experience these effects if you were trying to build weapons. Or a monopoly. Or lots of things.

The reason you haven't seen compelling evidence that regulation adds anything to technological progress is because it doesn't, almost by definition. Regulation serves to protect citizens - entrenched special interests too. That protection means funding space races and intense times of technological progress, or dampening an out-of-control feedback loop of wealth/power accumulation, or a bunch of things in between.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by pesmhey on Saturday December 23, 2017 @10:42PM (#15997799)
Imagine you're on a skateboard holding on to a bungee cord connected to the back of your buddy's truck - or some similar analogy. Imagine that truck starts going too fast, and you start lagging behind. Imagine your cord just snaps and your buddy just keeps going.

You're basically advocating that we step on the gas to make everyone go faster. Eventually, that link just snaps.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by malvosenior on Sunday December 24, 2017 @09:20AM (#15999632)
It's more like I bought a nice new truck and I'm taking it to the store when I pass a bunch of people who I don't know but ask me for a ride. I politely decline as I'm busy but instead they attach their bungee cords to my truck as I drive by. Then they complain incessantly that I'm driving too fast and that I'm going to break their cords.

Yeah, I'm advocating that people find their own ride and don't slow mine down.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by pesmhey on Sunday December 24, 2017 @12:43PM (#16000425)
A lot of the tech that has enabled the rise of the 'virtual class' is built on a marriage of public and private funds. The railroads that enabled westward expansion, the dams that powered it, so many things that enabled our situation today, built in part (though not fully, of course) on the contributions of a myriad of people - people that may not necessarily know each other.

People normally have benefitted from the type of tech built by public and private funds, but now, there's a big fear that the current tech being built has no upside for anyone but a very small number of people. With a little more social and political grace, these fears might be assuaged, but instead, there's this zeitgeist that 'we could build such a better world if only pesky people didn't get in the way'. It's a Cultural Revolution!

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by malvosenior on Sunday December 24, 2017 @02:40PM (#16000964)
The basic infrastructure you mention were enabled by cheap labor more than anything else. We still use that for manufacturing (among other things) via globalism.

> there's a big fear that the current tech being built has no upside for anyone but a very small number of people

Some people have that fear, a most people don't.

The quintessential example of an "evil" California company is Uber. That service has been absolutely trans-formative not just for myself and other tech workers, but also for the drivers. I take Uber all the time and despite the media FUD, nearly 100% of drivers say the service was life changing as they can now make money on demand, when it works for them.

I think there's a small pocket of very well connected people who are "afraid" of unchecked technological progress because they don't understand it and/or they're heavily invested in decaying power structures (old media, social scientists, politicians...). They make a lot of noise as a smoke screen to put the technologists under them in the social/financial hierarchy.

Most technologists and most regular people aren't afraid of anything and quite enjoy the fruits of our progress (cf Facebook usage).

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:32PM (#15995492)
But the trend is not that some people are taking the lead and others are following more slowly up behind them. The trend is one of continually growing wealth inequality.

And the truth is that even if we can educate the rest of the labor market to a point where they can meaningfully contribute to the tech industry, it would just serve to devalue tech labor. It's already happening, and as a result hiring practices are getting significantly more selective towards requiring degrees and other expensive credentials.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by malvosenior on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:39PM (#15995530)
The trend is that the 20th century American lifestyle was never sustainable for the entire globe (or even the US for more than ~50 years). It was the byproduct of the US's unique position in and after World War I & II.

Technological progress is most definitely bring up the bottom rung of society. It may not be glamorous but if you go to an actual 3rd world country you can compare for yourself and see life isn't so bad here, even for the poorest.

Globalization is here to stay. Yes, certain classes of lifestyle have/will run out of gas, but that is inevitable.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by junkscience2017 on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:31PM (#15995148)
firefighters, cops and nurses in many Bay Area communities make more than typical programmers and have more deterministic career/salary upgrades...and in many cases, pensions. and they don't have to worry about market forces

the other day there was a story of a nurse in San Jose (no one special) making $260k...more than most people here I bet

Programming is declining in attractiveness and may become a McJob for most

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by garmaine on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:21PM (#15995440)
Data point of one: I’m a millennial that suffered through the financial collapse, having graduated with massive student debt from a private school while basically being unemployable in the market due to lack of experience, and even once I got a job watching housing prices rise faster than my savings for a down payment.

But this didn’t drive me to be anti-free market. Far from it. The financial collapse was due to the power of the banks which existed as a government authorized oligarchy. Allowing banks monopoly over the mechanisms of monetary policy is the source of the problem. 2007 was NOT an unregulated market by any reasonable measure.

Don’t let your partisanship blind you to be grievances of those who align with neither yours nor the opposing party platforms.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:38PM (#15995527)
You have a weird assumption here that somehow if there were less regulations the banks would somehow have less of a monopoly on the mechanisms of monetary policy. That's not how it works, not in theory or practice.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by roenxi on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:20PM (#15996308)
It is a weird, but entirely correct, assumption that all markets operate in a legal framework and are thus regulated.

What does 'more banking regulation' or 'less banking regulation' even mean? If the government enacts 'more' legislation that ossifies the practices from before financial crisis, that clearly cannot be an improvement.

Talking about more or less regulation is just setting the government up to be manipulated by the highest bidder, who can specify what changes in a way that looks like 'more' or 'less' of something. The rules need to be changed to promote honesty and not create perverse incentives. This requires /different/ regulation, and to demand specific changes. Nobody agrees on what those changes should be afaik.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by garmaine on Sunday December 24, 2017 @04:52AM (#15998854)
> It is a weird, but entirely correct, assumption that all markets operate in a legal framework and are thus regulated.

I’m not sure what you’re saying here. Counter pint: drug markets.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by garmaine on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:13PM (#15996286)
If there were less regulations you wouldn’t need to be a bank to do what a bank does. That was my point. Why so t we see the level of innovation we have in web in the financial sector? Operating a fintech company requires as much legal compliance as it does code and this protects incumbents and lets them extract rent from our society.

The GP seems to be saying “let’s regulate these rent seekers.” I’m saying “let’s stop paying rents in the first place.”

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by wfo on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:23PM (#15995759)
Unregulated corporate power destroyed your life and your response is "no, this is actually good" and then you tell us not to be blinded by partisan ideology?
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by garmaine on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:07PM (#15996266)
Banks are regulated. They require licenses to operate. Can I operate my own bank and issue retail credit without regulations? No?
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by alexasmyths on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:11PM (#15995688)
"They saw their future prospects destroyed by a deregulated financial market, and now they're seeing the economic restoration that follows skipping them entirely and consolidating global wealth in the hands of a few while they struggle with basic necessities.""

I don't agree at all.

Millennial have more opportunity than any generation in history, by far.

They can chose what they want to do.

They can stay single, get married, be gay, be bi, whatever.

They are the first generation for whom international travel is accssible.

They are the first gen. where females can generally choose whatever career and it's not a big deal.

They are the first gen. to grow up with all the world's information at their fingertips.

They are the first gen. to not know full-scale war, mass poverty.

The 'financial system' was not 'destroyed' by anything - this is laughable. It was an accounting correction. The 1930's - this was an economic catastrophe. People were literally dying. The 2008 meltdown ... millenials were too young to be participants, it may have only affected a few jobs - and and it kept their housing costs down.

Aside from University costs (should we all be going to college?), and possibly housing bubble, they have it better materially than any generation - ever - and there's nothing to compain about.

"I find it kind of amazing that the myth of personal responsibility"

There is no 'myth' to personal responsibility, it's a core tenet of civilization.

If you finish school, learn a trade or get a relevant education, you'll get a job and live an ok life.

You are not entitled to a massive house, vacays all over the world and full on job security.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by lifeisawesme on Sunday December 24, 2017 @12:36PM (#16000386)
I 100% agree with you! I'm 23. I worked full time while getting my BS in computer science and worked 80+ hours for 2 years and completely paid off my student loan debt.

I currently am blessed to have $400/mo rent and only spend $10,000 annually in living costs. My generation is beyond blessed!

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by mbrumlow on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:01PM (#15995338)
I feel like you missed malvosenior's point. Its not about never failing, it's about not having the opportunity to fail in safe spaces before they entered the real world. And by safe spaces I don't mean what is going on at today's universities.

Growing up I remember finding it weird that every kid won a trophy --- just for showing up to the swim meet. I also remember how it seemed to wash the meaning of my second place trophy away.

I was lucky enough to experience failure often at a young age but I had many and by many I mean almost all of my friends never seamed to have hardships or experience failure. And I remember very very vividly when my best friend at the time was rejected and failed for the first time in his life by getting denied to the school of his choice. He was devastated. And not in a normal way. But that only lasted shortly as his mother was able to pull some strings and some connections and got him in the backdoor -- failure adverted. Had many friend like that, and the majority of the kids who biggest disappointments as a child were stupid things like their favorite pizza store closed down, or it rained on their birthday.

In any case I think and malvosenior can correct me if I am wrong. That the point is that we have a generation of kids now adults that have not been giving the tools to properly deal with failure -- and this affects there life in a very adverse way.

That all being said please read the above with the notion that I don't really like to judge groups of people, and that individuals should be looked at as just that -- an in individual. But what I am saying is that if I were to make a classification that did fit this "never learned how to fail" notion I am sure I could find more than a hand full of people who I would classify with said trait.

Now clearly aallevich is talking of his/her experiences and they are most certainly valid. But what I think would be more healthy is to unyoke your life experiences from that of a "Millennial" and own it for who you are and how you became to be. From there you can then actually start to address the issues that you feel are holding you back and likely come out on top. As long as you look at it as a "us" problem it will always be too big of an issue for you to overcome by your self. Don't let a calcification dictate who you are.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:24PM (#15995449)
You realize that your perception of what your friends went through is driven by your own personal situation, and not that of millennials at-large, right?

Your friends, I assume, were rich kids, or at least comfortably middle-class. The problems my friends dealt with in high school weren't trivial. They dealt with divorce, drug addiction, alcoholic parents, unwanted pregnancies, struggles with poverty, bullying... To me the notion that they never had to learn how to deal with failure is ridiculous. The class gap is enormous, and I've lived a life where I've been intimately acquainted with both sides of it.

Besides, it's not me I'm worried about here. I'm worried about the people around me. I'm one of the lucky millennials who has a tech job. It's my friends who are struggling to eat.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by mbrumlow on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:52PM (#15995599)
First off by no means rich for the friends, and for me I was on food stamps and living in s single parent family with 2 children and a mother making less than 16k a year.

The problem is that the things you speak you do so as if they are not extraordinary -- these are things that all walks of people have to deal with, rich or poor (minus the poverty one). These also are not personal failures, and are not the type of failures I am talking about.

And no, the perception of my friends situation has nothing to do with my personal situation. These are reflections I had long after the situation and emotion removed from the conversation.

If you are fine -- that is awesome -- then please pass on to your friends to let their group identity keep them down. There are many jobs -- maybe not the one they want to do, or thought they wanted to do -- that today with 2 years of cheap training can bring in some real cash.

I will take my brother as a example. He dealt with EVERY ONE OF THE THINGS on your list, every last one! And today he is successful at what he does, but man does he have to work hard- much harder than I do (I am in tech as well). He took classes to be come a AC repair man, and now runs his own company. Did he make shit money at first? For sure, everybody does, but as he gained skill and saved money he was able to finally go out on his own and now has 6 people working for him. Not once did he say "I can't because ... I was bullied, I can't because ... I grew up on food stamps, I can't because ... my father was a abusive alcoholic, and I can't ... because my parents divorced (twice)", I can't because just are not words in his vocabulary.

And you sort of prove my point about some thing when you bring up that THOSE experiences, the things that many many many successful people experience are the things you sight as keeping your friends down today.

While horrible life experiences are some times out of our control, how you deal with them and what you do next is.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:15PM (#15995711)
I think there's a mismatch in what we're each trying to convey here. I understand very well how people can struggle through incredible odds and still manage to make success for themselves. I think such stories are deeply inspiring, and I likewise hold to a philosophy of never giving in despite the uphill climb you face.

But I'm not concerned with personal motivation here, I'm concerned with systemic issues that need to be addressed, and that I believe can be addressed. Personal motivation is a non-sequitur.

The idea that if people in a disadvantaged group were just motivated enough they have an equal chance to succeed is trivially false: the entire reason they're considered part of a disadvantaged group is because their chance of good outcomes is statistically lower than other groups. Demotivating factors certainly play a part in this, but the idea that their disadvantage would disappear if they just thought about things the right way is silly in the extreme (not to mention unsupported by data). You usually don't have to dig far to find an actual obstruction to the success of the group. And if we have the capability of removing this obstruction, why wouldn't we?

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by joejerryronnie on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:57PM (#15996217)
Are you including millennials in the list of systematically disadvantaged groups like minorities, women, handicapped, etc? I'm not even sure what to say to that.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by joejerryronnie on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:49AM (#15994925)
Hey Millennials, welcome to adulthood. Every generation has its hardships and every generation complains that they have it worse than everyone before them. Sure, you have a lot of self imposed student loan debt and you can't afford to buy a house in the most desirable locations in the world. But imagine being forced into actually shooting people for a cause you viscerally disagree with? Here's a news flash - big business, big government, and big money have always ruled the world and always will because of greedy human nature. Should you continue to rally against inequities and fight for what you believe is right? Absolutely, just try not to be so damn whiny and self righteous about it.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by dang on Saturday December 23, 2017 @06:00PM (#15996778)
This comment breaks the site guidelines. Flamewars and name-calling aren't welcome here; doubly so for something so pointlessly divisive and substanceless as generational flamewars. Please keep this stuff off HN.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by joejerryronnie on Saturday December 23, 2017 @09:19PM (#15997517)
Maybe needlessly snarky but I didn't call anyone names or say anything that isn't a widely held perception by many people. I was responding to someone who brought up the generational issue in a particularly militant manner, not starting a flamewar.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by dang on Sunday December 24, 2017 @02:28AM (#15998462)
By 'name-calling' I mean stuff like "so damn whiny and self righteous". That isn't calling anyone in particular names, but it counts as the same thing for HN purposes, since it adds indignation rather than information.

Generational flamewars are among the least substantive flamewars of all and they're particularly easy to avoid, so let's just all not go there.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by joejerryronnie on Sunday December 24, 2017 @04:47PM (#16001454)
Fair enough.

It does feel like people can say all sorts of disparaging things about the generations that came before millennials without any consequences on HN. I understand millennials are probably the largest contingent of HN users but I would just ask that the rules be applied equally across the board.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:00PM (#15994996)
What is this? What are you doing here? Millennials got "whiny" and "self-righteous" because we're actively under attack. The problem we have is not that we have struggles, every generation has had struggles; the problem is that the response to our attempts to rectify this situation is exactly the kind of derision you're showing here. You're essentially doing the same thing as calling a 1960s civil rights activist "uppity". You're even agreeing with the existence of the issues I'm raising and the need to speak out but feel some emotional need to respond to my perceived tone with an attack on a baseless stereotype.

Why is the response to the statement "millennials have problems" so commonly angry and defensive?

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by malvosenior on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:10PM (#15995051)
> Why is the response to the statement "millennials have problems" so commonly angry and defensive?

I can’t speak for the person you’re asking, but I think the answer to this question is that the proposed answer to “millennials have problems” is often: more regulation and government involvement. Some people feel very strongly that this is the wrong move and it will directly impact them.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:23PM (#15995109)
Many of millennials' problems specifically stem from a lack of government regulation. They're locked into temp jobs and self-employment because they reached adulthood in a recession driven by financial deregulation. They face massive invasions of privacy and personal autonomy as a result of lacking sufficient regulations on the usage of their personal data. They face brutally unfair treatment at the hands of tech companies giving them temp work (like Uber and Instacart) without regulations on their treatment of workers (which, by the way, artificially inflate the jobs numbers: no one thinks uber driver is a career, it is a way to be able to eat). And now we face an end to an open internet (one of the few ways to reliably start a small business) because of a lack of FCC regulation.

Libertarians need to wrap their heads around the fact that sometimes regulations are deeply necessary.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by Helloworldboy on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:14PM (#15995410)
What the fuck are you talking about? Have you looked at the markets recently? What recession?

I’m a millennial and i don’t feel like I was affected by the recession in the slightest. No millennial is locked into self employment, unemployment is at like 4.5%, the job market is doing fantastic. All this doom and gloom and “poor me” is fucking ridiculous.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:53PM (#15995604)
94% of the net job growth in the last decade has been "alternative" work (temp jobs, contractors, self-employed).

https://qz.com/851066/almost-all-the-10-million-jobs-created...

Wages are stagnant, so even with a booming stock market your average worker is seeing none of it:

https://hbr.org/2017/10/why-wages-arent-growing-in-america

Just because you're doing well does not mean anyone else is doing well. You are a sample size of one.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by dang on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:25PM (#15996095)
From this, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15993012, and many other uncivil/unsubstantive comments, it seems clear that you don't want to use the site as intended, so I've banned this account. If you don't want to be banned on HN, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by EdSharkey on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:10PM (#15995390)
In the abstract, your opinion sounds reasonable, even righteous. Unfortunately, there's just too many actual, concrete examples of regulation locking vulnerable individuals out of markets, of property being unjustly seized/devalued, etc.

Calling out libertarians isn't constructive when they're simply reacting in their own way to wrong-sized government. They dont respond to corrupt, shitty leadership with muddled "at least they meant well" excuses.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:46PM (#15995568)
But this is somehow the state of the discourse right now! It's laid out purely in extremes. People aren't even entertaining what ought to be the obvious conclusion given the data: there are good and bad regulations. The existence of bad regulations does not wipe out the existence of good regulations, and vice versa. Instead when I suggest that there are beneficial regulations we can put in place that would benefit a large portion of Americans, people get defensive about it! This doesn't preclude the notion that regulations can be done poorly, and that some regulations are even actively harmful. But when making arguments people rarely want to consider more than just the extreme positions.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by EdSharkey on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:40PM (#15996663)
Right, and there's truth in what you say - especially wrt extremism. Your argument brings to mind the argument that "capitalism isn't the problem, crony capitalism is". Like, if only powerful people wouldn't lie, cheat, steal and write the rules to apply differently for them.

I will concede that, on a limited basis, government - specifically in the regulatory (and law enforcement) capacity - can do some good.

I'm more pessimistic than you though and believe that the vast majority of new laws are not written for my benefit, and most of the time we - the society as a whole - would be better off without more rules. It's not about my trusting my fellow citizen more than the ruling class, my position is about my distrust of and opposition to busybodies and cronies.

If you believe - for whatever reasons - that laws are not written nor enforced for your benefit, then maybe libertarianism isn't the worst thing. And that's all I was driving at.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by joejerryronnie on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:59PM (#15995639)
>Why is the response to the statement "millennials have problems" so commonly angry and defensive?

Because many millennials want to have their cake and eat it too. You can't have it both ways:

- You can't choose to attend an $80,000 per year private liberal arts school and then complain you have too much student debt

- You can't move to the most expensive place in the country with no money and a low paying job and then complain it's too expensive

- You can't regularly use convenient and artificially cheap gig-economy services (like Uber and Instacart) and then complain when their business model doesn't support giving you a $150,000 a year job

- You can't demand free speech protection and then violently oppress viewpoints you disagree with (for the record, I am a political moderate)

The Millennial hypocrisy is astounding, but I'm sure every generation goes through this to some extent. The real generational moment of revelation is when you realize that every choice you make has consequences - and not just the choices/consequences you choose to believe. If I buy a cheap toy at Walmart, I know that some labor exploitation was involved. If I buy fruit at Costco, I know that burning of fossil fuels is involved. If I choose to use Google services, my data will be exploited for profit.

What everyone is asking Millennials to do is take some responsibility, acknowledge that your actions are part of the problem, and that you have some power to drive solutions. It's fine to lament about some level of inequity handed down from previous generations, we have all done it. What everyone is getting a little tired of is the classic Millennial argument that paints an entire generation as helpless victims and essentially says "You did this to us and now we want you to make the bad man go away!" Kind of like an entire generation of Robin Arryns for all you Game of Thrones fans.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by TheAdamAndChe on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:22PM (#15995752)
> You can't choose to attend an $80,000 per year private liberal arts school and then complain you have too much student debt

1. This assumes that everyone went to a private liberal arts college, which isn't true. 2. Historically a degree wasn't as necessary because employers actually provided growth potential and entry-level positions to people. Those aren't options for millennials. That kind of forces people to get degrees to have any chance of economic growth.

> You can't move to the most expensive place in the country with no money and a low paying job and then complain it's too expensive

If those are the only regions of the country experiencing economic growth, then what else are they supposed to do? Work in Dollar General in a city of 12,000 people their whole life?

> You can't regularly use convenient and artificially cheap gig-economy services (like Uber and Instacart) and then complain when their business model doesn't support giving you a $150,000 a year job

People will always use the cheapest or most efficient option when it comes to purchasing services or items. It's not their fault that such services are legal, it's the government's.

> You can't demand free speech protection and then violently oppress viewpoints you disagree with.

I agree with you here. The internet has made it so that those who complain the most are perceived to be the majority when they're not.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by wott on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:06PM (#15996516)
> what else are they supposed to do? Work in Dollar General in a city of 12,000 people their whole life?

And here we go... it did not take long. Why on Earth would living in a 12000 inhabitant city be infamous, be a failure, be a shame? Not fancy and shiny enough for you, eh?

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by wfo on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:04PM (#15995981)
Millenials aren't whiny, they are angry. They have been screwed and want revenge. They correctly asses that boomers climbed up the ladder then burned it to the ground. They took cheap publicly subsidized education then massively defunded it. They benefited from regulated financial markets then gifted them to oligarchs. They took pensions then ensured no one would ever get one again. They destroyed unions and therefore the middle class. They destroyed the environment for their own personal profit. They took all the benefits of the new deal, and the moment it looked like those benefits would start helping the new generation they stripped them away. The boomers will go down as the most selfish and short sighted generation in US history.

And millenials are very tired of these people who have had it so easy and worked to make it so much worse for their children, talking about "personal responsibility" and "participation trophies".

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by malvosenior on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:13PM (#15996034)
No one had it easy. Millennials have a much better life all things considered. You can’t get drafted to go die in a war, you brush off 70s stagflation like it was a non-event. Rascism is much less prevalent.

It’s precisely this ease of living that is part of the problem. Why not rack up tens of thousands of college debt to get a useless degree when you’re historically more privileged than 99% of people that have ever lived?

Reality is harsh and that seems to have escaped many millennials.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by Apocryphon on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:18PM (#15996302)
> Reality is harsh and that seems to have escaped many millennials.

I think part of the disillusionment was having grown up in the prosperous, peaceful '90s, that Boomers hyped up as the End of History. And then the western world became immersed in a seeming unending war, with the security state overreach accordingly, and then the bottom fell out of the economy after. Can you blame them for being pissed off that the promises of their childhood were a lie? At least previous generations that dealt with hardships were not lied to first.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by malvosenior on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:23PM (#15996319)
I agree with your analysis and think we're very close to talking about the same thing. The difference between gen-x and millennials is that boomers told both groups the same lies, it's just that gen-x didn't believe them. Gen-x cynicism is a real thing.

We're back to my original point of millennials not being close enough to boomers to know that they were lying (or ill informed).

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by Apocryphon on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:26PM (#15996332)
Gen X grew up during the Cold War, Reaganism, Thatcherism, Wall Street malfeasance, AIDS, the crack epidemic. This is a little biased generalization of the '80s, but I think overall you could say the '90s were much more hopeful and sunnier in comparison. It was easier to believe in lies back then. Could you blame them for believing in their helicopter parents with their self-esteem culture and dot-com money?
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by malvosenior on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:33PM (#15996360)
I blame them for not realizing their error and instead calling for state regulation and intervention. They'd probably get more support from gen x if they were listening to them instead of attacking their ideals (speaking in very broad generalities at this point).
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by Apocryphon on Sunday December 24, 2017 @05:50AM (#15998991)
Are Gen X's really a bunch of Yuppies who are against regulation? Even after everything that Reagan, Thatcher, and the Chicago Boys have done?
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by watwut on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:21PM (#15996315)
I like how you simultaneously blame them for spending too much money and for using cheap services too. And also blame them for relocating to place where the jobs are supposed to be.

I also like how everyone blames Millennials for lack of responsibility and then complains about them doing responsible choices - be it living cheap, postponing having children, having sex later and not dating enough, going less to restaurants, being overly focused on grades ... all real complains I have seen last weeks.

There is nothing hypocritical about demanding low wage workers protections, higher taxes for richer segments population, healthcare reform and the same social services other western countries have. You may disagree with those policies, but buying cheap toys at Walmart is in no way opposition to them.

Uber being artificially cheap is not Millenials doing.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:38PM (#15995855)
The problem here is that you are applying all the worst examples of a group to the majority of the group. None of these things are widely representative of the actual population of people we're talking about. They're just the things that make you angriest.

The other problem is that plenty of people (millennial or otherwise) are trying to fix the systemic problems, and others are actively moving to oppose us. It's like there's a house on fire, and I run to the neighbors and am like "help! this house is on fire!" and the neighbors respond with "stop crying and put it out yourself you hippie". It's not even my house! And the neighbors are too busy getting angry at the gall of me for asking for help putting out this house to realize that the fire's starting to spread to their house too.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by joejerryronnie on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:43PM (#15996172)
Here is the perception of non-millennials:

It's like you running to the neighbors and saying "Help, this house in on fire! And you started it by having that bbq two weeks ago. I'm sure the natural gas you used, in addition to ravaging the environment, was somehow at fault. By the way, you really should be eating this new meatless meat that's all the rage. Oh yeah, and while you're busy putting out that fire, I'm gonna hang out with my buddies drinking kale shakes and eating avo toast. Let me know when everything is all good again and I'll slip into that newly remodeled loft."

Clearly (and supported by the comment threads here) there is a wide gap between millennial and non-millennial perception of the existing problems and the proper solutions. You should do what us Gen-Xers did, figure out how to play the game to get what you want and work on solutions to the most important issues. Pick your battles - raging about every single issue and injustice desensitizes the rest of us to the real troubles you are having.

Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by Apocryphon on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:19PM (#15996305)
Somehow you have confused an entire generation with the conservative stereotype of latte-sipping limousine liberals.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by aalleavitch on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:42PM (#15996409)
And therein lies the problem. The entire premise is based on a politicized stereotype that has been forced down the public's throats specifically because it's emotionally resonant regardless of accuracy. It's literally just a list of "things I use to differentiate myself from another group of people that makes me feel insecure".
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by kevinh on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:52PM (#15995601)
Congratulations on managing to be whiny and self-righteous while complaining about an entire generation of people being whiny and self-righteous.
Re:The Californian Ideology (1995) by dang on Saturday December 23, 2017 @06:01PM (#15996782)
Please don't respond to a bad comment by making this place worse yourself. That's also against the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

Instead, as the guidelines say, you should flag egregious comments. For how to do that, see https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html. Or you can email us and we'll take a look.