This is the crux of the issue. The Linux ecosystem philosophy is rooted in choice. Normal users don't want and/or need that much choice.
Average Joe doesn't care what an operating system stands for, or how involved the developer community is, or how customization a system is. They need a spreadsheet/internet browser/email machine that can run some misc. business software, but most importantly they need something that just works.
For all of the benefits of using Linux, the one thing it has never nailed down is intuitiveness. Say what you want about the (many) flaws of Windows, but you can't deny that one of the easiest out-of-the-box-this-thing-just-works experiences. It's also the same experience every single time you use a Windows machine.
Try explaining the difference between Arch, Ubunutu, and Debian to a normal consumer and their eyes glaze over before you even begin.
Recently I helped a small company migrate their PCs from Windows 7 to Windows 10. Trust me, it is not the same experience at all for the end users. They (the users) will get used to the new interface and way of interacting with the OS not because it is more intuitive but because they will use it and gain experience with it.
Going from Windows 7 -> 10 is like going from English to Scottish. The grammar is mostly the same but a lot of the words and phrases are different.
Microsoft sabotaged their main platform. It would have a major opportunity for other OS.
-
https://www.theverge.com/2017/3/17/14956540/microsoft-window...
It's been a few releases since I used fedora, but I don't recall ever seeing any kind of ads in the apps menu... and the vast majority of linux distros don't have any of that kind of garbage
No need to take it. That's why ubuntu is a popular choice.
> Say what you want about the (many) flaws of Windows, but you can't deny that one of the easiest out-of-the-box-this-thing-just-works experiences.
Except when it doesn't install the right drivers(compared to distros like manjaro) and when you get a crappy browser by default or when the menu just crashes or fails to find what is certainly there. Or when you need to suspend your work because it's Update Time Like it or Not™. It's definitely not the best out-of-the-box experience, but the one which is the most advertized with the most misc software.
> Try explaining the difference between Arch, Ubunutu, and Debian to a normal consumer and their eyes glaze over before you even begin.
That's not true. Their main differences are how they handle software releases, install/update software and how you install them. If you're not a complete digital analphabet you'll understand such easy concepts.
I stopped rooting for Ubuntu to win the casual user, when they moved the caption buttons from right to left, and deliberately didn't provide an option in the UI to turn it back.
You may think it's trivial, but it showed attitude that was, in my opinion, totally user hostile. Even Microsoft wouldn't go that far.
Have you ever tried to debug a wi-fi issue? I had a Windows box that completely refused to connect to my home wi-fi. We never figured that out and corporate had to issue a new laptop for my wife to work from home. The second one worked. Nobody ever figured out what the problem with the first one was.
Really good point. In my "last mile" comment I failed to address these success stories, but the two points are pretty complementary. MacOS abandoned Linux entirely. Android abandoned most of it - kept a lot of the system bits but threw away practically all of the bits a user (or even a typical developer) would see. ChromeOS is the closest to a real Linux desktop, and even it's changed quite a bit. I have a second-gen Chromebook Pixel laptop and I love the fact that I can use it both as a turnkey web-browsing appliance and as a real Linux development machine simultaneously (via crouton). But that only happened because Google invested millions in crossing that "last mile" for their own users. Many millions if you include all the money they've poured into Chrome and Google Docs and other things without which Chromebooks wouldn't be usable for most people.
I guess I should amend my point to say that native app based desktop Linux will always succumb to the last-mile problem. The very freedom that lets anyone develop whatever they want also means there will be regression to the mean when it comes to quality - and the mean just isn't good enough. Someone has to pay to raise that standard, and anyone who's paying won't pay for random half-finished crap. An integrated, polished system is the only kind of desktop the market will support.
Graphical workstations, where the development environment was the genesis of modern IDEs, and the CLI was a REPL integrated with a live debugger, into the whole OS.
Think Smalltalk, Lisp Machines, Alto with its Star OS and XDE developers environment.
To actually provide better links I need my notes, but can leave you with the computer museum one.
http://www.computerhistory.org/revolution/input-output/14/34...
The above mentioned Unix interfaces were successful not because they dropped X or started fresh but because they were promoted by huge companies with big budgets that could afford to impose on what hardware you run the modified GUI.
That's a feature all three nail. apt-get is great, so it's not a hardware problem, but I have yet to come across a GUI that is at all consistent.
Are you referring to GUI frontends for distro package managers [0]? The CLI equivalents are as close to never failing as they can get on the distros I use (~0.1% of upgrades require manually editing or merging a new config file, or something of that nature). I wish Windows was that reliable in installing/updating applications.
[0] As an aside, I dont see any real user-demand for these. They seem about as desirable about the macOS store or the Microsoft Store -- just about no one wants or uses them. Trying to shoehorn in smartphone style features into desktop OS' generally hasnt been done well, or received well.
I've been using Linux for over 10 years at home, but man, all those issues, it's crazy. And every forum has the same answer to all your problems: just enter sudo... into your console.
For me as a more experienced user this might not be a problem (although I'm getting tired of it) but for normal users this doesn't work at al.
They see a GUI so they want to fix things via the GUI. And ofcourse they don't want to fix things at all.
I have my reasons to stay at Linux but it's no fun that sometimes sleep doesn't work, every update Cuda support is broken and so on.
Many programmers seem to forget other programmers are users too.
Just because I am a programmer doesn't mean I have to endure software that thinks a PDP-11 coupled with twm experience is the climax of UI/UX.
Also he doesn't mention any MS progress in software and moving from dark side to the good in the last decade.
I mean I am not one to bash Microsoft out of principle, but this is easy to understand - people choose Windows because that's what everyone is already familiar with.
The battle over the desktop space is over, and for the same reason Microsoft couldn't gain any traction in the mobile segment.
An example anecdote: we gave our technophobic MD a desktop that had been used by a previous sysadmin add a temporary machine while he was waiting for a new Windows one. It was running Maté on Mint. He never noticed it wasn't Windows.
The reason the Linux Desktop hasn't happened is multifaceted (as you contend) but by far the biggest factor is OEMs. Normal users don't know/care what an OS is, so they're certainly not going to install one.
If you're contending that usability is a factor, look at Windows 8.0 or early Androids. There was plenty of complaints about both, mostly valid imo, but they still got a lot more new users than traditional Linuxes. Because people don't download OSes, they buy devices. And if they get stuck with one that's less than usable, they just stay stuck, and maybe get a relative to help. They don't switch.
All the reasons you listed are valid and true criticisms, but the above makes them moot.
The idea that fixing X Windows' complexities or unifying the community on a focused UI/UX vision will popularise the Linux Desktop is hopelessly naïve. You won't get far without a device manufacturing operation and billions of dollars.
2 - X is not a UI API, Qt and GTK+ are. You're thinking about the graphics server which's not any better on windows(better isolation, maybe?).
3. Why is choice a bad thing? Even if fragmentation is a drawback it's not an important one.
4. Singular UI vision is the worst - just look at how clunky are all windows UIs. They're needlessly complex and uncustomizable. They also assume that their users are stupid but they aren't. I like nice and user-friendly UIs like KDE and cinnamon and clever UIs like i3 and awesomewm. I've installed linux for many non-techie users and they quickly learned how to use their desktops - and for my surprise they started to prefer using the terminal over the software center.
5. Not sure how windows is better there. Maybe you got used to it.
6. There IS accessibility support but not perfect.
Please, go on. But in the reality the actual reasons are these:
1. Regular users(or people in general) don't like change.
2. Missing apps: adobe suite, ms office, specialized apps(at schools and offices) and the most hyped games.
3. ms has far better marketing and makes deals with governments, schools, universities and hardware vendors/sellers.
- Needlessly complex UI APIs (e.g. X Window System)
- Fragmentation
- Lack of a singular UI vision
- Bad UI design, bad UX
- Lack of accessibility support
- Complex interfaces designed for 1% of users
I could go on...
The only successful UNIX interfaces dropped X Window, dropped most of the community's ideas and APIs, and started afresh. Look at Quartz (Apple), ChromeOS (Google), and Android (Google). They're much simpler at every layer, have a singular vision, and designed for normal users rather than by programmers for programmers.
But no doubt this thread will somehow find a way to blame Microsoft as is the tired song of the Linux community.