It's funny, because we already have a "government-backed currency" but we prefer to bail-out the banks instead of bailing-out individual in distress... I mean: it's not a problem of technology, it's the lack of political will. Crypto-currencies are not different from any other type of currency in this respect. I don't see why they are better fitted to implement a Universal Basic Income. I perhaps see reasons why they are worse than actual money (technological divide, lack of acceptance in shops, difficult to understand).
What, exactly, does “bailing out individuals in distress” comprise?
The main reason not to do this is because that would usually mean severe distress for many employers whose working capital would be lost and day-to-day business disrupted, possibly (especially during an economic downturn) bankrupting them; causing a ripple throughout the economy as a major bank going down takes down also many unrelated companies, their employees, their suppliers, etc, and possibly toppling the next weaker bank(s) as well.
Cryptos are good for reasons other than whatever macroeconomic theory is built into bitcoin. They're digital. That's useful. The digital economy needs better ways of moving around money. At present, if you want to run a digital "market" where money goes in and out it must be "thick". Chargebacks, fraud & transaction costs will add up to 5%. That means thin or fast are not options. For thin and/or fast (eg online securities trading or currencies), they need to already have all your money or trust that you'll pay. That's why you need an account with a brokerage. In other words, there is no digital cash.
How do you build a patreon without a "man-in-the-middle?" Can Estcoin do it? How do you trade currencies without some random institution holding your money. How do you do micropayments.
I think we need a separate bitcoin for building stuff on, away from the crazy currency trading. Government backed seems like a good way to go. I'd even recommend a central bank, just call it something less scary.
Edit: I don't get the downvotes. If people like the bitcoin "macroeconomic theory," that's great. You have bitcoin. Why can't we have 2?
There was a period of relative calm between the instantiation of post-1929-crash banking regulations and the repeal of Glass-Steagall (Gramm-Leach-Bliley) and the deregulation of derivatives (CFMA) in the late 90's/early 2000's. Perhaps finance is better understood than is recognized.
The truth is that crashes are cyclical... for reasons that are poorly understood. There are probably ways to manipulate cycles, but eventually human psychology takes over and people start acting irrationally en masse. What we can do, I think, is focus on how we respond to down turns.
[0] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2008/oct/24/economics-c...
Sensible regulation will buy us a lot, but you can't prevent people from doing big stupid things forever.
What period was that, exactly?
When 10,000 people get their salaries in it, then we can talk about EU-level issues. Meanwhile, let em play.
I'm generally pro-eurozone and I have no problems with this. If they figure something good out, they can share with the rest of us. Ideas like this are not going to come out of Brussels.
Go Estonia!
An extremely poor country outside Tallin (according to a single documentary I've watched), they went tech to try to thrive as a country.
Takes some balls, it's either that or tax heaven (which is something I think _my_ country--Italy--should do), they went the hardcore route.
> However, crypto tokens have far more significance than their > use as a currency and don’t necessarily fall into that category. >From Estonia’s perspective, estcoins were proposed as a way to raise money and support for the development of our digital nation from more people around the world. We would also want to structure the tokens so that they help build our e-resident community and incentivise our own key objective, which is to increase the number of companies started in Estonia through e-Residency.
Don't just take the things you want to hear out of context from the original meaning. Founding more Start Ups in Estonia is a valid use case. It's also a way to fight poverty.
OP argues that Estonia is a member of the EU, and is therefore bound to use the Euro and only the Euro as its national currency. It seems a bit sneaky and underhanded then to launch this cryptoCURRENCY as a "token" rather than a currency.
As someone mentioned further down, estonia probably won't make estcoin a legal tender (can't be forced to accept estcoin to settle all debts in court or pay taxes), avoiding the issue of competing directly with the euro while still allowing the government to play with this new tech.
Just a nitpick, this statement isn't quite true.
>Nine countries (Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Hungary, Poland, Romania, Sweden, and the United Kingdom) are EU members but do not use the euro. [1]
The term you are looking for is the Eurozone rather than the EU.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurozone#Future_enlargement
I won't provide a separate source for this statement since it's the same as yours, just a few sentences further down.
But ultimately denominated in Euros, right? Otherwise this is just "yet another crypto currency".
I'm pretty sure the country wouldn't be allowed otherwise, to set up a parallel economy with its own exchequer besides the ECB?
Why is it ridiculous for a small EU nation to pay lip service to EU regulations with regard to this financial experiment? What would be a better way to do what they're doing?
They admit in the article that it’s a solution looking for a problem, which is a good strategy for creating problems for no reason.
That being said, if a token has a central issuer, there’s no need to use any form of blockchain technology — digital signatures alone will suffice (add Chaumian blinding to make it more cash-like).
TIL of Chaumian e-cash and blind signatures.
[0] Chaumian e-cash:
https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/9544/how-does-ch...
[1] Blind signature:
Every EUR the government hands you (in EU not by a check, that's stone age, but on your account) is directly, immediately covered from their reserves (usually within 'their' central bank, who also can't issue new euros) or borrowed from someone, possibly the ECB.
My opinion how digital money should be used for debt-free tax-free money to pay e.g. a UBI: http://lustysociety.org/umi.html
It stems from you wanting everyone to use the website the way you want them to instead of the way they want to. In the example instance the powers that Be have explicitly stated it’s okay but as far as i know have not commented on the behavior in question.
You can check my comment history to see i never post links but I also have no issue with the behavior. The person has put a lot of effort (compared to a forum post) discussing their take on a topic and decided it’d relevant and of interest to the discussion at hand.
If you don’t want to digest information that way it’s easy to ignore it and engage only on site commenters. For those of us who like in depth analysis that can’t be conveyed in a short forum discussion will click through and continue the discussion after.
I enjoy reading through linked blog posts (both in the submissions and comments) but as I commented elsewhere in this thread its the laziness of not engaging at all and simply throwing out a link to your personal blog that bothers me. I may very well be in the minority.
If you had visited the web page you would know that the content was quite long for a comment and the formatting would disappear.
If you were an academic or a regular internet user, you would know about the virtue of references.
You are free to discuss the topic.
At least I know why I was downvoted instead of getting a sensible reply. Thanks for that explanation.
You do realize that Estonia, just like any other EU country, is part of the leglisative body that creates those rules and regulations?
"Democracy is the idea that the people know what they want and deserve to get it good and hard."
(Also, like a sibling wrote, being part of a decision process doesn't mean that you ultimately agree with all majority decisions, but whatever.)
Also in the context of present-day Europe, with a lot of successful extreme right eurosceptic parties, the term "oppression" associated to Europe rules is a lot more politically loaded. A bit like "Democrat" in the US does not simply mean someone that likes democracy.
One of them is not even tradeable and another would be pegged to Euro. The third one (community estcoin) is more like your typical token but even then, I would be quite surprised if EU would actually put the brakes on the ICO.
For example, instead of mining, what if only Estonia could generate estcoin? What if Estonia only sold them via Euro, and promised to pay Euro on a 1:1 basis to anyone who sold them back to Estonia?
Many people [...] wondered if the whole thing was nothing
more than a marketing stunt for the e-Residency programme.
I don't think I've ever read an opinion of Estonian E-Residency from an independent party (ie, someone who wasn't involved in it, promoting it every chance they get) that didn't write it off as hype. This article looks like just more of the same.Can any Europeans here chime in with their perspective?
The Brutish government is currently getting raked over the coals in negotiations, which serves as an almost daily reminder of the EU's value for member states. Escaping the terrible oppression that is the European Court of Justice, which I just now failed to find any controversial judgement for, appears to be acceptable after all, if it allows your airlines, banks, and software companies to freely do business in the world's largest economic area. Who woulda thunk?
Brexit has also had a unifying influence on the rest of the EU: Surveys show trust in the EU at a 10-year high. Almost more importantly, trust in the EU has for 20+ years been higher than trust in the respective national governments and parliaments. See http://ec.europa.eu/commfrontoffice/publicopinion/index.cfm/... (page 15).
With the elections in France, the Netherlands, the UK, and Germany, anti-EU populism has arguably shown to have passed its peak–a President Trump actually being rather helpful in this regard, thx.
It is an interesting play with words but of course the European policy makers would have to have the last say, and of course it would have to abide by European regulations. As long as it does, how could they possibly have a problem with it?
The EU is shifting. Not everyone loves todays German-ruled course of things (I'm German). This is especially true for the corridor between Baltic Sea and say Austria. These countries - Estonia as a very small one, in particular - have still to take care in how they express themselves in regard to sensible topics. Don't confuse this with non-dedication.
It's only as a matter of course that in any economic union such a force would have significant heft.
Anyone that isn't happy with that can and should improve their export game.
But, you simply can't argue with German productivity! Or the general quality of the goods they produce, and when it comes to getting good value groceries around Europe again it's the German supermarkets that are leading the way.
There is a problem to solve with regards to how German economic activity is balanced with the social needs of the European area. My personal bug bear is how the peripheral nations are expected to foot the bill of maintaining the periphery themselves, while Germany sits cosily in the centre printing Euros for herself.
But at the foot of Germany's success is doubtless her ability to manage her economy better than most, investment in education and to her fostering and nurturing of talent both home grown and from abroad.
It's fascinating to see how that is sold to the population, in the middle of an export boom, and very low inflation.
By producing cheap copies of established branded goods?
No I just think that it's all down to the fact that they're better at business.
The weakest of these German chains is in my opinion Lidl, but I'd prefer to go there than the Tesco I have around the corner any day!
The weakest of these German chains is in my opinion Lidl, but I'd prefer to go there than the Tesco I have around the corner any day!'
I agree the German supermarkets seem to have better management, that which is visible at shop floor level anyway, for sure.
I don't like Aldi and Lidl because the checkout process is so rushed and chaotic. Obviously, some people don't mind and see it as a fair trade-off?
I don't like rushed for the weekend food shopping. Monday - Friday 12 o'clock shopping needs to be rushed though and since you don't have much, I prefer Aldi before REWE. Especially because it's cheaper too.
World = US empire
Some highly generalized social group = perceived leader of previously mentioned social group.
> Estonia’s only currency is the euro and this is an essential feature of our EU membership, which we are proud to have. No one here is interested in changing that.
OK, great. Next sentence:
> That’s why we have always referred to estcoin as a proposed ‘crypto token’.
(top highlight!) Wow, clever! It's not a currency! Oppressive EU regulations (that we agree with and are not interested in changing) have been obeyed. Next sentence:
> Governments do need to consider the disruptive impact of how crypto tokens can be used as currency
Hahaha. Sorry, but this "we're launching a currency that we don't call a currency but that everybody, including us, knows is meant to be a currency <wink>" is ridiculous.
All that said, I think issuing some sort of government-backed currency might be one way of experimenting with implementing a universal basic income, in order to combat poverty among your citizens. But I don't see that discussed in the article.