News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by cm2012 on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:13AM (#15879682)
One thing that can take a while to remember, if you've generally ran with the "gifted" crowd in school (Read: top 10% reading comprehension scores on the SAT), is that most people are just uncomfortable reading, it takes them a lot of time, and they don't like doing it. It's almost always a good idea to shorten/simplify any text meant for an unknown audience.
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by norswap on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:33AM (#15879875)
I was top 1% in school and I still dislike reading, because very often, it's unnecessary verbiage.

As a senior PhD student, the advice I give my younger peers and master students regarding academic posters: you should be able to read it from across the room, or printing in A4 and held at arms' length. Most posters are horribly over-cramed.

I see the same things in academic papers. The length is limited, but many people find a way around by including tons for mathematic, which is much denser. When I take the pain to go through it, I usually find all this math to be unnecessary (but it does give the paper the halo of serious research).

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by Balgair on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:54AM (#15880033)
I agree! To combat this 'jargonification' and make ourselves better writers, some of the PhD and MS students at my alma mater decided to make a journal club for well written papers. Not papers that were good science, but just well written and easy to understand (in our field). We would submit papers and then go over them at lunch once a week. We found:

1) The appropriate metric for 'well written' is that you can read the whole thing aloud and understand the findings in the time it takes a person to eat a sandwich, a bag of chips, and drink a medium coffee. About 75 minutes. Anything more may be 'read' but not understood and anything less means you should have done more work.

2) Everyone loves jargon. The more obscure words the better. The more complicated and obfuscated, the better. I find that I want to grok the research. Most of my compatriots do not want to do that. However, we all think the same thing about everyone else. More complicated papers result in a 'treasure hunt' mentality that many researchers actually enjoy, it seems. The journal club evolved into a 'tennis game' of sorts where the submitter would lord over the others about their knowledge of the paper. i don't want to generalize too much, but I think this behavior of 'one-up-man-ship' and 'I-know-more-than-yoooou-dooo' is core to academia.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by miranda_rights on Friday December 08, 2017 @01:17PM (#15880642)
Your journal club sounds cool. Is there a list somewhere of the past papers you read?
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by Balgair on Friday December 08, 2017 @01:38PM (#15880792)
We had a dropbox, but that was only used by me. Mostly we just sent out emails to each other in a giant list. Sorry! >o
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by bluGill on Friday December 08, 2017 @12:52PM (#15880471)
That is you.

Some personalities like long explanations, some do not.

Beware that your personality will often miss important details that would be in the verbiage.

Those or like reading often waste too much time reading unnecessary details.

There are pros and cons of both.

(I hope I wrote that in the style you would like to read)

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by norswap on Friday December 08, 2017 @02:30PM (#15881276)
I'm not sure. Unlike the impression I might have given, I'm actually someone that puts a lot of stock in nuance and dislike simplifications that turn away from the truth.

But when you are communicating, it is common sense to make sure the important points come across, then only dive into the details. Unfortunately that is not always something you are incentivized to do in academic research, where fumigation is the norm.

I'd also point out that one can be terse and uninformative as well - point in case: most public Git repositories out there.

I enjoy reading, and will often read long pieces -- albeit I would wish they were terser, because often they could be, with no loss of precision.

I have also never met anyone that, even though they like to read like I do, would take pleasure in reading something that drones unnecessarily. When communicating, that is -- plenty of people enjoy the mini-novels put out by Slate, the New Yorker, ... (and me too, sometimes).

I have taken to the habit to summarizing the things I read on my blog. These summaries are of course less informative than the source, but the signal-to-noise ratio is much higher.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by whatshisface on Friday December 08, 2017 @01:25PM (#15880706)
Even if you enjoy it, you're still limited by human capabilities: I've seen so many slides that were laden with dense technical information that essentially nobody could get through in the time before the presenter hit "next slide," and I've made some, too. Your goal will not let you say less than necessary; so I say you should always cut every word whose absence won't defeat you. A second is a valuable thing, and you're either writing poetry or working where the second is a unit of cost. (In the extreme, if your goal doesn't require you to write or say anything, then why get words involved at all?)
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by bluGill on Friday December 08, 2017 @02:13PM (#15881106)
Somehow we have switch to slides/powerpoint from a more generic discussion on reading styles.

When doing a presentation there are other considerations/rules.

Those rules do not apply to the more generic discussion.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by gowld on Friday December 08, 2017 @01:41PM (#15880817)
Papers are wonderful.

Posters are wonderful.

Papers aren't Posters.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by leggomylibro on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:59AM (#15880076)
Elements of Style is very good. It can be a little prescriptive, but it's only 50-odd pages long and surprisingly fun to read.
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by eropple on Friday December 08, 2017 @01:35PM (#15880767)
Strunk and White are prescriptive, but at the same time the book acknowledges that mastery, and its use for effect, can replace the ideas that they generally prescribe.

> It is an old observation that the best writers sometimes disregard the rules of rhetoric. When they do so, however, the reader will usually find in the sentence some compensating merit, attained at the cost of the violation. Unless he is certain of doing as well, he will probably do best to follow the rules.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by combatentropy on Friday December 08, 2017 @02:39PM (#15881348)
> mastery, and its use for effect, can replace the ideas that they generally prescribe

Is there any field for which this is not true?

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by eropple on Friday December 08, 2017 @03:24PM (#15881718)
If I was a master electrician, I'd still turn the mains off?
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by leggomylibro on Sunday December 10, 2017 @09:42PM (#15894787)
Nuclear physics.

Just ask Louis Slotin. Oh wait. You can't.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by eropple on Monday December 11, 2017 @04:34PM (#15900686)
FWIW, I chuckled--this was a good pull!
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by Cerium on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:48AM (#15879993)
A poster is only big so many people can see it at once. Otherwise it is no different than a single sheet executive summary.
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by matte_black on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:21AM (#15879768)
Generally, people say to shorten a text because the best way to write a great text is to take a good text and cut out anything that isn't great, not because the audience has poor reading skills.
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by pessimizer on Friday December 08, 2017 @01:49PM (#15880895)
> the best way to write a great text is to take a good text and cut out anything that isn't great

This is for entertainment or marketing purposes, though.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by epicide on Friday December 08, 2017 @05:31PM (#15882662)
Possibly, but the people reading resumes are still subject to boredom and short attention spans.
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by bloopernova on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:21AM (#15879769)
That's really difficult for me. I always end up writing novels for emails then wondering why people only answered the first question.

(and they missed out parts (b) and (c) of the question, plus they didn't read the linked web pages supporting my assertions)

Yes, I really need to cut back on how much I type there, but I have trouble communicating in person so text is just so much more comfortable for me. Any tips would be greatly appreciated.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by nkrisc on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:28AM (#15879819)
One thing I've done that has helped is after a single introductory sentence, list all my questions with numbered bullet points. Only put the actual question here. Any supporting info can be described in paragraphs below, numbered similarly. Aggressively edit your writing to remove all unnecessary words and information. You probably don't need 40% of the words you wrote.

If your question has multiple parts, break them into separate, sequential questions.

Lastly if the question is so complex that this doesn't work, and for whatever reason you can't talk to them in person, present them with what you believe the answer is and let them critique it. This won't always work for every scenario but it might be worth trying.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by chadgeidel on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:24AM (#15879793)
Some ideas I've had luck with: Have one actionable item per email. State a question in the subject. Expect a clear answer (not quite "yes/no" but something definite). Spend a short time (one or two paragraphs describing the question in detail, but don't make it longer than that.

End the email with the question in the subject asked again.

EDIT: If you find that you need to have a conversation, either walk over to their desk or pick up the phone.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by rootusrootus on Friday December 08, 2017 @12:02PM (#15880098)
Allow me to be cynical for a moment. A big reason why people only answer the first question is they want to skip the harder ones that follow and hope the conversation will go off on a tangent instead.

Yeah, that really depends on the content of the conversation, but I have seen that tactic used in so many situations (including non-email) that I assume it as the default reason. So I limit myself to one question per email.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by epicide on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:42AM (#15879954)
Don't feel the need to explain everything you mean.

Some people will understand what you mean with very little. Others likely won't understand regardless of how much explanation you provide.

Make everything that is critical super obvious. Bulleted questions is a great suggestion.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by cm2012 on Friday December 08, 2017 @02:55PM (#15881472)
> Some people will understand what you mean with very little. Others likely won't understand regardless of how much explanation you provide.

Super true

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by notyourwork on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:38AM (#15879926)
I had this problem as well and can offer you what has worked well for me: (Would love other's input.)

1. Place most important piece at the top. Answer the following question to your audience: What is the purpose of this email and how does it apply to me?

2. Bulleted or numbered lists are ideal for multiple questions/points. It visually divides, gives you ability to order most to least important and also allows someone an easy way to respond inline to each question.

3. Iterate on your first revision with goal of reducing length and maintaining intention. This takes practice and forces you to ask do I really need this line of text.

4. If you distribute to a large list, identify at the top the scope so those it doesn't apply to can discard.

5. If you are emailing a group and you need replies or action items for different people call this out. You can do this by calling each name out: @Joe - Can you help identify x? @Jane - Can you follow up with so and so? etc. This way their name is attached to it.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by moron4hire on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:27AM (#15879809)
I've found that leading people into a back and forth conversation where I can guide them through those same points, rather than try to get them all out at once, works better. Just go one at a time until you are sure they are on the same page.

I also try to eliminate parentheticals. Branching lines of thought are very difficult for most people.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by saganus on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:32AM (#15879869)
"Branching lines of thought are very difficult for most people."

This is something that I hadn't thought about but now that you mention it, it does seem to match what I've experienced.

Nice catch.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by cr0sh on Friday December 08, 2017 @01:42PM (#15880827)
> Branching lines of thought are very difficult for most people.

I haven't watched it, so this question might not be relevant - but how do you explain the popularity of shows like "Game of Thrones"?

From what I gather, it has several various plot lines woven over and around multiple episodes and seasons.

People also don't seem to have any problems deciphering the various "plot lines" within their own circles of family and friends (in my experience with people who seem to have waaaay too much drama in their lives).

Is there something about "video" that makes it easier to parse in this fashion than text? Does emotional attachment to characters in such dramas (or personal involvement) make it easier to understand intertwined plot lines?

Just musing on things here...hmm.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by cm2012 on Friday December 08, 2017 @02:13PM (#15881110)
Most people who watch GOT don't get all the plotlines. If you talk to regular showwatchers (not book), they regularly mistake Stannis for Tywin for Roose etc...They get enough of the gist to enjoy it.
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by moron4hire on Friday December 08, 2017 @03:46PM (#15881892)
I think most people enjoy GoT despite the story line. The content is otherwise quite gratuitous in the violence and sex departments, so it has a lot to offer to the most casual of observers without having a full grasp of the story line.
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by make3 on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:33AM (#15879873)
I would suggest you use chat platforms like slack instead of email. The flow of conversations is more obvious that way. You can then ask one question, and work parts b and c into normal interaction.

Once that's done, you can ask if they have the time to answer another question, and continue with the interaction.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by manyxcxi on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:52AM (#15880022)
- After you write the novel, break it up into bullet points

- Make each bullet point actionable/respondable

- Condense the bullet points/trim the fat

- Use sub-bullets as an aside or to provide narrative/opinion/background

Now people have essentially been informed up front that you expect X number of things for them to respond to and they’ll be less likely to miss the stuff in the middle.

You’ll also find that you’ll get the same information and intent across with your TL;DR bulletpoint summary, but in a way that doesn’t cause the reader to bail out.

It’ll also make it easier for them to respond because you’ve essentially given them references names for each point they’d respond to.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by dec0dedab0de on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:34AM (#15879885)
One thing that really bothers me in long emails is redundancy. Something like "Only one single widget is alone on the shelf" instead of "One widget is on the shelf."
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by zimpenfish on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:35AM (#15879891)
> "One widget is on the shelf."

Where are the rest of them then?

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by drewmol on Friday December 08, 2017 @12:14PM (#15880188)
The shelf contains one widget
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by Izkata on Friday December 08, 2017 @02:52PM (#15881446)
The ambiguity is whether the second widget is on the table, in use, or if it even exists.
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by combatentropy on Friday December 08, 2017 @02:52PM (#15881445)
1. Put yourself in the reader's shoes. Imagine getting your email in the midst of all the other emails they get, all the other things they're thinking about, all the other problems, in and out of work, that they might be dealing with.

2. Read The Elements of Style, by William Strunk and E. B. White (< 100 pages).

3. Read the first several chapters of On Writing Well, by William Zinnser (< 100 pages).

(Don't like reading? Oh :)

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by froindt on Friday December 08, 2017 @01:02PM (#15880544)
I've embraced my relative youth and tried @tagging someone in an email body one time...and was surprised to learn Outlook actually supports it.

I've since started tagging people in the body for specific items I need from them. Varying levels of success, if people are on the email and see themselves tagged in a specific part of the email, they know where to read carefully and what response I expect from them.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by grahamburger on Friday December 08, 2017 @03:40PM (#15881847)
I struggle with this too. Sometimes I will only ask the first question, let the recipient respond, and then ask the next question. It can give the interchange a more conversational feel and some people really prefer that.
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by fpisfun on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:53AM (#15880029)
Haha so true, to me, and I'm sure a lot of others here, reading comes very naturally, it's by far the easiest way for me to consume information. I hate watching tutorial videos, for example because I'd much rather read tutorial and speed through it at my in pace. As I've started trying to be more entrepreneurial I've had to realize not everyone is like this and take this into account when dealing with others.
Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by yawz on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:58AM (#15880070)
"I made this one [letter] longer only because I have not had the leisure to make it shorter."[1] - Blaise Pascal

The contemporary interpretation/translation of this quote is usually "I would have written a shorter letter, but I did not have the time."

[1] - "Je n'ai fait celle-ci plus longue que parce que je n'ai pas eu le loisir de la faire plus courte."

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by dalbasal on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:39AM (#15879928)
I don’t think this is the reason, necessarily.

I think it’s for the same reason elevator pitches are short. Shorter usually equates to better written, more relevant and the the point. I guess concise is a concise way of putting it. The writer has decided what’s relevant or not, so the reader doesn’t have to.

There’s a tendency for people describing themselves (or their company, etc.) with too many loose end details. We also do this and could do that. ..not wanting to limit themselves or leave anything outside the frame.

Imagine describing your diet. You could do it in 20 words, 200, or 2000. I’m trying to sort people into diet piles. I can do it with 20 words. If you use 200, that probably means I have to trim your 200 to 20, and sort from there.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by anonacct37 on Friday December 08, 2017 @02:00PM (#15880995)
Also keep in mind people are lazy. The higher up the chain you go the worse it seems to get.

I recommend all e-mails to Director and above be written as if your audience is a hyperactive teenager. Go with simple statements (they don't understand nuance) and bullet points.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by madamelic on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:41AM (#15879940)
>It's almost always a good idea to shorten/simplify any text meant for an unknown audience.

Also, take a look at your resume and take off all acronyms unless they are well-known (eg: HTML) and reword any overly technical statement into simple words "Utilized X to lower the Y by leveraging Z technology which resulted in a 25% speed increase". Nah, do this: "Increased speed of [project] by 25% by leveraging [technology you mentioned on your resume]"

I dislike all resumes that are overly technical and I can't imagine how recruiters feel about seeing borderline non-sense.

Re:Rip Your Resume in Half and Other Things You Won't Hear f... by ashark on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:57AM (#15880059)
More generally, following a couple easy, basic rules like:

1) emphasize the most important verb by putting it first, and favor more-active and more-specific verbs over very general or passive ones, as in putting "increased" ahead of "utilized" and "leveraged", and

2) favor simple language ("leverage" or "utilize" can often just be "use", for example) because, counterintuitively for middling or poor writers, simpler language usually comes off as more forceful, confident, and authoritative than fancier fluff.[1] It's also easier to read, and you're less likely to make small blunders that will bother some readers.

improves most writing significantly.

[1] Incidentally, I think high school and university paper length requirements that reward such flabby writing without without sufficiently punishing weak style choices are part of why people write that way, especially when they're trying to write "formally".