News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by chiefalchemist on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @06:28PM (#15709027)
Does this (read: could this) help explain why some couples have problems conceiving? Perhaps, at least in some cases, the egg is saying, "no way buddy."
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by Alex3917 on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @11:13PM (#15710215)
> Perhaps, at least in some cases, the egg is saying, "no way buddy."

Assuming this is true, it would be happening in less than 1% of cases (given the prevalence of male-factor infertility and the prevalence of its known causes). So if such an ability exists, it doesn't seem to be getting used very often. Which, given the evolutionary complexity that would be required to evolve such a system, seems surprising. So my guess is that either that's not a thing, or else it exists only as a failure state of some other mechanism rather than as something that has evolved to directly confer some sort of reproductive advantage.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by gjjrfcbugxbhf on Thursday November 16, 2017 @02:31AM (#15710804)
I thought that partner incompatibility was extremely common?
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by caio1982 on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:50AM (#15711682)
Just incompatibility, without the partner. Fluids pH problems are much more common than you'd think, and it has nothing to do with the partner (besides being treatable). And it's just one of the many problems that may occur, but none of them is like a partner issue because your bodies don't "match".
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by chiefalchemist on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:01AM (#15712007)
Yes. But if the egg is making a decision can't other parts of the process, at least in theory, be serving as gate keepers as well? Thst is, it's not just the egg being selective. Selective is baked into the recieving organism (i.e., the human female).

To me that doesn't sound too far fetched and to some extent makes perfect sense.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by thiagocsf on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @09:07PM (#15709788)
I haven’t looked it up but I’d say there’s anectodal evidence of couples that conceived with different partners after having trouble conceiving between them.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by novalis78 on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @09:11PM (#15709802)
Just met an airbnb host with the exact same story. Tried for years then broke up - both had kids right away with their new partners
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by chiefalchemist on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @09:45PM (#15709917)
And a miscarriage is the egg doing a "Oops. Got that one wrong"?
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by louhike on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:34AM (#15711591)
You cannot throw this kind of jokes around given how this subject can be hard to read for people to which it happened. HN is a community with people of lot of different backgrounds so it's important to be careful.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by gjjrfcbugxbhf on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:41AM (#15711626)
Please don't speak for other people we don't need your protection.

Edit: miscarriages are incredibly common. This will/has affected people of almost all backgrounds. The culture of silence on the topic leaves you totally unprepared for it as a reality.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by kwhitefoot on Thursday November 16, 2017 @06:04AM (#15711754)
The problem is that 'miscarriage' covers everything from what seems like just a late period to something really quite awful.

I agree that silence doesn't help and on HN is most likely unnecessary. But in general conversation it is reasonable to be a bit more circumspect.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by saturdaysaint on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:38AM (#15712169)
I've talked to people who have miscarried, and the parent post is actually a fine, lighthearted summary of the most reassuring conclusion that they came to: there was something off genetically and the potential child would have had severe health issues. I don't think it's out of place or off color in a discussion of conception.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by khamisiyah on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:56AM (#15712266)
That's quite the generalization you're making. It doesn't apply nearly to all people, especially for couples who miscarry at a very late stage in the pregnancy.

A friend of mine to who had the misfortune of this happening to him described it as the "worst thing he could ever image happening to a person" - they were mentally broken for months. So I wouldn't say this is a lighthearted comment to make, especially if you said it to them face-to-face.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by gjjrfcbugxbhf on Thursday November 16, 2017 @08:27AM (#15712440)
Late in the pregnancy it is called a stillbirth rather than a miscarriage.

Stillbirth is rare. Miscarriage is incredibly common.

Both are painful I suspect a stillbirth far more so. The difference is that people shouldn't expect a stillbirth anymore than the death of a child - there is no need to prepare for it as a likely outcome. Meanwhile if you are intending to have more than one birth child you are more likely to experience miscarriage than not - it is better to be ready for it than have it come as a total surprise.

Edited slightly.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by khamisiyah on Thursday November 16, 2017 @08:42AM (#15712521)
Good point, thanks for clarifying.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by dcow on Thursday November 16, 2017 @06:02AM (#15711748)
I don't think there was any joke intended. Often times someone will try to understand a murky topic by creating a (often personified) metaphor.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by chiefalchemist on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:08AM (#15712045)
Apology aside, I'd like to add, I was also trying to suggest (perhaps poorly) there are times (e.g., miscarriage) when Mother Nature is actually do a positive. That is, it realizes something is off target.

Mind you, I get the couple is often guttes. But emotions aside, it's a biological positive.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by gjjrfcbugxbhf on Thursday November 16, 2017 @08:30AM (#15712460)
Don't apologize. You said nothing wrong.

When you experience this the only thing that helps is understanding that it is nothing you did but a simple case of things not having worked.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by chiefalchemist on Thursday November 16, 2017 @09:36AM (#15712873)
While I don't like his politics, I am a proponent of Frank Luntz's "It's not what you say, it's what they hear."

I agree, on the surface my intent (from my POV) was not to offend. That said, I can see how my word / idea choice could have been better.

The apology is to acknowledge that yes I could have done better and then even if I didn't mean to offend the receiver's does still have value. Human to human, I wanted to acknowledge that.

Perhaps not very HN but I'm comfortable with that ;)

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by gjjrfcbugxbhf on Thursday November 16, 2017 @10:42AM (#15713535)
This is of course your prerogative. However, I would rather discuss this with someone who starts with a slightly off comment than not have it discussed at all.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by chiefalchemist on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:03AM (#15712020)
I apologize. It wasn't a joke per se. Just a simple / casual way of getting the point across. My context was biology, not couples reproduction.

None the less, sorry about that.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by andai on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:48AM (#15711667)
We had this in biology in high school, don't remember the exact details but essentially some gene combinations just "don't work", and in mammals that manifests as a miscarriage.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by bencollier49 on Thursday November 16, 2017 @06:36AM (#15711886)
DNA damage usually I think.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by golemotron on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:39AM (#15711364)
The biggest issue in conception is the age of the mother [1]. As couples don't attempt pregnancy until later (often their mid 30s) this effect is masked as partner incompatibility.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_and_female_fertility

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by klmr on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:49AM (#15711670)
Unlikely. As a selective mechanism its effect would be very subtle, and there are other, well-known, much stronger mechanisms that prevent conception. Age of the mother was mentioned. More generally, it’s defects in the oocyte’s ability to perform chromosome segregation or to nest in the uterine lining.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by avdempsey on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @08:20PM (#15709580)
Cool to seen this on HN; my wife did the illustration for this article!
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by caio1982 on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:53AM (#15711692)
She did a great job!
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by cwkoss on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @06:20PM (#15708967)
Reminds me of the CS problem: write a program which prints out its own source code.

But way more impressive. How can a cell with a single strand of DNA 'decide' which copy of a gene is a mutation? Or do eggs just bias for sperm with more genetic differences?

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by vikiomega9 on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @07:39PM (#15709366)
These decisions interface via binding sites[1] which can be thought of as having "bias".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binding_site

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by sjg007 on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @10:01PM (#15709973)
If I understand correctly, they see associations of alleles in the zygotes that suggest the gametes have not paired randomly.

Basically it could be that the egg and the sperm have different proteins expressed on their cellular surfaces which go together like a lock and key and may also function as attractors ( chemical sensing or something).. all of this would originate from genes in the gametes.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by jblow on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @07:09PM (#15709226)
crc32
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by rllin on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @06:56PM (#15709169)
I feel like this is a misunderstanding how strict Mendelian genetics is.

Most evolutionary theorists think more like physicists and do realize every trait is selectable.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by mannykannot on Thursday November 16, 2017 @09:01AM (#15712638)
This is a problem I have with this sort of journalism. In the big picture, the prevalence of the effect is low, and so we do not have to throw away all of reproductive and evolutionary biology as a consequence, but that is exactly what creationists will claim.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by gewa on Thursday November 16, 2017 @03:34AM (#15711070)
This... Mendel's law is only applicable to a really small hand full of traits.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by dekhn on Thursday November 16, 2017 @08:02AM (#15712301)
Try saying that around a geneticist :( most i know consider mendelian genetics to apply to everything and nearly all traits/phylogenies are considered monogenic.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by klmr on Thursday November 16, 2017 @09:47AM (#15712973)
You hang out with the wrong geneticists. Most do not consider most traits to be monogenetic. It’s just vastly easier to focus on them when doing research. But the field as a whole has long since accepted that most interesting traits aren’t Mendelian. The whole field of GWAS and (e)QTL studies is founded around that recognition, and virtually all modern genetic models assume at least an additive effect of (known and unknown) variations as contributors to a given phenotype (and have, for a very long time).
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by gowld on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @06:58PM (#15709176)
Did they rule out the possibility that the mutant gene they put in the male mice caused the sperm to be bad at sperming?
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by psloth on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @11:03PM (#15710190)
"Perhaps, Nadeau reasoned, the problem lay in the sperm, not the egg. He therefore bred male mice with and without the mutation to healthy mutation-free females and found no differences in the males’ fertility"
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by sjg007 on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @09:52PM (#15709943)
I thought there was evidence that the female immune system also "selects" against some sperm as well.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by mozumder on Thursday November 16, 2017 @02:50AM (#15710864)
This probably answers a question I have about genetics - that there just isn't enough variety if reproduction was random.

Genetic differences that have no bearing on survivability, like skin patterns or colors or whatever, should be widespread through every species, but they're not.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by azeotropic on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:18AM (#15712089)
Skin patterns and colors do have impacts on survivability! Some species use camouflage to avoid predation, others use bright coloration to attract mates.

There's also a flaw in your premise -- reproduction is not random, it's subject to selection at a number of levels. Most selective forces act to reduce genetic diversity, both at the selected gene, and at nearby genes.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by andai on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:53AM (#15711694)
That's really interesting to think about. Somewhat related, I asked a geneticist once why there was so much diversity in humans vs pigeons which all looked the same to me.

He said, "We're tuned to notice differences between people, not pigeons. Perhaps we all look the same to them!"

Perhaps there is precisely this sort of random variation in the differences we don't notice, because by being oblivious to them they are not sexually selected for or against?

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by rsynnott on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:33AM (#15712146)
If anything, humans have abnormally _small_ genetic diversity; most species have more. We went through a population trap at some point in the past, and nearly went extinct; we probably lost most of our diversity then.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by rscar on Thursday November 16, 2017 @09:53AM (#15713027)
Don't be surprised if Todd Akin comes out of the woodwork to say he was right.

i.e. Mr. "It seems to be, first of all, from what I understand from doctors, it’s really rare. If it’s a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to try to shut the whole thing down."

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by m3kw9 on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @09:26PM (#15709852)
It would make evolutionary sense to have the ability to select better sperm.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by gweinberg on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @09:56PM (#15709962)
It could if the egg could somehow know which ones were better. But how could it know that?
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by m3kw9 on Friday November 17, 2017 @02:41PM (#15725338)
Probably some sort of gene expression
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by andai on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:50AM (#15711675)
The same way women do!
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by graeme on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @08:09PM (#15709520)
I thought the standard view was that eggs did some selecting. At least, that’s what I gathered by reading about IVF and birth defects.

I can’t find a specific reference offhand though.

Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by biomcgary on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @06:57PM (#15709170)
The current evidence is inconclusive, but many obvious alternatives have been ruled out.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by pishpash on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @07:05PM (#15709209)
Furthermore, if true, it shouldn't be overly surprising, since gametes are another stage in the life of an organism with great selection pressure. Why assume it behaves randomly?
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by virmundi on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @08:47PM (#15709702)
No known sense organs to pick another environmental benefit. Classic biology assumes such a means to respond by selecting in this case.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by phaitour on Thursday November 16, 2017 @11:05AM (#15713728)
this is interestingly in line with chinese traditional medicines perspective on reproduction. their theory is that it’s heavily based on the receptability of the egg and therefore it’s largely the mother who’s largely in control of things like gender selection. things like eating more acidic or basic foods affect the environment for the sperm to swim in and even the month of the mother’s life has an effect on what the egg would choose.
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by amelius on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:09AM (#15712048)
Not a biologist, but wouldn't an alternative hypothesis be that the DDX1 gene somehow affects the sperm cell's physical abilities, e.g. motility?
Re:Choosy Eggs May Pick Sperm for Their Genes, Defying Mende... by skate22 on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:14AM (#15712067)
So... we are the chosen ones?