News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by rrggrr on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:28PM (#15637583)
If passed, and for a brief period of time, Trump's dollar repatriation tax scheme brings home some of the +2 trillion dollars sequestered abroad - including some of the billions Apple has parked offshore.

http://www.businessinsider.com/trump-gop-tax-reform-plan-bil...

There's something to be said for Apple's efforts to level the playing field against the favorable tax & public policies under which Samsung and Huawei Technologies operate. I'm not crying 'boo hoo' for Apple, but their tax strategies are understandable.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by canuckintime on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:36PM (#15637658)
Or the US Congress could just change the law, close the loophole and require corporations to bring the money home anyway without any tax holidays...
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by mistercow on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:38PM (#15637680)
I'm always skeptical when someone precedes "close the loophole" with the word "just", especially when the entity searching for loopholes has hundreds of billions of dollars in cash. Closing loopholes is good, but they'll almost certainly find another one.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by vidarh on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:49PM (#15637781)
The thing, though, is that their main "loophole" currently consists of "play chicken with the government until someone passes a tax holiday". If you make it clear there will never be a tax holiday, but that you will instead keep adjusting the rules to go after earnings withheld abroad, at some point the rational choice for them will be to bite the bullet and repatriate the income.

As it is, the most rational choice for them is to keep waiting for that amnesty/tax holiday unless they badly need the cash.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by osteele on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:28PM (#15638237)
> If you make it clear there will never be a tax holiday, but that you will instead keep adjusting the rules to go after earnings withheld abroad, at some point the rational choice for them will be to bite the bullet and repatriate the income.

Another rational choice is to relocate the company, a la Burger King's move to Canada [1,2].

Then the government can counter with tariffs [3,4]. It's a balancing act, though.

[1] "Tax inversion", Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_inversion

[2] "Let's Abolish The Corporate Income Tax", John C. Goodman, Forbes, Aug 26, 2014. https://www.forbes.com/sites/johngoodman/2014/08/26/lets-abo...

[3] "Trump takes aim at Obama's ban on tax inversions", Larry Light, Moneywatch, April 21, 2017. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-taxes-corporate-transfer-...

[4] "Trump to keep Obama rule curbing corporate tax inversion deals", Reuters, October 4, 2017. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-tax-inversions/trump-...

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by toomuchtodo on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:15PM (#15638653)
> It's a balancing act, though.

At the end of the day, there is no way you as a corporation can entirely subvert a nation state. I find it odd even that rational individuals think its possible against an adversary (typically with effectively unlimited resources) that can tariff you, dissolve your organization, and even jail you.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by landryraccoon on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:24PM (#15638711)
It's not corporation against nation state, it's nation state against nation state.

I'm pretty sure China would be quite happy if the US punishes Apple. That means that their protectionist policy towards Huawei will be even more effective. It is difficult for me to imagine other nations either not rolling out the red carpet to bring Apple over, or giving virtually tax free giveaways to their own companies to gain smartphone supremacy.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by crdoconnor on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:41PM (#15639259)
>I'm pretty sure China would be quite happy if the US punishes Apple. That means that their protectionist policy towards Huawei will be even more effective.

If the US put onerous taxes on the purchase of Apple phones that might be true.

If the US instead just collects a larger share of Apple's profits then Apple is going to go on exactly as before and just not deliver quite as much cash to its shareholders.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by mattnewton on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:44PM (#15639659)
Taxing the phone or the company’s margins should have the same effect, right? They’re both costs on apple’s revenue. Barring maybe some enforcement issue or something it makes no difference how you collect it, Apple will pass some of it off to their customers and eat another percentage based on whatever the new cost/demand curve looks like to them.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by crdoconnor on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:43PM (#15639976)
>Taxing the phone or the company’s margins should have the same effect, right?

Wrong

>They’re both costs on apple’s revenue.

Hardly. Make zero profit and you pay zero tax on that profit.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by mattnewton on Monday November 06, 2017 @07:20PM (#15640163)
My argument is that since apple can move the price, if you tax the company they increase the cost of the phone as much as makes sense and eat the rest. If you tax the phone, they leave as much as the increase on the cost to the end user as makes sense and lower the price beyond that, eating it. In neither case are profits or demand going to zero.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by crdoconnor on Monday November 06, 2017 @08:06PM (#15640345)
>if you tax the company they increase the cost of the phone

Raising your prices in response to not making as much profit as you desired is not often a winning move in business.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by mattnewton on Monday November 06, 2017 @09:46PM (#15640718)
And a tax on the phone does this, so they either lower the cost and eat it, or suffer the same fall in demand as when the price of the phone increases to protect their margins.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by crdoconnor on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @07:20AM (#15642771)
Perhaps, but a tax on profits does not do this.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by landryraccoon on Monday November 06, 2017 @08:07PM (#15640348)
Are you arguing that a 100% tax on Apple profits wouldn’t impact their competitiveness? How would they build new factories, develop new products or hire more workers without reinvesting profits into their company? Why wouldn’t a company that can raise more money from capital markets and that has the support of its government quickly overtake Apple’s position?
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by crdoconnor on Monday November 06, 2017 @08:16PM (#15640373)
>Are you arguing that a 100% tax on Apple profits wouldn’t impact their competitiveness?

Pretty much. It would render their stock worthless, but there's nothing about a 100% tax on realized profits from preventing a business from operating exactly as before.

>How would they build new factories, develop new products or hire more workers

With relative ease. Corporation tax is paid only on realized profits. Reinvesting earnings has often been a way of avoiding paying it at all, which is actually supposed to be a feature.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by landryraccoon on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @12:03AM (#15641189)
> With relative ease.

Yeah, but why would they? Why would any employee or manager have an incentive to do extra work to do so? Where do they get the money from, and more importantly, why would they reinvest the money if there is absolutely no gain to doing so, instead of paying it out to executives and shareholders and just cashing out?

> Corporation tax is paid only on realized profits.

I’m not sure you know what this means. A new factory is an asset, taxes are definitely paid on it if Apple buys a new factory with retained earnings. Are you claiming that a corporation can gain new long term assets without paying any tax unless investors put more money into the business or banks loan them money?

I'm sorry if I sound shocked, but I actually file corporation taxes for a small business. Corporate profits are taxable whether they get paid out to shareholders or reinvested into the company.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by crdoconnor on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @07:40AM (#15642855)
>Yeah, but why would they? Why would any employee or manager have an incentive to do extra work to do so?

Coz they get paid.

>why would they reinvest the money if there is absolutely no gain to doing so, instead of paying it out to executives

It's true that with a higher profit tax you'd may see execs paying themselves higher and higher salaries and shareholders would be less inclined to prevent it.

>I’m not sure you know what this means. A new factory is an asset, taxes are definitely paid on it if Apple buys a new factory with retained earnings. Are you claiming that a corporation can gain new long term assets without paying any tax unless investors put more money into the business or banks loan them money?

>I'm sorry if I sound shocked, but I actually file corporation taxes for a small business.

So do I. Actually, the year before last I personally paid more in corporation tax than Facebook did (they paid £4,000).

I'm pretty sure they were taking neither investment nor loans.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by osteele on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:09PM (#15639024)
It's a balancing act, not (just) an arms race. As a government, raise corporate taxes too high, and corporations leave and/or overseas corporations outcompete them and/or new corporations form overseas instead of domestically. Raise tariffs too high, and domestic consumer choice and quality decrease, and consumer purchasing power decreases. These aren't consequences that dissolving your domestic corporations or jailing their managers address.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by crdoconnor on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:37PM (#15639239)
>As a government, raise corporate taxes too high, and corporations leave

Only when there's almost no cost to leaving, which in itself is a tax loophole. If you declare that residency is about where you do the most business and has nothing to do with which letterbox has the word "headquarters" on it then their reaction would be limited to tantrums in Wall Street Journal op eds.

>or overseas corporations outcompete them

That's not how corporation tax works. It's paid on profits and does not affect the competitiveness of the firm.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by osteele on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:32PM (#15639587)
>>As a government, raise corporate taxes too high, and corporations leave

>Only when there's almost no cost to leaving, which in itself is a tax loophole. If you declare that residency is about where you do the most business and has nothing to do with which letterbox has the word "headquarters" on it then their reaction would be limited to tantrums in Wall Street Journal op eds

Or to the other two arms of the disjunction in the text that you elided.

>>or overseas corporations outcompete them

>That's not how corporation tax works. It's paid on profits and does not affect the competitiveness of the firm.

It has to come from somewhere. It can come from owners, workers, or consumers. If it came from consumers (higher price or lower quality for products and services) this would affect the competitiveness in a straightforward way. [1] and [2] claim that it instead comes from owners and workers, with considerable uncertainty about the ratio between those. If it comes from owners, it increases the corporation's cost of capital – but only to the extent that investment is global. If it comes from workers, it decreases the ability for the corporation to compete for labor – but only to the extent that labor is global. So you're correct that it does not affect competitiveness in a sufficiently non-global economy.

[1] "Who Pays the Corporate Income Tax", Bruce Bartlett, New York Times, Feb 19, 2013. https://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/02/19/who-pays-the-c...

[2] "Who Ultimately Pays the Corporate Income Tax?", Uwe E. Reinhardt (Economics @ Princeton), New York Times, July 23, 2010. https://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/07/23/who-ultimately...

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by crdoconnor on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:21PM (#15639867)
>It has to come from somewhere. It can come from owners, workers, or consumers.

Owners. It comes from owners.

>If it comes from owners, it increases the corporation's cost of capital

There is currently an almost absurd overabundance of capital relative to aggregate demand.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by sanxiyn on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @02:08AM (#15641541)
It is collected from owners. Tax collection and tax incidence are separate issues. In economics parlance, where tax "comes from" or "falls on" refers to tax incidence, not tax collection.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by crdoconnor on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @11:19AM (#15644624)
Tax collection and tax incidence are indeed separate issues.

The tax incidence falls on owners - probably at least until profit taxes reach ~80% or capital became magically very scarce for some reason that clearly doesn't apply to the present day.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by ikeboy on Monday November 06, 2017 @09:15PM (#15640591)
>That's not how corporation tax works. It's paid on profits and does not affect the competitiveness of the firm.

Corporations often need to raise money from investors, who will rationally only fund corporations that are expected to generate enough profit to produce a good enough return for the risk and so on. If profit is lower in some countries, that reduces the amount of money going to investment in that country as the potential reward has gone down. Therefore such companies are less competitive in fundraising.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by hinkley on Monday November 06, 2017 @08:13PM (#15640368)
Having to move your headquarters every time you open up a foreign market that is more lucrative than your home market is insane. Suicidal, in fact.

I don’t think you’ve thought your solution through.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by alasdair_ on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:33PM (#15638765)
>At the end of the day, there is no way you as a corporation can entirely subvert a nation state.

There are countless examples of this happening, from the East India Company (who essentially ruled India for a century) to the United Fruit Company to present-day Shell Oil.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by davidgay on Monday November 06, 2017 @11:35PM (#15641106)
The relevant link for the "East India Company" would appear to be: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_India_Company#Regulating_...

The first sentence there ends with "this clearly established Parliament's sovereignty and ultimate control over the company". So not a very convincing example of company independence over its host nation.

[Influence and control over another, relatively weak country is clearly a separate issue, but that's not always clearly separable from the host country's influence]

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by toomuchtodo on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:36PM (#15638798)
Can you provide an example present day of a company successfully subverting the US government? To my knowledge, they're even pursuing companies successfully outside of their jurisdiction (Kim Dotcom/MEGA).
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by hinkley on Monday November 06, 2017 @08:16PM (#15640376)
So many that there’s a term for it: Regulatory capture.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by gaius on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:11PM (#15639046)
Halliburton?
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by white-flame on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:34PM (#15639936)
Large corporations simply have the ability to shop around to figure out which tax/legal jurisdiction they want to incorporate under, and which instruments they choose to represent their incomes, expenses, and holdings. If things like tariffs are implemented, then the cost/benefit situation changes and shopping around resumes. A smaller company or individual often doesn't practically have that scale of flexibility & research to pull off the same changes, though technically they do.

But even in your personal purchasing, because you might shop around and even negotiate prices with sellers to get a good deal, does that make you an adversary of the economy? No, it makes you part of the economic structure, like the various corporate implements are part of various jurisdictions' tax structures, and the governments benefit from their presence in various ways, not just directly through taxes. That's what all the negotiations are based on.

Of course, I'm speaking of options that are legal, and it gets arguable (and sometimes flagrant) how some corporate actions get interpreted in that sense.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by valuearb on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:40PM (#15638818)
Samsung subverts the tax laws of the US every day, forcing repatriation would just give our foreign competitors even bigger advantages.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by DigitalJack on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:18PM (#15638122)
In this case it's not a loophole in American laws. It's a problem with European and Carribean laws. This money was earned abroad. Blame the Irish, and now whatever this Jersey Island place is.

The EU made a move to close the loophole, apple found another.

I suppose there are loopholes with them selling IP assets to subsidiaries. But that's a different loophole than the one with them floating money around different countries. That money wasn't earned in America, so why are you trying to "repatriate" it? The better term would be "appropriate" it as it was never here in the first place.

Until it costs more for apple to pay interest on a loan (and/or penalties and fines) than they would pay in taxes, that money will never come here.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by _0ffh on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:06PM (#15638595)
It's a British crown dependency, and afaik not the only tax haven under British rule. And it seems like there's no much the EU will be able to do about those.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by charlesdm on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:15PM (#15638663)
Perhaps this might change after brexit though.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by toyg on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:53PM (#15638919)
Yes, French and German authorities have made it known that they cannot wait for brexit to happen because it will relieve them of any need to play nice with the UK about shenanigans like these. At the same time, the Irish border problem puts the Republic of Ireland in a similar position of weakness, and they are enemy n.2 for honest tax authorities worldwide. Enemy 3 and 4 (Luxembourg and NL) have also been weakened by the disappearance of the “free trade alliance” that ran from Poland to Ireland, and when left isolated, they have been successfully bullied in the past anyway.

This is one of the very few areas where brexit might actually end up a net positive for the world at large.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by charlesdm on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:58PM (#15638956)
Maybe. It's likely a UK-EU trade deal will appear before Brexit (in some way or another) and that might not lead to many changes in the end.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by deong on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:51PM (#15638902)
The US government doesn't, as a general rule, care if the money has ever been here. If you as a private US citizen choose to live and work abroad, you are required to file US income taxes and declare all foreign income. And depending on the precise details of the foreign government's treaty situation and tax rates, you may be required to pay the normal US tax rate on some or all of that income.

I don't know that it counts as a "loophole" exactly that the system for corporations works the way it does. "Loophole" sort of implies an unintended consequence, when the reality is that the laws are written with the express purpose of making this type of tax avoidance possible.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by landryraccoon on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:35PM (#15639614)
> If you as a private US citizen choose to live and work abroad, you are required to file US income taxes and declare all foreign income.

Do you support this practice though? Does any other country try to tax people for income earned entirely abroad? This puts US citizens at a disadvantage compared to citizens of say, the EU.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by sokoloff on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @01:36AM (#15641455)
The US and Eritrea are the only two.

In practice, the US has tax treaties with most other nations that permit foreign taxes paid (on income that would be taxable federally, so not on wealth taxes) to be taken as a dollar-for-dollar credit. That means that any country with a lower tax rate than the US will generally not increase your overall income tax bill. If you owed $X to a foreign country and $Y to the US for work done in the foreign country, you pay $X to the foreign country (regardless) and if Y is greater than X, you pay $(Y-X) to the US.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by deong on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @09:56AM (#15652968)
It's a pretty weird practice, and I can't come up with a good reason why I think it should be done, but it is. Just not for corporations. That's my point -- not that it's desirable, just that corporations get special treatment here.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by malandrew on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:01PM (#15639395)
At some point you tax people too much and they leave your country for one with better taxes. Never forget that the top 20% of citizens are responsible for like 87% of all the tax revenue the US and state governments rely on.

In fact this already happens at the state level in the US: http://www.howmoneywalks.com/irs-tax-migration/

If the new cut cut cut tax plan passes and Californian's can no longer write off state income tax on their federal returns, you will see even more people leave California.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by ubernostrum on Monday November 06, 2017 @07:14PM (#15640124)
Never forget that the top 20% of citizens are responsible for like 87% of all the tax revenue the US and state governments rely on.

Never forget that you implicitly assumed this is because taxes on that segment are too high, rather than because various aspects of our economy were rigged to give those people a disproportionately high share of the total taxable income.

In other words: there are two ways to reduce your tax bill, and only one of them requires Congress to pass a law that puts you in a lower bracket.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by malandrew on Monday November 06, 2017 @08:36PM (#15640450)
> "various aspects of our economy were rigged"

This is an entirely handwavy and unsupported assertion, whereas stating the percentage of tax paid by the top 20% is a statement of fact with no implicit assumptions.

The people of a country get the tax system written by the representatives they voted for, and are complicit in any "rigging" of the economy.

What we have is a tax code that is layer upon layer of exceptions that came about when Group A supported a tax on Group B to pay for a benefit for Group A. Sometimes group A is in the top 20% (e.g. taxes used to subsidize an industry) and sometimes group A is in the bottom 20% (e.g. taxes used for food stamps). The former arises from things such as regulatory capture and the latter arises from uninhibited populism.

No politically active bloc of voters is innocent. Everyone from the rich to the poor are special interests and all are equally as guilty of "rigging our economy". Only a flat tax that treats no group as special is fair.

I'm curious what you think of Nozick's Wilt Chamberlain example: http://resources.seattlecentral.edu/faculty/jhubert/wiltcham...

In it, absent any tax code distortions, Wilt Chamberlain would end up with most of the taxable income through entirely voluntary transactions. If thousands of people voluntarily pay Wilt Chamberlain to be entertained and Wilt ends up with most of the income, is that a rigged system? Power law distributions in income are a naturally occurring phenomena. No rigging is required.

If the system is indeed rigged, it's rigged in favor of the 45% of Americans that don't pay any federal income tax. They get all of the benefits at none of the cost.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by snowwrestler on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @01:06AM (#15641350)
Apple is not waiting for anything. They store their money abroad, and they invest it abroad, in foreign manufacturing and foreign retail expansion and foreign R&D and foreign acquisitions. And when domestic investors complain, Apple takes on domestic debt (at very good terms) to fund stock buybacks and dividends.

The idea that U.S. international tax policy is somehow hampering Apple is just not true. There's a big world out there outside U.S. borders.

What it is hampering is U.S. domestic investment and job growth.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by glenstein on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:46PM (#15637743)
I think once a loophole has been identified, it becomes a "just." But you are right that the trickier problem is with the more fundamental process of constantly searching for loopholes. If only we could "just" close that one, too.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by wpietri on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:53PM (#15637826)
Yup. It's to some extent an adversarial process. But that's part of why we have a legislature all the time, rather than just relying on laws written decades ago.

A fine example is wire fraud. Existing fraud laws didn't really cover it, and innovative criminals made extensive use of the loopholes until wire fraud was criminalized. (For those interested, the Yellow Kid's autobiography is a fun read. [1])

Same thing with any sort of security hole, really. We'll always have on-line attackers, but that's not a reason to give up. It's a reason to keep plugging holes and improving state of the art.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Yellow-Kid-Weil-Autobiography-America...

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by munk-a on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:00PM (#15637922)
This reads a bit fatalist, why don't we close this particular loophole and deal with the next when it comes along. This may be a game of whack-a-mole but we're never going to have a sane tax code if we don't start killing some moles.

If anyone is knowledgeable in accounting and wants to point out some future loopholes that may arise, sure we can get those as well but... don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by cozzyd on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:46PM (#15638417)
Clearly we need stochastic regulations, where the regulations are chosen randomly from time to time subject to the constraints that they accomplish their policy goals. Just have to change them faster than the accountants can figure out how to exploit them...
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by tialaramex on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:58PM (#15640059)
Several places have what's called a "General anti-avoidance rule". The way this works is, if you think you've got a brilliant wheeze that avoids taxes, you're required to tell the tax officials about it. If you choose not to tell them then they can prosecute for evasion, and if you tell the court actually it was a clever avoidance tactic not evasion the court says hang on, why didn't you obey the General anti-avoidance rule? So you're screwed either way.

On the other hand if you tell them, they get to look at your clever idea and decide to either allow it, change the rule for next year, or go to court saying you're wrong this avoidance method doesn't work so you owe taxes.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by 1123581321 on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @03:10AM (#15641717)
Tax minimization is still possible in such a system if it’s consistently adjudicated. If not, it is subject to regulatory capture and possibly bribes. And the nation executing this scheme still has a target effective tax rate, so the base rates will be adjusted up or down depending on the extent of minimization. I am not sure if you’re presenting this as an solution or a warning. :)
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by petre on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @12:40AM (#15641275)
This translates to arbitrary legislation.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by petre on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @12:37AM (#15641270)
That's a terrible idea. You need stable tax regulations in order to make a business plan, get a loan etc. If you kill or drive away the taxpayer you're going to be left without taxes to collect.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by pbhjpbhj on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:19PM (#15638133)
You can close all loopholes that rely on literal interpretation by changing the approach to interpretation of the law/tax code. You can reinforce it with minimum taxation based on revenue, which prevents you having to wade through treacle in the courts.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by jnordwick on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:50PM (#15640017)
Taxing revenues means taxing products on every step in production, many many times on their path through production and the economy. You would essentially also destroy low margin businesses, like grocery and retail and Adobe they ate such low margin the entire tax bill would be paid by the end consumer.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by ImSkeptical on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:49PM (#15637791)
We should just keep pursuing the tax loopholes as they are discovered, they should be closed. I also think we should be lowering tax rates in conjunction with this as our tax code becomes more effective.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by ljf on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:46PM (#15638409)
How about: it would be good if we lowered taxes /except/ for companies that had been abusing loopholes...

Though to be perfectly honest, I'd rather the state used the funds for the betterment of man, but then I'm a boring lefty

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by valuearb on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:42PM (#15638829)
No, We need to eliminate corporate income taxes. They are a tax on investment and job formation.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by solotronics on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:12PM (#15639461)
the company would likely relocate

to bring business and money here, make the corporate tax rate very low (5%?) and have no writeoffs and no exemptions

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by pjc50 on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:46PM (#15637754)
Indeed. Doing business with the tax havens is a choice in the same way that refusing to do business with Iran is a choice.

The tax havens are almost all small islands that are dependent on food and fuel imports. Iran-level sanctions would collapse them in a week.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by wildmusings on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:33PM (#15638772)
It seems that you're suggesting that we tax corporations on overseas income, even when reinvested overseas. That would put American companies at an extreme disadvantage compared to those from other countries, by forcing them to pay double taxes, US and foreign corporate taxes, on all income.

The logical solution is to get rid of the corporate tax altogether. The only reason why it exists is to be a plank for politicians who want to tax the "greedy corporations." All corporate income is either paid as dividends, paid as salaries, or reinvested. When it is paid as dividends, it is taxed as capital gains. When it is paid as salaries, it is taxed as income. When it is reinvested, it is either lost, or eventually becomes income and capital gains. There is no need to have another layer of taxation that just makes a giant accounting mess and creates all sorts of ridiculous incentives to use tax shelters.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by jfoutz on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:50PM (#15638891)
That's fine, but all other things remaining equal, there's not as much revenue coming in. So, you need to raise capital gains tax and income tax in some proportion to retain the balance. Does that still seem easier?

Alternatively, we could cut a bunch of spending, but that turns into its own dogfight.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by wildmusings on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:40PM (#15639643)
The corporate tax is actually a small (but not negligible) portion of tax revenue. Part of the logic for capital gains tax being lower than income tax is to account for the double taxation of the corporate tax. So I would be in favor of raising the capital gains tax to make up for eliminating the corporate tax.

I also happen to think that taxes should be lower overall, but I think it’s best to divide the two issues: 1) how much we should be taxed, from 2) how we should be taxed.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by jjtheblunt on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:17PM (#15638106)
No, they couldn't. The money belongs to foreign corporations also named Apple whatever.

That little issue is purposefully glossed over for the sake of sensationalism to sell advertising, of course.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by kobeya on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:41PM (#15638361)
Treat income of any foreign company wholly owned or with substantially similar ownership structure of a domestic company as taxable income for that domestic company.

I don't think this is a good idea; I'm just demonstrating that it's not impossible.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by cc439 on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:47PM (#15640004)
How do you define "domestic"? Is it a company that earns the majority of its revenues in your country? That won't work because Toyota is certainly not an American company but the US market represents the majority of their revenues. Is it a company that was founded in your country? That won't work because of companies like Airbus that are supranational in origin. Is it a company that is headquartered in your country? That won't work because a headquarters can be moved in a matter of months (look at how GE left CT for a more regional example).
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by kobeya on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @12:36PM (#15645508)
Domestic has a technical meaning: a company registered in a US state. To do business in the US you have to spin up a US company. Toyota USA would be taxed for global Toyota income. You could try to mitigate that by saying these rules only apply to companies whose ownership or control structure is more than 25% american, directly or indirectly. But yeah, these side effects are part of why I say I don’t agree with such a proposal.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by matt4077 on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:46PM (#15638414)
Those foreign corporations named "Apple whatever" are owned, and controlled by "Apple Inc. (forever)". Such conglomerates are usually treated as one for tax purposes, which is why Apple and others can't just create 2500 shell companies each year to take advantage of various "startup" incentives across the world.

That's the sort of knowledge journalists learn in journalism 101, before they advance to their seminar on "sensationalism and selling advertisement" and the group therapy session "some know-nothing on the internet thinks I have anything to do with the BBC's business side, completely ignoring that online advertisement is, like, 0.001% of the BBC's revenue and that, being one of x thousand people working for the BBC, and my articles' revenue going into one big pot with all the others', my personal future is almost completely devoid of anything resembling a link to my articles' readership numbers".

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by notyourday on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:57PM (#15638504)
If congress is to simplify the tax code to $rate = $rate->{calculate_bracket($amount_of_revenue)} then the members of congress would lose 99% of their net worth because there would be nothing special that is worth any money that the members of congress could do so they could reap some money for doing it.

which is why this would never happen.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by ballenf on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:00PM (#15639385)
David Mitchell makes an interesting argument regarding moral outrage against entities taking advantage of "loopholes".

https://youtu.be/m2q-Csk-ktc?t=25s

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by glenstein on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:43PM (#15637719)
Exactly. And it avoids the problem of losing tax revenue by creating an expectation of additional future tax holidays at regular intervals, incentivizing people to keep untaxed money offshore.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by valuearb on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:38PM (#15638810)
We won’t do that because it’s terrible tax policy and would damage this country even more than our current bad corporate tax policy does.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by seanmcdirmid on Monday November 06, 2017 @07:47PM (#15640266)
So wait, wouldn’t that just mean an end to USA companies operating abroad as USA companies? Microsoft has to invest money in china for example, they just can repatriate profits from China willy nippy, and China would get pissed of about it. Also, might as well make SAP do it also, even if a German company, otherwise American companies can’t compete with them.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by slavik81 on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:43PM (#15637714)
What's your proposed rule that would close the loophole? I don't think it's actually possible.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by glenstein on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:05PM (#15637980)
The Stop Tax Haven Abuse Act would help:

https://www.congress.gov/bill/113th-congress/senate-bill/153...

Also, as a meta point, since I seem to see these kinds of challenges often: any time a person is put on the spot to name a specific change to a specific provision of law to enact a policy goal, it's probably going to be difficult to immediately give a specific answer. To translate policy into legislation often requires the assistance of multiple layers of paid staff and legislative analysts.

So the difficulty of answering that type of question is a function of the complexity of legislating, and not necessarily a sign that someone's preferred policy is a bad idea.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by landryraccoon on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:26PM (#15638722)
Won't help against foreign state sanctioned competitors to Apple, e.g. Samsung (Korea) or Huawei (China).

I am sure foreign nations would be quite happy to gain any advantage for their own companies over US corporations like Apple. Personally I would prefer that the US maintain a technological advantage for as long as possible.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by canuckintime on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:08PM (#15639436)
Apple has been using tax strategies since the '80s and pioneered many of the techniques [1]. Samsung or Huawei weren't competitors then (perhaps Sony is the bogeyman you're looking for?)

[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/29/business/apples-tax-strate...

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by glenstein on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:00PM (#15638973)
It also won't make Apple's bezels smaller or write their ad copy for them, because that's simply not among the objectives of any prospective law targeted at reigning in tax havens.

If we need to prop up the U.S. tech sector with special tax handouts because they can't compete, we can do that on a targeted basis when that day comes rather than continuing to perpetuate an open-ended tax giveaway enjoyed by major companies in every sector of the economy.

And in the meantime perhaps we can use the missing revenue to bring our infrastructure up to parity with the rest of the modern world.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by pjc50 on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:48PM (#15637773)
"Any kind of business or financial transfer or ownership of assets or beneficiary interest in the Cayman Islands (Etc) is a criminal offence"?
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by slavik81 on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:58PM (#15637891)
That's insufficient. Most of the world has a lower corporate tax rate than the United States. The Cayman Islands might be the most attractive place to park their funds, but pretty much anywhere would still be more attractive than bringing it to the US.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by charlesdm on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:08PM (#15638605)
Lowering the US corporate tax rate to say 10 or 15% is the only reasonably feasible solution. Incentivize companies to book profits in the US. Then increase the dividend tax rate to compensate (depending on if this ends up being tax neutral or not -- it might very well be tax neutral given the extra profits that would be booked in the US)
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by slavik81 on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:26PM (#15639163)
That's more or less what I would suggest. Though, I would probably put the rate at 25% and only tax domestic profits. That would bring US policy in line with the rest of the G7. Raising taxes on dividends and capital gains to make it revenue neutral is also a good idea.

At the moment, tax policy basically penalizes companies bringing money earned in other countries home into the United States. It's stupid. Tax holidays are also stupid. Fix the problem at its heart.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by 1123581321 on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @03:15AM (#15641728)
The US reserves these kinds of hostile sanctions for its established enemies such as North Korea and Iran. In general, trade between nations should be encouraged, not blocked by economic nationalism.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by nautilus12 on Monday November 06, 2017 @09:45PM (#15640712)
You cannot close the loophole, they will just create another one. In cases like this we (meaning the judicial system and society as a whole) should be able to use judgement and just say that its clear they are creating these complex scenarios to avoid paying taxes.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by lucio on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:43PM (#15639270)
It depends, if you decide to tax them too much, they'll "just" change home.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by snowwrestler on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @12:58AM (#15641320)
How do you propose forcing a company to move money from one country to another?
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by charlesdm on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:15PM (#15638656)
Or Apple could reincorporate abroad?
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by cmurf on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:39PM (#15638346)
They could also get their thumbs out of their asses, but they won't.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by joshmn on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:38PM (#15637678)
Yeah but then they couldn't pay congress as much!
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by nautilus12 on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:42PM (#15637710)
So you are saying that rather than taxing the middle class more that we should simply make large corporations like Apple actually follow the existing tax laws?

Owing to its source it doesn't sound like this idea is going to be popular on hacker news, in spite of its blatant rationality.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by JumpCrisscross on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:46PM (#15637745)
> we should simply make large corporations like Apple actually follow the existing tax laws

Apple is in compliance with our tax laws. The laws, not Apple, are the underlying problem.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by nautilus12 on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:53PM (#15637836)
No, the spirit of the law is effectively being broken. Sidestepping the law does not constitute following it in my opinion. Laws are meant to be guidelines and legal precedent defines its true extent, you cannot make laws extensive enough to cover every scenario. If they make it illegal to offshore money then apple will simply find a way to establish a corporation on the moon. Its clearly demonstrable that they are going through great lengths to sidestep the law.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by c517402 on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:07PM (#15639017)
A product has its components fabricated in east Asia, is assembled in east Asia, sold in Europe, and the profits from the sale are held in Europe. Somehow you consider this “illegally offshoring money”. Somehow you think the US government deserves 34% of these profits. Apparently, the spirit of the law being violated is that the US government has the right to stick it’s nose in anyplace in the world it wants and extract rent.

At a physics conference Wolfgang Pauli heard a talk that was so misguided that his comment was that “it wasn’t even wrong.” IMO your comment isn’t even wrong.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by revelation on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:07PM (#15639780)
I don't think the US government deserves 34% of these profits, but some country out there does. Make it point of sale, if you want.

But right now that money isn't taxed at all. That money is what the Irish subsidiary owes Apple US for the license to Apple IP. So the Irish subsidiary isn't paying taxes on it, and Apple isn't paying taxes on it in the US because they are refusing to "bring it home".

That is why Apple is lobbying so hard for some sort of "tax holiday". They want to pay 0, nada tax on those overseas profits.

You seem to be missing this little detail.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by vixen99 on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:31PM (#15638278)
A British judge, Lord Hoffman commented ‘The only way in which Parliament can express an intention to impose a tax is by a statute that means that such a tax is to be imposed,’.

In other words, for tax there is no distinction between the spirit and letter of the law. They’re one and the same.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by Marazan on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:01PM (#15638550)
Except the General Anti Avoidance Rule flatly contradicts that.

The GAAR takes the spirit of the law into consideration when considering whether the law has been broken.

The Ramsey Principle (first stated with respect to a case governing circular transactions) also raises the spirit of the tax law being superior to the strict rules based interpretation.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by gsnedders on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:44PM (#15638391)
English law has three typical means of statutory interpretation: the literal rule (where you literally apply the letter of the law), the mischief rule (where the defendant is clearly guilty of the mischief that the law was intended to address), and the golden rule (where you reinterpret as necessary to avoid an absurd result).

That said, when it comes to most tax law the mischief rule doesn't apply (because in principle it needs to be dealing with a limitation of the common law). The golden rule rarely comes into play with tax law (though consider the case of murdering a parent and the consequences on inheritance tax, for example). So yeah, the literal rule almost always applies.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:01PM (#15638549)
Let’s keep it concrete.

Should we force companies to repatriate all foreign-earned profits?

If yes, then the US will lose its economic advantage. No international company would be insane enough to incorporate in the US.

If no, then we have our current situation.

IMO the tax law itself is broken, not Apple’s response to asinine laws. Remember that Apple has not violated the law. I also agree with the comment you replied to - for tax law, there should not be a difference between the law and the intent. What is written is what needs to be followed. And right now Apple is following it to the letter of the law.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by crdoconnor on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:52PM (#15639325)
>In other words, for tax there is no distinction between the spirit and letter of the law.

HMRC's essentially disagreed with the spirit was being followed in this case and Google paid up:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-35381130

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by charlesdm on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:11PM (#15638633)
it's hard enough to interpret the letter of the law sometimes (i.e. ambiguous situations). You might as well have random or no laws then if you have to reflect about the fact whether you're breaking the "spirit of the law". This would mean different things to different people, and things are complex enough as they are.

Also, the spirit of the law argument seems more like a pass to politicians for doing crappy legislative work. If you make proper laws, this shouldn't be an issue.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by abritinthebay on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:34PM (#15638307)
> If they make it illegal to offshore money...

... then the US would immediately end up losing all it's multinational companies to less insane countries.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by vkou on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:00PM (#15638969)
Is Apple going to pack up and move 50,000 people from Cupertino to the Cayman Islands?
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by abritinthebay on Thursday November 09, 2017 @12:04PM (#15663992)
Apple might not, but we were talking in general
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by anigbrowl on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:37PM (#15638334)
Prove it. I think companies like being in the US because of the sophisticated capital markets, strong and predictable legal environment, and deep pockets of American consumers. I'd like some evidence instead of hyperbole.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:57PM (#15638506)
How about you provide the evidence? If US makes it defacto illegal to operate internationally as a US-based company, the US will lose its economic moat within a matter of decades [citation needed, I know]

I’m not a tax expert but IME the people who are blaming Apple don’t know what they’re talking about. Only the US has such an insane attitude towards international profits.

And remember that there’s no loophole to close, unless the “loophole” is deciding what to do with your capital. Who is the US to tell Apple that its foreign subsidiaries must return their foreign-made profits back to the US?

Also remember that with our current laws, repatriating the money before a tax holiday is arguably a violation of Apple’s fiduciary duty to its shareholders.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by anigbrowl on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:06PM (#15638592)
The person making the claim has the burden of proof.

Maybe repeating a string of specious arguments that have already been debunked or refuted elsewhere in the thread isn't the best approach for your brand-new HN account.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:46PM (#15639997)
Debunked/refuted where?

I admit I haven't provided much in the way of evidence. However we're talking about a complicated tax situation so it's hard to stick to the concrete.

Do you agree that the only way to "close the loophole" is to force companies to repatriate their earnings? I don't see another way to address it.

Right now the issue is that iff Apple repatriates its money, it must pay taxes. So Apple has been fulfilling their fiduciary obligations by opting not to repatriate (which would destroy 30%+ of the value, I don't know the actual number but I believe I am being conservative), instead choosing to take on cheap debt domestically to fund share repurchases.

Thus I don't see a "solution" to the "loophole" (obviously I don't believe it's a loophole because it's the law) that doesn't involve forced repatriation.

If there's something wrong with what I've said or something I haven't considered, I'm all ears.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by Frondo on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:10PM (#15638618)
No one is saying the US would make it illegal to operate an international company.

They're looking for ways to close some of these loopholes that are keeping a ton of tax money out of the coffers belonging to We the People.

Please don't conflate "closing tax loopholes" with "making it illegal to operate internationally".

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:47PM (#15640007)
Please define the specific tax loophole.

The "loophole" as far as I can tell is that a company can choose not to repatriate their earnings, which is completely legal.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by Frondo on Monday November 06, 2017 @09:12PM (#15640570)
You were saying "make it de facto illegal to operate a multinational" and that is not on the table and has never been anywhere close to it.

Are you walking that back, and want to talk about loopholes now?

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @04:48AM (#15642060)
I consider forced repatriation to be a no-go. Others probably disagree with me, maybe even Tim Cook himself. IMO if you force companies to do something like that with their capital, then they won't incorporate in the US.

I do want to talk about loopholes. How do we close the "repatriation loophole"?

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by MichaelGG on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:54PM (#15638931)
Huawei and Samsung seem to be operating in the US just fine.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by opo on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:36PM (#15639233)
Oh, would you then also force Samsung to pay US taxes on all profits it made in Korea and elsewhere? The same for Huawei and the profits it makes in China?

For obvious reasons, no other developed country in the world has a corporate tax system like the US. We should try to reform it, not make it worse.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by MichaelGG on Monday November 06, 2017 @09:49PM (#15640727)
Exactly. I honestly do not understand how people think Apple is evading US taxes on overseas sales. Seems like any real way of taxing them on it will be a bad solution and advantage foreign companies.

A lower repatriation rate seems like a good idea to get money back into the US for local spending as well as collecting a bit in taxes.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by sliverstorm on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:03PM (#15638561)
This is like that lawsuit, I forget against whom, where the defendant was arguing he de facto didn't steal anything or commit any crimes because the server let him do it. (Nevermind he was exploiting the server)

There are no bugs, only features?

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by cmiles74 on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:33PM (#15638301)
I don't believe that this is accurate. Apple believes they are in compliance and at this time it appears the US federal government agrees. If the government was to disagree, they could take action and force Apple to comply with the existing tax laws. Apple would have their day in court and precedent would be set. Should Apple win that case, then we'd need to look into creating new laws.

I am not convinced that new laws are necessary, in fact, I think this just used to distract from the issue and to allow the polishing of that old chestnut about more laws creating more loopholes.

It is my opinion, but I do feel the argument that the problem is the law, and not the large corporations who can afford to flout them, is disingenuous. Apple is under no obligation to pay as little taxes as they can convince themselves is reasonable.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by kobeya on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:43PM (#15638379)
Companies have had days in court and presidents have been set, even if the name of the defendant was not Apple. This isn't some crazy scheme that Apple's accountants cooked up. Even when the dutch sandwich was new, it was still built from components that individually had case law backing them up.

You don't just get to reinterpret the law because you don't like what effects it has. The courts are only really able to interpret ambiguities. Where the law is clear (and it is pretty clear here), you need to change the laws.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by cmiles74 on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:57PM (#15638511)
That's pretty much all courts do: interpret the law. There's a lot of ambiguity here, hence all the push-back on Apple stowing profits offshore. In my opinion, the only case that can be made is that, in general, profits made outside of the US by corporations is not subject to tax. That is hardly the only issue being discussed, in fact, it strikes me as the most simplistic interpretation.

There are lots of other good questions, and it may not turn out to be the case that everything Apple has done is legal. For instance...

Is it legal for Apple to attribute all of their intellectual property to their Irish subsidiary?

Is it legal for Apple to avoid paying taxes in Ireland by sending the money to a fictitious head office with no physical location?

And so on and so forth.

https://blogs.wsj.com/briefly/2016/08/30/apples-irish-tax-bi...

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:52PM (#15638461)
Pure foolishness.

The law says “if you bring your foreign-earned profits abroad, you must pay taxes”. (I left it vague because I’m not an expert but my understanding is Apple would be responsible for around a 30% or higher tax rate).

Apple says, “okay we’re not going to bring the money back at that rate. Instead we’ll leave it invested in liquid assets abroad and take on cheap debt in the US to fund our share repurchases”.

So what’s your proposal? Forced repatriation? I hope it’s clear why that isn’t a good approach.

Our international tax code is completely fucked. Apple’s not the problem.

Full disclosure: My portfolio is heavily weighted towards Apple at an average cost of $120/share

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by cmiles74 on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:03PM (#15638563)
I don't think it's at all that straightforward. Apple has assigned intellectual property to their subsidiaries in Ireland and has used that as a way to direct profits out of the US. Is that legal? I am not an expert, but surely it is not straightforward.

Once profits collect in Ireland, Apple moves the profits to it's "head office", which not only is not in Ireland, it's not physical in any way. Thus they avoid the bulk of Irish taxes. The EU is suing Ireland and seem fairly serious, at least in this case it looks like Apple will pay some of the taxes, eventually.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-apple-taxavoidance-cou...

Is this the only way they are avoiding taxes? I strongly suspect it is not and that they are breaking the law in more than one case.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:49PM (#15640015)
Which issue are we discussing? The age old double dutch irish or whatever it's called, or tax repatriation?

I surmise that you're stating that the two are linked. That's fair. However isn't Apple already paying taxes on its US-sold goods?

This thread seems to specifically be about the repatriation side of things, and the only way to force repatriation is to...force repatriation.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by andrepd on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:08PM (#15638604)
>Forced repatriation? I hope it’s clear why that isn’t a good approach.

It isn't clear to me. Why is that?

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by anigbrowl on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:35PM (#15638319)
Apple spent ~$3.5 million on lobbying in the first 6 months of the Trump administration: https://9to5mac.com/2017/07/21/apple-trump-lobbying-increase...

How many times do we have to reiterate the point that large corporations and the people who own them spend a fortune on lobbying sitting politicians and bankrolling their election campaigns, and that the controls on such spending limits have been systematically dismantled over the years, in decisions like Citizens United, among others?

Trotting out these facile arguments like 'it's not corporations, it's the laws!' without acknowledging this point borders on trolling. Could you please do your fellow HNers the courtesy of acknowledging what they're actually saying instead of just repeating simplistic shallow comebacks?

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by quest88 on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:49PM (#15638436)
Where did the $3.5 go to?

> The company specifically outlined in its filing that a strong focus of its lobbying has been for immigration.

> In addition to immigration, Apple’s government filing indicates lobbying for climate change, patent reform, accessibility, health initiatives, diversity, and education.

Seems like worthwhile lobbying to me.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by anigbrowl on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:56PM (#15638494)
I'm not complaining about the existence of lobbying per se, I'm pointing out that they have the resources to lobby for special treatment and that companies in general shape the law by paying to influence lawmakers. Please don't obfuscate the point this way.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by andrepd on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:11PM (#15638628)
> In addition to immigration, Apple’s government filing indicates lobbying for climate change, patent reform, accessibility, health initiatives, diversity, and education.

Right. And we're supposed to eat that up. Why didn't they add happiness, rainbows, and kittens to that list.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:03PM (#15638566)
$3.5 million is absolutely nothing. Compare that figure to Apple’s yearly FCF (free cash flow)...
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by specialist on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:22PM (#15639129)
Letter of the law vs the spirit.

Play many board games? I have. With any sufficiently complicated ruleset, there are always cheats, exploits, holes.

To have a good time together, players often agree to play in the spirit of the game, vs the literal rules.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by deadmetheny on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:43PM (#15638849)
>it doesn't sound like this idea is going to be popular on hacker news, in spite of its blatant rationality

An hour later, this statement is proven hilariously accurate given the number of "rules as written having loopholes doesn't mean anyone's breaking the law" replies to this post.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by nautilus12 on Monday November 06, 2017 @09:44PM (#15640707)
Right?
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by whatok on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:45PM (#15637736)
Pretty sure Apple is following existing tax laws.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by PeterStuer on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:53PM (#15637830)
Pretty sure Apple and their 'class' is writing the existing tax laws.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by abritinthebay on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:36PM (#15638326)
Apple has actually argued for better tax laws (that they'd pay more under!) but the problem here is that the US is absolutely a complete anomaly in how it handles this issue.

It's literally cheaper for Apple to store the cash outside the US and then get loans for the money they can't bring into the country.

That's just wacky. For a country that is incredibly pro-business and pro-corporate the USA is very strange on this front.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by mrguyorama on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:04PM (#15637961)
That depends if you believe tax law should be about checkboxes or about keeping to the spirit of giving back to the community that made you
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by koenigdavidmj on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:16PM (#15638099)
Yes, I prefer a law where I can take a possible action and judge by the text whether that action is legal or not, rather than always trying to avoid pissing off a fickle public, like trying to avoid waking a husband who drinks too much so you don't get a black eye.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by sliverstorm on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:14PM (#15638650)
Except tax law is not always capable of being totally black and white. Have you ever had to work through small business or rental deductions on your taxes? Grey areas, grey areas everywhere, at least if you want to take all the deductions & credits you are entitled to. Nobody including the IRS can give you a black and white answer. (Repairs vs improvements, which are deducted differently, is a good toy example)

Part of this I think may actually be intentional, to prevent the accidental creation of technically-legal-but-obviously-exploitative loophole tax strategies. If it's fuzzy, you have to weight your risk of audit, your ability to justify your choice, and so on.

Anyway, in the corporate case there are also fundamentally difficult-to-define areas. For example:

Company A transfers its global IP portfolio to Subsidiary B. B is incorporated in Ireland, but is controlled and managed by directors based in a low corporate tax jurisdiction such as Bermuda, the Cayman Islands or Andorra; crucially, under Irish law, this characteristic renders B tax resident in these havens and therefore subject to their relevant tax legislation. Subsequently, B grants licences to exploit the IP portfolio to Subsidiary C which is incorporated and tax resident in Ireland; it is this link between two Irish subsidiaries which yielded the name “Double Irish”. C is the actual operative unit of the Company A: it owns real estate, it employs workers, it exploits the IP portfolio, it sells advertising and collects payments, ultimately generating earnings. Nevertheless, C does not make profits, as it has to pay royalties to B for the IP licences; crucially, B pays very little corporate taxes because it is based in a tax haven. Thus this structure allows A to shift all profits emerging from its IP portfolio to a jurisdiction where they will not be subject to a significant rate of taxation.

This scheme depends in part upon the ability of the company to set royalties and IP transfer costs at whatever they like, independent of the real value of the IP. Clearly this is not quite right, but what is the real value? Who determines it?

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by nautilus12 on Monday November 06, 2017 @09:33PM (#15640661)
This is exactly my point, if the company can create a complex web of interactions to the point that it creates a grey area at what point to we as a society throw our hands up, call a spade a spade and instead pursue a determination that they are clearing trying to avoid paying taxes, regardless of what the specific technical interpretation of the scenario they have set up.

For example, what if they said that the taxable location of the entity was a function of the output of a quantum state? This is a grey area, but is even this enough for us to say that they are clearly just trying to pull the wool over the governments eye?

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by madeofpalk on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:52PM (#15638463)
In our society, taxation laws are a system of rules. I think its important that if companies and people are following the law that they're then not held to some other second arbitrary standard.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by nautilus12 on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:06PM (#15637991)
mrguyorama I agree 1000% and most reasonable people should as well. The technical letter of the law should not matter as much as the spirit of the law!
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:52PM (#15640035)
The spirit of the law is not clearly defined. In fact, by definition it means "person X's interpretation of what the law was trying to achieve".

How could that be the basis for an intelligent taxation system?

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by lucio on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:51PM (#15639317)
Then you're at the mercy of the judge. That's a very bad scenario. With literal interpretation, the legal system is way more previsible.

What if the literal interpretation create unfair loopholes?

Then you change the law.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by nautilus12 on Monday November 06, 2017 @09:38PM (#15640679)
Not in this case. They have created a complex tax haven out of juggling around entities and IP's. We should NOT expect the law to have a specific technical description of this, and they shouldn't be around to get around the law just because they created a new scenario. In this case we should just use the obvious determination that its clearly they are trying to dodge taxes, rather than try to change to law to account for every possible scenario they could come up with.

Specific laws don't preclude the ability to use common sense and judgement, and the law shouldn't be expected to explicate every possible permutation in order to be enforceable.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by osteele on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:08PM (#15638606)
My understanding of the economics (via popular-press reporting [1,2]) is that corporate taxes are effectively paid by workers and shareholders.

In the case of Apple, many employees are high-income individuals. One way to tax them is to raise Apple's effective tax rate, by closing loopholes. Another would to move these individuals to a higher bracket, and tax them directly on income. The latter would allow the tax system to target only those employees who actually are high-income individuals. I don't know how that plays on Hacker News, but it doesn't seem to be politically feasible.

Apple's individual investors are probably mostly high-net-worth individuals. (Apple might have more non-rich investors than a blue chip like GE does. I know quite a few middle class individuals whose only outside of funds are in APPL or TSLA. They have brand loyalty even if [with TSLA] they don't own the product. It's like playing fantasy football.) (The individual investors with the greatest number of shares are super-high-net-worth, of course[3].) To a progressive, it seems fair to tax them more, which taxing Apple effectively does. Those individuals aren't going to pay taxes on stock appreciation unless the capital gains exemption is rolled back. Now that Apple is paying dividends instead of just appreciating, raising the income bracket could be an alternative to closing the loophole.

My understanding is that institutional investors in general are largely funds, endowments, and pensions. Apple seems to be mostly funds[4]. Funds are probably held by middle and middle-upper class individuals with mutuals or indices in their portfolios. (The poor don't own stocks. The rich own them directly.) The loophole benefits them. [Big disclaimer: I'm a novice in how to interpret this, and I wouldn't be surprised to be wrong.]

[1] "Who Pays the Corporate Income Tax", Bruce Bartlett, New York Times, Feb 19, 2013. https://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/02/19/who-pays-the-c...

[2] "Who Ultimately Pays the Corporate Income Tax?", Uwe E. Reinhardt (Economics @ Princeton), New York Times, July 23, 2010. https://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/07/23/who-ultimately...

[3] "Top Apple Shareholders for 2017", John Edwards, Investopedia, October 6, 2017. http://www.investopedia.com/articles/markets/120115/top-5-ap...

[4] "Apple Inc. Institutional Ownership", NASDAQ. http://www.nasdaq.com/symbol/aapl/institutional-holdings

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by exelius on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:51PM (#15637816)
As I look at schemes to prevent this, it's pretty obvious that a low gross tax rate on exported goods is a net positive for a nation. But that leaves the question of how/whether to tax companies with comparatively few exports (think of telecoms as an example, where the majority of a company's total capital is physically located and impossible to move).

I don't think there's much argument that a near-zero corporate tax rate is ideal; unfortunately wealthy individuals would simply take advantage of that to lower their individual taxes and the country would end up with a revenue crisis.

I would actually argue that the largest contributing factor to the success of the US over the last 80 years has been our ability to consistently collect tax revenue. Many other countries are not nearly as successful at enforcing and collecting on their tax code as the US is (but then, their tax agencies don't have nearly as much power as the IRS).

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by osteele on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:47PM (#15638422)
There actually is a fair amount of argument [1-4] that a near-zero corporate tax rate is ideal. [5-6] argue that it isn't.

(These are all, except [2], popular press articles. I imagine that there's more considered discussion in the academic literature.)

[1] "Six Policies Economists Love (And Politicians Hate)", Planet Money (podcast). http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/07/19/157047211/six-p.... This contains interviews with Dean Baker (co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research in Washington, D.C.); Russ Roberts (George Mason University economics professor); Katherine Baicker (professor of health economics at Harvard University's Department of Health Policy and Management); Luigi Zingales (professor of entrepreneurship and finance and the University of Chicago's Booth School of Business); and Robert Frank (professor of management and economics at Cornell University's Johnson Graduate School of Management).

[2] "Simulating the Elimination of the U.S. Corporate Income Tax", Hans Fehra, Sabine Jokischb, Ashwin Kambhampatic and Laurence J. Kotlikoff. NBER Working Paper No. 19757. Issued in December 2013, Revised in April 2014.

[3] "Abolish the Corporate Income Tax", Laurence J. Kotlikoff (Economics @ U. Boston), New York Times, Jan 5, 2014. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/06/opinion/abolish-the-corpo...

[4] "Let's Abolish The Corporate Income Tax", John C. Goodman, Forbes. Aug 26, 2014. https://www.forbes.com/sites/johngoodman/2014/08/26/lets-abo...

[5] "Why Do We Tax Corporations?: Wouldn't it be easier just to tax individuals?", Christopher Beam, Slate, Oct 17 2008. http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/20...

[6] "10 reasons we should tax corporations", Nicholas Shaxson, The Guardian, March 15 2011. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2011/mar/15/tax-co...

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by exelius on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:49PM (#15638888)
I'm speaking of a near-zero corporate tax rate more from a game theory perspective -- if you look at the game from the perspective of a central government, and your competitors are both the corporations and the other countries. In this case, your goal is to maximize tax revenue while minimizing "brain drain" and "legal" tax loop holes.

But regardless of what system we choose, wealth redistribution needs to be a primary goal before inequality reaches "torches and pitchforks" levels.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by tooltalk on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:48PM (#15638880)
Can you elaborate on Samsung and Huawei's favorable tax and public policies under which they operate? Are you saying that their tax rates rates are lower?
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by pasbesoin on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:58PM (#15639719)
This was offered/done around 2004-2005, with the proviso that it would be a one-time deal.

Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.

Investigate. Confiscate. Incarcerate.

I'm done with the "business" line of rhetoric.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by ali_af on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:48PM (#15638881)
Note that Cook has been vocal about repatriation and has suggested that it be mandatory to all corporations, then taxed specifically for infrastructure development.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by aagha on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @12:07PM (#15645163)
What's the benefit to Apple or anyone else if the money is here in the US?
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by oh_sigh on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:50PM (#15637803)
What exactly is that money doing right now? What would the ramifications be of transferring that money back into the US economy?
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by delinka on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:15PM (#15638664)
If you mean "back into the US," then indeed there is the potential to continue sitting on that money and maybe it won't enter the US economy.

If, however, you do mean to ask "...back into the US economy," then ... jobs. How they choose to place the money into the economy is definitely a question, but ultimately any use should indeed support employment of the labor force. Loan the money out? The borrower puts someone to work. Use it for R&D? Hire humans to perform the research.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by sliverstorm on Monday November 06, 2017 @07:29PM (#15640187)
Unless it's paid out in dividends and executive compensation and stock buybacks. Which is what happened with the last tax holiday under Bush.

https://theintercept.com/2017/04/27/bush-already-tried-trump...

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by delinka on Monday November 06, 2017 @08:24PM (#15640413)
I would argue that's not "...back to the US economy."
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by sliverstorm on Monday November 06, 2017 @09:35PM (#15640666)
Yes, exactly the point. Sorry.