News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by JumpCrisscross on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:46PM (#15637745)
> we should simply make large corporations like Apple actually follow the existing tax laws

Apple is in compliance with our tax laws. The laws, not Apple, are the underlying problem.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by nautilus12 on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:53PM (#15637836)
No, the spirit of the law is effectively being broken. Sidestepping the law does not constitute following it in my opinion. Laws are meant to be guidelines and legal precedent defines its true extent, you cannot make laws extensive enough to cover every scenario. If they make it illegal to offshore money then apple will simply find a way to establish a corporation on the moon. Its clearly demonstrable that they are going through great lengths to sidestep the law.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by c517402 on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:07PM (#15639017)
A product has its components fabricated in east Asia, is assembled in east Asia, sold in Europe, and the profits from the sale are held in Europe. Somehow you consider this “illegally offshoring money”. Somehow you think the US government deserves 34% of these profits. Apparently, the spirit of the law being violated is that the US government has the right to stick it’s nose in anyplace in the world it wants and extract rent.

At a physics conference Wolfgang Pauli heard a talk that was so misguided that his comment was that “it wasn’t even wrong.” IMO your comment isn’t even wrong.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by revelation on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:07PM (#15639780)
I don't think the US government deserves 34% of these profits, but some country out there does. Make it point of sale, if you want.

But right now that money isn't taxed at all. That money is what the Irish subsidiary owes Apple US for the license to Apple IP. So the Irish subsidiary isn't paying taxes on it, and Apple isn't paying taxes on it in the US because they are refusing to "bring it home".

That is why Apple is lobbying so hard for some sort of "tax holiday". They want to pay 0, nada tax on those overseas profits.

You seem to be missing this little detail.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by vixen99 on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:31PM (#15638278)
A British judge, Lord Hoffman commented ‘The only way in which Parliament can express an intention to impose a tax is by a statute that means that such a tax is to be imposed,’.

In other words, for tax there is no distinction between the spirit and letter of the law. They’re one and the same.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by Marazan on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:01PM (#15638550)
Except the General Anti Avoidance Rule flatly contradicts that.

The GAAR takes the spirit of the law into consideration when considering whether the law has been broken.

The Ramsey Principle (first stated with respect to a case governing circular transactions) also raises the spirit of the tax law being superior to the strict rules based interpretation.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by gsnedders on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:44PM (#15638391)
English law has three typical means of statutory interpretation: the literal rule (where you literally apply the letter of the law), the mischief rule (where the defendant is clearly guilty of the mischief that the law was intended to address), and the golden rule (where you reinterpret as necessary to avoid an absurd result).

That said, when it comes to most tax law the mischief rule doesn't apply (because in principle it needs to be dealing with a limitation of the common law). The golden rule rarely comes into play with tax law (though consider the case of murdering a parent and the consequences on inheritance tax, for example). So yeah, the literal rule almost always applies.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:01PM (#15638549)
Let’s keep it concrete.

Should we force companies to repatriate all foreign-earned profits?

If yes, then the US will lose its economic advantage. No international company would be insane enough to incorporate in the US.

If no, then we have our current situation.

IMO the tax law itself is broken, not Apple’s response to asinine laws. Remember that Apple has not violated the law. I also agree with the comment you replied to - for tax law, there should not be a difference between the law and the intent. What is written is what needs to be followed. And right now Apple is following it to the letter of the law.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by crdoconnor on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:52PM (#15639325)
>In other words, for tax there is no distinction between the spirit and letter of the law.

HMRC's essentially disagreed with the spirit was being followed in this case and Google paid up:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-35381130

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by charlesdm on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:11PM (#15638633)
it's hard enough to interpret the letter of the law sometimes (i.e. ambiguous situations). You might as well have random or no laws then if you have to reflect about the fact whether you're breaking the "spirit of the law". This would mean different things to different people, and things are complex enough as they are.

Also, the spirit of the law argument seems more like a pass to politicians for doing crappy legislative work. If you make proper laws, this shouldn't be an issue.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by abritinthebay on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:34PM (#15638307)
> If they make it illegal to offshore money...

... then the US would immediately end up losing all it's multinational companies to less insane countries.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by vkou on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:00PM (#15638969)
Is Apple going to pack up and move 50,000 people from Cupertino to the Cayman Islands?
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by abritinthebay on Thursday November 09, 2017 @12:04PM (#15663992)
Apple might not, but we were talking in general
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by anigbrowl on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:37PM (#15638334)
Prove it. I think companies like being in the US because of the sophisticated capital markets, strong and predictable legal environment, and deep pockets of American consumers. I'd like some evidence instead of hyperbole.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:57PM (#15638506)
How about you provide the evidence? If US makes it defacto illegal to operate internationally as a US-based company, the US will lose its economic moat within a matter of decades [citation needed, I know]

I’m not a tax expert but IME the people who are blaming Apple don’t know what they’re talking about. Only the US has such an insane attitude towards international profits.

And remember that there’s no loophole to close, unless the “loophole” is deciding what to do with your capital. Who is the US to tell Apple that its foreign subsidiaries must return their foreign-made profits back to the US?

Also remember that with our current laws, repatriating the money before a tax holiday is arguably a violation of Apple’s fiduciary duty to its shareholders.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by anigbrowl on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:06PM (#15638592)
The person making the claim has the burden of proof.

Maybe repeating a string of specious arguments that have already been debunked or refuted elsewhere in the thread isn't the best approach for your brand-new HN account.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:46PM (#15639997)
Debunked/refuted where?

I admit I haven't provided much in the way of evidence. However we're talking about a complicated tax situation so it's hard to stick to the concrete.

Do you agree that the only way to "close the loophole" is to force companies to repatriate their earnings? I don't see another way to address it.

Right now the issue is that iff Apple repatriates its money, it must pay taxes. So Apple has been fulfilling their fiduciary obligations by opting not to repatriate (which would destroy 30%+ of the value, I don't know the actual number but I believe I am being conservative), instead choosing to take on cheap debt domestically to fund share repurchases.

Thus I don't see a "solution" to the "loophole" (obviously I don't believe it's a loophole because it's the law) that doesn't involve forced repatriation.

If there's something wrong with what I've said or something I haven't considered, I'm all ears.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by Frondo on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:10PM (#15638618)
No one is saying the US would make it illegal to operate an international company.

They're looking for ways to close some of these loopholes that are keeping a ton of tax money out of the coffers belonging to We the People.

Please don't conflate "closing tax loopholes" with "making it illegal to operate internationally".

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:47PM (#15640007)
Please define the specific tax loophole.

The "loophole" as far as I can tell is that a company can choose not to repatriate their earnings, which is completely legal.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by Frondo on Monday November 06, 2017 @09:12PM (#15640570)
You were saying "make it de facto illegal to operate a multinational" and that is not on the table and has never been anywhere close to it.

Are you walking that back, and want to talk about loopholes now?

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @04:48AM (#15642060)
I consider forced repatriation to be a no-go. Others probably disagree with me, maybe even Tim Cook himself. IMO if you force companies to do something like that with their capital, then they won't incorporate in the US.

I do want to talk about loopholes. How do we close the "repatriation loophole"?

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by MichaelGG on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:54PM (#15638931)
Huawei and Samsung seem to be operating in the US just fine.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by opo on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:36PM (#15639233)
Oh, would you then also force Samsung to pay US taxes on all profits it made in Korea and elsewhere? The same for Huawei and the profits it makes in China?

For obvious reasons, no other developed country in the world has a corporate tax system like the US. We should try to reform it, not make it worse.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by MichaelGG on Monday November 06, 2017 @09:49PM (#15640727)
Exactly. I honestly do not understand how people think Apple is evading US taxes on overseas sales. Seems like any real way of taxing them on it will be a bad solution and advantage foreign companies.

A lower repatriation rate seems like a good idea to get money back into the US for local spending as well as collecting a bit in taxes.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by sliverstorm on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:03PM (#15638561)
This is like that lawsuit, I forget against whom, where the defendant was arguing he de facto didn't steal anything or commit any crimes because the server let him do it. (Nevermind he was exploiting the server)

There are no bugs, only features?

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by cmiles74 on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:33PM (#15638301)
I don't believe that this is accurate. Apple believes they are in compliance and at this time it appears the US federal government agrees. If the government was to disagree, they could take action and force Apple to comply with the existing tax laws. Apple would have their day in court and precedent would be set. Should Apple win that case, then we'd need to look into creating new laws.

I am not convinced that new laws are necessary, in fact, I think this just used to distract from the issue and to allow the polishing of that old chestnut about more laws creating more loopholes.

It is my opinion, but I do feel the argument that the problem is the law, and not the large corporations who can afford to flout them, is disingenuous. Apple is under no obligation to pay as little taxes as they can convince themselves is reasonable.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by kobeya on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:43PM (#15638379)
Companies have had days in court and presidents have been set, even if the name of the defendant was not Apple. This isn't some crazy scheme that Apple's accountants cooked up. Even when the dutch sandwich was new, it was still built from components that individually had case law backing them up.

You don't just get to reinterpret the law because you don't like what effects it has. The courts are only really able to interpret ambiguities. Where the law is clear (and it is pretty clear here), you need to change the laws.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by cmiles74 on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:57PM (#15638511)
That's pretty much all courts do: interpret the law. There's a lot of ambiguity here, hence all the push-back on Apple stowing profits offshore. In my opinion, the only case that can be made is that, in general, profits made outside of the US by corporations is not subject to tax. That is hardly the only issue being discussed, in fact, it strikes me as the most simplistic interpretation.

There are lots of other good questions, and it may not turn out to be the case that everything Apple has done is legal. For instance...

Is it legal for Apple to attribute all of their intellectual property to their Irish subsidiary?

Is it legal for Apple to avoid paying taxes in Ireland by sending the money to a fictitious head office with no physical location?

And so on and so forth.

https://blogs.wsj.com/briefly/2016/08/30/apples-irish-tax-bi...

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:52PM (#15638461)
Pure foolishness.

The law says “if you bring your foreign-earned profits abroad, you must pay taxes”. (I left it vague because I’m not an expert but my understanding is Apple would be responsible for around a 30% or higher tax rate).

Apple says, “okay we’re not going to bring the money back at that rate. Instead we’ll leave it invested in liquid assets abroad and take on cheap debt in the US to fund our share repurchases”.

So what’s your proposal? Forced repatriation? I hope it’s clear why that isn’t a good approach.

Our international tax code is completely fucked. Apple’s not the problem.

Full disclosure: My portfolio is heavily weighted towards Apple at an average cost of $120/share

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by cmiles74 on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:03PM (#15638563)
I don't think it's at all that straightforward. Apple has assigned intellectual property to their subsidiaries in Ireland and has used that as a way to direct profits out of the US. Is that legal? I am not an expert, but surely it is not straightforward.

Once profits collect in Ireland, Apple moves the profits to it's "head office", which not only is not in Ireland, it's not physical in any way. Thus they avoid the bulk of Irish taxes. The EU is suing Ireland and seem fairly serious, at least in this case it looks like Apple will pay some of the taxes, eventually.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-apple-taxavoidance-cou...

Is this the only way they are avoiding taxes? I strongly suspect it is not and that they are breaking the law in more than one case.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:49PM (#15640015)
Which issue are we discussing? The age old double dutch irish or whatever it's called, or tax repatriation?

I surmise that you're stating that the two are linked. That's fair. However isn't Apple already paying taxes on its US-sold goods?

This thread seems to specifically be about the repatriation side of things, and the only way to force repatriation is to...force repatriation.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by andrepd on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:08PM (#15638604)
>Forced repatriation? I hope it’s clear why that isn’t a good approach.

It isn't clear to me. Why is that?

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by anigbrowl on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:35PM (#15638319)
Apple spent ~$3.5 million on lobbying in the first 6 months of the Trump administration: https://9to5mac.com/2017/07/21/apple-trump-lobbying-increase...

How many times do we have to reiterate the point that large corporations and the people who own them spend a fortune on lobbying sitting politicians and bankrolling their election campaigns, and that the controls on such spending limits have been systematically dismantled over the years, in decisions like Citizens United, among others?

Trotting out these facile arguments like 'it's not corporations, it's the laws!' without acknowledging this point borders on trolling. Could you please do your fellow HNers the courtesy of acknowledging what they're actually saying instead of just repeating simplistic shallow comebacks?

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by quest88 on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:49PM (#15638436)
Where did the $3.5 go to?

> The company specifically outlined in its filing that a strong focus of its lobbying has been for immigration.

> In addition to immigration, Apple’s government filing indicates lobbying for climate change, patent reform, accessibility, health initiatives, diversity, and education.

Seems like worthwhile lobbying to me.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by anigbrowl on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:56PM (#15638494)
I'm not complaining about the existence of lobbying per se, I'm pointing out that they have the resources to lobby for special treatment and that companies in general shape the law by paying to influence lawmakers. Please don't obfuscate the point this way.
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by andrepd on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:11PM (#15638628)
> In addition to immigration, Apple’s government filing indicates lobbying for climate change, patent reform, accessibility, health initiatives, diversity, and education.

Right. And we're supposed to eat that up. Why didn't they add happiness, rainbows, and kittens to that list.

Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by __blockcipher__ on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:03PM (#15638566)
$3.5 million is absolutely nothing. Compare that figure to Apple’s yearly FCF (free cash flow)...
Re:How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax p... by specialist on Monday November 06, 2017 @04:22PM (#15639129)
Letter of the law vs the spirit.

Play many board games? I have. With any sufficiently complicated ruleset, there are always cheats, exploits, holes.

To have a good time together, players often agree to play in the spirit of the game, vs the literal rules.