News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by barsonme on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @03:59PM (#15553583)
Other than using the federal lands more _and_ contacting your representatives (via phone!!) to express your support for keeping public federal lands, yes, donate.

While your money probably won't be ill-spent with your run-of-the-mill environmental groups, I'd really recommend searching out right-leaning groups that support public federal lands, like the American Conservation Coalition (https://acc.eco).

Sadly, the right has—for a variety of reasons—all but abandoned environmentalism and that's been a major hurdle for those of us who want to protect the environment. Eco-right groups have a _much_ better shot at changing the opinions of right-leaning folk than progressive groups like the Sierra Club do.

Full disclosure: I'm one of ACC's 42 unpaid volunteers.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by davidw on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:15PM (#15553750)
Interesting. What kinds of things has your group accomplished?

I'm not a conservative, but the Sierra Club will never see a dime from me until they lay off mountain bikers. It seems so stupid to antagonize a group that could share about 99% of what they want to accomplish.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by 24gttghh on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:11PM (#15554314)
Please correct me if I am wrong, but I thought the Sierra Club only opposed mtn biking in designated Wilderness Areas, which only make up 36M out of 192M NFS acerage.[0] (That's 145,000 km^2 out of 780,000 km^2)

Those areas really should just be left alone as much as possible. The White Mountain National Forest doesn't even like expanding or maintaining the leantos in much of their Wilderness Areas, so it's not like Mtn biking is singled out in my area. FWIW I love mountain biking and helping to build singletrack as much as possible, but I also like visiting the sublimely quiet wilderness areas with only my own two feet as my way into those natural cathedrals.

[0]https://www.fs.fed.us/land/staff/lar/LAR2011/LAR2011_Book_A5...

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by davidw on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:56PM (#15554639)
They've been pretty consistently anti MTB over the years.

There are absolutely wilderness areas where there should not be bikes, but it should be decided locally, just as certain trails outside of wilderness areas are, justly, hiker only.

For instance, this is a Wilderness area east of Bend, Oregon. It is not, however a "wilderness" - indeed many of the trails are former jeep roads:

https://www.google.com/maps/@44.0008533,-121.0058259,13154m/...

And don't forget: you can legally ride a string of horses into a Wilderness area, shoot an elk with a rifle and pack it out. To my way of thinking, riding a bike around is not nearly so impactful.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by njarboe on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @08:00PM (#15555334)
Give me bikes over horses every day. Not sure exactly why hiking in a bit of horseshit, here and there, bothers me so much. I think it mostly is that I imagine that when you are on a horse you are much higher off the trail and don't have to deal with the stink your horse created.
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by mikestew on Thursday October 26, 2017 @02:51AM (#15556903)
The shit is the least of it, as horses will pound a trail to dust. How anyone argues with a straight face that MTBs are more impactful than horses is beyond my comprehension.
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by njarboe on Thursday October 26, 2017 @11:35AM (#15559823)
Yes. If you are hiking behind someone, lots of dust. Horse shit in the dust. Not very pleasant. In conditions like that I hope for a little rain.
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by davidw on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:46PM (#15556203)
I'm happy to share, and happy for local decision makers to decide which users should get access to which trails. There are some that even hikers damage, let alone adding bikes and horses. Others are fine for everyone. Some places (not in Wilderness areas) should have some room for ATV people and so on.

I guess besides being a housing YIMBY, I'm a trail YIMBY too.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by 24gttghh on Thursday October 26, 2017 @08:16AM (#15558174)
The Oregon Badlands Wilderness you have pointed out seems very much wild to me. As a counterpoint, much of the WMNF in NH/ME was formerly logged, and there are remnant logging tracks (as opposed to jeep roads) scattered throughout, including in the wilderness areas. Eventually those jeep tracks will be just as unrecognizable as our logging tracks.

There are so many other places to ride and build trail, maybe we should just leave the wilderness areas alone.

The whole point of the wilderness areas is to halt further development in them. Those jeep roads were probably there before the area was "designated wilderness", as was the custom of horseback riding and hunting. Mountain biking wasn't a thing yet.

Oregon Badlands brochure for those interested:

https://www.blm.gov/or/districts/prineville/recreation/files...

Honestly most of that place seems really sandy, which isn't conducive to mountain biking in my mind.

One more thing. Many of these policies of no MTB were put in place before the advent of more sustainable trailbuilding practices were developed. Get out there and advocate for hardened, twisty, flowy, long-lasting singletrack!

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by davidw on Thursday October 26, 2017 @12:48PM (#15560616)
That Badlands place would certainly not the best riding around (it'd maybe be good in the winter), but it's really not 'wild' feeling at all and is a good example of Wilderness != wilderness.

> maybe we should just leave the wilderness areas alone.

Except that brings into conflict mountain bikers with the idea of expanding wilderness areas. Wouldn't we rather have more areas protected like that? As it stands, mountain bikers who are environmentalists face an agonizing choice between protecting the land in that way, and their access to trails.

That's not hypothetical, either:

https://www.singletracks.com/blog/mtb-news/oregon-crater-lak...

See also the Boulder-White Clouds wilderness in Idaho that closed a bunch of trails that mountain bikers were already riding.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by 24gttghh on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:05PM (#15561997)
What doesn't feel wild about it? 29,000 acres seem like a big enough place to get lost in and feel wild. For example, I've camped in the Presidential-Dry River Wilderness (also 29,000 acres) in the WMNF, and I have to say, even camping a half mile inside the area I felt like I could have been hundreds of miles from the nearest person. Being up over 4000 feet probably helps too...

I've never considered that wilderness areas were even being expanded on such a scale, let alone that it would be an issue. I will have to think about it now...I feel like if I could triple the amount of area that would be let to go wild, but lose mountain biking access in the process, that I'd be willing to accept the gain in wilderness with a loss in biking. I've done very little biking on any federal land to begin with. Most has either been on private land or town-organized easements.

To be fair, anywhere I've mountain-biked is nowhere close to being as remote as places out West. Maybe there is enough wilderness area in the West, but not enough here in the Northeast. That may be my perspective.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by davidw on Friday October 27, 2017 @12:32AM (#15565724)
Yeah, this is an actual wild Wilderness with lots of high, remote places, and 10X the area of the other one.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Sisters_Wilderness

Plenty of trails are also not suitable, nor maybe even really feasible for bikes.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by barsonme on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:34PM (#15553965)
We have a few different ways we're approaching this. In no particular order we:

1) Work with college republicans to introduce them to environmentalism. We saw lots of success here during National Clean Energy Week where we held events and had 20 CR chairs sign on to our clean energy pledge (https://www.acc.eco/cr-clean-energy-coalition) and we have 25 pilot campuses we're partnering with. We hope to more than double that number next year.

2) Are growing the climate solutions caucus. We've met with members of congress and support those who are pro-environment.

3) Have a policy newsletter with policy research

4) Work with city and county county officials to assist with their environmental policy. (This one has been my favorite to watch take off.)

and plenty more.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by davidw on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:10PM (#15554299)
> 4) Work with city and county county officials to assist with their environmental policy. (This one has been my favorite to watch take off.)

This one is so ripe for bipartisanship:

https://www.brookings.edu/research/reforming-land-use-regula...

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by barsonme on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:28PM (#15554443)
It's been so awesome to local politicians from across the political spectrum message us and say, "Hey, what we're doing isn't working, do you have advice?"

People are so much more invested in their own community and open to tangible solutions.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by davidw on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:46PM (#15554569)
Are you familiar with Strong Towns?

https://www.strongtowns.org/

They're good people, non-partisan, and also very much in line with "something isn't working":

https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2015/1/7/americas-suburb...

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by barsonme on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @06:00PM (#15554675)
I personally am not, but will definitely run it by some people. At first blush this looks really neat. Thanks for sharing!
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by clumsysmurf on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:20PM (#15553796)
They have a different definition of environmentalism

“True environmentalism, from my perspective, is using natural resources that God has blessed us with,” Pruitt told the Heritage Foundation last week.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by barsonme on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:40PM (#15554051)
Thankfully Mr. Pruitt does not speak for the ACC. Our view on public lands:

    In order to protect America’s natural resources and wildlife, the federal
    government ought to retain ownership of the majority of its federal lands.
    Preventing the sale of federal lands to interests contrary to their
    preservation requires citizens to hold officials accountable at every level
    of government.
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by nickik on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @09:02PM (#15555562)
I don't think 'the right' (whatever that means) has abandoned the environment.

At least libertarians have not.

Check out www.perc.org, these are free market people who are extremely passionate about the environment and they are quite popular and have made great inroads to provide an alternative way of thinking about the environment compared to the leftist big government bureaucracy style of protecting it.

They support great projects like Oregon Water Trust, The Nature Conservancy and do research on how to think in an economically sensible way about these questions.

Here some cool videos, Terry Anderson about Wildlife in Yellow-Stone and about the history of property rights in Montana.

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DBcpal2le2Y

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jPrzUwl0suM

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by wandernotlost on Thursday October 26, 2017 @01:50AM (#15556675)
PERC is partly the subject of the article:

PERC’s affiliation with politically connected outfitters that stand to profit if trails are closed bolsters the sense, to Wilson and others confronting locked gates, that a void in coherent policy about public land management is being filled by cronyism that rewards wealth and connections above all else. Another co-owner of the Wonder Ranch, Frank-Paul King, a friend and former student of Anderson’s, served on PERC’s board. Hudson, the man who got Representative Sessions involved, is King’s brother-in-law, and he’s also a board member and the former president of the Dallas Safari Club, a group that made national headlines in 2014 when it auctioned off a trip to Africa to hunt an endangered rhinoceros.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by nickik on Thursday October 26, 2017 @05:22AM (#15557449)
I read the article. I just wanted to show that they do more then just what is in the article, because the article points them in a pretty particular way, whatever your opinion of the article is.
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by barsonme on Thursday October 26, 2017 @12:52AM (#15556437)
We at ACC like PERC :-) And we do partner with other eco-right groups: https://www.acc.eco/founding-coalition/

Obviously I'm generalizing a bit, but I don't think it's unfair to say the right has lagged far behind on environmental issues since at least the '80s.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by jdhn on Thursday October 26, 2017 @08:54AM (#15558351)
I'm kind of late to the game, but what do you think about RepublicEn[0]?

[0] www.republicen.org

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by barsonme on Thursday October 26, 2017 @01:33PM (#15561132)
They're great! And Bob was one of our first supporters.

[0] https://twitter.com/republicEn/status/918153164146266112

[1] https://www.acc.eco/endorsements/

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by kharms on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:15PM (#15553749)
Why do you recommend seeking out right-leaning groups?
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by barsonme on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:19PM (#15553789)
Lots of environmental issues get tied up in a debate that usually goes like:

    Left: "Issue X is a problem"
    Right: "No it's not"
    Left: " ... "
...and repeats ad nauseam. If the right was more open to solving environmental issues, we wouldn't have these issues and the debate could be about policy, not the existence of the issue itself.

Right-leaning groups already have an "in" with the right and will naturally be better at educating and convincing the right than left-leaning groups.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by cbcoutinho on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:32PM (#15553944)
I would recommend right-leaning groups as well, but that's mostly because of the hunting communities are usually associated with the actual 'use' of public lands, and have been supporting most of the ecological/wildlife research. There's recently been a big push towards historically sustainable wildlife systems, and that's a topic that resonates with most of the more conservative hunting communities.
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by dbcurtis on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:43PM (#15554083)
Yup. A lot of people don't want to admit that hunters were the original conservationists. And also, a lot of non-hunters don't support hunting-oriented conservation methods. For instance, just because you buy a duck stamp it doesn't mean you have to go duck hunting. Duck stamps support the preservation of duck habitat and other wetlands. Buying a duck stamp is an easy way to directly contribute targetted money to wetlands preservation. Just for an example.
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by cbcoutinho on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:15AM (#15556968)
Yea this is exactly what I was talking about. Buying a fishing tag or a hunting tag is also an excellent way to get money directly into the hands of those who work in environmental conservation
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by eonw on Thursday October 26, 2017 @05:28AM (#15557474)
hunters originally only wanted to 'preserve' what they wanted to kill... otherwise we'd still have wolves, grizzlies, and other predators of all sizes, at their historic populations. likewise, certain hunters favorites wouldn't be dealing with population issues now. the ranchers have done the most harm though, they seem to want to kill everything, imo.
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by cdoxsey on Thursday October 26, 2017 @05:49AM (#15557544)
Ironically one of the consequences of strict laws protecting endangered species is it actually leads to more destruction not less. A rancher notices a protected animal on his land and gets rid of it to avoid getting harangued by the government. "Shoot, Shovel and Shutup"
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by dbcurtis on Thursday October 26, 2017 @05:20PM (#15563119)
Not entirely. In practice, the net result is that hunters want to preserve habitat. The large predator species that you mention require a huge range. It is the fragmentation of habitat that has done them in as much as anything else.
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by djrogers on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:53PM (#15555306)
warning - generalizations ahead

Progressives tend to already support/buy in to conservation issues, so reaching and tapping In to the political right is where you can get the most bang for your buck.

The obvious question is why can’t other groups reach the conservative environmentalists? Some progressive leaning environmentalist groups embrace ideals which can be at odds with conservative views, while only being tangential to important things like wilderness conservation. Some progressive leaning environmental groups use ‘evil conservatives’ as a fund raising meme. Some simply identify as progressive and don’t leave any room for conservatives.

Truth is, in a huge chunk of this great nation, the people that enjoy, visit, and use national wilderness the most are conservative. They’re hunters and multi-generation farmers and ranchers. Sure, one of them might leave a beer bottle on the ground behind their skyjacked F250, but if they caught you poaching a doe out of season there’d be hell to pay.

Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by steauengeglase on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:53PM (#15554161)
Because they are a bit of an untapped resource. The right are more likely to be open to conservation efforts rather than traditional crunchy environmental efforts, but they too often feel driven out.
Re:The fight over preserving public land takes a twist in Mo... by sliverstorm on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:21PM (#15554384)
The right controls the government today. The right listens to right-leaning hunting groups a lot more than left-leaning conservation groups. See Chaffetz's rescinded bill from earlier this year.