There are absolutely wilderness areas where there should not be bikes, but it should be decided locally, just as certain trails outside of wilderness areas are, justly, hiker only.
For instance, this is a Wilderness area east of Bend, Oregon. It is not, however a "wilderness" - indeed many of the trails are former jeep roads:
https://www.google.com/maps/@44.0008533,-121.0058259,13154m/...
And don't forget: you can legally ride a string of horses into a Wilderness area, shoot an elk with a rifle and pack it out. To my way of thinking, riding a bike around is not nearly so impactful.
I guess besides being a housing YIMBY, I'm a trail YIMBY too.
There are so many other places to ride and build trail, maybe we should just leave the wilderness areas alone.
The whole point of the wilderness areas is to halt further development in them. Those jeep roads were probably there before the area was "designated wilderness", as was the custom of horseback riding and hunting. Mountain biking wasn't a thing yet.
Oregon Badlands brochure for those interested:
https://www.blm.gov/or/districts/prineville/recreation/files...
Honestly most of that place seems really sandy, which isn't conducive to mountain biking in my mind.
One more thing. Many of these policies of no MTB were put in place before the advent of more sustainable trailbuilding practices were developed. Get out there and advocate for hardened, twisty, flowy, long-lasting singletrack!
> maybe we should just leave the wilderness areas alone.
Except that brings into conflict mountain bikers with the idea of expanding wilderness areas. Wouldn't we rather have more areas protected like that? As it stands, mountain bikers who are environmentalists face an agonizing choice between protecting the land in that way, and their access to trails.
That's not hypothetical, either:
https://www.singletracks.com/blog/mtb-news/oregon-crater-lak...
See also the Boulder-White Clouds wilderness in Idaho that closed a bunch of trails that mountain bikers were already riding.
I've never considered that wilderness areas were even being expanded on such a scale, let alone that it would be an issue. I will have to think about it now...I feel like if I could triple the amount of area that would be let to go wild, but lose mountain biking access in the process, that I'd be willing to accept the gain in wilderness with a loss in biking. I've done very little biking on any federal land to begin with. Most has either been on private land or town-organized easements.
To be fair, anywhere I've mountain-biked is nowhere close to being as remote as places out West. Maybe there is enough wilderness area in the West, but not enough here in the Northeast. That may be my perspective.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Sisters_Wilderness
Plenty of trails are also not suitable, nor maybe even really feasible for bikes.
Those areas really should just be left alone as much as possible. The White Mountain National Forest doesn't even like expanding or maintaining the leantos in much of their Wilderness Areas, so it's not like Mtn biking is singled out in my area. FWIW I love mountain biking and helping to build singletrack as much as possible, but I also like visiting the sublimely quiet wilderness areas with only my own two feet as my way into those natural cathedrals.
[0]https://www.fs.fed.us/land/staff/lar/LAR2011/LAR2011_Book_A5...