I have three pairs of driving glasses, a pair for running,a rimless pair, and a pair for use at work. They are all from Zenni and were all bought 4 to 6 years ago. They have various levels of tinting from none to fairly dark. Antireflection and antiscratch coating were standard. The most expensive was $30.
I would like to buy some new glasses from Zenni, but my optometric prescription has not changed and the frames and lenses are still in ridiculously good shape.
I rejoiced when my work glasses has a nasal bridge fall off. Unfortunately, I found that I was able to repair it in a few seconds.
So despite the pittance that it costs, I still use these old glasses. Perhaps if I carefully drop some dumbbells on them.... :-)
What's the cost of your hearing aids?
How many 'hearphones' could you have for, say, 50% of that cost.
10 hour of hearing seems close enough to a day's usage, perhaps a bit shy but probably not by much. Certainly two recharged pairs should see you through a day.
How much charge do they need - or rather, what's the size of a recharge battery pack, and how would you compare the cap-ex of your hearing aids versus the cost /convenience trade-offs of an alternative?
Rather, the problem is that people are currently going without because hearing aids can cost as much as a used car. And the batteries - which do last longer, yes - are one-time-use instead of rechargeable.
Given the choice between recharging something in the middle of the day that costs $20 to a few hundred dollars, or theoretically having multi-day battery life with hearing aids that you can't afford, the former is an easy sacrifice to make.
I wasn't suggesting that people only be allowed to hear for ten hours out of every twenty-four.
As noted in the sentence that followed that one you reacted to, I went on to write:
"Certainly two recharged pairs should see you through a day."
TFA, and parent, is about how danged expensive hearing aids <tm> are -- while parent is all about the alternative of 'hearphones' that are around US$500 (about 1/6th of what hearing aids cost in Australia).
(I worry that the smartphone / bluetooth connectivity is too complicated for tech-averse elderly, and that the inline volume controls are too small for arthritic hands. But I like the idea and I love my own QC25s.)
These are pricey though (around 200 EUR), but definitely cheaper than hearing loss.
Etymotic https://amzn.com/dp/B0015WJQ7A
The great thing about my hearing aids is I put them in and I can ignore them. Unless I'm swapping batteries, which is infrequent enough, I don't even notice I'm wearing them.
Yeah, my hearing aids were expensive. Yes, insurance doesn't usually pitch in at all for hearing aids unless there's surgery required (BAHA, cochlear, etc). It's worth it. The alternatives are toys that get in the way of just going about your normal life.
> Unless I'm swapping batteries, which is infrequent enough, I don't even notice I'm wearing them.
Presumably when you're swapping batteries, you're not actually wearing them, no?
Anyway, I think you have missed the points being made. For people who can't afford, or don't have access to the services around, hearing aids, consultancy, replacement batteries, and so on, there's an alternative.
A more exaggerated example: Someone who is nearsighted using their smartphone to look at more distant objects. Sure, it works, but it's not exactly practical.
The fact that they are cheaper means that they are a substitute for hearing aids.
They may not be quite as good right now ... but we've been over the affordability aspect already.
For people without access to USD $5k for hearing aids, a 'poor substitute' may be a perfectly reasonable alternative.
- mics
- DSPs
- drivers (speakers)
- custom wireless chipset
- batteries
i.e. all of the stuff that you need to build a regular HA. The differences are that:
- they have shorter battery life (but a lower capacity battery)
- built in larger quantities
- not 'medical grade'
Telecoil doesn't add significantly to the cost, but it does use a bit of internal volume. They are incredibly useful and are not going away anytime soon.
It's not like you need the 2017 model of HA; for most people the 2000 model would be just fine, and (for the company) the costs of IC development and regulatory have long been recovered. ASICs are expensive to produce, but not that expensive that it adds thousands to the COGS.
The real reason is simple market forces: people will pay a lot of money for healthcare. Insurance coverage in the target market determines much of the price.
That's the whole ball game in electronics.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Headphones#Balanced_armature
Sonion
Knowles
Molex
Bellsing
and supposedly sony creates(used to create) some
And probably some others I don't know about.
Some of them cost that much yeah, but not all of them. Nowadays you can get 10BA(though it's more likely 5 doubles each side from china for $600). There are a few exceptions like noble audio that are premium priced with custom units, but most people use factory devices.
You can get 3 BA sub 100 iems on aliexpress. Are they good? sometimes, but the point is I would say there's an audio revolution going on that is hardly noticeable unless you're actively watching it.
See, one balanced armature transducer will cost you about this much. Electronics is not the problem, power requirements and miniature size are. In a hearing aid, the main power cost is the transducers (including MEMS microphones) and amplifiers.
BA transducers are so expensive because only 3 companies make them. (Knowles, Sonion and one other I do not remember off the top of head.) Only a few more make MEMS microphones.
This is also on the verge or actually nanotechnology which is why Chinese manufacturers couldn't get in.
Trying to use a dynamic driver or microphone instead will cost you about half of battery life and will be larger.
I'm pretty sure there is space for disruption here.
[0] : https://www.digikey.com/product-detail/en/knowles/SPW2430HR5...
The space requires micromechanical research and manufacturing expertise. Good luck "disrupting" it.
- Far too big
- Requires about 1/3 of the entire power budget
> I'm pretty sure there is space for disruption here.
[hackernews noises]
If they are 1/10th the cost, then the number of people that could benefit goes up tremendously. I'm sure lots of people would accept having two sets that they have to charge every night if the alternative is not having any.
Does it also work when the source of noise is a crowd? I'm near-deaf on one side, which has the side-effect of not being able to isolate voices.
Source: I work in the industry.
If a doctor prescribed you hearing aids, could you get the Bluetooth kind instead, and still have them covered by your insurance? Or is this like the Epi-pen/Adrenaclick thing?
However, Grogenaut has also misread Mgerdts's comment to some extent, as when Mgerdts mentioned a "problem" they meant that Derefr's question wasn't that relevant to reality, not that there's a problem selecting hearing aids.
> If a doctor prescribed you hearing aids, could you get the Bluetooth kind instead, and still have them covered by your insurance?
If insurance plans don't cover hearing aids in general, they won't cover hearing aids in any specific situation either.
Since I only need one hearing aid, the bluetooth feature was of minimal interest. I've not heard of any hearing aids that have a microphone that is useful for the bluetooth headset profile. The microphones for this use tend to be an add-on device which may or may not come with a pair of hearing aids. Admittedly, I've not researched this area much.
GP was asking about insurance plans that do.
I'm confused - what part is custom and what is made by the Swiss and Danish companies?
No, they do.
The short answer is: you need to develop your own custom IC's that 1) have analog circuitry 2) support Telecoil[1] - an ancient induction standard from the 1970's 3) are made by 1 of 4 companies in Copenhagen or Switzerland - one of which has 55% market share and 4) run on fumes. Seriously, the crest factor on these is ridiculous.
The long answer is available in this great podcast episode: https://theamphour.com/338-an-interview-with-jorgen-jakobsen...
Of course, Bluetooth alternatives to hearing aids are being developed. People in the industry know this and joke about it. But, crucially, they can't be called "hearing aids". It's a protected term. An interesting example are Bose's new $500 "Hearphones" strongly targeted at an older demographic[2] with features like Bluetooth and tunable noise cancellation based off their earlier $300 QC30 dynamic noise cancelling platform. But also not the exact same use case. More power intensive. More capable. But less endurance.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hearing_aid#Telecoil [2] https://www.bose.com/en_us/products/headphones/conversation_...