http://www.chevybolt.org/forum/#/topics/7778?page=1
“On this rainy morning while turning to park in a stall and so I take my food off the accelerator and expected the heavy regenerative braking. Instead it accelerated in to the stall and so I had to brake heavily and it still didn't seem to take hold. Luckily the cement parking block stopped the car albeit I still went over it.”
Response from other owner:
“Very possible for Regen to deactivate in slippery conditions. Hitting a large bump may also disengage Regen, which will feel like the car is actually speeding up (since you are expecting it to decelerate).”
In comparison I've driven our Tesla in heavy rain, snow and regenerative braking has never disabled, although traction control does take over occasionally. Tesla also gradually ramps down the braking to zero at 5mph so it doesn't suddenly disappear.
is removing your foot from the accelerator instead of using the brake a standard learned behavior amongst bolt/volt owners?
To me regenerative braking feels like putting the car in D3 or turning off overdrive. As soon as you stop giving enough gas to accelerate or hold speed it just drags the car down.
I would never expect it to slow the car to a stop for me.
Also in the Leaf the amount of regenerative braking applied is diminished if the car is over 90-95% charged. It has 4 dots indicating level and they have halos indicating the max possible based on conditions.
If people are used to the car reacting in a certain way and it suddenly changes I'm not surprised that in can be enough to momentarily lose control. I wouldn't like that at all.
Having something that switches from braking to no brake without warning seems like ... terrible design.
Above a certain rpm the engine cuts fuel completely and engine braking is strong. In cars with electronic throttle control the computer might also open the throttle to maximize energy consumed compressing air.
As you pass through that cutoff range the engine starts firing again, maybe 700 rpm above idle. Engine braking stops being effective when this happens.
Also, newer cars don't do a full fuel cut when engine braking with a cold engine or if the catalyst is getting too cold to work. So sometimes engine braking isn't very strong.
Basically you can't rely on engine braking so when you're doing it your foot usually hovers on the brake pedal. This isn't any different than the hybrids
Whatever the case, I've found engine braking to be fairly consistent in manual transmission cars at a given speed/gear. But, I've never thought I could rely on it to bring me to a stop in a parking lot. It blows my mind that an EV driver would think that.
Also, since Tesla regenerative braking always turns off below 5 mph, I always have my foot over the brake pedal at low speeds.
So there's no need to "avoid the brake pedal to use regen" the way it sounds like these Bolt drivers are doing. Which seems really dangerous.
"Hitting a large bump may also disengage Regen, which will feel like the car is actually speeding up (since you are expecting it to decelerate)."
But that's not a design fault, you're essentially using a "weaker brake" to stop, then you go over a large bump which overpowers the brake for a second. Even real brakes have that issue, but they "catch" quicker than the regen-only.
I just don't drive with L, the regen pedal allows much finer tuning.
This site here lists the Volt as lowest death rate listed among small 4-dr cars.
I wonder if the volt does so well because of limited range — I doubt typical owners clock many highway miles at speed, given that it is most useful in congested cities.
Anyway, here are lists of recalls across their lines. Glancing at it reveals shocking things (the GMC canyon hood can unexpectedly open, and it has killed people, to pick one at random).
I don’t know of a decent comparison of such things across makes, but from a qualitative perspective, I think GM’s recent track record is unacceptable.
My 2012 Volt has had no recalls. It's been in the shop 3 times since I bought it in 2012. Two were for oil changes and one was a regular check up. That's it. I haven't been to a gas station in around 6 months (because I haven't had any really long trips in this car during that time).
It's fun to say all cars are bad because a few are bad, but it sure isn't accurate.
I never cared much about car brands but usually leaned towards GM as a result, Pontiac always caught my eye. GM's lineup seemed as good as anything. Once I had to take my car in for a recall I found how wrong I was. Both the dealer screwed me (expected) and GM corporate did as well (unexpected).
Long story short, they did an ignition console swap and after they were done they gave me 2 sets of keys and told me that one was for the door and one was for the new ignition. GM's CEO even stated on her blog that this was not to be the case. I wasn't the only person complaining about being told to have two sets of keys either. I filed a corporate complaint and they told me to pound sand. I did file a BBB report on the dealer and they never replied so I guess it just went on their record uncontested.
As well, GM later denied payment for a faulty gas tank issue that they sent me a mailer about for reimbursement but never paid me. The fix had already been done at the tune of $550. I followed their instructions exactly, quite time consuming tracking down receipts I no longer had and so forth. They still said I had something wrong with my application. Don't know what it was, at that point I was done hassling with them and had made my final decision on GM.
The verdict is no more GM for me or my family for the rest of our lives. There's plenty of alternatives. My wife now has a Subaru Crosstrek and I'm buying a Tesla Model 3. The new Honda Civic hatchback is pretty neat. Ultimately I believe I'm going electric from here on out, but never GM.
At that point, other GM dealers refused to look at it without taking a large up-front deposit.
Corporate didn’t actually use the words “pound sand”. It would have saved me time if they had.
Eventually, I took it to a Chevy dealer, and they upgraded the radio firmware. The electical problems were caused by a CAM protocol bug that prevented the ABS from powering off sometimes.
This was all in the first 1000 miles.
It had unrelated issues due to the fake parts, but the dealer “honored” the warranty by switching them out for a different brand.
Amazing. Well, I wasn't going to hand GM any money again anyway, but my slight admiration I had of their Bolt is now gone, so thank you for that. GM is pulling their usual cheap Android vendor that wants Apple prices method I suppose, which I should've known. Yup GM corporate simply told me that the dealer is their eyes and ears and could do nothing other than side with them. Really helpful.
I certainly hope you don't have any further issues with it for the remainder of its lifespan because this stuff is a big waste of time. I've been at the point for years that I'll just pay more and get the Toyota or Honda even if it looks like I'm paying for nothing on the spec sheet.
GM really goes out of their way to charm all their loyal customers.
A few months after that, the driver-side heater went out, and the radio started to fail.
The fact that so many things failed makes me think there are significant systemic issues with GM vehicle platforms (and not just individual components).
The more I think about the regenerative braking issue on the Bolt, the more I think my car had the same root-cause problem, which makes me wonder if it impacts their whole line: Traction control sporadically engages on a regular basis.
That’s not a big deal on ICE cars, but if they really disable regenerative braking when traction control enganges, it’ll eventually kill or severely injure a pedestrian. One of the worst things a vehicle can do is have an intermittent braking system!
Anyway, I no longer own the vehicle. Getting rid of it was worth every wasted penny. :-)
https://www.consumerreports.org/car-reliability-owner-satisf...
And the Bolt is their most reliable car, apparently.
Perhaps I am being unfair, or perhaps they improved. Still, given the nature of the issues I hit and continue to hear about, I’ll continue to avoid them.
> (Most years of this model had software bugs that were so bad, they could literally kill you — for example, the exhaust system could overheat, and burn the car down)
Has anyone died?
The most egregious bug caused seatbelts to fail to deploy, so I assume there were at least injuries.
I just checked, and I don’t think the exhaust fires injured anyone (it happened 8 times before the recall, and at that point there were zero injuries).
GM has been during PR on this car but the software is still far from complete.
I recently test drove a Honda CRV and told the salesperson explicitly not to call me and that we're just test driving and comparing various models for a couple months. He not only sat us down with the 'hard sell' but literally called me every day for 2 months. Note his 'hard sell' was $300 off MSRP.
I feel the independent dealer system has largely failed us and they're all terrible and unfixable. If I end up buying a Tesla it will be less for the car and more for the lack of traditional dealer experiences. Or I end up buying a 3 year old car and enjoy the savings from massive depreciation.
Which one? You are talking about what sounds like serious safety issues. Which car was it so we can find out more?
1 https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-our-patent-are-belong-you
2 http://bgr.com/2017/09/25/tesla-vs-mercedes-elon-musk-not-im..., https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2015/09/27/tesla-ceo-...
[1] https://jalopnik.com/chevy-bolt-ordering-delayed-by-three-mo...
Even when new, the new model handled terribly compared to the old GM (same model, engine size, etc).
Its compauter regularly locked the rear wheels when turning and going uphill, and the steering geometry caused it to squeal the tires at low speeds in parking lots. Neither the old GM, nor the replacement had these problems, and all three are essentially identical body styles.
Tl;dr: Congrats to GM, but I’m waiting for literally anyone else to ship a competitive EV.