News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by dvdhnt on Monday September 18, 2017 @01:00PM (#15277556)
Many of us love to pat ourselves on the back for all the "free" knowledge and information available thanks to the internet, ignoring that most of what is available is merely entertainment and opinion.

Stories like this are a good reminder that the most valuable information is still being concealed by those with the power. They use their position, money, and authority to protect it at all costs.

We still have a long way to go.

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by jxramos on Monday September 18, 2017 @02:45PM (#15278414)
Pretty scary thought; makes me think about the Magna Carta and the idea that you couldn't be pulled into a court and charged for things not explicitly spelled out in some body of law that folks could possibly know in advance. In other words administrative bodies could not produce some novel "law" on the spot and charge you with it.

I long to see the day when laws and other civic documents are compiled and evolved in some source control like git or something domain specific for such documents.

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by pc86 on Monday September 18, 2017 @03:15PM (#15278660)
This "git for law" meme is a nearly constant refrain but it is simply not appropriate for legal text. Yes, for de minimus yet important changes, like changing a "shall" to a "may," it makes sense. For anything beyond that, trying to shoehorn legislation into a format and workflow design for software is a fool's errand at best.
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by KingPrad on Monday September 18, 2017 @04:11PM (#15279104)
I disagree that version control is inappropriate. I worked for a company whose primary product was tracking government legislation through a database built on Subversion. (acted as a DB but used Subversion for a variety of reasons. I know it sounds strange).

It seemed to work fine to record incremental changes, tag specific revisions as being checkpoints for various stages of review and approvals. And anyone could search current and historical versions.

The overall legislation system needs flexibility to deal with complex and changing workflows, but storing documents (with change over time) and the links between them can be encoded just fine. As long as there are flexible ways to string them together, they can be represented in whatever structure makes sense: final law with all current amendments; original law, with amendments as annotations, separate pieces of legislation, linked by the overall law, etc. None of that has to be encoded in a super-strict heirarchy, but as long as it's all being stored in can be presented however one wants.

I don't see the fatal flaw. I see imperfections and compromises, but not the flaw so bad as to say "don't bother".

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by jxramos on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:14PM (#15280155)
The key is incremental change I agree; if legislators only interact and record changes in final form with all the mass of changes dumped onto a user for review then such a project would be untenable. Small changes would really improve usefulness, and I daydream sometimes about what sort of dodgy log messages folks would use to obscure intent. Either way it could really empower a lot of analysis I'd imagine.

Do you mind sharing with us the company and the product you developed in this space?

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by walshemj on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:49PM (#15280381)
Correct parliamentary procedure should track all motions changes and proposed changes (even those ruled out of order) to motions I certainly do as a member of a CBC / SOC (Conference Business Committee / Standing Orders Committee)
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by adekok on Monday September 18, 2017 @05:09PM (#15279620)
The alternative is that we are unable to track changes in the law. Which to me, makes the law untrustworthy.

Untrustworthy laws are rather more foolish than doing revision tracking on English text. I mean... FFS how hard is it to track changes to English text? Really?

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by KZeillmann on Monday September 18, 2017 @03:45PM (#15278889)
I'd at least like to see the diffs in a more readable format. Many laws are compilations of, "Amend [section of law] to read as follows: [new wording]"
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by walshemj on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:53PM (#15280400)
yes that is how its done you normally produce an omnibus showing motions with the amendments next to them plus a list of Consequentials eg if motion 57 passes motion 63 falls.
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by hueving on Monday September 18, 2017 @05:37PM (#15279847)
>trying to shoehorn legislation into a format and workflow design for software is a fool's errand at best.

It's not for software, it's for text. Is the law no longer written in text?

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by walshemj on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:51PM (#15280389)
There are already "workflows" designed for parliamentary procedures Citrine's ABC of Chairmanship and Roberts rules are two examples.
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by bobwaycott on Monday September 18, 2017 @08:44PM (#15280949)
The suggestion isn’t to use git or a git-like for procedures, but for tracking the text of laws.
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by walshemj on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @12:26PM (#15286063)
Yes that is how Citrine and Roberts are used today in parliamentary systems I have been doing this for years for formal conferences.

The procedure is similar to they way git is used for code though with a greater or lesser amount of automation - in the old days you had multiple documents and you physically cut and pasted them together to produce the final document

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by jxramos on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:25PM (#15280232)
Looks like some fellas in Germany took a stab at it. I'm interesting in seeing how they've carried on since this taping back in 2013, sounded very manual but some pirate party adopted the idea if I understand him correctly https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qql1Ess7qM
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by petre on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @12:54AM (#15281893)
It's inappropriate if your goal is to obfuscate the law and make cross references to past laws, thus creating demand for more lawyers.
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by Chathamization on Monday September 18, 2017 @03:15PM (#15278664)
That's true, but there's still a ton of useful information freely available out there that gets ignored. For the vast majority of people the problem isn't lack of access to information that the government is concealing, but rather lack of interest in useful information they can access in seconds.

That's not to say that lack of access isn't a major problem - it is - but even when you solve that, you're going to be left with the much bigger lack of interest problem.

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by NaOH on Monday September 18, 2017 @10:47PM (#15281413)
It's akin to what Steve Jobs once said:

“When you’re young, you look at television and think, There’s a conspiracy. The networks have conspired to dumb us down. But when you get a little older, you realize that’s not true. The networks are in business to give people exactly what they want. That’s a far more depressing thought. Conspiracy is optimistic! You can shoot the bastards! We can have a revolution! But the networks are really in business to give people what they want. It’s the truth.”

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by specialist on Monday September 18, 2017 @09:11PM (#15281067)
Steep learning curve. It took me a long time to figure out what was going on, much less figuring how how to ask useful questions.
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by Markoff on Monday September 18, 2017 @03:48PM (#15278908)
i don't think the problem is really lack of interest, but form in what is information delivered. if you give me 200 pages text document ful of numbers, nobody will bother to read it, if you make simple infographic based on this document you will see people are interested
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by abakker on Monday September 18, 2017 @03:54PM (#15278935)
In other words, if you do the analysis and the work, and provide the opinion and results for free?
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by lovich on Monday September 18, 2017 @05:16PM (#15279677)
What you said is technically true, but it is literally impossible for someone to be up to date on every piece of information that affects them. Even just limiting the domain to legal terms, the US government doesn't know how many laws it has. How is someone supposed to "do the analysis and work" on all of that, on all of the terms of services for every single product that exists, all the information pertinent to their health, for companies they never even consented to work with ala Facebook and Equifax data tracking, etc?

It's extremely disingenuous to call people lazy for not analyzing all of that when there is not a single person on the planet who has done so

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by manigandham on Monday September 18, 2017 @01:36PM (#15277850)
Long way to go until what exactly?
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by heymijo on Monday September 18, 2017 @02:36PM (#15278340)
I'm grasping at straws, but it seems relevant to this branch of the thread...

Wasn't there recently an uproar in the U.S. about a [state/municipality/or some such] that gave copyright over to their [regulations/building codes/or some such] to a private entity? Thus, citizens had to pay to know what the law was and couldn't make copies.

This seems right along the lines of what op was talking about.

My memory is too fuzzy to get a good search result so if anyone could help out with the specifics I would appreciate it.

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by mikeyouse on Monday September 18, 2017 @02:59PM (#15278523)
There have been several cases, mostly along building standards, but the state of Georgia famously sued Carl Malamud for infringing on the copyright of state laws when he publishing the full annotated version of their laws online:

http://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-mh-state-of-ge...

Malamud had worked with Aaron Swartz on opening up Pacer:

https://public.resource.org/crime/

And he was joined by the EFF defending against a suit by the Sheet Metal and Air Conditioning Contractors Association after he published the details of a Federally-mandated safety standard:

https://www.eff.org/press/releases/publicresourceorg-prevail...

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by apendleton on Monday September 18, 2017 @03:04PM (#15278567)
So there are a couple different issues here. One is just states claiming copyright on their actual state criminal code or whatever, and selling the rights to republish it to Lexis or WestLaw or whatever as a state revenue source. This is happens, but is not actually that common in the US, and there's pretty broad agreement that it's shitty, and it doesn't happen at the federal level because the US federal government can't own copyrights.

Much trickier is "incorporation by reference," which is when the official law or regulation says "as part of our building codes we're going to adopt the 2012 version of the International Building Code in its entirety, and then amend it as follows..." without actually including the text of the IBC (or the fire code, or whatever), which is a document created by a private entity, and is copyrighted. This happens all the time, across levels of government, and it pretty clearly poses a problem, but it's not really clear whose fault it is or what to do about it. Individual city governments don't have the requisite expertise to concoct an entire set of fire codes for themselves, and it's not clear you'd want them to: we arguably all benefit from having the greatest experts in the country craft the best possible code, and product makers that sell across markets benefit from having a uniform standard. But because professional associations end up taking on this role since no single government will, it's not clear how to pay for the work of researching and writing the code, so they end up self-funding by selling the text itself. It's not clear that either the governments or the organizations are in the wrong, even if the public ends up suffering.

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by nobodyorother on Monday September 18, 2017 @02:49PM (#15278444)
It was Georgia state law, two years ago, essentially saying that while you can have the text of the law, you can't have the annotations that inform the interpretation of the law:

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/03/public-records-a...

However, since court decisions about US law are based on prior rulings, the text itself is mostly useless and doesn't actually tell you what the whole law is. It's like an Ikea assembly manual without pictures.

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by stult on Monday September 18, 2017 @03:17PM (#15278674)
You're referring to the Official Code of Georgia Annotated (OGCA).

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/03/public-records-a...

The Official Code of Georgia is available online for free. However, the Official Code of Georgia Annotated is not. The law itself is not copyrighted, merely the annotations. The annotations are produced by private companies (Westlaw and LexisNexis), but are considered essential for legal research purposes. So although they are private written works subject to copyright, they possess something akin to but somewhat less than the power of law.

Most if not all of the major obstacles to full public access to case and statutory law arise from the LexisNexis/Westlaw duopoly over legal research. Courts historically have relied on the companies to collate and publish the reporters containing all the significant judicial opinions, rather than incurring the costs of typesetting and publishing the opinions themselves. They also publish annotated versions of the state and federal statutes and administrative regulations. The annotations make them copyrightable, but also provide added value to legal researchers. Lex/West then turn around and charge enormous sums of money for access to these reporters and annotated codes and to their searchable databases based on those. Many citizens are thus unable to access legal opinions which set common law precedents or statutory interpretations binding as law on those citizens.

Even where the opinions are published online for free by the court, e.g. Supreme Court opinions, lawyers rely heavily on the cross-citation services and topical annotations provided by Lex/West. Raw opinions and statutes just aren't that easy to use for research purposes without a fairly intense indexing system. So even though a lot of law is available for free online, it's hard to make full use of.

A few firms, like FastCase, are trying to produce relatively cheap/free alternatives to the traditional services, but it's extremely difficult to collate and annotate the massive volumes of judicial opinions, administrative decisions, rule makings, and statutes generated at the state and federal levels each year, never mind historically.

On the other hand, it's probably worth mentioning that the more significant a law is, the more likely you will have free access to it. Most inaccessible laws deal with small jurisdictions or narrow issues. Or they require a strong legal education to understand and apply. You may not be able to find an opinion issued by the California Board of Equalization in a 1973 tax dispute about what constitutes constitutionally sufficient notice of a propose adjustment to taxes owed, but the issue is so obscure and technical that access isn't really valuable to the general public anyway. The costs of providing access to that law are more efficiently allocated to the rare individuals who need it than to the general public. Those individuals pay their lawyers who pay West/Lex, who bear the costs of preserving and organizing these legal texts. Or so the argument more or less goes.

Really, this whole debate cuts to the core of the legal profession. Why should people have to pay a premium to ensure they are complying with the law or to resolve a dispute or to defend themselves against charges from the state? Which is really another way of asking, why is the law so complex that an elite caste of specialists is required to administer it?

Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by dvdhnt on Monday September 18, 2017 @02:26PM (#15278259)
Until organizations who should act transparently can no longer impede the free-flow of information, because as they have proven time and time again, they cannot be trusted to do so willingly.
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by ramy_d on Monday September 18, 2017 @01:39PM (#15277877)
Until relevant information is free.
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by killjoywashere on Monday September 18, 2017 @02:06PM (#15278090)
All information is relevant to someone, somewhere, who doesn't already know. We all have secrets.
Re:Governments turn tables by suing public records requesters by hellbanner on Monday September 18, 2017 @05:34PM (#15279809)
May I interest you in the Black Iron Prison: http://www.principiadiscordia.com/bip/1.php