> We ban accounts that use Hacker News primarily for political or ideological battle, regardless of which politics they favor.
"You understand what I'm saying? We knew we couldn't make it illegal to be either against the war or black, but by getting the public to associate the hippies with marijuana and blacks with heroin. And then criminalizing both heavily, we could disrupt those communities," Ehrlichman said. "We could arrest their leaders. raid their homes, break up their meetings, and vilify them night after night on the evening news. Did we know we were lying about the drugs? Of course we did."
Yeah. Cancerous lefties indeed.
Sounds like something that should be backed up by a data point if you're looking to contribute something to the discussion.
>Leftism is a cancer, and a road to third world culture, paved by good intentions.
You've given exactly one point, with no references. When you jump to extreme conclusions such as the one you're making, that undoubtably creates a 'cancer' you're speaking of because it puts down any intelligent discussion. Without that, how can you or I be informed? I would argue that extremes such as that are what contribute to a political climate where its more important what party or political idealogy you belong to, than what you're actually saying.
Why? People state their opinions and experiences on HN all the time without such a requirement.
"language X is better than Y" is an opinion we accept at face value without sources, since it doesn't affect users of language Y, and has limited impact if it's wrong. Comparing a political stance to a disease does affect the users (implies they're 'sick' and need treatment) and has a big impact if it's wrong (and the non-leftism policies get put into place).
Compare "Perl is better than PHP" to "PHP is the brain tumor of server-side web languages".
Plus: there's no indication of which policies have caused this situation, so it's presumptuous to claim they're caused by leftism.
If I say Marxism is evil, aren't I also vilifying subscribers to that philosophy? That's fine, since it's a choice; both to take ideological criticisms personally, and to subscribe to it in the first place.
> Comparing a political stance to a disease does affect the users
I can't see how.
Yes, and I would not be surprised to see people challenging that statement/asking for facts.
> > Comparing a political stance to a disease does affect the users
> I can't see how.
See my example from the post you quoted. Does it make sense? Try to put yourself in the shoes of a professional, successful PHP programmer who is aware of the advantages and disadvantages of the language & is comfortable weighing up the various trade-offs.
Then we disagree. I distinguish ideology from person.
> Try to put yourself in the shoes of a professional, successful PHP programmer
I'd say that programmer has too much of their ego invested in their choice of language. The question is not of being merely unhappy about criticism, but being personally affected.
Would you happily say the same wrt criticism of a belief in flat-earth?
So do I? Bit of a non-sequitur…
> Would you happily say the same wrt criticism of a belief in flat-earth?
Happily? What a loaded question.
Would I expect a flat-earther to respond to claims which criticized their point-of-view by requesting evidence? Yes I would.
edit
> The question is not of being merely unhappy about criticism, but being personally affected.
People are affected by criticism simply by receiving it. Feeling unhappy because of criticism is being personally affected. Words can harm and kill.
Do you? you said you agree that "X is evil" villifies subscribers that philosophy.
> Feeling unhappy because of criticism is being personally affected
Not really, there is a difference between "I am a bad person" and "I subscribe to a bad ideology". The difference is you can un-subscribe if persuaded.
> Words can harm and kill
that's a non-sequitur..
> Do you? you said you agree that "X is evil" villifies subscribers that philosophy.
It does. That's what those words mean. I didn't say I would find them evil (which is what you're claiming I meant). You haven't asked me how I feel about any particular economical-political theory.
Is there something I could say that would cause you to reconsider your stance? If there is not, then please consider if this is the most productive use of your time.
I disagree. Care to back up that personal insult?
> Is there something I could say that would cause you to reconsider your stance?
Same to you.
Because we're literally talking about an article about how fact-free policies are a bad thing.
I think that's a big part of the problem right there. Politics doesn't have two sides; it's got far more dimensions and nuances than that, but in some cases it's been turned into a brutal, hatred-prone "us and them" of a ridiculously simple and inflexible two tribe system.
What did happen in the western world that made parents not allowing their kids to wander around?
He proposed one explanation in a contrived way: leftist politics. Instead of mindless downvoting, how would you explain it?
I think environmental difference are more important than cultural.
wat? Well, since I can only speak for the country I grew up in.
Switzerland: Definitely not the case. Letting kids wander around alone is the norm here, and no, that's not because everyone is poor.
Of course if you're six and eight and not really into chess, nothing could be more boring. So we asked Dad if we could do something else. He gave us a few nickels and quarters and said "sure, how about riding the cable cars and go see the town?"
So we did! It was the most awesomest thing ever. We rode every cable car we could find, walked around town and saw the sights. The best part was when we found a street with our last name on it!
Everyone was nice. The cable car operators saw that we were a couple of kids riding around on our own, so they showed us how the grip and the brakes worked, pointed out interesting things to see, and made sure we knew how to ride safely - even when we were sitting on the outside of the cable car kicking our feet.
We forgot to ask for lunch money, so when we got back to the chess club as Dad was finishing his games, he took us out for a bite to eat and we told him all the stories of our adventure.
What a great day!
[1] https://chessclub.org