The majority of the article is about the Vietnam War, but do a search and you won't find either Muhammad Ali or even the word "draft". Muhammad Ali was an outspoken, black, Muslim who refused the draft, again history might pretend he had the love and support of the people, but he didn't at least at the time. The War still had the full support of the American people, and Ali was persecuted, striped of his championship title/livelihood, labeled Anti-American in the media, he was also prosecuted by the Government, and convicted of draft dodging and sentenced to 5 years of prison. But he continued to fight, the Country began shifting its attitude about the War and the draft, and Ali prevailed in the Courts.
Obviously Ali wasn't alone, just look at some of the most famous 1st Amendment cases at the time. The Government prosecuting a guy for wearing a jacket that read "Fuck the Draft" in a Courtroom trying to chill his speech, eventually the Supreme Court agreed that was protected speech. Or the Government prosecuting protesters for burning their draft cards, ultimately they lost and the Supreme Court ruled burning draft cards is not protected speech. All these anti-war protests were done majorly by students, granted to your point their message and goal was much clearer than protests of today. Never mind the individual wins and loses, they were done by students, not middle class, and still they won overall because there hasn't been a draft in the US since, because its become politically untenable. Students, racial minorities, religious minorities...not the middle class.
Such is the popular image, but it is incorrect. She was the secretary of her local NAACP chapter, and she certainly was making a stand for civil rights. From her autobiography:
"People always say that I didn't give up my seat because I was tired, but that isn't true. I was not tired physically, or no more tired than I usually was at the end of a working day. I was not old, although some people have an image of me as being old then. I was forty-two. No, the only tired I was, was tired of giving in."
This gets into it a little ...
http://www.npr.org/2009/03/15/101719889/before-rosa-parks-th...
When asked why she is little known and why everyone thinks only of Rosa Parks, Colvin says the NAACP and all the other black organizations felt Parks would be a good icon because "she was an adult. They didn't think teenagers would be reliable."
She also says Parks had the right hair and the right look.
"Her skin texture was the kind that people associate with the middle class," says Colvin. "She fit that profile."
David Garrow, a historian and the author of Bearing the Cross: Martin Luther King Jr. and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, says people may think that Parks' action was spontaneous, but black civic leaders had been thinking about what to do about the Montgomery buses for years.
"I did not think about [being the test case for the NAACP] at all. In fact if I had let myself think too deeply about what might happen to me, I might have gotten off the bus. But I chose to remain."[1]
There's a lot of propaganda chaff around Rosa Parks. It seems that it was neither carefully planned, nor a completely spontaneous act of rebellion. She and a great many other people had been seething about the buses for years, and on that day she had simply had enough. I suspect the "carefully planned NAACP sting operation" narrative arose as a backlash to the equally inaccurate "totally random uninvolved old lady stands up for herself" narrative.
[1] https://contexts.org/articles/telling-stories-about-rosa-par...
Here is a pretty famous Parks' radio interview from 1956, I'll just say I have listened to it for inspiration for sometime and will continue to do so, I may not know much, but I know her own words well, and I just don't think this was some grand scheme she was cooking up for sometime as a leader of the NAACP;
>The time had just come when I had been pushed as far as I could stand to be pushed, I suppose [tired] They placed me under arrest. And I wasn’t afraid. I don’t know why I wasn’t, but I didn’t feel afraid. I had decided that I would have to know once and for all what rights I had as a human being and a citizen, even in Montgomery, Alabama.
https://www.democracynow.org/2005/10/25/rosa_parks_1913_2005...
STOP. SPREADING. LIES.
Parks herself:
> People always say that I didn't give up my seat because I was tired, but that isn't true
https://www.democracynow.org/2005/10/25/rosa_parks_1913_2005...
One of the most effective protests in Indian history was the Gandhi-led boycott of British-made goods. This directly impacted British economic structures.
A handful of people blocking a highway for a few hours isn't going to impact anything much.
With their constant crying wolf and manufactured outrage, the US media has all but neutered themselves.
There is also a huge difference between media being willing to cover the conflict, and media willingly amplifying your message. In the former the power stays in the hands of the media (and the people it usually serves), only in the latter I would say that one has something that can be an effective power.
More a general comment, I don't know how BLM does wrt to media coverage.
I saw a comment here not long ago that managed to peel off the vehicle murderer in Charlottesville from the white supremacist organizers that praised him and at the same time directly blamed BLM for police killings that many leaders in the movement have condemned. I imagine media coverage contributes to such mental acrobatics.
http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/james-di-fiore/black-lives-matt...
Quite the apologia.
> maybe if this was her only controversial statement all could be forgiven
A rare thing for someone to get so toxic even HuffPo calls her out, but flip it around and they would have no problem calling someone white with similar views a white-supremacist, and condemning them - without the "respect" or second chances.
In fact, they pretty much spell it out:
> many media outlets faced scrutiny for focusing on that tweet instead of the issues black communities are facing
Yusra is now causing more harm than good, so she has to go. Otherwise, they'd tolerate her.
Do you think they made a mistake by publishing her op-ed?
First of all, it strikes me that pretty much any movement concerning a minority is fundamentally about power.
Second, surely 'perceived [have] wronged them' is an odd statement in the context of a minority group that has seriously been wronged in the distant and recent past, and not to mention is still suffering from being wronged on a regular basis.
Now I don't know the fine details of BLM as a movement so I'm honestly open to hear where my thinking is faulty. Could you elaborate a bit?
Please, give me an example when ever in history a or a series of not-lame-ass protests did change something.
G20 in Hamburg was a good example of several not-lame-ass protests which didn't lead to anything beyond violence and destruction. Absolutely nothing changed or started to change because of them.
http://www.tagesspiegel.de/berlin/die-gekaufte-demo/789302.h...
For a protest to achieve something it has to have a goal, and the goal is always 'protesting', that doesn't change anything.
If you want to overthrow the Government then go shoot your local senator[0], taking the kids and waving hand made protest signs at the local park isn't going to do sh*t.
[0] It's an example. I'm in no way advocating anyone actually do this!
American's protest problem is simple, life is too easy to have anything generate enough interest for people to assemble about other than bad government and the political parties have figured out how to effectively redirect that ire.
Here in my country we even had politicians caught on tape laughing and joking: "What are they gonna do, kill us? They can't do shit, they can only distract themselves from their miserable life...<pause and laughter>...and that's the only reason we don't bomb the protests with tear gas, so these peasants can feel better about themselves that they are actually changing something". Then the whole table full of politicians proceeds to laugh even more.
...You know what? They are 100% correct. Protests amount to nothing.
If you don't hit the politicians where it hurts -- their funding and their political power -- then they'll never change anything. That's just how human beings in power always worked, and whoever disagrees with that is blissfully deluded.
Yeah okay you try threatening people in power and see how far that gets you. They will show up at your house with machine guns, murder your entire family, and then they'll lie about what happened to the neighbors. "Drug bust gone wrong" or something. If you're a person who exercises your 2nd amendment rights they'll say you had a "cache of weapons". Remember WACO? That's what they do to people who threaten those in power.
The neighbors will believe whatever they're told, for 2 reasons. They don't want to believe that life is a nightmare, or they are already terrified for their lives and want to go on clinging to whatever table scraps they're currently feeding on.
This stuff has been going on for many many years.
"They will give you ALL the tools you need to destroy yourself." - Afeni Shakur
But... the Branch Davidians did have a cache of weapons.
Which is a constitutionally protected inalienable right given to all citizens of The United States. There is no limitation to how many firearms a U.S. citizen can own. There are many people who own hundreds of rifles and handguns. Any other commodity and we'd call it a "collection" but when it's firearms suddenly it's a "cache of weapons".
What matters, what you seemed to miss, is the way they describe the situation. They call it a "cache of weapons" on TV because that sounds like terrorism. When it's only American citizens exercising their rights.
They do that to manipulate ignorant people. They don't want you to ask questions when they murder a house full of people. Which they do a whole lot. WACO was unusual, being a big media circus, but they're actually really efficient at this murder business and it happens pretty frequently.
You get millions on streets to protest on the day Trump took office, to ask for.... WHAT? The guy is democratically-elected. He made no huge mistake at that point. Apparently they were "supporting women" or "anti-discrimination" or something. I get it, you don't like him - but this was just wasted effort. No, it was worse than wasted effort - it discredited the idea that millions on the people on the streets would mean something. It would be one thing if millions came out after the announcement of the muslim ban, to protest against THAT.
You don't protest against a person, that is ineffective - you protest against policy changes. If you tell someone "I will never vote YOU"... well, ok, what can he do? Nothing. if you say, "I will never vote those who support this policy!", then politicians actually have a choice to back off
You know, watching the news and seeing 100k people protesting looks impressive, until you realize that you live in a country of 350M citizens and that 100k protesters is just 0.029% of total population. Add social media to the equation and it is entirely possible to organize flash mob of 100k of Game of Thrones fans demanding "EPIC BOATSEX".
So, as a politician you learn very early in your career to ignore all protests, simply because someone is always protesting against something. You wouldn't get much done if you spent most of your time talking to protesters.
>Movements like BLM are ineffectual when protesting because they do neither
Can you imagine the tone of public discourse if it even appeared that BLM was trying to overwhelm the seat of governance? I mean people scream 'thug' and call in the National Guard at the sight of African-Americans breaking a supermarket window what do you think they'll do if it appears they might overthrow a government (even a local one)?
Riots and revolutions have shown historically to be very effective at: getting people killed, at decreasing voter support, giving the opposing side more power, and be successful at toppling power. In more instable regions where such events happen in regular waves, the ability of violence to cause lasting change is minimal to none unless you are willing to commit genocide.
If for an example, BLM would convince all the nurses to halt their job, all the firemen -- that would make a difference.
But by the look of it, BLM does not have the support of the average working class person. Maybe I'm wrong, I'm not from the United States. The police killings are rare, especially when it comes to killing black people and the topic is only political.
Also, your comment implies that there's an acceptable number of police killings of unarmed/fleeing suspects - what would you say that number is in your country?
> "A new study confirms that black men and women are treated differently in the hands of law enforcement. They are more likely to be touched, handcuffed, pushed to the ground or pepper-sprayed by a police officer, even after accounting for how, where and when they encounter the police.
But when it comes to the most lethal form of force — police shootings — the study finds no racial bias."
https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/12/upshot/surprising-new-evi...
http://www.nber.org/papers/w22399.pdf
> "The conventional thinking about police-involved shootings, and some scientific research, has been that black suspects are more likely to be shot than white suspects because of an implicit racial bias among police officers. But now a new study has found exactly the opposite: even with white officers who do have racial biases, officers are three times less likely to shoot unarmed black suspects than unarmed white suspects."
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/true-crime/wp/2016/04/27...
Lastly, we're setting a low bar if our standard for police mistreatment is killing as opposed to inappropriate behavior, writ large.
I do see your point, but I'm not sure this data undercuts the importance of a movement like BLM.
EDIT: For the second link, I'm not sure how much I believe a psychology experiment in this setting - I don't know this literature but my a priori bias is that the individuals who would do this type of study in Seattle are not representative of the median US police officer
None of the articles or studies undercuts BLM. They're meant to show that the situation is more complicated and nuanced and teasing out proper and actionable conclusions will take more data and time. But that kind of headline doesn't get you eyeballs and clicks.
More white people are shot by police officers in your country, yet black community has a bigger crime rate.
[0]:https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2016/07/1...
The article wants to talk about population but we all know that crime rate is what matters. If anything, you should protest all the killings, but media has turned into a racial issue.
Viewing it in this way is a bit ahistorical. The problem is not just police violence, but a generally turbid relationship between law enforcement and communities of color. There is widespread distrust on both sides, so when a killing happens it is difficult for the community to take it in good faith.
Also, for comparison, the last time there was a high profile wrongful police killing of a white person, the police chief of Minneapolis had to resign almost immediately. I'm hard-pressed to find the last time one had to quit after the killing of a non-white one.
You have distorted world view that there are only two ways of living. Either democrat or republican and it all comes with a package, beliefs and media you watch.
[0]:https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2016/07/1...
The article wants to talk about population but we all know that crime rate is what matters. If anything, you should protest all the killings, but media has turned into a racial issue.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2015/jun/...
The point of BL M and many protests is not only the number of people killed by police, it's a symbol of a more widespread issue of racial injustice, specifically in the criminal justice system. Why are our increasingly militarized police murdering and brutalizing unarmed or non-aggressive citizens? Aren't these people they're supposed to be protecting?
Why are we letting white supremacists and racists in our police forces?
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/fbi-white-supremacists-i...
Why is there almost a gap of 20% in sentencing rate between black and white people, for the same crimes?
https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/race/news/2012/03/13...
Same for the disparity in conviction rates. Did you know many states strip felons of the right to vote?
Why are drug crimes, despite similar usage rates among races, so skewed in actual prosecutions and incarcerations towards blacks?
https://www.hrw.org/news/2009/03/02/us-drug-arrests-skewed-r...
The only way you can change something by protesting is by projecting power. You do that either by the way you do the protesting, i.e. by actively engaging the police forces in trying to reach the seats of power (Parliament, Government's buildings) or by taking up in the streets the people who have the most power come election day, i.e. lots and lots of middle class people.
Movements like BLM are ineffectual when protesting because they do neither of the 2 things I mentioned above: they don't actively engage the powers in Washington and they are not joined by lots and lots of middle class people. As such, they'll remain ineffectual as long as nothing changes.
Source: me, a guy living in Eastern Europe who has grown-up by watching protests toppling Governments and who has actively joined those kind of protests once I grew up.