Re:Is There Any Point to Protesting?
by darepublic on Saturday August 26, 2017 @09:33AM
(#15105345)
Many of these protests don't effect change because their cause is not worthy. They have no coherent message nor righteous cause as in mlk and gandhi.
Re:Is There Any Point to Protesting?
by honestoHeminway on Saturday August 26, 2017 @11:25AM
(#15105833)
Eh, there are peacefull demos, which damage society even more. For example the bought Doctordemo in berlin.
http://www.tagesspiegel.de/berlin/die-gekaufte-demo/789302.h...
It is about who is protesting. I will give MLK and Gandhi.
A protest by its very definition is 'lame ass'. When you protest you're accepting the status quo, that's why they're allowed even in places like Turkey and China. They're a steam valve for people to feel they're doing something then they go back to their television and Big Macs.
For a protest to achieve something it has to have a goal, and the goal is always 'protesting', that doesn't change anything.
If you want to overthrow the Government then go shoot your local senator[0], taking the kids and waving hand made protest signs at the local park isn't going to do sh*t.
[0] It's an example. I'm in no way advocating anyone actually do this!
You're getting downvoted but you've hit on something: Most of these protest movements are or aim to be nonviolent, whereas the power of the state is always ultimately projected via violence. For a protest or movement to have real impact, it has to either use violence itself (projecting political power directly), or it has to prepare for a sustained nonviolent absorption/withstanding of state violence (to get political power on its side). Either way you need a lot more determination, organization, sustained effort, and friends than it takes to organize a flash mob.
Please, give me an example when ever in history a or a series of not-lame-ass protests did change something.
G20 in Hamburg was a good example of several not-lame-ass protests which didn't lead to anything beyond violence and destruction. Absolutely nothing changed or started to change because of them.