"Despite their polished 'Designed in California' efforts to strike a tone that resonates with the affluent organic free-range eco-democratic westcoast set, when the rubber hits the road, Apple kowtows to authoritarian despots if the profits are 'iphone-scale'."
Does that also sound like flamebait to you? If so, then I suggest you introspect about where and why your fires burn.
Did Apple cooperate with the FBI when they asked to help with the Pulse Club terrorist? No.
Pretending there isn't a moral dimension to it just because "it's business" is absurd.
To a degree. Every business has to follow the law of their head office and umbrella group. When local law is inconsistent with head office law, then a grey area is entered. If this grey area is not reconcilable, then head office wins and local office capitulates or shuts down if pushed to that extent.
Lastly, we don't have the right to tell China what is right for China. We can say we don't agree but similarly do we listen to China when they tell us what they don't like?
If they have good points, yeah. Grading ideas based on the source is a good way to stay ignorant.
Don't tell us you would say "no".
They've done it with various anti-LGBT efforts that have taken place around the US, they've done it with the fight with the FBI and they're doing it right now in Australia [1], among others.
What they don't do is shoot themselves in the head in some misguided attempt at ideological purity.
[1] https://www.macrumors.com/2017/07/20/apple-talks-australian-...
well, according to the post, they are actually complying with the law even now. The law might suck, but it's the law.
I would say "no". Tons of us would say "no".
There are various things on this spectrum that any business can choose to do, or not do: use child labor, use political prison labor, dump toxic waste in public streams and rivers (after funding lobbyists to make it legal), etc.
(And not just in China. For instance, Apple banned an app I used to keep rough tabs on how many civilians my democratically elected government was killing with drone strikes.)
There's a even strong chance I'd actively hamper company operations surrounding the project, and bust out psychological warfare on management until fired.
Millions lifted out of poverty. Nationalistic fervor. Chinese tourists traveling abroad (shows affluence.)
I'm no China apologist but we could do with less grandstanding overall.
The Chinese are the People, that's the point. Socialism. That's the definition of socialism.
The way you phrase 'The Chinese treat their people' is what socialism exists to fight against... or that's the ideological angle...
You cannot confuse nation, nationality, and identity for mainland China. They're rolled into one, which is perfect for the current hegemony.
Of course no one takes them seriously, because the actual reality on the field is that nothing other than profits matter.
I would love to see the party trying to come up with an excuse for their VIPs and their angry daughters for an Apple block.
If anything will add to the further downfall of Apple in China, it stripping functionality of the most popular mobile payment app in China. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-04-19/tencent-s...
Even more reasons to not do it. If Chinese Government decided they want you out, you will be out. Why not take some advertisement with them for the rest of the world? They surely knew how that works with the FBI problem.
Companies like Apple, Google, and Facebook can sway the world right into totalitarianism via their support of censorship and disregard for basic human rights. If these companies do side with the least common denominator, where does that leave the rest of us?
Even without VPN clients, iPhones still provide superior client-side security to a lot of other phones out there.