News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by chx on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @05:50AM (#14846444)
Microsoft is playing a fantastic Linux game with putting Linux userspace on the Windows desktop where drivers and UI are far better than the Linux drivers and UI and putting SQL Server on Linux server where the Linux kernel is much stronger. They know their strengths and weaknesses and not afraid to play to them.

Here's my writeup on setting up Windows 10 as a long, long time Linux user https://github.com/chx/chx.github.io/wiki/How-I-set-up-my-Wi...

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by thriftwy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:05AM (#14846502)
Too bad that Windows 10 barely usable on itself.

Every application looks different (yes they used to blame Linux/X11 on that one). It has two control panels (or three maybe), two web browsers shipped with it.

Takes more than a minute to boot on a new and pretty formidable laptop. This is the fresh factory install.

Can freeze the desktop while apparently doing something under the hood (installing updates? scanning malware? summoning the devil?), without any indication as to why, and not come back in five minutes.

Seriously considering overwriting it with Ubuntu even when it's aimed for a non-technical user.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by tw04 on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @11:34AM (#14848514)
>Every application looks different (yes they used to blame Linux/X11 on that one). It has two control panels (or three maybe), two web browsers shipped with it.

So you want your cake and you want to eat it too? It's pretty well known that as part of the new iterative release cycle they're slowly moving things into the new "control panel". That's not going to happen overnight, and unless you want to go back to only seeing new releases every 4+ years, we're going to have to be patient.

>Takes more than a minute to boot on a new and pretty formidable laptop. This is the fresh factory install.

Then something is seriously broken with the laptop, or you're running off a spinning drive. Regardless, if boot time is your primary factor in choosing an OS, you're doing it wrong.

>Can freeze the desktop while apparently doing something under the hood (installing updates? scanning malware? summoning the devil?), without any indication as to why, and not come back in five minutes.

Between that and your boot times, I would imagine you've got a garbage hard drive. I've never had windows "Freeze the desktop for 5 minutes at a time". A quick google search also finds no relevant posts on other people experiencing the same behavior. Windows updates wouldn't freeze your desktop. Heck, video card driver updates will cause your screen to black out for a couple seconds, but not freeze for 5 minutes.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by thriftwy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @11:54AM (#14848700)
> 's pretty well known that as part of the new iterative release cycle they're slowly moving things

Linux DEs were blasted for things like that, but now they're suddenly OK for a multi-billion-dollar company's flagship product?

> you're running off a spinning drive

I also happen to walk on the ground and climb up the stairs, being aware of alternatives. That's what I've got in a shop and it has MS Windows logo glued to it.

> I would imagine you've got a garbage hard drive.

I imagine that's what gets sold these days. BTW, I've also bought Xiaomi phone for $200 and it's a real snap.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by tw04 on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @12:27PM (#14849074)
>Linux DEs were blasted for things like that, but now they're suddenly OK for a multi-billion-dollar company's flagship product?

Yes actually. It's what users asked for, and I rather appreciate it. Linux DEs were BLASTED for breaking things. MS isn't breaking anything as they make the slow transition to the new panels. If you want to use the old control panel, everything is right there where it always was. If you want to use the new panel it will get you 90% of the way there on day-to-day tasks.

>I also happen to walk on the ground and climb up the stairs, being aware of alternatives. That's what I've got in a shop and it has MS Windows logo glued to it.

You're seriously on a technical site claiming you're pissed that you bought a dirt cheap laptop and got dirt cheap components? It's 2017, if you aren't willing to crack it and put an SSD into it, don't complain about performance. The laptop will be slow regardless of OS with a spinning drive.

Having a "windows logo" makes no guarantees of performance. Are you also pissed you can't run games in 4K on your $300 laptop?

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by thriftwy on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @04:50PM (#14860220)
> MS isn't breaking anything

Whoooa! I've now tried to find when you can change the hotkey for changing keyboard layout. It turns out, you can't find it now. New control panel has nothing and drops you into the old one immediately, which has nothing too.

It was working under Windows XP. Obviously you can't find how to configure anything in Windows these days without extensive googling.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by thriftwy on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @02:45AM (#14854091)
> you bought a dirt cheap laptop

As I've already said, you're a wrongfullt accusing right here. I've bought a mid-range laptop.

> The laptop will be slow regardless of OS with a spinning drive

As I've already said, you're wrong. Linux will still boot in 10 seconds and won't freeze for minutes during work.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by flukus on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @11:34PM (#14853504)
> and unless you want to go back to only seeing new releases every 4+ years

I was fine with that, I like my desktop to just be there and get out of the way, not something that has to impress me with shiny new features constantly. Even the ported apps aren't consistent though, look at the mail app and the hideous background image they put in it.

> I've never had windows "Freeze the desktop for 5 minutes at a time".

I certainly have on an intermittent internet connection, the start menu can freeze for several minutes. That isn't good enough for a basic OS feature that shouldn't even have an internet connection. On the same connection it can also take several minutes to login to login to the machine because it's tied to the MS account.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by aykutcan on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:49AM (#14846686)
Windows 10 is usable in every aspect.

Boot speed is pretty good and doesnt freeze like that.

Check your hardware if that is a fresh factory install. You are doing something wrong.

They are not common problems. They are yours.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by vidarh on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:42AM (#14846943)
I bought my son a new laptop earlier this year. It is something like ten times faster than his old Linux laptop (my old hand-me-downs), yet it boots slow and is sluggish with Windows where his old Linux setup was fast. I haven't had it freeze, but I've spent far more time solving problems with his new laptop in the last few months than in the last few years of having him use Linux. If it wasn't for some of the games he likes that aren't available for Linux, I'd have insisted he stick to it.

Maybe they're not common problems, but it's certainly not just him that find it gives a poor experience.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by alkonaut on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:57AM (#14847022)
If a new laptop is slow something must be wrong. Such as it having a mechanical disk. It might not seem like a big problem but it's almost a complete no go with win 10. If there are performance issues/freezing on a machine with 8GB and SSD then something is wrong and you should contact the manufacturer, chances are a bios or driver update will fix it
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by thriftwy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @08:05AM (#14847061)
> Such as it having a mechanical disk. it's almost a complete no go with win 10

Why then do Windows 10 laptops get sold with HDDs? You come to store and that's what you get out of it.

Also, Linux doesn't mind running from HDD. Not ten years ago, not now.

Lesson to MS: Get your act together or get out of this business. Come back from make-believe world. MS is running on make-believe for the last 10 years. Windows 8, the whole Avalon story, Windows Phone and now this Windows 10 "which only works well on SSD but never discourages anybody from getting an HDD laptop". Supposedly we should learn about this by telepathy or something.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by tw04 on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @11:38AM (#14848555)
>Also, Linux doesn't mind running from HDD. Not ten years ago, not now.

That's factually incorrect. OSX, Windows, Linux, it makes no difference. You cannot hide the 8ms of response time that comes with a crappy laptop spinning drive. If you spend all your time in a web browser with ample amounts of memory... sure. If you're doing ANYTHING that requires disk I/O - whether it be launching a game, or opening a large directory, you will experience significant lag time with a spinning drive.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by thriftwy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @11:56AM (#14848728)
Guess what, Linux distros figured out how to sprint read everything that is needed into RAM and boot under 10 seconds. Windows takes more than a minute on better hardware by seeking the hell out of it.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by tw04 on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @12:23PM (#14849029)
That's just not even remotely based in reality. Linux is SIGNIFICANTLY slower to boot on HDD than SSD.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bgmph_bL8V4

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X-Rsr4E6b68

But I would once again question why you care how long it takes to cold boot a laptop. I think my laptop gets cold booted MAYBE once a month.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by thriftwy on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @02:52AM (#14854111)
For some reason, my Windows 10 install reboots itself regularly. Or sometimes it freezes so the only solution is hard reset. That I'm not going to blame solely on Windows, but still, that's what I'm observing.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by alkonaut on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @08:16PM (#14852919)
Is there any Linux dist, even a minimal one, that out-boots windows? TIL.

On my SSD, my Win10 cold boots faster than my Dell U2410 screen displays anything if powered at the same time (couple of secs)

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by beagle3 on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @12:38AM (#14853675)
Yes. For years now (at least since 14.04), on HDD, Ubuntu boots to login screen (and once password is given, gets faster to usable desktop) than Win7, Win8.1 and Win10 on every hardware I've run both. And Ubuntu isn't the fastest booting desktop out there.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by flukus on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @11:43PM (#14853535)
> That's factually incorrect. OSX, Windows, Linux, it makes no difference. You cannot hide the 8ms of response time that comes with a crappy laptop spinning drive.

Sure you can, you can load stuff in memory so you don't have to hit the hard drive every time you do something like open the start menu. Once in a while the taskbar likes to "refresh" itself and the icons disappear while the drive spins up. It's not a problem I ever had on windows 7 or any linux machine.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by alkonaut on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @10:53AM (#14848144)
> Why then do Windows 10 laptops get sold with HDDs?

Excellent question. These machines should do better with Win7 but Microsoft doesn't want to sell it.

Microsoft sells windows 10 and Microsoft sells laptops with Windows 10 on an SSD. I doubt (but do correct me if I'm wrong) Microsoft sells any computers with Windows 10 on a mechanical drive.

Various manufacturers sell underpowered computers with Win10 on it, but thats hardly microsofts fault. They do that because otherwise they can't hit the lowest price segments.

What IS Microsoft's fault:

1)Microsofts "hardware requirements" only say what's necessary to use it, not what's needed for a decent experience.

2) not selling Win7 or making newer versions of windows work with older hardware.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by thriftwy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @11:58AM (#14848752)
> they can't hit the lowest price segments

That's a lie right here because the laptop in question not low end, definitely middle one.

> Various manufacturers sell underpowered computers with Win10

That was always part of Microsoft deal. You get your computer from a manufacturer other than MS and they still have to deliver experience, and they've failed that one.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by alkonaut on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @07:48AM (#14855358)
A recent middle range laptop didn't have an SSD? Obviously it might be a config option so a buyer might opt for a better gpu instead at the same price for example, but it still makes me a bit upset it's even possible to get a hdd if the laptop isn't low budget.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by vidarh on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @04:57AM (#14854574)
So in other words we need to buy substantially more expensive computers to get a usable experience with Windows vs. Linux. On top of the Windows license.

You'll note that with respect to my sons laptop, Linux ran just fine on his much older, slower laptop.

Says it all, really.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by alkonaut on Thursday July 27, 2017 @05:48PM (#14869930)
> So in other words we need to buy substantially more expensive computers to get a usable experience with Windows vs. Linux.

Well, "Linux" is much broader than a specific version of windows (Windows 10). But yes, for most kinds of linux setup (distro, window managers etc) I'd say the bare OS definitely needs less resources on Linux than on Windows.

I do find that apart from the storage issues, Win10 actually runs about as lean (on cpu and mem) as Win7. The problem with consumer hardware such as cheap or midrange laptops is usually that it's infested with crapware from the start, something I also blame microsoft for, not manufacturers.

The OEM agreeements microsoft do with laptop manufacturers should explicitly ban them from installing any crapware such as antivirus trial versions, poorly written hardware apps and similar. I realize the $400 price of a cheap laptop sometimes includes a big rebate due to the software bundles - but ms ought to put a stop to it. Has to be damaging to their brand.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by vidarh on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @04:54AM (#14854554)
Maybe we have different expectations of speed - I've never seen a Windows machine since about Windows 95 was current that didn't feel sluggish.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by kuschku on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @08:04AM (#14847055)
Oh, so you're offering to buy me an SSD for Windows 10? That's so nice of you!

/s

If it doesn't work on a mechanical drive, it's fucking broken.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by alkonaut on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @10:46AM (#14848078)
I didn't understand the question here (the /s was lost on me because I'm slow probably)
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by kuschku on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @01:30PM (#14849869)
If you say that a product that is forced upon me by an automatic upgrade just needs better hardware than what I had before, then that hardware upgrade should also happen automatically, or at least for free.

Additionally, you don't get to compare two products if one of them has massively higher hardware requirements.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by alkonaut on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @08:19PM (#14852932)
Oh - updates. Right.

Completely agree that having a major version bump as an automatic is insane.

That's why they should just skip the version numbering and just make it a subscription. Then they can sunset hardware 5-6 years old continuously like iOS, but let people choose to stay on the of version indefinitely.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by dboreham on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @10:25AM (#14847925)
I feel I have to counter this. I have seen similar problems on multiple different machines. I know they are not "my" problems. I've been a Windows user and supporter for decades but my experience in the past 5 years is that it unfortunately doesn't "just work" these days.

Also: your recommendation for resolving reliability issues is to reinstall the OS? Yes I know the historical reasons for saying this, but in 2017 if the user has to re-install the OS to get it to work I suggest the problem lies somewhere other than in the user.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by aykutcan on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @01:19PM (#14849721)
i am not recommending reinstall the OS. its so 90s. He/She said slow boot and freeze with "fresh factory install". Clearly having some issues.

I am also a technician and installed win10 more than i can count. Yes Old & Slow and New Budget-friendly machines are problematic with windows 10. Thats mainly because hardware. Because its new OS and getting better hardware is a must. You cant complain about a calculator can not run win10 properly. OF course 5200 rpm hdd and celeron cpu fails.

win10 is confusing? Yes. Sometimes goes hard on user? Yes. Annoying with their "windows store"? Oh very yes.

Slow and Freezing constantly? No. Proper UEFI setups works like a charm with proper machines.

Usable? yes it is.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by wbl on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @09:23PM (#14853131)
And what more features do I get? Everything I do today on a computer I could do in 1995.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by lottin on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:30AM (#14846876)
It seems to me that Windows users have a different idea of what constitutes a problem, because I always hear that Windows "just works" and yet whenever I have to use Windows I run into all sorts of issues. This isn't an isolated incident, it happens to me all the time.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by yjftsjthsd-h on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @09:03AM (#14847367)
> Check your hardware if that is a fresh factory install. You are doing something wrong.

And here I thought it was Linux users that were supposed to say "you're holding it wrong" and "just make sure you get supported hardware"

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by sz4kerto on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:25AM (#14846575)
> Too bad that Windows 10 barely usable on itself.

I am always surprised to hear these statements. Hundreds of millions of people use W10, so it must be usable to some extent. I think it's also quite rare that the system stops for 5 minutes -- actually I've never seen that happening.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by dboreham on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @10:19AM (#14847882)
Well...I'm a Windows user since around 1992 and have done pretty much all my coding typing on a keyboard connected to a Windows machine. However, I have to say that in recent years I have experienced similar hassles to the parent -- general unreliability, sleep/resume problems, machine just won't resume from sleep, endless WiFi driver bugs, touch screens that randomly stop working, pens that randomly stop working, and on and on. Initially (3-4 years ago) I assumed this was all due to lazy hardware OEMs not fixing their driver bugs so I switched to Microsoft hardware (Surfacen) but to be honest the buggy unreliability didn't change much.

I don't use Macs so I can't say if the grass is greener there. I do have a feeling that if I were using Linux on the laptop it would be much worse than Windows, but that's just a hunch based on my historical experience with Linux and device drivers.

I use Linux servers extensively and all my code runs on Linux in production fwiw. Linux on the server is almost at Solaris-level reliability today. The comments above relate to desktop/laptop machines.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by rjbwork on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:47AM (#14846679)
>I am always surprised to hear these statements.

No kidding. I use it every day nearly all day and I can count the number of times I've had the OS itself get in my way on 1 hand.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by ethbro on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @09:03AM (#14847363)
> I can count the number of times I've had the OS itself get in my way on 1 hand

I could overflow both hands just counting two Explorer things: (1) trying to figure out where MS put a setting/option if it's not on Ribbon & (2) trying to use any advanced search operators.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by rjbwork on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @09:58AM (#14847713)
I usually grep (powershell Get-ChildItem | Select-String) if I'm trying to do anything crazy in searching files.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by ethbro on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @12:07PM (#14848848)
Then there's also Powershell (as much as it improves on cmd) reminding me of adventure games where I have to remember which of the five synonymous verbs is recognized and does the thing I want.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by lenkite on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @12:43PM (#14849268)
You don't have to remember anything in powershell as you get parameter completion and command completion by default. Powershell useability beats the standard UNIX shells (bash/zsh) in command discovery and assistance. You even use PSReadLine if you want VI keybindings at the command line.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by ethbro on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:06PM (#14852308)
Am I using it wrong? I realize a large majority of those aren't used frequently, but there are ~250 cmdlets, each of which attempts to have a unique-but-also-generic name.

https://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ff714569.aspx

Let's say I didn't know ForEach-Object existed (trivial example, but generalizes), how do I find out there is a cmdlet that does what I'm looking for?

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by lenkite on Friday July 28, 2017 @01:19PM (#14875860)
`Get-Command` lists all the cmdlets in the current sesion. You can also alternatively hit `help -category cmdlet` which lists all cmdlets with their short alias and long name. You can do `man -category cmdlet` if you wish to page through. The first thing in powershell you should do is `help help` :).
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by thwd on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:46AM (#14846675)
Argumentum ad populum; people just don't know better. Also, I doubt it's really hundreds of millions (of people, as opposed to installs).
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by sz4kerto on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:21AM (#14846825)
What should they 'know'? If they can use it for their purposes then it is, per definition, usable. It's like saying that 'most cars are unusable for getting around'.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by thriftwy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:52AM (#14846990)
As somebody born in the USSR I can easily imagine how cars will be barely usable for getting around, and people who bother with cars will be called 'car enthusiasts' instead of 'people'.

We're there with Windows 10. We were better off with Windows XP and arguably we're much better with Android.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by thwd on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @09:30AM (#14847547)
They should know that not all cars break down two times a month on average and that black smoke is definitively not a feature.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by aykutcan on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:59AM (#14846731)
That was an anectodal evidence at first place.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by eddieroger on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @08:08AM (#14847073)
Barely usable is dramatic, but the multiple interfaces to do seemingly the same thing is annoying and I agree makes usability a challenge. What differentiates when a setting is in the old Control Panel versus the new one? What's the difference between Edge and Internet Explorer, and why is my browser sometimes a traditional window and sometimes a full screen, touch focused app (this is a gaming PC hooked to a TV, so no touching)? I'm often accused of being an Apple fanboy, and while I try to stay agnostic, I think some of the things Windows has done with 10 are pretty confusing, though markedly better than whatever they tried to do with 8.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by futurix on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @09:55AM (#14847696)
You already know the answer to all of these questions, stop posturing. Yes, Microsoft kept old versions of IE and Control Panel for compatibility - but you don't get to access them unless you really want to.

As for full screen browser, touch-optimised IE was in Windows 8. It is not in Windows 10. Your rant is 2 years out of date.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by thriftwy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @12:02PM (#14848799)
> Microsoft kept... Control Panel for compatibility

Around half settings that the internets tell me to tweak these days are on [the old] Control Panel. Another half is in the registry or group policy or some "Run..." utility and never the new one.

> you don't get to access them unless you really want to

That one is correct, I can never find the thing when it's needed again.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by bb611 on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @11:01AM (#14848193)
My boot time on an SSD + i5 on my 4.5 year old desktop is <10 seconds. The same PC boots Ubuntu in ~5. ~2 seconds of both is BIOS boot time. I haven't experienced any annoying issues with Win 10.

Obviously, there is some variation in experience, and I doubt all of it can be chalked up to the OS.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by tiernano on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:19AM (#14846556)
just curious: you say "new, factory fresh install"... is this factory fresh, as in "OEM" install, or your own install? if its OEM, could it be whatever crap was installed? third party antivirus, etc? i have Win10 installed on a Surface Book, and, other them me installing stuff i shouldent, the machine works well... i did have to uninstall corporate AV (the standard MS one works just as well... and its cheaper than the corporate one...) but other than that, as long as i dont install "stupid" stuff (other AV, any other crap that fecks with the system) all is good...
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by thriftwy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:36AM (#14846912)
It's OEM. There was some crapware, I have removed most of it, but to no avail.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by tiernano on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @01:43PM (#14850025)
First thing I have done with most non Microsoft hardware is format and reinstall... even removing stuff still leave crap on your machine...
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by JCharante on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @11:17AM (#14848342)
> Takes more than a minute to boot on a new and pretty formidable laptop. This is the fresh factory install.

Oh come on, you can't blame the OS for that. Whenever I want to play games my Desktop is loading the desktop in less than 20 seconds, it's not optimal but if it takes 1 minute there has to be something wrong with the laptop.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by 43224gg252 on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @08:21AM (#14847153)
Agreed. No "hacker" would ever use or recommend Windows. It's awful for development, and even microsoft agrees, which is why they created a Linux sub-system.

Why would a so called "hacker" choose to use an OS that's slow, has horrible update policies, horrible privacy standards, injects ads into the main programs and start menu, requires anti-virus, etc?

Also, the idea that Windows has good drivers and Linux doesn't is asinine. My current dell came pre-loaded with windows 10 and failed to wake from sleep without me opening and closing the lid, then when it woke up, wifi would not come on and the only thing that fixed it was a reboot. Then when I used the touch screen things were going fine until I tried to select text and got an instant BSOD. Also I learned not to accidentally touch the screen and then try to type immediately afterward, or it would lock up the whole OS.

Linux just worked. Literally. Even the touch screen. I get 15 minutes less battery life but it's worth it.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by kyberias on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @10:04AM (#14847759)
Why are there no ads on my Start menu? I'm also quite happy developing software with it.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by geofft on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @10:01AM (#14847737)
> Why would a so called "hacker" choose to use an OS that's slow, has horrible update policies, horrible privacy standards, injects ads into the main programs and start menu, requires anti-virus, etc?

I don't know, but that's why I use Windows 10 instead of Ubuntu.

Please back up your polemics with facts. I don't run antivirus on Windows and never have; it's the same fundamental security model as desktop Linux, and if you don't go around installing programs from untrustworthy places (whether download.com or SourceForge), you don't need it. And at a more-than-first-order level, Windows' security model is far better.

I have patches in the Linux kernel and I strongly recommend that someone looking for a secure desktop OS use Windows instead of Linux.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by ekianjo on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:07AM (#14846511)
Thats if you dont mind the hugely privacy invasive win10 environment to begin with.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by geofft on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @10:03AM (#14847749)
Good point. Let me switch to Ubuntu, which definitely doesn't have any privacy invasions in its desktop environment....
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by beagle3 on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @12:48AM (#14853709)
They don't, since a long time ago. And for the short time they did, they documented exactly what was sent, to who, and how to turn it off (and you were able to verify that by looking at the source, recompiling yourself, etc.)

Please explain how to do any of those things on Windows - either the new 10, or the retrofitted-telemetry 7 which one has to retrofit with telemetry if they want security updates.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by geofft on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @10:08AM (#14856265)
> and you were able to verify that by looking at the source

How much of Ubuntu has undergone a security audit by people who are looking for actively maliciously obfuscated code?

In a codebase the size of Ubuntu (and all its packages), "you can look at the source" is a mindgame, nothing more.

Also, you can look at Windows' source code. In addition to the numerous programs Microsoft has for licensing the code to universities, researchers (including security auditors!), well-known community members, etc. the source code has been leaked multiple times.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by beagle3 on Thursday July 27, 2017 @02:19AM (#14863053)
> How much of Ubuntu has undergone a security audit by people who are looking for actively maliciously obfuscated code?

You've just moved the goal posts from "we can look at what it's doing" to "we assume they tried to hide what it is doing" - which we know that e.g. Microsoft did bundling telemetry into Win7 security updates, but that Canonical never did. Nice.

I don't know how much has been gone through by people looking for underhanded code, but ... quite a few looking at the basic code. And if you expect underhanded code, I think you should just not trust the vendor.

> In a codebase the size of Ubuntu (and all its packages), "you can look at the source" is a mindgame, nothing more.

Actually, quite a few people diff ubuntu against debian to see the changes, and Ubuntu's original, independent code is not that huge - in fact, the community took over Unity, so there are a lot of people looking at it.

> Also, you can look at Windows' source code. In addition to the numerous programs Microsoft has for licensing the code to universities, researchers (including security auditors!), well-known community members, etc. the source code has been leaked multiple times.

Now, that's a complete joke.

Unlike ubuntu (which I have, in the very distant past 8.04 or 6.06 days rebuilt the base of, and which others regularly do), you have absolutely zero way to verify that the 400MB executable you installed does not include, in addition to the source you have, backdoors, telemetry etc.

When I was in Uni, I talked to one of the guys who get access to the source. It was view-only, can't rebuild, some critical parts missing. Maybe these days it is buildable, but I'd be surprised. And even if it is, you're not allowed to use it (except for auditing purposes), which goes back to the previous point - you have little idea what you're actually running.

> the source code has been leaked multiple times.

That's another joke. First, no professional would review _that_ because of legal ramifications.

I have a simple proof that you are completely, utterly, wrong in your assertions, and I would love for you to refute it.

If it's so easy to see what Microsoft is doing, how come there wasn't a single source for what Win10 actually sends home, for what the Win7/8.1 telemetry sends home, that was based on facts? In fact, the only semi-reliable (but not audited, or 3rd party confirmed!) source of what Win10 sends is from Microsoft, released over a year after Win10 was out. And it's frightening enough as it is.

I call bullshit on your claims. You're welcome to like Microsoft better than Ubuntu, but please stick to the facts.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by ekianjo on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @01:41AM (#14853877)
Oh, you mean the Amazon searches that were disabled with one click? Win10 goes WAY beyond that. And Linux != Ubuntu as far as I know. Nice strawman.
Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by pjmlp on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:16AM (#14846798)
It is way less than what Google does on my Android devices.

Now Google Maps even asks me to upload pictures of places where I happen to be.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by 43224gg252 on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @08:27AM (#14847175)
So because Google is worse that makes it okay for MS?

I disagree. If you're a programmer who cares about privacy use Linux.

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by pjmlp on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @08:44AM (#14847245)
I already do on my phone, doesn't help.

https://source.android.com/source/

Re:How Microsoft brought SQL Server to Linux by yulaow on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:40AM (#14846654)
At least their new privacy settings are far more decent and complete than before... still hope they put it as opt-in instead of opt-out.