News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by osrec on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @11:59AM (#14797563)
I think this is well known. The real problem is that the traders are much smarter than the regulators, and their ability to obscure far exceeds the regulators' ability to untangle. Incentivise your regulators better and you might end up attracting some real talent who can unearth the tricks the crafty traders pull every day (I am an ex trader, from a bulge bracket IB, and trust me, what some of these guys do is not at all kosher).
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:14PM (#14798241)
Or we can just ban anything insufficiently transparent and be done with it. After all, the point of a market transaction for pricing is its ability to convey transparent, accurate information to other market participants -- right?
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by rosser on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:24PM (#14798342)
In theory, sure.

How's that working out for us?

EDIT: Meta, I will never tire of hearing people be all, "But markets!" as if they aren't just as corruptible as any other human institution — if not more so.

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:49PM (#14798595)
Well, I agree that it's not working out very ideally for us. This is why I think all those hyper-complicated trades don't necessarily have much real economic value, and banning them is unlikely to be very harmful.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by Brockenstein on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @02:36PM (#14798964)
"But but the regulations impeding economic growth... "
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @02:46PM (#14799027)
> After all, the point of a market transaction for pricing is its ability to convey transparent, accurate information to other market participants

Arguably, the transparency for pricing that matters is only the final trade price, but I'd argue, in any case, that providing liquidity and actually pricing trades that occur is the more important function of markets, not providing pricing information.

OTOH, transparent pricing information brings some participants to the market, which increases liquidity; conversely, though, so does providing various dark trading vehicles. So, in the liquidity-focussed view, there is a trade-off and a balance to be struck.

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by osrec on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @12:04PM (#14797610)
Also, there is an argument for more time controlled auctions rather than giving everyone a continuous look at the order book. Much like the start of day auction, you could have something similar every minute, where traders submit prices but matching only occurs at the end of each minute. This would certainly put an end to the annoying high/low ticking that happens all too often.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by harryh on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @12:07PM (#14797637)
There is no good argument for this. The problems you think it might solve...it doesn't solve.

Hint: if the minute long auction closes at precisely the minute boundary at what time do you want to put your orders in?

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by pishpash on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:27PM (#14798370)
Sure there is. The idea isn't to quantize to arbitrarily long times, but to make it long enough compared to the time of information generation and more importantly, communication. Otherwise you may as well give up the notion of a common market. The number may not be a minute but it sure as hell ain't a nanosecond.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by harryh on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:33PM (#14798437)
The real world is continuous. It cannot be quantized.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:39PM (#14798502)
> The real world is continuous. It cannot be quantized.

I thought modern physics leaned more toward “the real world is quantized, but the quanta are small enough that things usually seem continuous to human perception.”

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by harryh on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:41PM (#14798521)
Heh. Perhaps that is true. But since we're all up here operating at speeds far slower than planck time I am gonna cheat and call it continuous. For the discussion at hand it is true enough.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by r00fus on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @03:44PM (#14799468)
Finance is NOT the real world. Lets not pretend that stock movements obey some sort of "universal laws" or such nonsense.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by pfortuny on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @02:40PM (#14798988)
like 32 bit fixed point continuous?
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by pishpash on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:43PM (#14798544)
What a fatuous comment. The real world satisfies laws of physics. Your fantasy of a continuous single market doesn't exist. This (information coherency) problem has been solved many times in engineering and the solution is quantization.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by harryh on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:44PM (#14798561)
I do not have that fantasy. I'm sorry if I gave you the impression that I did. I have communicated poorly somehow if that is the case.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by jcfrei on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @02:23PM (#14798867)
There are some good economic arguments to be made in favor of frequent batch auctions. Check out the following presentation by Eric Budish from the University of Chicago ( https://simons.berkeley.edu/talks/eric-budish-2015-11-19 ).
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by joosters on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @12:25PM (#14797796)
As well as making the current bids invisible, you can reduce the auction times considerably - once per second, for instance.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by osrec on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @12:34PM (#14797883)
Yes absolutely. The SETS order book (London SE) now runs an intra day auction at 12pm where it limits the amount of info available during the auction. It is a price forming auction - it aims to decide a fair price for the stock while limiting information to participants. See: http://www.lseg.com/markets-products-and-services/our-market...
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by gnaritas on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @04:40PM (#14799885)
> once per second, for instance.

That won't change anything, he who trades first still wins, HFT will still exist.

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by osrec on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @12:08PM (#14797653)
Hint: If you can't see the orders during that minute, it doesn't matter when you submit...
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by sseveran on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @12:24PM (#14797782)
Of course it does. A trader (not an investor) is incentivized to wait to the last possible moment when he can still expect a fill. This is why exchanges disseminate auction imbalance information, to attract people to the auction prior to its completion.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by orclev on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @12:43PM (#14797981)
In what way is he incentivized? What advantage does he get from waiting till the last possible moment? He has no clue what the current bids are, so whether he bids at the start or the end he still has exactly as much information. He'll have more information after the bidding closes and the winner is announced of course, but by then it's too late, only thing he can do then is participate in the next round of bidding, but that puts him right back in the situation he was in before where until the close the only thing he knows is what the previous winning bid was.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by sseveran on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:01PM (#14798127)
First off a trader with the results of all previous auctions should be able to make some educated estimates about what the auction contains. Secondly prices are formed by incorporating information into the price. Supply and demand information is only one type of information. Say that we have an auction expiring at 10AM. At 9:59:59.500 Goldman's equity research desk announces that it is downgrading a security. Our trader can now in the remaining 500 milliseconds place aggressive asks to take advantage of what is likely to be a downward price movement. Other's in the auction with resting bids are now going to trade into a price that is moving lower. And arguing against colocation will not help here. There will always be traders who are able to place themselves at whatever the closest allowed point, whether inside the exchange or not.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by Retric on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:41PM (#14798527)
Sure, but this is combined with all other information over that minute/hour. Suppose you had exactly 1 price exchange per day, now yes you might gain incite waiting for that last millisecond, but you have to weigh all other information over the day, approximate it's changes in the price, and then make a bid. Further if the ticks are say every 15 minutes it's easy to not disclose information on a tick boundary. (Simply because of relative time frames.)
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by harryh on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:46PM (#14798573)
Further if the ticks are say every 15 minutes it's easy to not disclose information on a tick boundary.

This is not true. Lots of things are happening in the world all of the time. You can't tell everyone to stop what they are doing every 15 minutes and wait for the stock market auction to close.

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by Retric on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @02:38PM (#14798976)
If ticks are 15 minutes, then 99.9% of all things don't happen in that last 1/2 second. Compared to the current situation where every single piece of news is a race for 1/1,000th of a second head starts.

So rather than a race vs time, it's a race to better interpret information. And considering that's basically the point of the stock market in the first place I would call that a net win.

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by harryh on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @12:45PM (#14798000)
There are lots of other forms of information in the world other than the orders in a closed auction.

Serious question: Why do people always forget this? This comes up ALL THE TIME when people talk about quantized auction times.

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by osrec on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:21PM (#14798314)
Your definition of a quantised auction is a bit different to mine. In my definition, you submit at the start and get an outcome at the end. You have no ability to modify the contents of the auction during the auction itself. I feel what you're describing is still a continuous auction... I mean if you can continually modify your order, or indeed submit at different times, at which point in time do you do your matching?
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by harryh on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:32PM (#14798410)
TBH I don't really understand what you are trying to say, but if you submit at "the start" and that is a single moment in time then participants have every incentive to wait until the last possible microsecond before that moment to determine their bids/asks.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by URSpider94 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @02:22AM (#14802317)
There always has to be a moment when you lock in the bids, and a non-infinitescimal window before that time when bids are accepted. As long as that window has a start and an end, there will still be traders who write algorithms to deliver their orders at the final microsecond the window is open. 99.999999% of the time, nothing happens. But, in that one case where the articles of impeachment are released just before the window closes, those algos will pay for themselves a billion times over.

Separating the last moment when bids are accepted from the time when the auction closes has no practical effect, other than just a simple time delay.

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by stale2002 on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:23PM (#14798325)
"What advantage does he get from waiting till the last possible moment? "

He gets more advantage from outside information sources.

You are correct that you cannot gain info from the bids that are happening on THAT market, but you can instead get bid/price info on OTHER markets/auctions.

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by osrec on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:12PM (#14798234)
You seem to be describing a standard, continuous auction. Consider a more discrete time auction, like the opening auction described here: https://uk.advfn.com/Help/the-opening-auction-68.html - I'm not saying this format is perfect, but with modification, it may be reasonable
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by sseveran on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @09:39PM (#14801522)
Actually the continuous cross is the special one from strictly the auction design perspective. I am very familiar with discrete auctions and their advantages and drawbacks. It turns out there there are many times to participate in such discrete crosses. Nasdaq for instance runs 3 or 4 every day in addition to the opening and closing crosses.

Just remember that from a market structure perspective, the continuous cross is the best for liquidity. All markets for things like derivatives try to move in the direction of a continuous cross over time.

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by harryh on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @12:10PM (#14797667)
Might other things be happening in the world besides orders on a single exchange?
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by orclev on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @12:51PM (#14798053)
It seems like that would only matter if you assume that a bid can't be canceled or changed. Assuming you're free to cancel or modify a bid right up until the close, whether you put the bid in at the start of the window or the close of the window wouldn't matter as you could always modify or cancel the bid as new information comes in.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by harryh on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @01:03PM (#14798145)
If you can always modify or cancel a bid then people will compete to see who can ingest information the fastest and update all of their bids as close to the auction time as possible.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by princeb on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @02:08PM (#14798730)
even if you can't modify or cancel a bid people will still compete on speed and submit their one (and only) order as close to the auction time as possible.

i have no idea what he's trying to come up with. there's no need to belabour the point plenty here have tried to show that the power of information (of all kinds: central bank actions, Donald Trump's tweets, corporate filing, obituaries, declaration of war, natural disasters, etc) and the ability to push order submission to the last moment is going to be king. the only way i can imagine one would nullify the value of information is to assign every participant of the market a random price on their trade that has no correlation to the value of the asset that they are trying to buy or sell.

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by lordnacho on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @03:04PM (#14799159)
A couple of facts about the auctions:

- They often end at a randomized time in a given window

- They often cross a very large proportion of a day's trading

So in some sense the things you are after - hard to game, transparent auctions - are already in existence. If you're happy with waiting, you can pretty much ignore the continuous trading when you're buying/selling your shares. The exchanges I look at all have an opening and closing auction, and a few have a midday auction as well.

I'm literally coding a system that uses the auctions right now. To game the randomized end would not be easy, though there are a number of particular market models that open for it.

In general, the exchange system has gotten out of hand. There's a lot of weird rules that only make sense if you're told what they're for, and it will undermine confidence if they continue to grow. It's become a catch-22 though, as the markets need the market makers, and the market makers can't make money so easily without an advantage of some sort.

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by loeg on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @12:25PM (#14797793)
> I think this is well known.

I hadn't heard of this. But then again, I'm not an institutional investor and I don't place a lot of trades.

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by c3534l on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @03:13PM (#14799238)
> The real problem is that the traders are much smarter than the regulators

They're not smarter, they have massively more resources. The SEC investigates and takes to court the tiny, tiny portion of investors which are the most egregious and easy-to-prosecute criminals. This isn't like hackers fighting against security systems.

Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by daodedickinson on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @02:28PM (#14798908)
Eh, somebody in their spare time figured out Bernie Madoff's scheme in the 90's and wrote them an explanation such that ignorance was no excuse. The SEC regulator marrying Madoff's daughter seems relevant.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by chuckkir on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @02:42PM (#14799004)
Madoff didn't have a daughter.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by andrewla on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @02:53PM (#14799079)
Not to support GP's point, but he's probably referring to Shana Madoff, Bernie's niece, who was a compliance officer at the firm and married an SEC regulator. I'm not aware of any report "exposing" the Ponzi before it actually happened, but Shana met her husband during an SEC investigation into allegations of front-running by Madoff's fund.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by TearsInTheRain on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @12:56PM (#14798085)
you have to target the disgruntled employees that already know the tricks and get them to flip.
Re:Wall Street Profits by Putting Investors in the Slow Lane by osrec on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @12:59PM (#14798107)
You know, I've always thought this! Even better, get the guys that have been convicted of serious financial fraud to help the regulators out!