I thought modern physics leaned more toward “the real world is quantized, but the quanta are small enough that things usually seem continuous to human perception.”
That won't change anything, he who trades first still wins, HFT will still exist.
This is not true. Lots of things are happening in the world all of the time. You can't tell everyone to stop what they are doing every 15 minutes and wait for the stock market auction to close.
So rather than a race vs time, it's a race to better interpret information. And considering that's basically the point of the stock market in the first place I would call that a net win.
Serious question: Why do people always forget this? This comes up ALL THE TIME when people talk about quantized auction times.
Separating the last moment when bids are accepted from the time when the auction closes has no practical effect, other than just a simple time delay.
He gets more advantage from outside information sources.
You are correct that you cannot gain info from the bids that are happening on THAT market, but you can instead get bid/price info on OTHER markets/auctions.
Just remember that from a market structure perspective, the continuous cross is the best for liquidity. All markets for things like derivatives try to move in the direction of a continuous cross over time.
i have no idea what he's trying to come up with. there's no need to belabour the point plenty here have tried to show that the power of information (of all kinds: central bank actions, Donald Trump's tweets, corporate filing, obituaries, declaration of war, natural disasters, etc) and the ability to push order submission to the last moment is going to be king. the only way i can imagine one would nullify the value of information is to assign every participant of the market a random price on their trade that has no correlation to the value of the asset that they are trying to buy or sell.
Hint: if the minute long auction closes at precisely the minute boundary at what time do you want to put your orders in?