Even if not, the pilot would've probably aborted the landing since he saw the other aircrafts. So it was certainly a dangerous situation but I doubt that a crash would've happened without that pilot's comment (it was certainly helpful though).
At night, there are many visual cues to see the runway environment - it sounds to me like this complacent pilot ignored many red flags and was about to drive his plane on top of those on the taxiway.
A big heavy airliner can't just stop its decent instantly; it's a good thing that pilot on the ground chimed in when he did.
I betcha the landing pilot won't have a job pretty soon.
A C-5 that's trying to drop out of the sky ASAP before anyone can shoot at it is a different story.
The pilot and copilot were clearly in WTF mode since there were planes on what they thought was the runway. If nobody had spoken up it would likely have gone back and fourth between them and the tower a few times ("are you sure the runway is clear?") and in all likelihood they would have caught it. If they didn't the pilots would have likely requested to go around. Backing off of what you're doing and assessing the situation when anything is not quite right is SOP in every facet of aviation.
Edit: here's a good example of a terminal radar display. The two parallel diagonal lines are the extended centerlines of two runways that are about 1570m apart (Athens airport, LGAV).
https://www.hvacc.gr/site/images/content/events/2003/athens-...
http://flightaware.com/resources/airport/SFO/APD/AIRPORT+DIA...
It's sometimes harder when there's nothing impeding you at all to do everything right because the routine-ness of habit takes over. Being busy (but not overwhelmed), while more mentally and physically tiring, is sometimes easier, because you pay attention to the right things at the right time.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SgPuyzogFuI
It's from a Delta flight a few years ago that slid off the runway at LaGuardia in snow. The action starts about 5 minutes into that recording; Tower has just set up another incoming Delta flight to land, and is trying to confirm Delta 1086 has cleared the runway. Delta 1086 is poking its nose out over the water at this point, and the controller can't see it.
At around 5:56 a ground vehicle calls in to ask permission to cross the runway and gets it. Then the ground vehicle sees what's happened (Delta 1086 slid off the end of the runway), and this is where it gets interesting, because you see very quickly two important things:
1. Trusting the report: the guy up in the tower does not have a perfect view, and in fact in this incident he can't see what has happened to this Delta plane. He's getting an unsolicited report from a ground vehicle, but he believes it and acts immediately on it. If the report's mistaken, worst outcome is some planes circle a bit more before they finally land. If the report's right, though, the worst outcome is planes trying to land on a crash site.
2. Division of responsibility. From the moment the crash becomes known, it's the job of the emergency/rescue teams to figure out what's happened and deal with it. The guy in the tower probably desperately wants to know more about what's going on, but he's got planes stacked up waiting to land, and his curiosity is going to have to wait. Beyond getting confirmation of a couple unusual orders, Tower just lets the folks on the ground do their job, and sticks to doing his.
Here's a rough annotated transcript (timestamps are from the video), since I know people complain that ATC recordings are hard to make out:
6:08: Delta 1086, Tower? (trying to contact the plane that's just gone off the end of the runway -- Tower still doesn't know what's happened)
Tower, call 100, Runway 13 is closed. (ground vehicle has seen the accident)
Tower, red team to go onto 13.
Tower, you copy? Call 100, Runway 13 is closed.
Call 100, you said Runway 13 is closed? (Tower confirms what he's just heard)
Affirmative, 13 is closed.
Team red, Tower?
Tower, you have an aircraft off the runway.
6:45: Delta 1999, go around!
1999, going around.
6:50: The airport is closed. The airport is closed. We've got a 34. (ground crew saying this is bad enough the airport needs to close)
Call 100, say again?
6:59: Tower, you have an aircraft off 31 on the north vehicle service road, please advise crash rescue, LaGuardia Airport is closed at this time.
7:12: Good afternoon, Tower, Delta 2522's on the ILS for 13 (another Delta flight is lining up to land on the runway where the crash happened* -- they can't hear what's happening below)
Delta 2522, LaGuardia Tower, go around!
Go around, Delta 2522. (pilot confirms that he's going around)
From there on out, it's just Tower giving instructions to other planes on what to do, and a report from the ground to tell the pilot of the crashed plane (if he does get on the radio again) that the plane is leaking fuel from a ruptured wing.
Now: what if the ground vehicle hadn't gone out there? Or hadn't seen the crash in time, or hadn't been able to get a report to the tower in time, or the tower had hesitated a bit more in accepting the report and starting to reroute planes? A similar problem to the SFO incident, only instead of an occupied taxiway it would've been an occupied runway (and one that had already caused one plane to slide off in the snow, and now had emergency vehicles converging on it).
The point is, though, that this isn't necessarily a miracle or a lucky escape -- everybody is involved in ensuring safety, and that's what happened in both cases, providing extra layers of watchfulness which averted much more serious trouble.
* The runway is referred to as both "13" and "31" at different points; runways are numbered according to compass heading, so "13" means it's aligned to a heading of 130 degrees. The dual numbers are because you can take off or land from either end; the other number is always +/- 18, since it's 180 degrees around from the first one. In this case, the designation of the runway is 13 from one end, and 31 (for 310 degrees, 130 + 180) from the other end.
/sarcasm
AM is not prone to capture effect, wherein the loudest signal captures the receiver. With AM, you can hear multiple people talking on top of each other at the same time.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capture_effect
For uncontrolled radio situations where you have a number of unknown people who need to access a radio channel, neither digital nor encryption bring any wanted benefits.
As a note - the audio from this recording is very clear to me - I've heard far worse out of scratchy narrowband FM.. with AM the weaker the signal generally the quieter it is - but not generally that much noisier.
I've been into amateur radio for ages, presumably that has trained my ear. I routinely copy voice signals which are just a garbled gibberish to innocent bystanders. (Same obviously goes for ATCs and pilots to an even larger degree, being exposed to comms several hours a day)
Yeah, Even with P25 - the same skills apply, but instead of pulling it out of noise, you're relying on your skills of interpolation to suck it out of the noise. Still it's a neat parlor trick :-D
73's
They too have uncontrolled radio, a large number of unknown people who need to communicate with whoever happens to be nearby, they have more powerful transmitters owned by governments that "need" to shout down less powerful ones on transport vessels occasionally.
Now, maritime radio IS a different environment. I'm not suggesting that DSC should just be dropped in as a replacement for AM analogue transceivers on planes, but I _am_ saying that I don't buy the theory that it so happens AM analogue is the right choice and not just the result of inertia.
> Just imagine the economic damage that a single asshole can do with a high-powered transmitter near an airport.
the pilots could probably just pull their cell phones out and call the tower. there is much worse trouble single assholes could get up to.
On the other hand, AM is simple and cheap and usable worldwide without significant investment.
I assure you that there is a reason AM is used. The reason is that in the case that two stations are transmitting, everyone will be aware of it and the stronger signal may be heard. This is not something that FM can guarantee. And a digital protocol requires a much better signal (where old analog tv gave snowy picture digital TV gives nothing). Not to mention the insane costs that digital radio retofitting would require of every single plane in the sky.
Edit: parent seems to have deleted his post. It previously asked condescendingly why we still use AM for comms in the air.
I think a digital system could be done much better than what we have. But I'm sure it's not worth the huge effort it would take to design and build.
What it normally does is reduce gain on high strength signals, and increases it on weak ones to give a constant volume level.
I'm honestly surprised the radios in general aviation craft are not so equipped, as its generally a standard part of most AM radios.
So sure, you could pay a bunch of extra money for military features and end up with a product that is even less what you want than AM radio. And then you'd have to retrofit everything with these systems.
AM is wonderful. You put a bunch of people on the same channel and it just works.
Note that that technology has been around since World War II. And fun fact, while we're on that topic, this page is worth a read: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hedy_Lamarr
Evie might know this, too, so I think you should be concerned about jamming. Luckily, AM provides jamming resistance, since Evie would have to bring a powerful transmitter to be loud enough to drown out the other signals.
Nevertheless, I think large airports should have fast response teams who can rapidly fix the position of a jammer and silence it, if needed. If Evie could effectively take out, say, the main airports of LA and SF for a few hours with a few strong AM transmitters, I doubt all will end well.
Heck, the FCC will even track you down if you operate an unlicensed radio station. See: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QIGAOLJh-XE
This kind of thinking has also lead to a ton of success in Silicon Valley. See Tesla for example.
Companies like Uber, Google, Amazon certainly disrupted markets but I wouldn't be so sure about Tesla.
Volvo has credited Tesla for pushing car makers into EVs, so at least one incumbent thinks that: https://electrek.co/2017/05/17/volvo-tesla-says-stop-diesel-...
Audi seems to as well, although it's not quite as clear: http://insideevs.com/audis-electromobility-boss-i-hate-to-ad...
Well, not exactly a role model for success. 2016 was the first time they made any profit in all those years -- and its uncertain if 2017 will follow.
And it might still be beaten up in all its markets (electric cars and eventually self-driving ones), not a sure winner yet.
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Date_and_time_representation_b...
https://forums.liveatc.net/atcaviation-audio-clips/7-july-ks...
> Audio from the air traffic controller communication archived by a user on LiveATC.net and reviewed by this newspaper organization showed how a the confused Air Canada pilot asks if he’s clear to land on 28R because he sees lights on the runway.
> “There’s no one on 28R but you,” the air controller responds.
> An unidentified voice, presumably another pilot, then chimes in: “Where’s this guy going. He’s on the taxiway.”
> The air controller quickly tells the Air Canada pilot to “go around.” telling the pilot “it looks like you were lined up for Charlie (Taxiway C) there.”
> A United Airlines pilot radios in: “United One, Air Canada flew directly over us.”
> “Yeah, I saw that guys,” the control tower responds.