News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by fooker on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @08:18PM (#14699162)
The brain is incredibly good at math, just the APIs are not exposed.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by deaddodo on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @12:45AM (#14700023)
Exactly. I always have to make this clear to people. The conscious mind is incapable of fast arithmetic, but the subconscious mind is amazingly capable. It's doing complex, freebase (relative vs static) calculations constantly. The ability to track and accurately move your limbs with a non-determined base point with a few hundred nanosecond-millesecond latency (proactive) or 150-250ms latency (responsive) is without compare.

Just look at machines that don't do precalculated movements (ASIMO, but even many of its patterns are prepared; Boston Dynamics robots, etc) versus those that do (industrial assembly line robots) and it gap is insanely wide. And even then, the dynamic bots are doing maybe one or two things at a time (walk, stop, pickup, walk, drop) nothing complex or integrated.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by pjc50 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @05:03AM (#14700889)
Is it? Is there any evidence that it's converting the signals to symbols and performing arithemtic on the symbols? Or is the signal processing being performed "directly", through the essentially analogue operation of the neurons?

Otherwise you're asserting "doing arithmetic" as a property of any analogue system, and would say that a falling ball needs to understand calculus in order to make an arc. Downthread someone is saying that crystal formation is "doing arithmetic". While there may be a philosophical sense in saying that all actions of the universe are in some sense arithmetical as they obey physical laws, this is not a useful way to talk.

(Repost of my comment above)

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by visarga on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @09:00AM (#14702016)
What's the difference between "crystal formation" and cpu processing? They are both physical processes that don't understand the mathematical concepts that underpin their functioning. Maybe they do computation, but not math. Only humans can do math so far, and maybe some AIs, in a limited sense. Understanding math is harder than computing.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by fooker on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @06:43AM (#14701326)
>Or is the signal processing being performed "directly", through the essentially analogue operation of the neurons?

You almost described a transistor. :)

The physical world, at our scale in inherently analogue.

(Might be digital at a quantum level, but we don't know that yet.)

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by pjc50 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @07:14AM (#14701451)
The point I'm trying to make is that computers "do arithmetic" through digital operations where there is a symbolic representation (through assigning analogue state to discrete symbolic values). Not through transistors operating continuously in their linear region.

Inside neuronal systems there doesn't seem to be a direct symbolic representation - and if there is, the neuronal patterns of somebody doing calculus on paper versus e.g. catching a ball are entirely different.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by fooker on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @02:42PM (#14705070)
The symbolic representation is just a language though. We might not be equipped to understand a language different from the formalisms we came up with.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by heavenlyblue on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @06:42AM (#14701320)
Isn't a computer an essentially analogue operation of transistors restricted to a subset of it's states?
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by vacri on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @10:13PM (#14699581)
To expand on that point, the brain is not good at simple products of large numbers, but is fantastic at doing things like triangulation. Or calculating how much muscle to contract to keep your balance going into a turn whilst running. Or eyeballing quantities - we notice when we get it wrong, but the vast majority of the time, we're pretty good at getting estimates correct about the human-scale world around us.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by fooker on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @05:48AM (#14701065)
What we do regularly (..say.. move your hand to reach something or catch a ball) does take a large amount of very precise products though (i.e. Inverse Kinematics).

It is not very meaningful from an information theoretic pov to debate whether the results come from the multiplication algorithms computers follow or via some trained analog network; the result is the same.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by TheSpiceIsLife on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @11:02PM (#14699727)
Have you seen that fellow that calls himself a mathemagician, Arthur Benjamin?

I believe he would argue it's a matter of training.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by vacri on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @04:10AM (#14700679)
Well, yes, but that's not a very useful distinction. You train computers as well by programming them. In meatspace, there was a famous experiment in the '60s where kittens had their heads locked into position so that they only saw vertical lines - their nascent neuroplastic brains then trained that way, and as they matured, they simply couldn't see horizontal lines (eg: would walk into horizontal bars).

In the Nature vs Nurture debate, the purists on either side tend to use tortured, hair-splitting definitions to make their arguments, and it's usually those somewhere in the middle that sound the sanest.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by TheSpiceIsLife on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @10:57PM (#14707851)
In which case, computers, as in microprocessors, are extraordinarily bad at math.

Without the appropriate programming they can't do anything.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by mannykannot on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @10:31AM (#14702673)
> The brain is incredibly good at math.

I agree (though probably not in the sense you intended) - in fact, the human brain is the only thing we know of in the universe that can do math.

I do not hold the apparently widespread view that anything performing an action that can be modeled mathematically is doing mathematics, but it is clear by now the two sides on this issue are not going to reach an agreement.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by GuiA on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @09:55PM (#14699527)
What are you basing this claim on?
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by Retric on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @09:59PM (#14699536)
The ability to walk without falling over takes a lot of computation, even if it seems effortless.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by GuiA on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @10:08PM (#14699573)
Seems like you can easily expand that argument to say that all plants, animals, and even natural processes like crystal formation are good at math.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by tpeo on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @10:42PM (#14699667)
Would that be really an issue, though?

At least in so far as living macroscopic beings are concerned, they're all doing computation of some sort by processing environmental information and using the results to produce behavior. They're about as good at math as any other computer programmed to reproduce those algorithms.

So long as "processing" information isn't the same as actually producing that behavior, as in the case of crystal growth, they're doing something besides what they're doing.

Though I'd prefer to think that crystals are actually doing math too, but they're so good they don't even need to think about it.

_______________________________________________________

>Therefore the sage goes about doing nothing, teaching no-talking.

>The ten thousand things rise and fall without cease,

>Creating, yet not possessing.

>Working, yet not taking credit.

>Work is done, then forgotten.

>Therefore it lasts forever.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by GuiA on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @10:52PM (#14699694)
It is an "issue" in the sense that it raises more questions than it answers.

See http://www.scottaaronson.com/papers/philos.pdf

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by tpeo on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @11:26PM (#14699800)
Aren't you overshooting what you mean by linking to that paper? Treating some physical processes as computational processes might lead to some intractable problems, but it also might lead so some insights. Aaronson's section on space seems like an example of this.

Neither is an issue that some way of thinking might raise more questions than it answers. Actually, if any of those questions is both interesting and solvable, that is a virtue.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by GuiA on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @12:48AM (#14700030)
I don't believe I am overshooting. I am pursuing this conversation thread in light of the original claim; that the brain is incredibly good at math. I just wanted to poke at this statement a bit, to show that if you accept this claim (that the brain is "incredibly good at math" based on its inherent structure), it opens the door to a whole other discussion around what constitutes computation.

In sum, I was just trying to see through what angle OP was framing their point.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by lomnakkus on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @03:50AM (#14700594)
Daniel Dennett has a nice phrase for what plants, etc. do: Competence without comprehension. I think it sort of applies here. (And broadly to a lot of human activities, but I would definitely classify "good at math" as requiring some degree of comprehension whereas limb movement... not so much[1].)

[1] You don't really need to understand _how_ you're moving your arm. You just do it -- it's on autopilot.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by skc on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @04:37AM (#14700786)
I'm reading Dennet's From Bacteria to Bach and Back right now.

Highly recommended if you're interested in philosophical discussions about this sort of stuff. I'm finding it highly entertaining and deliciously provocative.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by lomnakkus on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @05:23AM (#14700965)
Yup, that's where I first read this phrase. It's great book.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by lomnakkus on Saturday July 08, 2017 @07:28AM (#14725036)
... and I love the old Real Magic isn't Magic (etc.) spiel. So much fun and he genuinely seems like a grand old dag (or some shit).
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by chongli on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @10:11PM (#14699579)
Yeah, think about how complicated it is to play a sport like tennis or frisbee. Running with co-moving objects and players. Integrating the position, velocity, and acceleration of all these things in order to compute a solution. That's some decent undergrad math!
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by mentat on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @10:39PM (#14699655)
It doesn't do it by calculating the information though, it uses a set of heuristics learned through consistent experience.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by tpeo on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @10:45PM (#14699670)
Computing a heuristic is doing computation, though.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by khedoros1 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @02:44AM (#14700358)
Is it still, if the computation involved is a giant table lookup?
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by fooker on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @05:50AM (#14701074)
Why not?

You can also claim that Google is a giant lookup table. They should stop hiring computer scientists and start repurposing brains!

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by lyan on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @03:19AM (#14700466)
I don't think it is a mathimatical computation in that way. Let's say you want to press the powerbutton on your pc with your finger. It's not like the brain takes the 3D position in space of your finger and the position of the power button in 3D space and calculates the way it has to move your body/arm etc. to press the button. That would be insane inefficient..
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by kazinator on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @06:27AM (#14701242)
No, that would be insanely efficient compared to what it actually does: it infers those 3D positions from real-time 2D image processing.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @07:59AM (#14701669)
As a matter of fact, the ability to walk without falling relies on lightly controlling the passive dynamics of the biped. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e2Q2Lx8O6Cg
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by Retric on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:18AM (#14703062)
People don't just deal with nice high friction, level surfaces, without giant gaping holes.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by eli_gottlieb on Thursday July 06, 2017 @04:28PM (#14713669)
I realize. And we have to exercise a lot more control effort on non-nice surfaces!
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by goatlover on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @11:38PM (#14699827)
Assuming computation has ontological existence, as opposed to cultural demarcation, where we arrange certain physical devices to have predictable behavior we can modify, and call that computation. Or before computers, denoting the markings human beings make on paper as computation.

Saying the brain literally computes is making a philosophical claim as to what exists, as opposed to a useful metaphor.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by backtoyoujim on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @11:09PM (#14699743)
A top can do the same thing with just a spin.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by Retric on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @04:07PM (#14705714)
Walking usually involves ending up in distant places so you can say get food or something to drink etc. A top generally falls over within a few feet of where it was spun.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by snowwrestler on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @12:41AM (#14700014)
But who built and spun it?
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by snambi on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @11:20PM (#14699781)
basic common sense?
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by agumonkey on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @07:49AM (#14701616)
RTFM. /s

-- Mother Nature