News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by chroem- on Saturday July 01, 2017 @03:50PM (#14678635)
Unpopular opinion, but I really don't see why we should want high speed rail in the first place. It's slower than flying on a commuter airline, but the tickets cost nearly as much, and it's also enormously expensive to build. Then there's also the issue of throughput and last mile logistics. You're limited to putting people in a few train cars, as opposed to a continuous stream of people on a freeway. Being a high speed train, stops are necessarily few and far between, so once you arrive at the station you still have to figure out how to travel tens of miles to where you really want to go.

My perception is that it's a huge money pit for something that's quite frankly inferior to our current infrastructure. We would be much better off improving our current insterstate system.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by jacquesm on Saturday July 01, 2017 @03:55PM (#14678657)
Rail is superior to highways on quite a few dimensions:

- faster (200 Km/h and up)

- much lower accident per passenger mile

- in theory it should be cheaper (it isn't for a variety of reasons, many of those are political)

- it allows you to work while you're in motion (much harder in a car or a plane)

- more land efficient

- connects the centers of cities rather than the outskirts which in many cases removes that last mile problem because the majority of traffic is city-to-city

For the United States the situation is better served anyway by comparing rail and air travel, air travel scales better as the distance increases, is (roughly) comparable in cost per ticket and tends to be faster on longer distances.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:07PM (#14678720)
You forgot one important point: Anyone can take rail. In order to drive, you already have to own a car (and be able to drive). Many people, especially those who live in cities, don't have cars, so taking a train just costs the price of the ticket, whereas driving requires renting or buying a car. Unless you're traveling very frequently, it's cheaper to not own a car.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by brightball on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:19PM (#14678785)
Aren't most cities more expensive to live in than the cost of owning a car in the suburbs?
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by jacquesm on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:21PM (#14678792)
There are other costs associated with living in the suburbs than just the cost of a car. There is also commute time, which - if your time isn't valuable to you - need not be a problem but for many people this wasted time is a real issue.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by Scarblac on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:52PM (#14678961)
And the same time spent in a train can be productive. In a car, it's just a complete waste.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by closeparen on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:55PM (#14678978)
On which systems is it the norm for train commuters to get seats? Or can they be productive in standing room somehow?
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by Scarblac on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:00PM (#14679009)
I'm in the Netherlands, where I spend some extra money to get a 1st class ticket (because that has the room to work on a laptop), and I nearly always have a seat in that. I guess during rush hour about a fifth of the rest has to stand, true.

Even if you have to stand now and then, you can use an ereader.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by closeparen on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:24PM (#14679120)
I think there'd be riots if any US city proposed class-segregated seats on its public transit system. Though I would love it.

I'd pay almost as much for a guaranteed seat on BART as I would for a car.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Sunday July 02, 2017 @01:20PM (#14683373)
Some of the commuter rail systems in the US do have class-based systems. Heavy rail (rapid transit aka "the subway") does not, but that's more about the particularities of how heavy rail works.

We tolerate different pricing for various classes of seats in concerts, trains, buses, airplanes, pretty much everything imaginable. I don't see why commuter rail would be any different.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by closeparen on Sunday July 02, 2017 @02:06PM (#14683602)
Heavy rail is a taxpayer-funded government service, provided by governments with particularly liberal electorates (large dense cities). One of its key selling points, among certain constituents, is as an equalizer: getting the rich out their Audis and into the same miserable conditions as everyone else.

I think most people who can't afford first class on airlines do resent it, but since airlines aren't state-owned and, more importantly, it's always been there (not a new proposal), there's not much they can do.

Look at the popular outrage about scalping. People absolutely feel that you shouldn't be able to buy your way into a good seat, and instead ought to be lucky/first.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Monday July 03, 2017 @12:57PM (#14689703)
> provided by governments with particularly liberal electorates [...] One of its key selling points, among certain constituents, is as an equalizer: getting the rich out their Audis and into the same miserable conditions as everyone else.

It's hard to take what you're saying seriously when you're so clearly biased towards one end of the political spectrum.

The actual truth is much less political. Cities like New York City are way too dense for everyone to drive a personal vehicle, full stop, your non sequitur about Audis notwithstanding. Mass transit is the only transportation method that scales to handle a population the size of a large, dense city. Individual vehicle transportation does not. It doesn't matter if you're rich or poor, whether you're driving an Audi or a beater; if you're trying to drive to your job in the heart of Manhattan from the suburbs it's going to take you hours. Mass transit is the better choice for almost everyone.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by pavel_lishin on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:13PM (#14679063)
I guess it depends on what you mean by productivity, but I can read a book while standing, I can read and respond to emails, and I can actually zone out and relax.

In a car, I have to be on moderately high alert the entire time I'm driving, especially in traffic.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:28PM (#14679141)
Every commuter rail system I can think of provides seats for passengers.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by closeparen on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:33PM (#14679154)
Every commuter rail system I can think of has at least a 2:1 ratio of passengers to seats during commute hours.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:39PM (#14679186)
What systems are you thinking of? Because every commuter rail system I can think of has seats for almost everyone.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by lanstin on Saturday July 01, 2017 @07:03PM (#14679584)
Even the mediocre VTA light rail in Silicon Valley has people standing during rush hour. although that is exacerbated by the California reluctance to sit right next to someone. Here when half the seats are sat in the rest of the people stand unless it is a big group like a field trip.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Sunday July 02, 2017 @01:22PM (#14683383)
You can't complain about standing if there are still seats available though ...

Also, you don't see that here in NYC. People are gonna sit down if there's space available. Unless it's next to a crazy homeless person, but I've only ever experienced that on heavy rail, not commuter rail.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by gsnedders on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:21PM (#14679384)
Look at anywhere around London or Paris, for example; plenty of routes are crush loaded at rush hour. Heck, Tokyo is famous for some lines having people to push people further into each car.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by s0rce on Sunday July 02, 2017 @12:03AM (#14680823)
Those are intra-city subways not commuter rail systems that are largely discussed above.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Monday July 03, 2017 @12:58PM (#14689710)
The delineations at play here for those who don't know, in order of scale, are light rail (typically at-grade), heavy rail/rapid transit/subway/metro (all the same thing), commuter rail, then regional/long-distance rail.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by closeparen on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:42PM (#14679199)
MTA, CTA, Muni, BART, Caltrain.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:56PM (#14679261)
Every time I've ever taken MTA Metro-North there's been more than enough seats available. It's one of the systems I was going to mention as having seats for passengers. There isn't even enough room in those trains for twice as many people to stand as have seats; it's basically an all-seating arrangement with an aisle for reaching the seats down the middle. Are you sure about your examples?

Edit: And it's the exact same for the Long Island Railroad, which is the other major commuter rail system run by the MTA. They have a third system, the Staten Island Railway, but I've never taken it and thus can't comment.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by closeparen on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:11PM (#14679329)
I guess I'm talking about connectivity for outlying urban and inner suburban neighborhoods ("the subway") more than regional rail systems like LIRR or, in Chicago's case, Metra.

It may actually be a good strategy to live even further from the city if it lets you switch from a crowded urban transit system to a more spacious suburban one.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:17PM (#14679358)
Commuter rail tends to be more expensive than heavy rail too.

It's a good question though (let's put aside costs for now): How much more time would you be willing to spend on commuter rail over heavy rail if it means getting a seat? I'm not sure. I think I'd rather be seated for 40 minutes than standing for thirty, but at an hour, I might just prefer the shorter trip. You can still easily listen to podcasts on crowded heavy rail, or get good at holding a Kindle in one hand.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by mattkrause on Saturday July 01, 2017 @08:01PM (#14679855)
I have never had to stand on MetroNorth, even during the morning rush.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by closeparen on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:53PM (#14678969)
In cities with the worst traffic problems, sure.

In smaller cities, it takes less time to get downtown from the suburbs than it does to get across downtown on foot or even a bike. (Buses there move at walking speed in the average case, or bicycle speed in the best case, but only come every half hour or so).

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:38PM (#14679180)
The differential in costs between living in the city core versus in the suburbs is much different for such cities, however. It may well be reversed entirely, as in many small cities that don't suffer from bad traffic, living in newer suburbs is more desirable than living in a potentially decaying urban core.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by mtalantikite on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:03PM (#14679019)
Not really, you just get more space outside of the cities.

I have some friends that have moved to upstate New York from Brooklyn and rent is the same, just with a lot more space. However, you then have to add on $400/month for the commuter rail along with an extra hour per day of commuting, plus owning a car and needing to drive everywhere instead of walking. It actually ends up being more expensive, but the trade off is getting more space (if you care about that for some reason).

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by closeparen on Saturday July 01, 2017 @08:31PM (#14679998)
You can pretty easily convert "the rent is the same, just with a lot more space" to "the rent is cheaper" by having roommates.

Or to "the rent is the same, but I don't have to have roommates" by not having them.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by niklasrde on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:34PM (#14678855)
I'd be spending 2-3x as much on parking alone as I'm currently spending on my rail commute.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by thesagan on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:38PM (#14678881)
Cost of car ownership = cost of car + insurance + fuel + storage + maintenance + misc tickets and administrative fees.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by cderwin on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:20PM (#14679098)
There are only a couple cities in the US where it is realistic for a normal (i.e. able to afford a car) person to live without a car, and most of those cities are already served by Acela.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:27PM (#14679137)
There are way more than two cities in the US where it's reasonable to not own a car. What makes you say it's only two?! Just because you can't imagine doing it doesn't mean that other people aren't perfectly content to do so. Here are some cities that I happen to know of offhand where people I know live perfectly "normal" (to use your word) lives without cars, and this is just in the northeast of the US: Boston, NYC, Jersey City, Philadelphia, Baltimore, DC, Alexandria, Bethesda, and Arlington.

I can easily afford a car, but I don't own one because I don't have need for one very frequently, so it's simply cheaper to rent when I need one rather than have to worry about owning one 24/7.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by nostrademons on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:51PM (#14679242)
I think this is the Acela corridor he was talking about. He probably misspoke when saying "a couple" - some people interpret that strictly as "two", while others interpret it loosely as "a handful" - but "most of these" implies that he meant the second meaning.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:55PM (#14679254)
That interpretation doesn't make sense to me though. The Acela corridor is used for longer distance transportation -- anywhere else you'd simply fly. Neither has much to do with owning or not owning a car. I live in NYC, don't have a car, and I take any of bus/train/plane depending on where I'm going and if it's on the Northeast Corridor. If I lived in, say, Austin, I'd simply just always take a plane to any of those places, but my car ownership situation wouldn't necessarily change.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by closeparen on Saturday July 01, 2017 @08:56PM (#14680113)
It's true that, along the Acela corridor, there are normal people who can't use the freeways to travel between cities for lack of car ownership. So the Acela is helpful.

Almost everywhere else that isn't the Acela corridor, people will have cars by default, so rail doesn't meaningfully increase access to inter-city travel over existing freeways.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Sunday July 02, 2017 @01:24PM (#14683399)
This is where we still disagree. There are plenty of big cities that are not along the Acela corridor where people do not own cars by default (e.g. people living in downtown Chicago).

I don't understand your argument anyway. People own cars because they need them frequently for daily activities like commuting or errands. Infrequent longer distance trips are not the primary drivers of car ownership at all. If you don't own a car for your daily life then you certainly aren't going to own one just for the occasional road trip; no, you'll take a train/bus/plane in that case, or even just rent one.

Also, I live in NYC, and most of the places I go to are too far to drive to anyway. So having a car wouldn't be helpful. I'm renting a car in Las Vegas next month for DEF CON, but if I owned a car here I certainly wouldn't drive all the way there. I go to DC regularly, but even if I had a car I wouldn't want to use it for that trip as I find long drives unpleasant and would much rather read a book on a bus for four hours.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by closeparen on Sunday July 02, 2017 @02:01PM (#14683584)
> people living in downtown Chicago

You can get to every significant Midwestern city on Amtrak from downtown Chicago. In fact, one of Amtrak's main weaknesses is that you often have to transfer through Chicago when it doesn't make geographic sense. That doesn't apply to Chicagoans. The Amtrak map is enlightening [0].

You can even do some train trips from downtown Chicago that make absolutely no sense in the era of flight (the rail tickets cost more than airfare and take 10x as long). I'd argue that anywhere you can't easily get on a train from Chicago is either too small to support rail service, or too far to be convenient by any mode except air.

There are a couple other places where people tend to live without cars, like the Bay Area. We already have good passenger rail service to Sacramento/Davis, and the SF/LA corridor is being developed.

>People own cars because they need them frequently for daily activities like commuting or errands

Correct, and when they already own cars, they already have easy access to inter-city travel (within distances that would be convenient by rail) via the interstates. Building HSR on these routes could provide a more convenient alternative, but the improvement is minor and incremental.

We need a massive investment in rail in this country, but we need it on urban and commuter systems. Inter-city travel already works almost as well as we could reasonably expect it to.

[0] https://www.amtrak.com/ccurl/948/674/System0211_101web,0.pdf

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by landon32 on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:12PM (#14678742)
I don't think high speed rail would help here. We already have normal speed trains that are affordable, and I'd imagine high speed rails would just be more expensive.

Unless you're talking about the highly possible near future where even the middle class doesn't has cars, but would pay more for a train ticket that's faster.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by jacquesm on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:12PM (#14678743)
Ah good one, totally missed that point. Thank you.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by cirrus-clouds on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:35PM (#14678859)
>in theory it should be cheaper

Rail is heavily subsidised in many European countries. But a well-run and affordable rail service is such an essential motor of economic well-being that subsidies are generally accepted as essential by governments and most of the public.

For an example of what what happens when more and more of the cost of a ticket is shouldered by the commuter, look at the UK. We have some of the highest rail fares in the whole of Europe.

Below is research from the TUC (Trades Union Congress) in the UK who campaign against rail privatisation. Whether or not you agree with their stance on privatisation, the cost of a monthly season ticket in the UK is enormous.

Monthly season ticket comparison: UK vs Europe:

UK: Luton to London St. Pancras (35 miles) £387

UK: Liverpool Lime Street to Manchester Piccadilly (32 miles) £292

Germany: Dusseldorf to Cologne (28 miles) £85

France: Mantes-la-Jolie to Paris (34 miles) £61

Italy: Anzione to Rome (31 miles) £61

Spain: Aranjuez to Madrid (31 miles) £75

Source: https://www.tuc.org.uk/industrial-issues/transport-policy/uk...

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by peoplewindow on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:28PM (#14679142)
That's hardly related to privatisation though. Railways are not that profitable. The government could up subsidies if it wanted to to reduce ticket prices without nationalising the routes: it already enforces price controls.

One reason those routes are so expensive is that UK rail is in many regions frequently at or over capacity. Supply/demand does its thing until prices hit the caps. This is especially true around London. Price controls always cause shortages and in this case it's a shortage of seats and investment in capacity upgrades. Seems people prefer that to more expensive tickets or higher taxpayer subsidies.

Also the infrastructure is ancient - the steam locomotive was literally invented in the UK - and investment was largely abandoned during the decades of government ownership. The current railways often have infrastructure in them built a century ago.

Finally, some lines actually pay the government money rather than receive subsidies.

I don't think the UK position is wrong. It just means people who choose to use the railways instead of driving or moving pay more of the costs. Seems fair.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by gsnedders on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:27PM (#14679408)
It's important to realise that the yearly price rises are almost all a result of subsidy dropping, and as peoplewindow says, many fares are already set by the government. Notably, the total premiums paid by the train operating companies (TOCs) now exceeds the amount of total subsidy, so for the first time since nationalisation, the railways are making an operational profit.

From memory, something like 4% of fare revenue ends up as profit going to the TOCs at the end of the year; for many, this isn't enough to buy a single extra train, yet alone anything bigger. The profits these private companies are taking aren't huge in terms of the costs of operating a railway!

That said...

> I don't think the UK position is wrong. It just means people who choose to use the railways instead of driving or moving pay more of the costs. Seems fair.

Surely that same argument should apply to driving? i.e., those using for the roads should pay more of the costs instead of it all coming out of general taxation?

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by peoplewindow on Sunday July 02, 2017 @06:15AM (#14681822)
They do. Fuel taxes pay for the costs of road maintenance and then a lot more on top (typically, rail subsidies!)

http://www.roadusers.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/8.4-2...

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by tonyedgecombe on Sunday July 02, 2017 @04:17AM (#14681481)
The interesting thing in the UK is despite those high costs the network is running at capacity, people seem willing to pay the fares.

Given that is the case I think it's hard to justify extra subsidy for people who are clearly getting enough utility from the system.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CalChris on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:05PM (#14678707)
Rail is mostly used for cargo. Rail is about 4 times more efficient than a truck is fuel wise. Labor wise, more than an order of magnitude. A 100-unit train can carry 10,000 tons whereas a truck is closer to 20 tons.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by jacquesm on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:13PM (#14678748)
Rail is only mostly used for cargo in the United States because there hardly is any passenger rail left. In the rest of the world rail is mostly used for passengers, and also (usually at night) used for cargo.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CalChris on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:47PM (#14679225)
Yep, passenger miles Amtrak rail in the US is about 1% of air.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by masklinn on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:09PM (#14678729)
The context of the discussion is high speed rail, which is for passengers.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by IntelMiner on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:16PM (#14678774)
There's no reason that high speed rail couldn't work for both, however
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by masklinn on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:35PM (#14678863)
There are plenty of reasons:

* the weight of freight significantly impacts the track's lifecycle, and HSR tend to be on the "light cargo" side with a train being about 10% cargo by weight

* the bulk and varying shape makes it impossible to build high-speed trains with any interesting flexibility and capability as they need to be highly profiled

* and you don't want your high-speed passenger traffic to be held up by freight.

* the cost/benefit calculation makes no sense, it's much more price-efficient to carry freight using gigantic regular-speed trainsets than using small high-speed ones, and what little freight is so time-sensitive that you need to put it on an HSR can be put there as a special case

None of the big HSR countries use it for anything resembling serious freight, the only one which came even remotely close was France which had 3.5 mail trainsets, which were wound down and ultimately retired in 2015: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNCF_TGV_La_Poste

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by gsnedders on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:32PM (#14679436)
China has some freight going on HSR nowadays, though they are mostly on slower lines (i.e., 200-250km/h, so 125-155mph IIRC) that were opened on new routes.

But yes, weight is a big deal: the LGV in France, for example, have a maximum axle loading of 17 tons. Much of the US freight network is over 35 tons, from memory.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by jacquesm on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:19PM (#14678788)
There is relatively little economic incentive to make high speed rail work for cargo. Cargo that's large enough to go by rail tends to go for the lowest price per ton that can be found, it competes with long haul trucks, barges and oceangoing ships. It does not compete with air cargo (which tends to focus on high value and light stuff).
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by patrickg_zill on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:01PM (#14679012)
Trucks are closer to 40 tons, actually.

And many shippers will absolutely not use rail freight for a variety of reasons in the USA, including slow delivery time (can't ship produce and other perishables easily), lackluster quality of service from the rail lines (they want coal, oil, large commodity business, not smaller firms), higher chance of damage; as well as not meeting minimum qty/volume for it to be worth it.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CalChris on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:32PM (#14679147)
Something like 40 tons, 80,000 lb max loaded. But more like 20 ton average cargo payload (5 axle).

https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/reports/tswstudy/Vol2-Chapter3.pdf

As for speed, it's interesting to compare trucks with slow steaming.

> Slow steaming refers to the practice of operating transoceanic cargo ships, especially container ships, at significantly less than their maximum speed. An analyst at National Ports and Waterways Institute stated in 2010 that nearly all global shipping lines were using slow steaming to save money on fuel.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slow_steaming

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by patrickg_zill on Saturday July 01, 2017 @08:19PM (#14679942)
That is Federal but there are many exemptions, especially in the western states. For instance, Rocky Mountain doubles can go to 120,000 and certain other combinations even more.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by gumby on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:58PM (#14678995)
This is true in the US, but is the opposite in Europe and China. (I don't know about Japan, the other HSR powerhouse).
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by vosper on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:15PM (#14678764)
I suspect that by the time we could build a high speed rail network in the US (say 30-40 years, minimum) autonomous vehicles on the freeway will be the superior option. There's no fundamental reason that road vehicles couldn't exceed 200kph, just that humans are completely incapable of piloting safely at anywhere near those speeds. Once the need for a forward-looking pilot is gone you could design vehicles completely around the comfort of the occupants.

And, better than HSR, the same vehicle can go door-to-door.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by jacquesm on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:33PM (#14678850)
> here's no fundamental reason that road vehicles couldn't exceed 200kph

Actually, there is: energy costs for road traffic go up as the square of the velocity, for rail this is much better because there is only one (very aerodynamic) front section for as many carriages as you want to put behind the loc and steel-on-steel has much better rolling resistance than rubber-on-asphalt or concrete.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by vosper on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:43PM (#14678905)
That's a fair point, what's the energy cost of building thousands of miles of new railways, rather than using existing freeways? (okay, I'm being a little facetious)

With regard to aerodynamics, I am assuming that following distances for advanced autonomous vehicles will be minimal. They could maybe drive bumper-to-bumper as long as all cars in the ... er ... train were similarly capable.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by sangnoir on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:54PM (#14679528)
You'd want to physically couple those cars because should any one of them unexpectedly lose locomotion, they'll be a huge train wreck.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by ocschwar on Saturday July 01, 2017 @08:59PM (#14680137)
Track costs far less (in money and energy) to build and maintain than freeway.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CamperBob2 on Sunday July 02, 2017 @01:42AM (#14681094)
Unlike roads, fixed rail is virtually guaranteed not to be where you are, or to go where you want to go.

There is a reason the US isn't well-connected by rail, and it has nothing to do with loony conspiracy theories about General Motors buying all the tracks up.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by ocschwar on Monday July 03, 2017 @02:20PM (#14690308)
> Unlike roads, fixed rail is virtually guaranteed not to be where you are, or to go where you want to go.

For no reason except the political. Go to any country in Europe, and you'll find that even the shopping malls have railway sidings and not just truck loading bays.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CamperBob2 on Monday July 03, 2017 @05:13PM (#14691448)
To us, 200 years seems like a long time. To you, 200 kilometers seems like a long distance.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by ocschwar on Monday July 03, 2017 @11:39PM (#14693377)
Dude, I'm American.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CamperBob2 on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @12:53AM (#14693618)
Then you should know why it's not practical to run rails to every grocery store and dry cleaner in every town in the US.

I will never understand the obsession with fixed-rail transit on this site. It's interesting to observe, but it's never been satisfactorily explained. Is it just a matter of people never having been out of the Bay Area in their lives?

In an age where personal mobility is becoming more important rather than less, when costs associated with large-scale civic construction projects have skyrocketed and completion times have come to be measured in decades, and when networked fleets of self-driving cars are almost literally just around the corner, rail transit in the general case is about the dumbest thing ever. But I recognize that this is essentially a religious argument, and that you're equally certain you're right. Not much we can do but vote accordingly, I guess.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by ocschwar on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @08:18AM (#14695399)
> Then you should know why it's not practical to run rails to every grocery store and dry cleaner in every town in the US.

Then I know that track costs less to install and maintain than roads. If it isn't practical to run track, it isn't practical to run roads.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CamperBob2 on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @03:22PM (#14697752)
Then I know that track costs less to install and maintain than roads. If it isn't practical to run track, it isn't practical to run roads.

I don't see how that can be true in the general case. Around here, in the Seattle area, a recent 34-mile light rail installation cost about $368 million. Four-lane roads cost about $500K per mile these days, from what I can tell. (And yes, that seems unrealistically low by an order of magnitude -- I think the sources I Googled up are referring only to initial costs, or costs associated with building rural Interstates.)

Our next big rail project, ST3, will install 62 miles of rail over 20+ years at a cost of over $50 billion.

Rail serves a tiny contingent of the population at enormous expense, effectively rooting them to the spot in the process. It has never really been shown to be effective at removing cars from the roads, certainly not in proportion to its price.

There has to be a better way. There may not be, right now, but there darned sure will be by the time the megaprojects we're considering today are complete and ready for service.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by ocschwar on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @09:45PM (#14699490)
> Our next big rail project, ST3, will install 62 miles of rail over 20+ years at a cost of over $50 billion.

Good basis for comparison. Because you see, for a typical freeway, a billion per mile is the cost.

And that's just installation.

Add in the cost to maintain the roads, and they lose to tracks hands down. Tracks don't need to be resurfaced. And track beds don't need a resurfacing just to get inspected.

(You're also missing the added cost for the overhead wiring if you're going to compare against electrified rail.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CamperBob2 on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @11:42PM (#14699842)
Good basis for comparison. Because you see, for a typical freeway, a billion per mile is the cost.

Where do you get that? Obviously we got more than 500 miles of freeway for the $500B (inflation-adjusted) that the Eisenhower Interstate System cost us. We got about 50,000 miles, which works out to $10M/mile.

So something seems to have made both highway and rail construction cost ludicrous amounts of money, if you're right about the $1B/mile figure. I don't think you are, though -- that amount is what I've heard cited for the most expensive mile of highway in the country, which supposedly is the stretch of I-90 that crosses Mercer Island. I'd have to throw a [Citation Needed] flag on the billion-dollar-per-mile figure, in the general case. If we're really spending that much on roads these days, somebody needs to figure out where all that money is going.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by Numberwang on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:55PM (#14678976)
how about those volvo systems that line up auto cars behind each-other?
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by gsnedders on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:39PM (#14679469)
You still have induced drag from low pressure areas unless you design your cars so they're more box-like (i.e., the front of one car matches up with the rear of another, without any bonnet/hood/etc. or similar).
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by Numberwang on Sunday July 02, 2017 @11:43AM (#14682991)
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CamperBob2 on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:17PM (#14679079)
There are so many opportunities to save energy with self-driving cars that I suspect this point will not be a clear win.

But that assumes we do the right thing by constructing a standardized network and enforcing conformance with it, so they can behave more like high-speed train segments and less like individual vehicles. Here in the US, we generally do the right thing, but only after trying everything else first.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by zkms on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:05PM (#14679301)
> There's no fundamental reason that road vehicles couldn't exceed 200kph

There sorta is. Air resistance and tyre/pavement rolling resistance get mighty expensive at that sort of speed, and the need to carry along energy storage makes this even more problematic.

High-speed rail vehicles amortise, over the whole train, the part of the drag that comes from the frontal area. Automobiles cannot do this.

Once you've created a curve-free, very flat, grade-separated controlled access freeway for your 250kph cars, you've...got most of what you need for high-speed rail anyway. At that point you might as well just build some rails and overhead line and buy some TGV rolling stock.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by Tiktaalik on Saturday July 01, 2017 @08:12PM (#14679906)
Autonomous vehicles won't be superior to high speed rail due to much worse space efficiency and induced demand putting a strain on road infrastructure.

Even if autonomous cars are smaller than the ones we have now, they still take up too much space. Autonomous cars will expand the amount of drivers as one no longer needs a license, and the amount of cars will increase. This new demand will cause increased road congestion unless an expensive expansion of the road network takes place, an we know from induced demand that road expansion doesn't fix congestion in the long term anyway.

Automobile oriented infrastructure doesn't scale whether the cars are autonomous or not, and it's a bad idea to base the entire transportation system around them.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by leemailll on Saturday July 01, 2017 @09:38PM (#14680297)
>There's no fundamental reason that road vehicles couldn't exceed 200kph

Then a blown tire will be a deadly accident.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by adrianN on Sunday July 02, 2017 @06:22AM (#14681839)
A blown tyre is probably deadly even at normal speeds of ~130km/h. They don't blow very often though.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by chillingeffect on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:14PM (#14678758)
Rail also doesn't have taxiing time, takeoff/landing time nor baggage time. And no seat belts. I love it, but I also understand much of America is located farther apart than other countries. Yet, we should prepare for denser days.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by imnotlost on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:36PM (#14678873)
And no TSA which is a huge win. You can bring your devices without worrying about having them inspected and potentially cloned.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by DrScump on Sunday July 02, 2017 @01:16AM (#14681026)

  You can bring your devices without worrying about having them inspected 
Why not?

True, hostage-taking is generally not a risk on rail (Pelham 1-2-3 aside), but HSR is just as tempting a target for terrorism.

Imagine a detonation that derails an HSR from elevated rail, at speed, in an urban setting.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by Klockan on Sunday July 02, 2017 @07:04AM (#14681963)
The easiest way to derail a train is to manipulate its tracks, inspecting passengers would do nothing to prevent this.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by avar on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:30PM (#14679423)
Germany has 200km/h and up roads in some places, so this is hardly a convincing counterargument to simply improving the interstate system.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by lorenzhs on Sunday July 02, 2017 @04:53AM (#14681586)
You're allowed to go as fast as you safely can on some of our roads, but even on those the flow of traffic is maybe at 130-140 km/h (80-90 mph). Sustaining 200km/h in a car is very hard (extreme focus is required) and quite expensive as fuel economy drops sharply. Plus most cars can't actually do it.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:05PM (#14678705)
Airports are located pretty far from city centers. It's not uncommon to have to add at least an hour on both ends to handle transportation to/from airports, and that transportation can often be expensive in its own right if a cab is the best option.

When I go from NYC to DC and back, I don't fly, I take the train or bus. It ends up being significantly cheaper and doesn't take any longer, plus there's less annoying switching between modes of transit. Cities less than 400 km apart are already better traveled between using bus or low-speed rail -- now more than double that minimum radius for true high-speed rail and you can see how it would have a big impact on US long-distance travel.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by Gibbon1 on Sunday July 02, 2017 @12:58AM (#14680986)
5 years ago I tool the train from Edinburgh to London. That is not a fast train. 400 miles in 4.5 hours. But was kinda like being on a BART train without the crazy people. The trip is longer than flying (not by much) but the stress load is a lot less than flying.

Someone mentioned longer distances in the US. But far as I get most places building rail through the flat nowhere lands is really cheap. And the trains can run at max speed with few stops.

If you built a line from Chicago to Denver, okay 900 miles. But at 220 MPH, four hours. Be better than flying.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CydeWeys on Sunday July 02, 2017 @01:27PM (#14683409)
Totally agreed that I'm willing to spend a little bit longer on a train over a plane. It is a more enjoyable and relaxed travel experience.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by michaelchisari on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:02PM (#14678693)
slower than flying on a commuter airline

Less security, bigger seats, room to move around. The time loss going from New York to Chicago or Seattle to Los Angeles would be minimal if you count the total time spent in transit, and the trip would be much less stressful.

you still have to figure out how to travel tens of miles to where you really want to go.

Same with air travel, except it's easier for trains to end up in city centers instead of airports outside of the city.

as opposed to a continuous stream of people on a freeway

Which is much more environmentally damaging, and requires drivers. When autonomous, electric vehicles are the rule instead of the exception this might not be the case, but for now I'd much rather take a train than drive.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by ivan_gammel on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:43PM (#14678910)
>>you still have to figure out how to travel tens of miles to where you really want to go. >Same with air travel, except it's easier for trains to end up in city centers instead of airports outside of the city.

With developed network of local and regional lines it's usually more convenient to travel by train, because you just switch to metro or local train on the same station. E.g. in Germany there are long distance speed trains (ICE), regionals (RE), local trains (S-Bahn), metro (U-Bahn) and very good public transit. I haven't find a place yet, where you will really need a car to get there.

One comment on the website mentions airport-like security checks, saying that they'll slow down the boarding by the same amount of time. Actually, it's not true - just look at "Sapsan" trains between Moscow and St.Petersburg in Russia. There's, in fact, airport-like security check right before the train and it does not make boarding significantly slower.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by vvpan on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:13PM (#14678749)
Well, here's an example. The route between Moscow and St. Petersburg (about 400 miles, about the same as LA to SF) is a very popular train route. Flying between these cities makes no sense because a high speed train between them takes 4 hours and you board and get off right in the middle of each city. If you were flying you'd need to get to the airport, pass through security, fly, collect baggage, get to the destination city. So train ends up being faster, cheaper and much much more comfortable.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by fatjokes on Saturday July 01, 2017 @03:54PM (#14678651)
Some of the negatives you're listing are only true in America. In Asia and Europe, high-speed train is much cheaper than train, faster when accounting for security and check-in, and 10x more comfortable. You also don't generally get abused by TSA and airline workers.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by rdiddly on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:35PM (#14679449)
Your opinion is not unpopular; it's the default and prevailing opinion in the US or any economy with access to cheap energy and without any efficiency incentives (read: scarcity or foresight).

Flying is the most energy- and carbon-intensive mode per passenger-mile. Which as alluded above, is not a meaningful economic factor, yet. (Unfortunately by the time it becomes meaningful enough to be profitable, it might be too late to transition to anything else because the capital won't be there.)

RE highway vs. train - If you can imagine a continuous stream of cars on a highway, why wouldn't you be able to also imagine a continuous stream of trains on a track? A mile of track filled with train cars can hold more people than a mile of highway, easily. And it has one centralized power plant with a much higher efficiency factor (because it's a larger engine and because it uses better fuel for the purpose). It also has far less total wind resistance, since the train has only one front face and one rear face. And if it's high-speed rail, well, it moves faster than cars. But again, efficiency is not currently a meaningful factor.

Traveling the last few miles from the train stop is very much a solved problem. Even if you drive, that beats making the whole journey by car in my book. But those wishing to minimize it can always move closer in near the stop... thereby concentrating land-use in cities again and maybe letting the scourge of suburbia die off like it needs to... in a paroxysm of mold-infested particle-board.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by zkms on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:26PM (#14678822)
> It's slower than flying on a commuter airline, but the tickets cost nearly as much, and it's also enormously expensive to build

High-speed rail in many non-US countries is vastly cheaper to construct and much faster and reliable than USian high-speed rail.

> You're limited to putting people in a few train cars, as opposed to a continuous stream of people on a freeway.

With off-the-shelf railcars and a well-tested train control system rail can get far higher throughput than freeways. If you do the USian thing and have to get extremely customised/bespoke rolling stock and try to make your own bespoke train control system, well, you indeed do get the disaster you're describing.

> My perception is that it's a huge money pit for something that's quite frankly inferior to our current infrastructure. We would be much better off improving our current insterstate system.

US rail indeed sucks and it needs to be unfucked before more money is dumped into it. None of the suckiness (slowness, high construction cost per mile, high ticket prices) is inherent to high-speed rail, though.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by krschultz on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:18PM (#14678783)
The northeast corridor is faster than flying. The trains stop in the downtown of each city which cuts out the travel time to and from the airport, and you don't have to arrive at the train station as early before boarding.

The ticket prices are high because Amtrak is subsidizing the non-profitable routes with the North East Corridor. If it was run as a business they would cut all the trains in the middle of the country and re-invest the profit in the NEC, or lower fares. If it was run as a public good, then there would be more of a subsidy. Right now Amtrak in this place where it's restricted by being beholden to politics but not enjoying the benefit of full throated government support.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by mehwoot on Saturday July 01, 2017 @08:32PM (#14680002)
I went to Japan for the first time recently, and holy crap, high speed rail is amazing. It's like flying business class, or better. You have so much leg room, free wifi and a powerpoint next to you. You don't have to check your bags in or go through security or any of that crap, you just turn up at the station 5 minutes before it leaves and then sit down in genuine comfort and hack away on your laptop for a couple of hours.

If it were an option in my country I'd definitely take it for any trip up to ~1,200km.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by usaphp on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:24PM (#14678809)
> It's slower than flying on a commuter airline

When the flight says it's 40 minutes - it's not really 40 minutes, add time for tsa, baggage, landing etc and you get at least 2-3 hours wasted of your day

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by WillPostForFood on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:59PM (#14679003)
It doesn't include TSA or boarding, but it does include landing/taxiing. Flight time = gate to gate.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by gumby on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:57PM (#14678990)
Have you used it? Your experience doesn't match mine in using HSR in Europe, China and Japan.

The vehicle speed is lower but the total travel time (much less inconvenience) of rail vs air is much lower, except for transcontinental trips. And the rail stations are usually more conveniently located compared to airports.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by vorg on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:46PM (#14679222)
And in larger Chinese cities, every HSL station is connected directly to the city subway system (or has the subway station under construction). That also means you don't have to allow extra time for contingencies, which usually means arriving early at the airport.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by pavel_lishin on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:11PM (#14679058)
> * the tickets cost nearly as much*

Given that we don't have a high speed rail system in place, I'm not sure where this number is coming from.

> You're limited to putting people in a few train cars, as opposed to a continuous stream of people on a freeway.

My wife, my kid and I flew down to Texas, and are going to be spending about 20 hours doing long-distance drives.

I would absolutely love to be in a few high-speed train cars than stuck in a car, in a continuous stream of people, where one of us has to remain at relatively high alert for hours at a time, while the other one is strapped into a seat, trying to entertain the other other one who is strapped into a smaller seat, but has boundless energy and no concept of patience.

If we had some sort of road-train system where we weren't welded to a gas pedal and a steering wheel, then maybe.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by melling on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:30PM (#14678834)
Hey, your opinion is quite popular, and wrong.

How do people figure out how to get from airports to their final destinations?

How many people can put put in trains? China is going to get 32,000 people per hour in their low-speed maglev:

http://gbtimes.com/china/beijing-launch-first-maglev-line-20...

The throughput is higher in rail than cars. Also, you are trying to make HSR fit as a solution where cars would be better. No one said that trains are best in every situation. And absolutely no one said that we should remove all of our high-ways and replace them with rail.

However, between cities over several hundred thousand people, and within 500-7600 miles, they work out well.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by trophycase on Saturday July 01, 2017 @09:59PM (#14680386)
Flying sucks. Hard or impossible to sleep, uncomfortable, can't walk around, little to no food, airport security.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by fooker on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:17PM (#14678778)
>It's slower than flying on a commuter airline, but the tickets cost nearly as much

That is a good indication there is demand. Prices can only go down if trains are more frequent and available to all places.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by rocky1138 on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:27PM (#14678823)
Have you ever actually traveled on high speed rail?
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by prodikl on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:23PM (#14679114)
i think we can all agree that the main issue (in america) is population density (lack thereof, could the system ever pay for itself?) and the american suburban lifestyle not being compatible with high speed rail