News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by vosper on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:15PM (#14678764)
I suspect that by the time we could build a high speed rail network in the US (say 30-40 years, minimum) autonomous vehicles on the freeway will be the superior option. There's no fundamental reason that road vehicles couldn't exceed 200kph, just that humans are completely incapable of piloting safely at anywhere near those speeds. Once the need for a forward-looking pilot is gone you could design vehicles completely around the comfort of the occupants.

And, better than HSR, the same vehicle can go door-to-door.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by jacquesm on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:33PM (#14678850)
> here's no fundamental reason that road vehicles couldn't exceed 200kph

Actually, there is: energy costs for road traffic go up as the square of the velocity, for rail this is much better because there is only one (very aerodynamic) front section for as many carriages as you want to put behind the loc and steel-on-steel has much better rolling resistance than rubber-on-asphalt or concrete.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by vosper on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:43PM (#14678905)
That's a fair point, what's the energy cost of building thousands of miles of new railways, rather than using existing freeways? (okay, I'm being a little facetious)

With regard to aerodynamics, I am assuming that following distances for advanced autonomous vehicles will be minimal. They could maybe drive bumper-to-bumper as long as all cars in the ... er ... train were similarly capable.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by sangnoir on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:54PM (#14679528)
You'd want to physically couple those cars because should any one of them unexpectedly lose locomotion, they'll be a huge train wreck.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by ocschwar on Saturday July 01, 2017 @08:59PM (#14680137)
Track costs far less (in money and energy) to build and maintain than freeway.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CamperBob2 on Sunday July 02, 2017 @01:42AM (#14681094)
Unlike roads, fixed rail is virtually guaranteed not to be where you are, or to go where you want to go.

There is a reason the US isn't well-connected by rail, and it has nothing to do with loony conspiracy theories about General Motors buying all the tracks up.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by ocschwar on Monday July 03, 2017 @02:20PM (#14690308)
> Unlike roads, fixed rail is virtually guaranteed not to be where you are, or to go where you want to go.

For no reason except the political. Go to any country in Europe, and you'll find that even the shopping malls have railway sidings and not just truck loading bays.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CamperBob2 on Monday July 03, 2017 @05:13PM (#14691448)
To us, 200 years seems like a long time. To you, 200 kilometers seems like a long distance.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by ocschwar on Monday July 03, 2017 @11:39PM (#14693377)
Dude, I'm American.
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CamperBob2 on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @12:53AM (#14693618)
Then you should know why it's not practical to run rails to every grocery store and dry cleaner in every town in the US.

I will never understand the obsession with fixed-rail transit on this site. It's interesting to observe, but it's never been satisfactorily explained. Is it just a matter of people never having been out of the Bay Area in their lives?

In an age where personal mobility is becoming more important rather than less, when costs associated with large-scale civic construction projects have skyrocketed and completion times have come to be measured in decades, and when networked fleets of self-driving cars are almost literally just around the corner, rail transit in the general case is about the dumbest thing ever. But I recognize that this is essentially a religious argument, and that you're equally certain you're right. Not much we can do but vote accordingly, I guess.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by ocschwar on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @08:18AM (#14695399)
> Then you should know why it's not practical to run rails to every grocery store and dry cleaner in every town in the US.

Then I know that track costs less to install and maintain than roads. If it isn't practical to run track, it isn't practical to run roads.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CamperBob2 on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @03:22PM (#14697752)
Then I know that track costs less to install and maintain than roads. If it isn't practical to run track, it isn't practical to run roads.

I don't see how that can be true in the general case. Around here, in the Seattle area, a recent 34-mile light rail installation cost about $368 million. Four-lane roads cost about $500K per mile these days, from what I can tell. (And yes, that seems unrealistically low by an order of magnitude -- I think the sources I Googled up are referring only to initial costs, or costs associated with building rural Interstates.)

Our next big rail project, ST3, will install 62 miles of rail over 20+ years at a cost of over $50 billion.

Rail serves a tiny contingent of the population at enormous expense, effectively rooting them to the spot in the process. It has never really been shown to be effective at removing cars from the roads, certainly not in proportion to its price.

There has to be a better way. There may not be, right now, but there darned sure will be by the time the megaprojects we're considering today are complete and ready for service.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by ocschwar on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @09:45PM (#14699490)
> Our next big rail project, ST3, will install 62 miles of rail over 20+ years at a cost of over $50 billion.

Good basis for comparison. Because you see, for a typical freeway, a billion per mile is the cost.

And that's just installation.

Add in the cost to maintain the roads, and they lose to tracks hands down. Tracks don't need to be resurfaced. And track beds don't need a resurfacing just to get inspected.

(You're also missing the added cost for the overhead wiring if you're going to compare against electrified rail.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CamperBob2 on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @11:42PM (#14699842)
Good basis for comparison. Because you see, for a typical freeway, a billion per mile is the cost.

Where do you get that? Obviously we got more than 500 miles of freeway for the $500B (inflation-adjusted) that the Eisenhower Interstate System cost us. We got about 50,000 miles, which works out to $10M/mile.

So something seems to have made both highway and rail construction cost ludicrous amounts of money, if you're right about the $1B/mile figure. I don't think you are, though -- that amount is what I've heard cited for the most expensive mile of highway in the country, which supposedly is the stretch of I-90 that crosses Mercer Island. I'd have to throw a [Citation Needed] flag on the billion-dollar-per-mile figure, in the general case. If we're really spending that much on roads these days, somebody needs to figure out where all that money is going.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by Numberwang on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:55PM (#14678976)
how about those volvo systems that line up auto cars behind each-other?
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by gsnedders on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:39PM (#14679469)
You still have induced drag from low pressure areas unless you design your cars so they're more box-like (i.e., the front of one car matches up with the rear of another, without any bonnet/hood/etc. or similar).
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by Numberwang on Sunday July 02, 2017 @11:43AM (#14682991)
Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by CamperBob2 on Saturday July 01, 2017 @05:17PM (#14679079)
There are so many opportunities to save energy with self-driving cars that I suspect this point will not be a clear win.

But that assumes we do the right thing by constructing a standardized network and enforcing conformance with it, so they can behave more like high-speed train segments and less like individual vehicles. Here in the US, we generally do the right thing, but only after trying everything else first.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by zkms on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:05PM (#14679301)
> There's no fundamental reason that road vehicles couldn't exceed 200kph

There sorta is. Air resistance and tyre/pavement rolling resistance get mighty expensive at that sort of speed, and the need to carry along energy storage makes this even more problematic.

High-speed rail vehicles amortise, over the whole train, the part of the drag that comes from the frontal area. Automobiles cannot do this.

Once you've created a curve-free, very flat, grade-separated controlled access freeway for your 250kph cars, you've...got most of what you need for high-speed rail anyway. At that point you might as well just build some rails and overhead line and buy some TGV rolling stock.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by Tiktaalik on Saturday July 01, 2017 @08:12PM (#14679906)
Autonomous vehicles won't be superior to high speed rail due to much worse space efficiency and induced demand putting a strain on road infrastructure.

Even if autonomous cars are smaller than the ones we have now, they still take up too much space. Autonomous cars will expand the amount of drivers as one no longer needs a license, and the amount of cars will increase. This new demand will cause increased road congestion unless an expensive expansion of the road network takes place, an we know from induced demand that road expansion doesn't fix congestion in the long term anyway.

Automobile oriented infrastructure doesn't scale whether the cars are autonomous or not, and it's a bad idea to base the entire transportation system around them.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by leemailll on Saturday July 01, 2017 @09:38PM (#14680297)
>There's no fundamental reason that road vehicles couldn't exceed 200kph

Then a blown tire will be a deadly accident.

Re:As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail by adrianN on Sunday July 02, 2017 @06:22AM (#14681839)
A blown tyre is probably deadly even at normal speeds of ~130km/h. They don't blow very often though.