News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by bluthru on Saturday June 24, 2017 @10:28PM (#14628316)
An economy depending on population growth is incompatible with physics. If we care about climate change we should want every country to have a population decline until we can live within our carbon means.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by averagewall on Saturday June 24, 2017 @10:43PM (#14628355)
You mean like the low population of medieval Europe that didn't live within its tree-cutting means and destroyed nearly all its forests? Same for the ancient humans who killed off the megafauna, or the 1800's humans who nearly killed off the whales? Lower population also means lower chance of inventing new technology, and thus being harmed by smaller problems.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by bluthru on Saturday June 24, 2017 @11:22PM (#14628443)
>Lower population also means lower chance of inventing new technology

Really? Who do you think would have more technological advancements? 100 million Americans, or the projected four billion Africans?

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by themgt on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:50AM (#14628698)
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by shoo on Saturday June 24, 2017 @10:58PM (#14628390)
> Lower population also means lower chance of inventing new technology, and thus being harmed by smaller problems.

Supposing current technology level + ecological constraints, what do you think the rough optimal world population level should be?

  * less?
  * 0.01 billion people
  * 0.1 billion people
  * 1 billion people
  * 10 billion people
  * 100 billion people
  * 1000 billion people
  * more?

edit: to try to answer this question myself, i think 1 or 0.1 billion people would be vastly preferable to the status quo of 7.5b and growing in terms of buying time for us to sort out how to live without damaging global ecology.

i have no idea how to actually reach that state without a lot of planned/unplanned misery.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by fooker on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:41AM (#14628682)
>world population

It is a big assumption that we will be restricted to the 'world'. When we are not, it doesn't make much sense to stop a population explosion.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by majewsky on Sunday June 25, 2017 @10:29AM (#14630134)
Yes it does. Assuming a constant positive reproduction rate (i.e. N children per woman with N > 2.3), the population will grow exponentially, i.e. the population growth function is O(e^t).

If you solve this with space travel, i.e. by colonizing habitable planets within our reach, then you will be limited by the speed of light (i.e., how fast people can reach new planets to colonize). Given a time t, the radius of that available region is O(t), and therefore its volume is O(t^3).

As you see, O(t^3) is much smaller growth than O(e^t). (In fact, there's a theorem in analysis that for any exponential function, there exists no polynomial function that it won't eventually outgrow.)

So, if population growth is the problem, you can buy yourself a few more years by colonizing other planets, but the same problem ultimately re-emerges.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by collyw on Sunday June 25, 2017 @09:21AM (#14629860)
At present we pretty much are restricted to the world. Technically we have a few people in a space station, but I am pretty sure that isn't the answer to our overpopulation problems.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by lapsock on Saturday June 24, 2017 @10:56PM (#14628386)
>You mean like the low population of medieval Europe that didn't live within its tree-cutting means and destroyed nearly all its forests?

What?

Forests get destroyed because of stupidity, not because of population numbers.

And I agree with OP, I don't see what's the big deal about lack of new people. If anything I think it's a good thing.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by NickM on Saturday June 24, 2017 @11:13PM (#14628424)
Climate change isn't a problem of having too many people on earth, it's a problem of emitting too much CO2 per person. If we got rid of 90% of the world population, we would still be dealing with climate change, it would just be happening more slowly. Trying to fix climate change by reducing population is like trying to fix a leaky pipe by reducing the water pressure; yeah it might cause less water to leak but it doesn't solve the underlying problem.

One could argue that having fewer people on earth would still be a good thing because it would give us more time to solve the real problem of reducing CO2 per person; but it would also mean we'd have fewer scientists and engineers working to develop the sustainable technology needed to solve our problems. It's not clear if fewer people would lead to a better or worse end result, or if it would just get us to the same place more slowly.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by losteric on Saturday June 24, 2017 @11:17PM (#14628429)
Thats not entirely accurate... The planet can adapt to a certain amount of CO2, a small enough population could use fossil fuels indefinitely. Climate change reflects a massive population each with a massive ecological footprint.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by NickM on Saturday June 24, 2017 @11:23PM (#14628450)
Fair point, but in practice we're not likely to get down to such a low population level any time soon (if ever).
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by bluthru on Saturday June 24, 2017 @11:19PM (#14628435)
>but it would also mean we'd have fewer scientists and engineers working to develop the sustainable technology needed to solve our problems

No it wouldn't. Quality over quantity. Having to support less productive and low-IQ people means less resources available to solve difficult problems.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by colechristensen on Saturday June 24, 2017 @10:32PM (#14628326)
The universe is a big place. Moving to other planets isn't only reasonable, people are planning for it. Sustained growth is possible.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by yourapostasy on Saturday June 24, 2017 @11:07PM (#14628410)
Anytime I see talk of mass colonization as part of a solution to overpopulation, I direct people to Charles Stross' discussion about the infeasibility of doing so [1] [2]. The TL;DR is: until we find a breakthrough like cheap anti-gravity (like depicted in Interstellar), moving that much sheer mass of humanity is energetically (with the required specific impulse) not within our civilization's current capabilities.

[1] http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2007/06/the_high...

[2] http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2010/08/space-ca...

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by dangerlibrary on Saturday June 24, 2017 @10:43PM (#14628358)
There is nothing reasonable about moving to Mars - a place where the average temperature is -55C and there is no breathable atmosphere. Imagine such a place on earth, and now imagine trying to sell a home there to someone.

We may, one day, colonize other planets. But we evolved specifically to exist on this one. Each new environment will likely take centuries, if not millenia, to properly colonize. The fact that it is theoretically possible for a comically tiny fraction of Earth's population to eke out a hardscrabble, miserable life on other planets should not impact policy decisions on terra firma.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by serhei on Saturday June 24, 2017 @10:37PM (#14628341)
Until you have hard data on how people born and raised in <40% Earth gravity turn out, moving to other planets is only a possibility, not something you can plan for.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by cellis on Saturday June 24, 2017 @10:40PM (#14628348)
Also, with new technologies like CRISPR, AI, and bionics (and beyond) will we soon dramatically alter fundamentally what it means to be human? Perhaps on a unit basis our future selves will be far more resource efficient.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by yongjik on Saturday June 24, 2017 @11:01PM (#14628398)
Population growth is about as incompatible with physics as SUVs, that is, not very much, unless you like hyperboles.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by stale2002 on Saturday June 24, 2017 @10:41PM (#14628350)
Sure..... In the very long run.

But most of the planet is currently uninhabited.

We have at least a couple hundred years before we would really have to worry about overpopulation.

Not that it will get to that point, anyway. Birthrates will be below replacement rate in a couple decades.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by bluthru on Saturday June 24, 2017 @11:25PM (#14628456)
>We have at least a couple hundred years before we would really have to worry about overpopulation.

We are using energy and releasing carbon at an unsustainable rate. This means that we are overpopulated.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by nine_k on Sunday June 25, 2017 @02:44AM (#14628943)
We are hunting wooly mammoths at an unsustainable rate. It means we are overpopulated for our level of technology. We need to switch to domestication of animals and agriculture.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by stale2002 on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:30AM (#14628644)
People were saying that back in the 1960s, and that within 20 years, we'd be facing worldwide famine, where billions die.

Those predictions never came to pass.

Also, peak oil supply was supposed to hit us in the year 2000.

The peak oil people were correct, in the wrong way though.

We aren't going to hit peak oil supply. We are going to hit peak oil DEMAND. As in, our other technological solutions are going to overtake oil, because it will be cheaper and better before we come even close to running out of our non-renewable resources.

By looking at all of the recent developments in solar energy (which is currently following freaking "solar moores law". Within a decade, at current improvement rates it will be cheaper than coal in most locations. It already IS cheaper in high energy cost places like hawaii), and other technology progress, humans are easily easily on track to solving all of the supposed problems of overpopulation before come close to being an issue.

What the overpopulation people never figured out is that our rate of technological progress is faster than the rate that we use up resources, and it is faster by a long shot.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by antisthenes on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:49AM (#14628694)
You are creating multiple strawmen and arguing with yourself.

> What the overpopulation people never figured out is that our rate of technological progress is faster than the rate that we use up resources, and it is faster by a long shot.

What the techno-optimists haven't figured out is that technological progress and the resources aren't unlimited, the only case where your argument makes any sense.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by stale2002 on Sunday June 25, 2017 @01:18AM (#14628750)
"that technological progress and the resources aren't unlimited"

Of course they are not unlimited. In 1 billion years we will have hit that limit of technological progress.

Before we hit that limit, 1 billion years from now, we have a long way to go, and the limit is 'effectively' unlimited, for all intensive purposes.

The only way your argument makes any sense is if you think we will hit that limit within a decade or something. But all evidence points to the contrary, and that we instead will only have to worry about those limits, a long long time from now.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by majewsky on Sunday June 25, 2017 @10:31AM (#14630151)
> In 1 billion years we will have hit that limit of technological progress.

Citation needed.