The relatively high standard of living in the former socialist economies was to a large degree due to the need to compete with the capitalist economies, where standard of living, abundance and variety of products all grow naturally higher with time, rather than get "optimized" into oblivion.
USA, for example, has a lot of central planning, in the private sector alone, not even considering the public sector. Any large mega-corp is an example. Walmart has a huge centrally planned operations and supply chain.
> capitalist economies, where standard of living, abundance and variety of products all grow naturally higher with time
How would you explain stalled and declining standard of living in the Western capitalist economies over the past 30 years or so?
Both Walmart's supply of resources and other producers of its goods (or near-identical substitute goods) are outside the control of its planners, forcing them to spend most of their energy dealing with the vagaries of the market instead of just making their goods, which is what socialist planning was supposed to avoid.
Adding planners doesn't give you more (central planning) it gives you (less central) planning
Further, Walmart has an enormous influence, and often outright economical control over many of its suppliers, to the point that it can make or break them. It's notorious for playing hardball in their negotiations with suppliers.
Even further, there's such a thing as Walmart's brands, which place even further control over white label suppliers, and sometimes take over production on their own: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Walmart_brands
Even further, Walmart owns its trucking fleet and employs truck drivers directly.
Certainly during the USSR's time. But now you could issue every citizen a smartphone through which they could register their demand.
>the optimization then will lead to planning only for the type of production that can ensure basic survival and not much more.
Sorry, but I'm not seeing how this follows logically.
Unless they are expending a limited resource to do so, the same problem remains. In capitalist market economy that resource is money [1], and it's universal and fungible, both bid for goods and services (and not just in typically "consumer" markets) and bid against with offerings of labor. If you abolish meaningful markets for some goods and services—including wage labor—you limit the scope of utility signals you get—even if, as most real world state socialist systems have done, you retain exchange of currency for “consumer” goods and services.
[1] which, despite its utility, has significant issues, too. Nothing in this post is meant to endorse the optimality of capitalism, only to explain the problem of utility signalling in state socialism.
You could still have money but needing money to live a normal life or being able to use money to invest or stockpile goods would represent a failure of central planning.
Limiting the scope of markets limits the utility-signalling function of money, even if it is retained (as, in practice, centrally-planned systems tend to.)
This is a problem of input data that technology that provides alternative mechanisms to collect the same data (cell phone purchasing) does not address.
Well, it would serve to optimize (or come close to doing so) some utility function, which might be labeled "satisfaction of demand". But who defines that utility function? Some central planner.
But how does that central planner know what I actually want? Yeah, I could tell them with my smartphone. That's going to tell them a pretty coarse approximation to what my actual desires are, though.
For example: Life Savers candy. People choose to buy the stuff. A roll of them costs, what, $1? But how many people are going to bother listing that on their phones? A whole lot fewer people than actually buy Life Savers, I bet.
[Edit: What's actually going to happen is that an element of politics is likely to creep into the definition of the utility function. "Oh, they shouldn't want that; they should want this instead."]
That is exactly why it is incompatible with free market. Central Planning, ultimately, only cares about what you need, not about what you "want".
Certain basic needs are definitely not created artificially. So every human being has requirement for food, clothing, shelter and the very minimum. The more I think about it, the more it seems like, for instance, primary sectors could be handled so much better with central planning. e.g. instead of growing artificially subsidized corn, grow only an amount of corn that is required by the economy (perhaps a little extra). Continuously adjust production to meet demand if it increases.
Demand for fancy food is more artificial. Maybe I love oysters but you like quail instead. So there could be a free market operating for oysters and quails.
There's a reason why nobody tries to declare food a human right and give it away for free, even though people die if they don't eat.
The Soviet Union and East Germany seem to be the only states which attempted Central Planning genuinely, and from this article and other resources, it seems the problem was simply too complex even then... at that time.
Also, "centrally planned economy managed by the government" by definition leaves no space for "an open market" for "more productive or talented citizens" to "choose to earn more wealth and purchase from." Unless you're talking about a black market.
The reason that conflicting schools of economic can coexist indefinitely in economics (in the contrast to physics, say) is that very little is settled on economics since the question of how an economic system works is predicated
As other have said, your absolute pronouncements about socialism requiring a stagnant economy is coming from a rather specific ideological bent rather than a simple consensus.
Frankly, the burden of proof ought to be on you to show that it's going to work now just because we have shiny new computers that they didn't have between 1922 to 1991. Which is actually very thoughtfully discussed in the article.
If you're running a mixed economy, where some sectors are planned and some are not, thats fine... but it's also not what the post is taking about.
"Central planning" means "the government (or some other single entity, but usually the government) makes all of the decisions in the economy."
Corporations, despite being "centralized," and despite engaging in "planning," do not meet the definition of what we're talking about when we say "central planning." They emerge in a free market economy in order to reduce the transaction costs that would come with trying to coordinate mulitiple people as independent participants to do some specific activity. They do not exist to decide for the entire country exactly what everyone will be doing all the time to meet the entire nation's needs. That's a very big difference.
I'd hardly say that was either proven or agreed upon
>"centrally planned economy managed by the government" by definition leaves no space for "an open market" for "more productive or talented citizens" to "choose to earn more wealth and purchase from."
I don't see this a being "by definition" either. You can have a centrally planned economy with people who are independent (or at least as independent as they are in any other economic system) in what job they choose, where they choose to work and what they choose to buy. The government could assess the demand for a product at a given price, determine the resources (material or human) necessary to produce that product as well as all other demands for those resources. When the demands exceed resource availability, you then raise the price for that resource, refactor that into the price of the final product and then assess the demand for it at that new price. You raise the price for each constraining resource until the demand drops to a level that can be fulfilled. This would include specialized labor, so if a job is in high demand and short supply, the wage for that job would go up until the supply increases and/or demand decreases to reach equilibrium.
All of this already happens in an ad-hoc way in a free market, but in a free market it can take a long time for changes in input prices to be reflected in output prices, and it can take even longer to determine how those will affect demand. I don't see why that couldn't be formalized and worked out centrally. I'm imagining an economy where everyone is issued a smartphone through which they make all of their purchases and through which they find and respond to bids for employment. Demand could then be assessed fairly accurately and instantaneously. It seems like it would be way more efficient in terms of reductions in redundancy, overproduction, costs incurred attempting to generate demand that does not exist or siphon demand from competitors' products, and price increases solely for profit-maximization in cases where demand is inelastic and supplies are sufficient (like epi-pens or insulin).
Modeling it would probably be extremely complex and might still exceed our current computational capacity, I dunno, but I don't see any reason to call it impossible.
As the blog post notes, politicians will not leave their hands off sensitive prices, leading to unending systemic distortions. This already exists.
> All of this already happens in an ad-hoc way in a free market, but in a free market it can take a long time for changes in input prices to be reflected in output prices, and it can take even longer to determine how those will affect demand.
Market reactions vary according to the market. Petrol prices at the pump move up extremely quickly, because the station owner is going to pay for the next tank out of this tank. They move down slowly because that's about the only time they turn a profit.
Meanwhile, manufacturing industries can need 1-5 years of lead time to increase capacity. They can't and won't make massive changes without substantial, sustained market signals that it's required.
The difference between the market system -- really, the price system -- and non-market systems is that the price system is sufficient to solve the planning problem. A world of agents who know nothing but prices is still able to allocate resources and production in a way that adapts to changes in demand and supply, including large shocks.
In practice, real markets also make use of other information signals. But they do not require them. And they do not require a central coordinating planner to have perfect or near-perfect information of extremely wide ranges of local information.
Probably the best explanation of this distinction is found in Hayek.
Though of course the required central planning here is quite different, more about smart bets than optimizations, and focusing engineering resources at important problems, which doesn't seem that great at capitalistic economies either(think planned obsolesce, "my generation is optimizing ads", browser in-incompatibilities, etc) .
1. They weren't much better than the West. Consider that the capitalist world surpassed them at pretty much anything they started with an advantage in.
2. They were also really bad at managing the scarcity of very basic things their people needed. Like, food and medicine. The joke was that Russia had "bad weather" for 70 years under communism.
There was no competition on their domestic market, hence it sucked.
Well, space industry was quite suboptimal in USSR. Successes were achieved because of 1) all resources were spent on space and military and 2) great legacy of Russian Empire (especially great minds like Korolev, Tsiolkovsky and Tupolev). So I see it more like stagnation than development.
So the Objective Function assigned much higher "value" to Military production (either explicitly or implicitly) and this of course made military production more "efficient" than consumer goods production. (I put quotes around "efficient" because there still was a lot of waste and corruption even in that, of course).
I wouldn't say it's been "discussed to death" at all; have you read Cockshott's "Towards a New Socialism"? He tries to explain why the problem isn't really a problem at all, with his idea of computerised central planning.
I will google this book, but could you tell me what you find most persuasive about it?
I can't seem to find the document you're referring to and its conclusions, Wikipedia page? Is there a balanced discussion on the subject somewhere that is not from Mises Institute or some other libertarian ideologically-driven piece?
Has references to many of the original essays by Mises and Hayek that brought the problem to broader attention in economics.
Found this though, which brings up good counter-points to libertarian criticism of central planning: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem#C...
You may have mistaken Mises and Hayek, the fairly thoughtful and insightful market-favouring economists, with Mises and Hayek, the caricatures transmitted via a heavily mutating Murray Rothbard into US Arch-Libertarianism.
In particular Hayek is at great pains that he doesn't think the market is magical or morally superior. He clearly points out that markets assign by prices, not by commendable virtues.
But he does say that markets solve a problem that can't, beyond a certain scale, be safely solved in other ways without causing larger problems to emerge.
For example, Soviet economist Kantorovich won the same prize the year following Hayek for work related to central planning, and I'd consider him a lot less ideological, not because of winning the prize, but because of his overall approach to issues: http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economic-sciences/lau...
This is actually pretty fascinating. If we reach a level of automation such that factories are completely automated, I wonder if the data that is gathered from all those factories, along with more powerful computers and algorithms in the future, would allow central planning to work better than no planning. Some of the problems mentioned by the author are caused simply by the data being wrong, because of lying factory managers: automated factories would eliminate that problem at least.
At the very least, I hope that in the future there will be a centrally planned economy managed by the government to provide a decent living standard to most citizens, while minimizing environmental impact. More productive or talented citizens would/could choose to opt to earn more wealth and purchase from an open market.