News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Optimizing things in the USSR (2016) by AnimalMuppet on Thursday June 08, 2017 @08:06PM (#14518183)
> It would serve to optimally satisfy demand...

Well, it would serve to optimize (or come close to doing so) some utility function, which might be labeled "satisfaction of demand". But who defines that utility function? Some central planner.

But how does that central planner know what I actually want? Yeah, I could tell them with my smartphone. That's going to tell them a pretty coarse approximation to what my actual desires are, though.

For example: Life Savers candy. People choose to buy the stuff. A roll of them costs, what, $1? But how many people are going to bother listing that on their phones? A whole lot fewer people than actually buy Life Savers, I bet.

[Edit: What's actually going to happen is that an element of politics is likely to creep into the definition of the utility function. "Oh, they shouldn't want that; they should want this instead."]

Re:Optimizing things in the USSR (2016) by Koshkin on Friday June 09, 2017 @09:10AM (#14521066)
> how does that central planner know what I actually want?

That is exactly why it is incompatible with free market. Central Planning, ultimately, only cares about what you need, not about what you "want".