Re:Optimizing things in the USSR (2016)
by utexaspunk on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:44PM
(#14517045)
It wasn't my intent to imply this didn't involve money. You can have central planning and still have money, no? I would not disagree that it's nigh impossible to have a functional economy without money...
If you can do central planning, money becomes mostly superfluous. The whole point is that factories don't pay for their inputs, stores are stocked without borrowing to buy goods, profitability of individual firms becomes irrelevant, and the overwhelming majority of economic activity is based on supplying planned needs.
You could still have money but needing money to live a normal life or being able to use money to invest or stockpile goods would represent a failure of central planning.
Re:Optimizing things in the USSR (2016)
by utexaspunk on Thursday June 08, 2017 @09:18PM
(#14518516)
Maybe I'm dense, but I don't see how central planning makes money superfluous. Central planning doesn't mean you're beyond scarcity. Money quantifies the worker's share of the production and their spending communicates demands and priorities for subsequent production. There's no getting around having prices for things, the prices are just lower because they are not calculated to be as high as possible to maximize profits for investors and because the redundant production, marketing, and financing expenses associated with competition are eliminated.
Re:Optimizing things in the USSR (2016)
by dragonwriter on Thursday June 08, 2017 @05:22PM
(#14517294)
> It wasn't my intent to imply this didn't involve money
Limiting the scope of markets limits the utility-signalling function of money, even if it is retained (as, in practice, centrally-planned systems tend to.)
This is a problem of input data that technology that provides alternative mechanisms to collect the same data (cell phone purchasing) does not address.
Unless they are expending a limited resource to do so, the same problem remains. In capitalist market economy that resource is money [1], and it's universal and fungible, both bid for goods and services (and not just in typically "consumer" markets) and bid against with offerings of labor. If you abolish meaningful markets for some goods and services—including wage labor—you limit the scope of utility signals you get—even if, as most real world state socialist systems have done, you retain exchange of currency for “consumer” goods and services.
[1] which, despite its utility, has significant issues, too. Nothing in this post is meant to endorse the optimality of capitalism, only to explain the problem of utility signalling in state socialism.