News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by PretzelFisch on Monday June 05, 2017 @05:59PM (#14492594)
what do you mean "leveling the playing field" if you buy a house your property tax increase is limited to a fixed %. how is that not level.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by galago on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:13PM (#14492722)
Proposition 13 declared property taxes were to be assessed their 1975 value and restricted annual increases of the tax to an inflation factor, not to exceed 2% per year. A reassessment of the property tax can only be made a) when the property ownership changes or b) there is construction done.

Property often increases in value more than 2% per year, so your actual rate goes down.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_13_(197...

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by aidenn0 on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:18PM (#14492749)
Even more damaging is when housing prices go up much faster than 2%; then there is a disincentive to move or enlarge your unit, because doing so would increase your tax liability by oftentimes staggering amounts.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by djabatt on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:32PM (#14493300)
One solution for tax relief for elderly would be to remove or reduce tax payments at age 65 or earlier if one is handicapped. It seems to be a fare method to handle this for issue. For the rent inflation in LA I don't have a answer. That said allowing people to get homeless seems to be a great cost on society as a whole and their should be a smart and scalable solution.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by PretzelFisch on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:18PM (#14492753)
When someone buys a property today, it is subject to the same 2% a year rule. I don't see how this is not a level field.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by function_seven on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:30PM (#14492844)
My neighbor pays half the property tax that I do, despite our houses both being worth the same amount. My new neighbors pay %25 more than I do, also in a similarly valued house.

That's what parent is likely referring to. I'm not making a value judgement either way. Prop 13 was intended to address the real issue of people being forced out of their own homes due to rising values. But it appears to have the side effect of pushing the values even higher by restricting the sell side of the market.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by PretzelFisch on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:49PM (#14493432)
All of CA has the prop 13, where we see it get blamed for high prices are in very high demand areas. How much price reduction would you really see without it? Looking at New York it doesn't look like much since the primary issue seems to be supply.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by Decade on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @02:51PM (#14508896)
But in New York, if you find Manhattan to be unaffordable, then you can move to a suburb. In San Francisco, the suburbs are even more expensive than the city.

The bad incentives of Prop 13 reward cities for favoring offices over housing. The property tax generally doesn't support the infrastructure, so they approve other activities that they can tax. Cupertino just opened the Apple Spaceship, but they have no plans to approve housing for thousands more workers.

In the news a month ago, in the midst of a teacher housing affordability problem, San Jose rejects teacher housing. http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/05/08/san-jose-city-hall-bal...

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by eanzenberg on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:11PM (#14493148)
Sucks if you at some point can't afford property tax because house prices went up 1000% around you. Think everyone can pay $20k / year?
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by refurb on Monday June 05, 2017 @08:49PM (#14493817)
If your house just went up in value by 1000%, then yes, you can afford $20K per year. Just do what Texas does and allow the home owner to stop paying property taxes and have the state get their money when the person dies or sells the house.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by tehlike on Monday June 05, 2017 @09:23PM (#14493981)
The only way to afford what you say is taking a reverse mortgage.

It sounds problematic on so many levels: in some parts of bay area houses are worth 2.5m, but they werent that expensive years ago. Think mountain view before google.

That is around 30k in taxes right there, per year.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by refurb on Monday June 05, 2017 @10:08PM (#14494146)
Using your example, of 1000%, you're looking at a house purchased for $100K going to $1000K.

Assume at 1.5% property tax rate and it's $15K per year. With a $900K capital gain, you could pay the property taxes for 60 years.

And if the value of the home drops, then the gov't eats the difference.

I just don't think it's fair that the people who received most of the gains in property value are the ones that get the most generous tax break.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by tehlike on Monday June 05, 2017 @10:26PM (#14494239)
Why is it any different if their property hadnt appreciated? One gets the burden, other doesnt?
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by nerfhammer on Monday June 05, 2017 @09:33PM (#14494028)
So what you're saying is that without prop 13 this set of people would vote for policies that keep housing prices at sane levels?
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by tehlike on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @07:35PM (#14502477)
NIMBY is a real thing, there is no denial in that.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by function_seven on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:27PM (#14493263)
Yeah it does suck. No I don't think everyone can afford that.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by stickfigure on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:46PM (#14493405)
suck is all relative.

That person is now sitting on a property worth megabucks. They can't afford the taxes, but they can sell it and retire to Florida.

I personally wouldn't mind having a little more of that kind of suck in my life.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by alexqgb on Monday June 05, 2017 @08:10PM (#14493569)
That's a pretty shitty solution for everyone involved if they don't actually want to be separated from the rest of their family by 3,000 miles. And not just their families, but their friends and communities, which have a profound impact on overall well-being in their later years.

I wouldn't call your suggestion deliberately cruel since you don't seem to have any idea how socially damaging this kind of isolating displacement can be. But I would say that the forced separation of people from their famalies and communities is a really hideous policy outcome, and one that should be strenuously avoided.

Obviously, if somebody wants to move far away, fine. But forcing them to do so is horribly wrong.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by aianus on Monday June 05, 2017 @08:20PM (#14493633)
You don't need to move 3,000 miles away, you just have to move outside of commuting range where the prices fall off a cliff. You can still live in the same quality house and see your family frequently.

It's nuts to tax Joe Worker who needs to live in that area to get to work double or triple the property tax of the rich old guy next door who spends his days playing golf or w/e.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by alexqgb on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @06:55PM (#14510502)
Eh, "community range" turns out to be pretty massive around the SF Bay Area, for example. Moving people two or more hours away by car can still do a lot of damage to their relationships, especially when their ability to drive is becoming weaker.

No the answer here is "sorry, but no" to all the people who have decided to block density in central areas in order to keep their own property values astronomically high.

There's no good reason why we should be shipping everyone but the richest workers in their economic prime to painfully remote locals because people in San Francisco's Sunset District are blockading the kinds of buildings that make places like Barcelona, Amsterdam, and Brownstone Brooklyn such attractive places to live.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by mrbabbage on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:28PM (#14492834)
Age

The benefit accrues over many years, similar to rent control. As a result, the benefits flow to long-standing landholders, who skew disproportionately older.

The result, at least for me in San Francisco: I pay twice as much in rent for a bedroom in a four bed apartment as my grandmother does in property tax for a 4000 square foot mansion. She bought her place over fifty years ago; by definition, I could not have done so. Indeed, with the direction things are heading, huge categories of people are locked out of all segments of the SF housing market due to excessive prices; there's nothing level about that.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by cynicalbastard on Monday June 05, 2017 @08:04PM (#14493525)
i hope you've looked into minimizing the property tax liabilities for when that house gets transferred to you.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by ThrustVectoring on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:04PM (#14492628)
It's leveling it between existing owners and purchasers.

As it stands, it's essentially subsidizing commuting. If you bought a house at $100k that's now worth $1M, and your job moves an hour away, you'd be giving up the property tax lock-in by moving to cut down your commute. Rent stabilization/control measures have a very similar problem.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by m-j-fox on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:16PM (#14493186)
Freeways also subsidize commuting. Would people sit in traffic every day if they had a choice? But if you suggest dynamiting a few stretches of interstate you get the same reaction from the public as you get when you suggest taking away prop 13.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by closeparen on Monday June 05, 2017 @11:00PM (#14494380)
Would people sit on public transportation every day if they had a choice? Cleary not - BART ridership is falling during leisure time (when people have a choice) even as it rises during peak hours.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by Y7ZCQtNo39 on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:08PM (#14492669)
You could always rent the home so someone else could occupy it. Presumably you would've paid off the $100k home by now, and then you could get a second mortgage on a new property, or rent and break even (given the income from renting the first property).
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by CydeWeys on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:17PM (#14492747)
Why should people owning investment properties be given huge tax breaks that wouldn't apply to someone buying the same home in the present day in order to live in it?

Basing property taxes on the current value of the property makes sense, and is how it is done essentially everywhere else in the world. Basing property taxes on what the property cost the last time it was sold, even if that was decades ago and is some tiny fraction of the current value, is very unusual, and has all sorts of negative repercussions.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by sjg007 on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:51PM (#14493016)
There is an active debate with people lobbying Congress to remove the second mortgage deduction.

Current value makes sense but California introduced Prop-13 and rent control around the same time to basically allow senior citizens to stay in their homes/rentals. Problems with prop-13 include the fact that commercial buildings are not excluded.

California also has Prop-58 and another one where the parent or grandparent can transfer the house to a child/grandchild without an FMV appraisal as well.

I believe it works like this.. Say a $50k house is paid off by the parent, then the gift tax on that can be paid by a home equity loan on it's current $1m valuation. I'm not sure if the gift tax though is calculated on the $50k or the $1m. Or if it is calculated at all. It may depend on if the parent/grandparent is still alive. You may be able to specify the value as the last real property value or the FMV (to cut future capital gains). Either way you just pay the taxes on it. But I think you can exclude a certain amount up to $500k if married.

But you could rent it out as well and use it as collateral on another mortgage.

It could also be that these houses will continue to be passed down the generations.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by khuey on Monday June 05, 2017 @09:47PM (#14494079)
It's not the capital gains taxes that prop 58/etc allow you to escape, it's a reassessment of the valuation for property tax purposes. So in your example, the inheritors get a house with a $500/yr property tax bill (1% of 50k) instead of a $10000/yr property tax bill. (1% of 1M) Meanwhile all their neighbors who had to buy their homes recently are paying that $10k/yr.

The estate tax doesn't kick in until 5 or so million so the capital gains thing is mostly irrelevant.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by sjg007 on Monday June 05, 2017 @11:33PM (#14494549)
Yes I know that it's property tax. Sorry if that wasn't clear. I thought I had it covered by FMV appraisal.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by Y7ZCQtNo39 on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:32PM (#14492861)
I'm not disagreeing. I was attempting to show how you might make the housing market less rigid. Even if the numbers of units for sale is low, you could at least get people to rent them. A larger rental supply would help meet the demand in California and keep prices for renters and buyers lower. I completely agree, though, that Prop 13 isn't helping the situation.

But politically, we might as well accept that it won't go away. Your best bet is to save up enough to afford a down payment, and hope that property appreciates and you too can also reap Prop. 13's benefits down the road when you're older. And if you're house is worth 10x as much then, you won't lose it for being on a fixed income, like most retired people are.

...I'd still prefer not having Prop. 13. The more fruitful discussion is how to best navigate a world where it continues to exist. Voters will never approve its repeal; if politicians try to do something about it, they will get thrown out the next election cycle.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by PretzelFisch on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:14PM (#14492731)
Why would you buy a new property and lose 6% to realtors? Or take out a new possibly more expensive loan. I am not sure property tax is a big motivator. Do you have studies that show it's negative effect?
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by mturmon on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:45PM (#14492966)
Your comment indicates you may not know about how Prop. 13 works.

Property valuations can get small year-to-year bumps, but a sale triggers a re-assessment, with vastly increased property taxes after that. My neighbor across the street bought in 1975 for $28K, and their valuation for tax assessment last year was $162K. Their next-door neighbor bought last year for $1.5M and their assessed value is $920K. Their houses are quite similar, but one pays $7500 more a year in property taxes.

That difference can motivate people to endure a long commute, to hang on to a low assessment.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by shostack on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:30PM (#14493286)
Also, this can cause some really interesting (not in a good way) issues with what those tax dollars get you.

For example, there have been some local measures I've seen where they want tax assessments based on a percentage of your current tax, not a flat rate. As such, new residents end up paying massively higher amounts of the new measures than long-time residents.

Long-time residents have had the ability to make use of the services their tax dollars have provided for a long time, whereas new residents have not. Old residents might be all about taxes that get them things they want because they don't have to pay much at all, whereas new residents might see a material impact because of how high some of those amounts might be.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by rosege on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:12PM (#14493153)
As someone living in a country without annual property taxes Im not really qualified to comment, but, it almost sounds like the solution is to allow people to transfer their low assessments on to new properties - this is obviously a huge advantage to older people but it would allow real estate to be used more efficiently.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by exclusiv on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @06:20PM (#14501954)
What country is this and how are local taxes collected then? I'm intrigued.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by PretzelFisch on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:37PM (#14493335)
I understand how it works, I don't think if I bought a house for 100k that is now worth 1 million I would move across town for a shorter commute like the parent suggests. I would loose money from transactions costs and loan fees. My school district would change, along with other neighborhood amenities. It will more then likely work out better to commute a little.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by cjlars on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:35PM (#14492886)
Why would it not be a big motivator? don't know about LA, but in SF tax is just shy of 1.2%, if you have a mortgage at 3.5%, and you've held your property for a long time, you can easily see your property tax triple and your cost of living go up ~10-20% in aggregate just by being assessed at the current market level in a new home (with the same value) on the other side of town... And that's every year, not just once on the sale.

It seems pretty clear to me that 10% or 20% makes a big difference. Plenty of people will move across town to pay $2,400 a month instead of $3,000, why would home-owners be fundamentally different.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by PretzelFisch on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @09:24AM (#14496999)
I don't understand the downvotes. Using the term "leveling the playing field" implies that a new home purchaser has a different contract with the state then a home purchaser last year or 10 years ago. Yes what you paid for the house is more, and therefore your taxes are higher but the contract with the state is still the same.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by orik on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:06PM (#14492653)
because your property tax is no longer tied to what your house is worth, but instead tied to some arbitrary measurement (fixed % increase on what it used to be worth)

x != y

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by WillPostForFood on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:40PM (#14492929)
The price you paid is no more less arbitrary than approximate current worth.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by PretzelFisch on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:12PM (#14492706)
how is that not level? once someone buys a house they are in the same system?
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by henrikschroder on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:29PM (#14492838)
Over time, you accrue a large tax benefit as a homeowner, if the actual value of your home increases more than 2% every year. By moving, you reset this benefit, which is a disincentive to moving.