News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by gumby on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @02:46PM (#14447457)
I was thinking simply, "too little, too late" but then realized this could be quite interesting.

Uber's model in most domains is to push hard over the line in the hopes of moving that line. More charitably this could be called "ask for forgiveness rather than permission". So canning Levendowski could be seen as simply a case of this.

But Google's suit is against Uber, not Levendowski, who could now spill beans on all sorts of unsuspected malfeasance. At this point what has he got to lose? If he decides to cooperate with google things could get very interesting.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by CPLX on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:04PM (#14447609)
> At this point what has he got to lose?

All of his money and perhaps his freedom. If he essentially sold Google property to Uber he could be on the hook to hand over all the money he made from doing it plus punitive damages, and some of the conduct that's been alleged against him could even rise to the level of criminal charges.

He's taking the 5th here for a reason. He stands to lose, literally, everything.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by stouset on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:33PM (#14447867)
He's taking the 5th here for a reason, and that reason is that it is the advice that literally any lawyer will give you regardless of your guilt innocence.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by CPLX on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:46PM (#14447967)
That's patent nonsense.

It is extremely uncommon for someone to take the 5th Amendment in a civil dispute. It, justifiably, raises a ton of red flags that something very serious is going on.

When people sue each other they don't get to remain silent, they're subject to depositions, discovery, being put on the stand, and having to explain themselves. Your comment applies to criminal matters, it's not comparable at all.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by stouset on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:06PM (#14448134)
The current case between Waymo and Uber is a civil dispute, but there is absolutely the possibility here of criminal charges being filed against Levandowski. It's already been referred to a federal prosecutor.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:15PM (#14448190)
More: to take the 5th in a civil dispute that they aren't even a party to. That's extremely unusual - and in this case, it didn't fly.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by dllthomas on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @06:13PM (#14448979)
Well, I mean, it did fly, in that he was not compelled (... directly?) by the court to testify. Which isn't to say it didn't have other consequences...
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @06:21PM (#14449014)
But Levandowski tried to get the court to not allow Waymo to discover who wrote the due diligence report. (Not just block Waymo from seeing the report - he tried to block Waymo from even learning who wrote it.) He did this by claiming the 5th. On a court case that he wasn't a party to.

And the judge didn't buy it (rightly, IMHO).

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by dllthomas on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @06:37PM (#14449124)
Ah, yeah.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by dllthomas on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @06:18PM (#14449003)
> It is extremely uncommon for someone to take the 5th Amendment in a civil dispute. It, justifiably, raises a ton of red flags that something very serious is going on.

Except in this case, we already know that "something very serious is going on" - there are obvious, substantial criminal implications to what Google is alleging.

"Don't say anything that might increase the chance of you going to trial" starts sounding quite a bit more reasonable, there, even if Levandowski is innocent.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by jbigelow76 on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:45PM (#14447963)
He (most likely) forfeited his as of yet unvested $250 million in Uber stock he received as part of the acquisition. I suppose some innocent people would walk from $250 million on the advice of their lawyer, but not many.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by dmix on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @07:00PM (#14449266)
Depending on how much he currently has wealth-wise, his reputation and credibility here might be worth much more than that in the long run.

He's still a bright engineer who could go on to do things in the self-driving car space. His expertise and exposure to the most cutting-edge IP is worth quite a bit. The less damage he gets out of this legally and the less dirt thrown on his name the more he will be able to turn that into real long term monetary value.

Not to mention the social costs.

If I was him I'd also being doing as much as possible to minimize the negative outcome of these legal proceedings for all who were involved with him.

I'd rather have, say, $20M plus a reasonable shot at making a lot of money in the future with a marginal reputation than risk my name being run through the dirt for a chance at $250M. Many smart people who had a shaky past have gone on to be successful. Talent/having the right skillset at the right time seems to trump (no pun intended) bad press ... in America especially.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by jbigelow76 on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @08:57PM (#14449787)
If he is looking to protect his reputation, AND he is actually innocent, even at the expense of the money he should be wanting to tell his side of the story despite a lawyer telling him not to talk.

My, admittedly cynical, take is much simpler, his lawyer sat him down and said something along the lines of: "screw the 250 million, keep your damn mouth shut if you want to stay out of prison".

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by stouset on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @09:33PM (#14449896)
He should want to, perhaps, but being innocent does not inherently make saying anything a good legal idea given a potential future criminal case.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by jbigelow76 on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @10:03PM (#14449989)
Sure, people get railroaded by the justice system all to often. But more often than not those are usually unfortunate souls with little ability to defend themselves accused of crimes far more heinous than stealing trade secrets.

For what Levandowski is accused of and how he is accused of doing it, there should be plenty of either incriminating or exculpatory evidence, if the parties involved want to divulge it. Google isn't some district attorney trying to look tough on crime for the voters, nobody outside of Google and Uber really care all that much about the case really care or which way it goes. Levandowski, by pleading the 5th has already been found guilty in the court of public opinion (yes, yes, shame on all of us) so he can't be clinging to whatever shreds of his reputation are left for future jobs.

It's not impossible that he is innocent and his lawyer thinks the best strategy is to plead the 5th anyway, I just don't happen to buy it myself.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by CPLX on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @06:22AM (#14451436)
There's nothing shameful about making inferences from his behavior in this case. It's reasonable and proper to assume someone taking the 5th in a civil case has something to hide.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by tuna-piano on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:37PM (#14447893)
I don't know much - but perhaps Google could make a deal with Levandowski that if he spills the beans on what Uber did, then Google won't go after him?

Google obviously has much more to gain by suing Uber than suing a dude. If Google needs information, and Levandowski has that information, it would seem to be a good deal.

But if there's also possible criminal proceedings, Levandowski would need to make a similar deal with the government too?

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by scarmig on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:00PM (#14448083)
Eh. Waymo definitely worries about Uber as a competitor, and in general many people have a distaste for Uber's culture and values.

But there's still a pretty stark line between being a strategic competitor and being a scummy traitor who steals trade secrets and the labor of his coworkers. If it came down to a choice between shutting down Uber's self-driving car program and ruining Levandowski, I'm sure a lot of people would want to choose the latter, even though it's "irrational." Principles are important.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by monochromatic on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:27PM (#14448271)
An individual, sure. But Google is too big to take the irrational vindictive option. I have to think they'd let Levandowski off the hook to shut down a competitor like this.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by scarmig on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:42PM (#14448379)
I'd expect the same. But I'd bet a majority of the individual actors, including those making the final decision, would really like to be able to take that vindictive option.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by law_of_the_hobo on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:49PM (#14447990)
I have to imagine that google also wants to set a precedent that they won't tolerate people stealing their trade secrets.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by eitally on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @05:52PM (#14448852)
Google currently is in arbitration with Levandowski, so the odds are relatively good they'll get both (positive outcomes from both suing Uber and pursuing AL).
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by lurker456 on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:37PM (#14447895)
Couldn't google offer him immunity of sorts in return for spilling the beans on Uber ? They dont need to claw back the money, it is pocket change to them. Restricting Uber from entering that market (on potentially near equal footing) is far more valuable.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by pythonaut_16 on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:45PM (#14447956)
I don't think Google can offer immunity since any criminal charges would be brought by the state.

Google could offer not to bring a civil suit against him, but it sounds like criminal charges are on the table and he's trying to avoid anything that might help that investigation.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by ooqr on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:48PM (#14447981)
In spite of what you see on TV, it's not up to a victim to decide whether or not to press criminal charges in the end. That's up to the attorney general usually.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by amyjess on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:10PM (#14448155)
Though police do often drop criminal charges if the victim is uncooperative.

Here's a recent example: a friend of mine was raped and strangled to death last month. They caught her alleged murderer last week. When the media got a hold of it, they found out that he had been accused of rape and attempted strangulation five years ago, but police decided not to press charges because the victim wanted to let it drop.

So yeah, it happens; it's just a spectacularly bad idea for the police to do it. If they hadn't declined to file charges, my friend and another murder victim would probably still be alive today.

Source: https://www.dallasnews.com/news/crime/2017/05/26/man-killed-...

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by hluska on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:53PM (#14448448)
I'm very sorry about your friend. That is an absolute tragedy.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by gnicholas on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:58PM (#14448069)
Victims can choose not to cooperate with an investigation, which makes it much harder (and in some cases impossible) for a prosecution to proceed.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @05:31PM (#14448708)
If all the relevant material is "spilled" in a civil trial that the victim is pursuing against someone else, the victim's cooperation in the criminal case is less likely to be needed.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by JCharante on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @05:36PM (#14448744)
Correct. See: Aaron Swartz (rest in peace)
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by JKCalhoun on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:17PM (#14447720)
If he has done what he has alleged to have done, he deserves to lose everything.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @02:50PM (#14447494)
> But Google's suit is against Uber, not Levendowski, who could now spill beans on all sorts of unsuspected malfeasance. At this point what has he got to lose?

His freedom. There's a reason he took the Fifth, and tried to force Uber not to release information to support that.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by DINKDINK on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:13PM (#14447669)
>Google's suit is against Uber, not Levendowski, who could now spill beans on all sorts of unsuspected malfeasance. At this point what has he got to lose? If he decides to cooperate with google things could get very interesting.

Google's suit is against Uber, not Levendowski, because Uber has the capital to go after. I Am Not An IP Lawyer, but I'd guess that if Levendowski had substantial assets, he'd be named a party in the complaint.

My guess is that this firing is mainly a move to improve Uber's political capital "Look we fired the bad apple". I'd assume Uber has probably figured out how to tie his interests into cooperating with him (to the detriment of exposing IP theft) though maybe granting him equity or some sort of financial incentive.

Uber: Hey, we're really sorry that things didn't work out but "here's some equity for the time that you worked here" oh and by the way here's the estimated value of that equity if we win the lawsuit or don't win the law suit.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by georgespencer on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:24PM (#14447780)
> My guess is that this firing is mainly a move to improve Uber's political capital "Look we fired the bad apple". I'd assume Uber has probably figured out how to tie his interests into cooperating with him (to the detriment of exposing IP theft) though maybe granting him equity or some sort of financial incentive.

Uber is complying with a court order to do their utmost to compel him to cooperate and testify. This is not political and it's also possible that they still don't want him to testify either way but they have to be seen to do the "right thing" in the eyes of the court.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by xapata on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:18PM (#14447733)
Google's employment contract with Levendowski specified that all disputes are resolved by arbitration rather than court.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by nicolewhite on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:26PM (#14448266)
Does that apply now that he's no longer an employee there?
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by joshuamorton on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @05:18PM (#14448629)
In short, yes. And there's currently an ongoing arbitration between Google and Levandowski separate from this suit.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by CardenB on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:18PM (#14447723)
Source? AFAIK, the suit was against Uber because Google's employment agreement means that they can target the company rather than the employee, but not the actual employee.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by fullshark on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:31PM (#14448293)
I can't think of a single incentive he would have to cooperate with Google's lawsuit.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by it_learnses on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @02:47PM (#14447467)
Unless they promised to give him a large sum / stocks after everything is settled if he agrees not to talk.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by kognate on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:09PM (#14447644)
In the USA legal system, this would be (at best) witness tampering and possibly obstruction of justice. Federal witness tampering and obstruction are things that _very_ few lawyers would knowingly participate in because you don't have to be successful to be convicted. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Witness_tampering
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by DINKDINK on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:15PM (#14447697)
Uber: Hey, we're really sorry that things didn't work out but "here's some equity for the time that you worked here" oh and by the way here's the estimated value of that equity if we win the lawsuit or don't win the law suit.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by linkregister on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:27PM (#14447818)
Unlike a compiler that you can trick, the law operates on the intended spirit in addition to the letter of the statute and relevant precedent.

This "law hack" would be immediately caught by Waymo and Judge Alsop would rightfully penalize Uber. The corporate officers who signed off on an action like that would likely be criminally liable as well.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by DINKDINK on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @06:33PM (#14449104)
I'm not advocating for Uber to do what I said but given what's been written about their ethical practices, it's what I would expect from them.

The problem is, how do you differentiate between equity whose grant is meant to manipulate a party of a crime and equity justly earned by working there?

If I were Uber, I would fire him and if possible, revoke any equity he had to absolve the company from any accusations of implied manipulation.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by potatolicious on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:26PM (#14447798)
Despite popular belief, the judiciary is in fact not a pack of nincompoops that can be trivially bypassed by a nudge and a wink...

Nor is the judiciary powerless against attempts to exploit loopholes, if they indeed exist.

"Muahahaha! The law is powerless against me and I can violate it with impunity by judicious word choice" is largely a fantasy.

Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by mikestew on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:56PM (#14448048)
You're replying to a comment that mentioned witness tampering, and your proposed solution is more witness tampering? You know those non-technical people who think themselves clever by suggesting "all they need to do is make the computer understand human speech, then..."? Yeah, that's what this thread probably sounds like to a lawyer or judge.
Re:Uber Fires Anthony Levandowski by frozenport on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @02:50PM (#14447489)
Would be tricky to pull off without a serious charge of "impeding justice".